Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that opening up about your mental health issues can lead to further isolation

40 replies

Mentalhealthstruggles · 28/03/2023 09:47

I struggled for years, kept it hidden mostly and functioned ok amongst peers and in life. The past few years I have decided to open up about my struggles with anxiety and depression, be honest etc. now I have less friends. I am lonelier. I never get invited or included. I’ve been ghosted by almost everyone. It’s good to talk they say but in my case this has backfired. Has anyone else experienced this? I am sure that there are lots out there that talking has helped but are there any that are like me and wish I had never told anyone.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Barbecuebeans · 29/03/2023 23:39

NorseKiwi · 29/03/2023 23:23

Friends aren't therapists. I find it useful to join women's circles, healing groups, go try psycho drama, go to AA, find a group of people who are actively working on their stuff. It's a lifetimes work, we are all layers of an onion and "the work" is never finished.... its just lots of lessons to get through.

I've found a group of people who are committed to their healing and well-being and its changed my life - 5 years on I am still committed to every session and weekend retreat that is offered.

oh and never open up properly at work - people are sympathetic for a week or so, but then they want you to hurry up and get better/start performing again

I think this is very true.

I also think that people who have a tendency towards isolation are often very giving. So they get caught up with self absorbed people who enjoy being looked after and supported. They don't see reciprocity as part of the deal.

Sitting back when you meet new people and discovering if they're the type to treat you fairly or just be obsessed with their own issues is worth the time, rather than assuming that if you are nice to them, they'll be nice back when you need it.

SpookySpoon22 · 29/03/2023 23:27

I am worried that someone suicidal will read this thread and feel they have nowhere to turn :-( I would absolutely want to know if someone I cared about was feeling really low and I'd like to think I'd listen and support them in some way, even if that meant encouraging them to speak to a professional. I am not trying to minimize anyone's experience on here but I don't believe that most people would turn away, even if they found it difficult.

discobrain · 29/03/2023 23:25

Yep. So many people say they will be there to listen, and then you get crickets.

bakebeans · 29/03/2023 23:24

I am actuallly pleased you have posted this OP and for the wrong reasons. I've been suffering with my mental health for four years. Always managed it well, talked to myself and calmed down etc but since the last 6 months I have struggled like mad.
I want to be alone a lot, I have noticed I'm more withdrawn, i don't want to make conversation and I cannot be arsed with small talk. I haven't seen my boys all day and yet I just want to curl up in bed and be left alone. Every night! I used to enjoy the gym classes. I used to go daily. Ive not been for a while and even the fact I've booked a holiday in 3.5 months isn't motivating me.

with all this, I was planning to finally pluck uo
the courage to speak to someone but what you have said was already at the back of my mind which is the reason I've been bottling everything up for the last 4 years.
I work in the NHS. Gp's haven't got the time of skill to be dealing with mental health issues. The skilled trainers and mental health teams haven't got the capacity.it's absolutely Shit!

NorseKiwi · 29/03/2023 23:23

Friends aren't therapists. I find it useful to join women's circles, healing groups, go try psycho drama, go to AA, find a group of people who are actively working on their stuff. It's a lifetimes work, we are all layers of an onion and "the work" is never finished.... its just lots of lessons to get through.

I've found a group of people who are committed to their healing and well-being and its changed my life - 5 years on I am still committed to every session and weekend retreat that is offered.

oh and never open up properly at work - people are sympathetic for a week or so, but then they want you to hurry up and get better/start performing again

XenoBitch · 29/03/2023 23:09

CRP??? That should say CPR!

XenoBitch · 29/03/2023 23:09

daretodenim · 29/03/2023 23:04

Thing is we're told to open up and share. We're told that our friends "would want to know" and when someone dies by suicide we hear how everybody who knew them just wished the person had told them how they'd been feeling.

And actually it's not true. Very few people want to know. They think they do, and it sounds abjectly mean to say they don't want to hear, but the relative is that they actually don't. They just want their friends and family members and, perhaps, colleagues to be ok.

I don't blame them, because listening to someone with MH problems can be tough, frustrating and disempowering. But it's simply not true that everybody who says "I wish I knew", actually wanted to hear it.

And it's not like arthritis, or other physical ailments because often the social support, understanding and empathy would soften the impact of many MH issues. And that's assuming they're not part of the underlying problem in the first place.

