Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lack of independence in some adults

214 replies

Violaviolin · 28/03/2023 09:40

I am always amazed that some adults seem completely incapable of independence. The last week or so has shown up so many things.

  1. A friend saying her husband puts petrol in the car for her as she 'wouldn't know what to do.' She's been driving for over 10 years.
  1. A different friend saying there's 'no way she could fly by herself.' She's 36.
  1. Friends/family constantly having to check what partners are doing before agreeing to meet (not a childcare situation).
  1. Colleagues saying they can't drive to x and asking for a lift (miles out of my way) despite the fact they can drive and have a car. I'm nervous driving in cities but you just have to get on with it don't you.
  1. People who say they couldn't live by themselves.

AIBU that too many people lack independence?

OP posts:
Fallingoffacliff · 28/03/2023 10:21

I sympathise with people who suffer with genuine anxiety ( I say genuine, as its become a rather overused word ) but some people ( women, in my experience ) just become lazy eg husband always fills the car with petrol. Having said that, it's their business. I've been divorced 20 odd years so I'm as independent as a person can be.

SavBlancTonight · 28/03/2023 10:20

I think there's a difference between gendered incompetence - eg the women who can't put petrol in or the men who can't cook - and general incompetence. The first IS irritating as hell, yes, but its part of a complicated societal expectation of gendered expectations etc (And I know a lot of women who absolutely could/can do tires/petrol etc but are quite happy to say they can't because frankly it's one of the few tasks their DHs will take on).

For me, the kind of general incompetence that I see and find annoying (and agree with OP) on is things like:

oh, I can't sign up my child to that camp/sporting event/ after school activity online, can someone else do it for me?
Or
People who can't seem to read emails from school or other activities so ask questions that have been answered a dozen times (because they can't read them, or they have lost the email or whatever. And everyone does this now and again, but we all know those people who never ever manage it).
or
People you travel with who can't make a single plan/figure out a public transport system etc

Those sort of incompetent people are the ones that drive me mad. They don't seem to care that someone else must do it for them or that these are really basic simple skills that are completely normal in this day and age.

Flossflower · 28/03/2023 10:18

I think you are judgemental. People can be dependent on lots of things as well as other people. Some people are dependent on drugs, including cigarettes and alcohol. Some people can’t stop themselves from eating too much. I have my own car but I don’t like driving far. The only person I would expect to drive me is my husband, otherwise I would go by public transport or get a taxi

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 28/03/2023 10:14

One thing that shocked me some years ago, was an OU student saying how terrified she’d been at the thought of a week long residential school - in over 20 years of marriage she had never spent a single night away from her husband.

MrsSkylerWhite · 28/03/2023 10:14

There are very few things I wouldn’t attempt at least once but that’s my mindset. Others are different. Doesn’t bother me at all.

StrawberryWater · 28/03/2023 10:13

My two SIL’s are like that. Just completely helpless. We call them the daughters of the late colonel.

One still lives at home with her parents and can’t even work a washing machine or make toast for herself (she works but her mum will still get clothes out for her). The other is a little bit more independent and lives on her own but even then she can’t function without simple tasks being handled by someone else (such as the petrol thing or even buying a fridge which she can only do if a man gives her an opinion on it).

Neither are mentally or physically disabled. They just like to play this wee “I’m a woman so I must be helpless” role. They thing they’re being cute. Personally I think it’s creepy and lazy.

alwaysmovingforwards · 28/03/2023 10:13

We're all different and ain't none of us good at everything. Part of a relationship is covering each other so that as a team you're stronger than two identical individuals.

But it can put you at risk if you're no longer in that relationship. So it pays to know how to do stuff. I often think it's terrifying how many people who's OH does all the finances / life admin. Fine if they like doing the actual admin, but to not have an overview / basic understanding is just a derelict mindset.

Wfhwannabe · 28/03/2023 10:12

I'm with you op.

I live alone and find the incapability of many people to just find a way to do things for themselves exhausting.

I do everything you mention, except flying. I've had not reason or desire to fly since I was a child, pre 9/11. I have no plans to in the future. But if for some reason I had to I would find a way. Surely I can Google 'how to get through airport check in'?

Peoplepissmeoff · 28/03/2023 10:12

Good for you that you are able to do all of those things, but it's easy to judge when you're not dealing with anxiety, autism, introversion for example. The tasks you have mentioned vcan be huge challenges for some people. My husband puts petrol in my car, not because I don't know know how to do it but I get anxious in public places and feel pressured when I'm being watched. Sounds daft doesn't it but just be grateful you don't face these challenges yourself.

JamSandle · 28/03/2023 10:11

It's normal to me. We all have different strengths, weaknesses and personalities. I dont drive due to anxiety but I work full time and travel loads on my own.

DigitalTranny · 28/03/2023 10:10

DigitalTranny · 28/03/2023 10:09

Heavy physical stuff like changing the tires is very different from travelling alone, booking tickets online or changing a lightbulb.

This was meant for Catspyjamas17

LexMitior · 28/03/2023 10:09

Some of this is learned female incompetence- the giveaway is always, I couldn't do that.

What they mean is "I wouldn't do that".

Just don't jump in and do it for them unless you are prepared to do it over and over again.

Noicant · 28/03/2023 10:09

I struggle a bit but I have an anxiety disorder. I have lived by myself and got on a plane myself, I think sometimes when a person has an alternative rather than having to do something they find difficult they will take it.

DigitalTranny · 28/03/2023 10:09

Heavy physical stuff like changing the tires is very different from travelling alone, booking tickets online or changing a lightbulb.

PrehistoricGarbageTruck · 28/03/2023 10:08

I largely agree but I think you have to be careful judging someone if you don't know the full picture. I have a very intelligent thoughtful friend who, when I first met, mentioned they have trouble driving due to anxiety. I admit I slightly dismissed it - however they later explained the reasons and it was due to several specific incidents and other issues they have going on.

We all have our different anxieties.

This is so true. And often there are understandable reasons for them.

Snoken · 28/03/2023 10:05

Spendonsend · 28/03/2023 10:02

I dont think its cute or feminie to find motorways stressful! I find it fucking annoying.

I dont think anyone has ever associated the words cute or feminine with me, ever.

I do sometimes find motorways stressful but that is not because I am trying to be cute, I wish I could be cooler about it. I especially get nervous when there are a lot of HGVs and buses as it feels intimidating when in a small car. I still do the driving, but it's not enjoyable and I'd rather not.

Montgolfiergray34 · 28/03/2023 10:05

ComtesseDeSpair · 28/03/2023 09:56

I think the problem is that it isn’t “some adults” or that we’re “all different”: it’s that it’s almost invariably women who display this sort of helplessness and childlike dependency. How many men have you ever heard saying they wouldn’t know how to put petrol in the family car, or are nervous of driving on busy roads, or couldn’t travel on their own?

I don’t know whether it’s learned behaviour, because some women think that it’s feminine to be naive or that men find helplessness attractive, but it’s behaviour which really limits many women’s lives, not just a cute quirk.

Mmmm. I think there are cultural reasons for this. Men are mostly happy to jump in a car and run an errand rather than clean a lavatory.

ThreeFeetTall · 28/03/2023 10:04

I think if you can't do some things (due to anxiety etc) then you should seek what treatment you can for it.
I saw another thread where it said you shouldn't sit in another persons booked seat on a train because they might be too anxious to ask you politely to move. I mean...if you can't talk briefly to another adult then you should work on that as it will be impeding your life a lot.

FranklySonImTheGaffer · 28/03/2023 10:03

Also, thinking about your examples. DH would hate to live alone - he wouldn't be nervous but he needs company for his own well-being whereas I'd have no issues living alone.

And although we have no dc, we tend to check in with each other before making plans incase we already have plans and one of us has forgotten. That's just good manners I think.

Catspyjamas17 · 28/03/2023 10:02

I never really do anything with the car other than fill it with fuel as I get the annual service and MOT and DH tops up screen wash. And there's no way I could change a wheel on my own- I know how in principle but it isn't always even possible anyway. Last time DH had to use brute force to get the wheel nuts off, even though I am fit and healthy, and strong, I do yoga and lift weights, I would not have been able to shift them on my own. And one time we had a hire car, neither of use could budge the wheel nuts. Recovery came out and needed power tools to remove them.

As I am responsible for an awful lot of other fucking tedious things in life I'm glad I don't have to bother with this stuff.

It's not lack of independence, it's delegation.

Snoken · 28/03/2023 10:02

I have a friend like this too and it baffles me. Her husband has to do everything for her, book train tickets, pay bills, organise taxi's, maintain her car (oil check, washer fluids, petrol) etc. She doesn't have or know how to navigate online banking, she has never paid a bill, hasn't worked since she was a teenager and she only recently started using a bank card rather than just cash.

I find it hard to understand her choices but she is a lot of fun to hang out with and she is the kindest person I know. I try to nudge her into becoming more independent, especially since her husband is a lot older and won't be around forever, but she doesn't really see the problem.

Spendonsend · 28/03/2023 10:02

I dont think its cute or feminie to find motorways stressful! I find it fucking annoying.

I dont think anyone has ever associated the words cute or feminine with me, ever.

EilonwyWithRedGoldHair · 28/03/2023 10:02

ComtesseDeSpair · 28/03/2023 09:56

I think the problem is that it isn’t “some adults” or that we’re “all different”: it’s that it’s almost invariably women who display this sort of helplessness and childlike dependency. How many men have you ever heard saying they wouldn’t know how to put petrol in the family car, or are nervous of driving on busy roads, or couldn’t travel on their own?

I don’t know whether it’s learned behaviour, because some women think that it’s feminine to be naive or that men find helplessness attractive, but it’s behaviour which really limits many women’s lives, not just a cute quirk.

DH can't cook pasta, he just seems to have a blind spot for it. And this is someone who will make a curry from scratch (including base gravy) so it's not that he can't cook, he just finds pasta weirdly difficult for some reason.

(And there is no way I could fly by myself, but then I wouldn't want to fly with anyone either. Terrified of it, proper phobia.)

Montgolfiergray34 · 28/03/2023 10:01

TinaTeaspoons · 28/03/2023 09:48

We all have our different anxieties.
I wouldn't like flying alone but loved living alone when I had the opportunity.

Exactly this ^.

I'm so scared of flying that I haven't done it for over 25 years but I live in a very isolated situation that most people find very scary and I am alone there 75% of the time.

I don't drive in strange cities but I can gallop at 30 miles an hour on the back of a horse and jump an obstacle.

I wouldn't choose to travel on the London underground but I can wrangle a 700 kilo bull in to the back of a trailer by myself if it was necessary although for safety's sake you would probably do that with help.

FranklySonImTheGaffer · 28/03/2023 10:00

I don't think it's necessarily a man/woman thing, just that it's done differently because of societal expectations.

My parents are a perfect example. Both are intelligent, competent adults who hold down jobs.
My mum would tell you she can't put air in her tyres, drive new places or do anything in the garden.
My dad would tell you he doesn't know how to do laundry or cook a roast.

It's annoying either way but it happens. I don't drive long distances because my sense of direction is rubbish and it makes me stressed, plus I hate driving. DH enjoys it so he does it. It works for us and I know I can do it if I need to (have done so before).

You sound very judgmental OP.