This.
And also, when someone tells you that they are feeling suicidal or similar, it can feel like a huge responsibility, and that you are now in charge of keeping them safe.
It is like seeing someone have a heart attack in front of you, except you have no idea how to do CRP.

daretodenim · 29/03/2023 23:04

Thing is we're told to open up and share. We're told that our friends "would want to know" and when someone dies by suicide we hear how everybody who knew them just wished the person had told them how they'd been feeling.

And actually it's not true. Very few people want to know. They think they do, and it sounds abjectly mean to say they don't want to hear, but the relative is that they actually don't. They just want their friends and family members and, perhaps, colleagues to be ok.

I don't blame them, because listening to someone with MH problems can be tough, frustrating and disempowering. But it's simply not true that everybody who says "I wish I knew", actually wanted to hear it.

And it's not like arthritis, or other physical ailments because often the social support, understanding and empathy would soften the impact of many MH issues. And that's assuming they're not part of the underlying problem in the first place.

Alicehatter · 29/03/2023 22:56

EmmaEmerald · 28/03/2023 23:01

Also, I have compassion fatigue frankly. And when a young person tells me they have depression, i feel like saying "well, I was diagnosed long before it was fashionable, dahling". I honestly wonder if doctors have gone from being reluctant to diagnose to being keen to diagnose.

This.
It took me years to see MH issues in the same way as say, diabetes or arthritis, but they're exactly the same - a health condition. I'm no longer embarrassed to admit I have MH issues but controversially I have to admit I think it's banded about too much these days and I agree that doctors seem keen to diagnose it. On the flip side, I've seen people squirm with embarrassment when I've told them I have issues, which is weird considering how much we're told to discuss it and accept it in the same context as aforementioned conditions! 🤷🏼‍♀️ Anyway, I don't dump on my friends but do tell them when I'm having a 'down day', and they sit with me, talk to me about normal day to day happenings and distract me from my mind ❤️

XenoBitch · 29/03/2023 22:12

In terms of opening up about MH issues, there is a difference between saying you have xyz diagnosis and maybe informing people about it, and what some might call " trauma dumping".
I have had to pull away from friends with MH issues, as they were using me as an untrained and unpaid therapist. Yet, they will then go on to say I abandoned them due to their MH issues, and say they should have never opened up about them.

EmmaEmerald · 28/03/2023 23:43

Would anyone want to give an example of something they feel they should be able to share? Barold your post struck me in particular, as I often say to mum "could we talk about something more cheerful" and she gets cross and says "why isn't this an okay topic".

MysteryBelle · 28/03/2023 23:34

Same here. I agree with pp that it is hard to find people you can actually trust, that it usually does no good and somehow ends up with them betraying you or telling others they know you don’t trust. My situation was not a mental health issue exactly, just problems with certain vicious people in my life and I was so shocked and disappointed that the very few I confided in, either turned around and told everybody or secretly SIDED with the person who was awful to me.

Weirdly, it’s just easier to confide in my husband as what I say to him goes in one ear and out the other so while that means he then is still nice to my ‘enemy’, at least I don’t have to worry about him telling anyone since he didn’t really pay attention 😂

Barold · 28/03/2023 23:28

I’ve encountered this in recent years - and I always talk about my struggles factually so it’s not like I’m burdening them with any overly emotional sharing. I can also usually still muster up some banter and a laugh in the same conversation so I don’t completely drain the joy out of the room.

If I’m honest, I’m generally not looking for them to soothe me or say much either - I’m usually just explaining why I haven’t got much to report or didn’t have a good day or whatever. 🤷🏼‍♀️

It’s very hard. I couldn’t imagine doing the same in return.

Anyway, I don’t really share any of it now. But, like with you, I wish I hadn’t shared in the first place.

SpookySpoon22 · 28/03/2023 23:11

Greenfairydust · 28/03/2023 22:49

FFS.

If someone disappears because you mention you have a mental health condition, they were never your friends in the first place.

I have a long term health condition that causes chronic pain and also struggled with PTSD/childhood trauma.

I don't expect anyone to be my therapist or to care for me and I am very independent but I certainly am not going to hide the fact that I have health issues or had mental health issues because it might make people uncomfortable.

All that nonsense just keeps perpetuating stigma around disability/mental health.

People should not feel like they have to hide a part of who they are, as if it was some kind of dirty secret, just to be accepted.

I agree with this. I thought times had moved on and people had more awareness of mental health difficulties these days. We are all encouraged not to bottle things up, especially when we know this has sadly led to people unexpectedly taking their own lives. If a friend can't take some honesty and real talk, they aren't a true friend. It takes guts OP to be open about your struggles and I applaud you for it. I'm so sorry you've not been met with compassion and understanding.

EmmaEmerald · 28/03/2023 23:01

Also, I have compassion fatigue frankly. And when a young person tells me they have depression, i feel like saying "well, I was diagnosed long before it was fashionable, dahling". I honestly wonder if doctors have gone from being reluctant to diagnose to being keen to diagnose.

EmmaEmerald · 28/03/2023 22:57

OP I was diagnosed 25 years ago. Only told best friend and family as there was a stigma. I was scared to tell them. I have since told a couple of others but only because circumstances arose that made it relevant.

It wasn't a huge problem but they kind of didn't believe it. My mum and sister still forget that I have it and then get confused when I can't cope with certain things, or have a crying jag like I've had today.

Sorry, that was the long winded version. I'd be careful who you tell and I don't want my work contacts to know. I think it's really damaging that workplaces are telling people to open up. Frankly, I think there's an agenda there. I preferred it when this stuff was private.

I am sorry to hear you've had this experience. It's interesting to hear others talk of compassion fatigue. It's obviously your decision who you tell going forward but I will not be adding to the list of people who know unless it benefits me.

hamstersarse · 28/03/2023 22:54

I’m very sorry to hear of your experiences

I’ve always thought it to be absolutely terrible advice to have this narrative of encouraging people to open up about their MH in real life, in work, with every acquaintance and friend. It’s not straightforward and can make you more isolated, people can be cruel, impatient, scared for themselves….all sorts of things,and I think people should disclose their mh issues carefully

Greenfairydust · 28/03/2023 22:49

FFS.

If someone disappears because you mention you have a mental health condition, they were never your friends in the first place.

I have a long term health condition that causes chronic pain and also struggled with PTSD/childhood trauma.

I don't expect anyone to be my therapist or to care for me and I am very independent but I certainly am not going to hide the fact that I have health issues or had mental health issues because it might make people uncomfortable.

All that nonsense just keeps perpetuating stigma around disability/mental health.

People should not feel like they have to hide a part of who they are, as if it was some kind of dirty secret, just to be accepted.

wingburgerflower · 28/03/2023 21:47

It's very important to be selective and careful who you open up to and ideally do so to a relevant and qualified professional rather than friends or family because everyone is struggling and everyone hates an energy vampire. People have no capacity these days.

TomatoFrog · 28/03/2023 12:05

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Nily4567 · 28/03/2023 11:49

I had a very similar experience. It was pretty much dismissed by family and friends the few times over the years when I attempted to talk about it.

when I had a, what seemed to me, a pretty major breakdown a few years ago it really showed that who thought of as friends weren’t really anymore that acquaintances from a past life.

it was very sobering, I thought meant more to people and that I’d always tried to be there for them.

Maybe I just felt rejected, I don’t know - maybe I hadn’t been the friend to them I thought I was. Who knows.

Met one person who accepted me and all my issues and I couldn’t handle it. My own worst enemy at times.

good luck with your journey

PlantMania · 28/03/2023 11:36

I am usually a very private person and like you, have hidden "that part"of my life for years as I have been afraid of people's reaction and because ultimately I'm ashamed. A few years back I was going through a really low spot and I tentatively tried to open up to a few friends who I thought were the more caring types. One physically turned her back to me when I told her about my anxiety and completely ignored what I had said as if she hasn't heard and went on to talk about some tv programme! Never to be spoken about again. Another, listened but then told me that she wasn't a support worker and despite living less than 10 minutes away and drove past my house daily, didn't bother to check in on me at all during that time. Tellingly though, she still asked for favours and to help out with her kids! I can't go into it all but needless to say, neither are in my life anymore and I've stuffed it all back down . Better to keep it locked away inside unfortunately.

Mentalhealthstruggles · 28/03/2023 11:24

Thank you everyone, it’s always comforting to know that you aren’t alone in an experience- is sad as the experience is. 💐

OP posts:
threecupsofteaminimum · 28/03/2023 10:59

Definitely. My family are the worst. I'm very selective now about who I speak with and about what. I hope you're ok. Flowers

Mentalhealthstruggles · 28/03/2023 10:39

I was never looking for my friends to help me, be my therapists etc. just wanted to be honest about myself. Never asked for advice or help from anyone.
I regret it now.

OP posts: