Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lack of independence in some adults

214 replies

Violaviolin · 28/03/2023 09:40

I am always amazed that some adults seem completely incapable of independence. The last week or so has shown up so many things.

  1. A friend saying her husband puts petrol in the car for her as she 'wouldn't know what to do.' She's been driving for over 10 years.
  1. A different friend saying there's 'no way she could fly by herself.' She's 36.
  1. Friends/family constantly having to check what partners are doing before agreeing to meet (not a childcare situation).
  1. Colleagues saying they can't drive to x and asking for a lift (miles out of my way) despite the fact they can drive and have a car. I'm nervous driving in cities but you just have to get on with it don't you.
  1. People who say they couldn't live by themselves.

AIBU that too many people lack independence?

OP posts:
butterfliedtwo · 28/03/2023 11:05

People who don't know anything about finances through choice are going to be up shit's creek if the partner leaves or dies. It's about taking care of yourself as an adult.

pncr · 28/03/2023 11:05

I don't even do my own cleaning. I have a cleaner. I'm disabled. So I suppose I lose at that too according to some on this thread.

I really wonder why posters on here are so judgemental of others.

I don't ask anyone to do anything for me for free - my cleaner is paid well, I get a taxi or public transport if I don't want to drive (usually a combination of both - taxi to the train station and then the train or a bus).

What does it matter to you if I don't drive?

Wishawisha · 28/03/2023 11:04

I actually do disagree with you.

One of the liberating things about becoming an adult, having people in my life that I chose to be there and having enough money to be able to delegate the tasks I find hard or don’t want to do is that I can pick and choose what I do in my life, within reason. Is the friend who doesn’t put petrol in her own car hurting anyone? Maybe your friend who doesn’t fly alone has considered flying alone and decided … shock horror… what she doesn’t want to?

I’ve flown alone lots in the past but not in the past 10 years or so and now I don’t fly for work and have a family and go on holiday abroad max once a year, I can quite plausibly see that I’ll never fly alone again. That’s fine. Why is that an issue?

Between DH and I we have delegated tasks, things he does and things I do. It makes us both happier.

This reminds me a bit of the stupid “snack” thread - as an adult I rarely eat 3 square meals a day. I just graze all day long. Is that … a problem to anyone? Why can’t we just live our adult lives as we want?

Bawdrip · 28/03/2023 11:04

Violaviolin · 28/03/2023 10:57

My thread isn't confrontational at all. Not being defensive at all. No I can't do plumbing. I am sure the vast proportion of the population can't either. I can do basic plumbing things like re pressurising my boiler etc and I'm sure I could do more if I really wanted to. If I needed to learn, I would.

And if I NEEDED to go to the bar and order by myself I would. But I would still feel excruciatingly uncomfortable doing it. And because I don't go to bars without my dp, I don't need to. But thanks for letting me know that I'm being judged for not doing it, I'll add that to my list of things that I know I'm being judged for.

My point was, nobody is good at everything and we all have our idiosyncrasies. But everyone is good or confident at something.

Oopswediditagain2023 · 28/03/2023 11:03

I agree mostly, especially with friends of mine who let their own "anxieties" get to their kids and then their kids lose their independence and miss out on opportunities. My goddaughter had an opportunity to go abroad on a volunteering trip when she was 16 but her mother was horrified and went on and on and on about how she herself couldn't do something like that, what if she didn't like the food, what if the bed wasn't comfy etc - very trivial things, so her daughter missed out on the trip which was a shame. I see it too with driving, where because the mother won't drive on motorways etc, they then don't let their own daughters drive on motorways or make it into a big thing.

That said I do always check what my partner's doing before I make plans but it's more as a courtesy and he does the same with me

BubziOwl · 28/03/2023 11:02

DigitalTranny · 28/03/2023 09:51

I love nothing more than doing things myself and being independent. To be so dependent on others would be the death of me.
I know a woman who completely relies on her husband to put the rubbish sacks from their house outside which literally takes 1-2 minutes and no heavy lifting is involved whatsoever. She never does it herself, saying it’s a man’s job 🙄

I mean, the bins are my husband's job in our house. I never do it because I just don't like it. That doesn't mean I'm dependant on him to do it. If he decides to leave me tonight, I'm sure I will be quite capable of putting the bins out this week...

Violaviolin · 28/03/2023 11:01

pncr · 28/03/2023 11:00

Your have been scathing and very confrontational and you completely ignored sensible posts.

I haven't been scathing at all. I haven't replied to all comments as there are too many.

OP posts:
Divorcedalongtime · 28/03/2023 11:01

I agree with the parts where many women need to check with husband first. As a single parent for over 10 years I’ve never understood how they can’t plan a single thing at a weekend without partner.

I have also found that those women tend to bring husband up in literally any conversation whilst men rarely mention their wives.
I do think it’s a power imbalance for sure.

my friends got divorced after 19 years and suddenly realised how much fuel cost because husband had made that his job tk fill her car up every week. That really shocked me.

Champagneforeveryone · 28/03/2023 11:00

DigitalTranny · 28/03/2023 09:51

I love nothing more than doing things myself and being independent. To be so dependent on others would be the death of me.
I know a woman who completely relies on her husband to put the rubbish sacks from their house outside which literally takes 1-2 minutes and no heavy lifting is involved whatsoever. She never does it herself, saying it’s a man’s job 🙄

I have a colleague who has "blue jobs and pink jobs". I was so taken aback by that when she told me that I was genuinely speechless. The funny thing is she seemed really proud of it and like it was funny 😲

The other one that gets me is when you see the threads on here where there's a spider or mouse in someone's house. The endless comments about burning the house down, moving to the next county etc just baffle me. These are grown ass women who want to be taken seriously in life and treated equally to men 🙄

pncr · 28/03/2023 11:00

Your have been scathing and very confrontational and you completely ignored sensible posts.

pncr · 28/03/2023 10:59

And fwiw I don't like driving at night because I have astigmatism and as my eyesight has worsened the halo effect and blinding lights of on coming traffic has got worse.

Again, that's a common age related thing. It's nothing to do with not wanting to drive at night, it's because I no longer feel I'm as competent, due to my vision.

I have (very expensive) new glasses ordered at the optician so I'm hoping they make a significant difference.

Imtryingnottobother · 28/03/2023 10:59

My mum and sil are like this. I think in some instances it’s a manipulation and she’s getting you to do something she doesn’t want to do. Other times she doesn’t seem to grasp that people might initially feel nervous doing the things she flatly refuses to do and that confidence is built up through repetition of it, it’s not something that people are magically born with.

Violaviolin · 28/03/2023 10:58

pncr · 28/03/2023 10:56

Why are you ignoring sensible comments op?

I'm a single parent of 20 years. I had to do stuff on my own.

Anxiety at menopause is very common.

Why are you so scathing? Is it better for me to take a cab or would you prefer I drove and had a panic attack on a busy motorway?

I've not been scathing.

OP posts:
coldmarchmorn · 28/03/2023 10:58

ComtesseDeSpair · 28/03/2023 10:53

Men do do it too - but as you acknowledge, with men it’s usually cleaning / shopping / childcare: basically “not knowing” about things which mean they get an easier life because mummy or wifey does all the shit work. With women it’s more often not driving / not being involved with or having access to family finances / not going out alone: things which make them more reliant and thus more vulnerable. How many women post on MN saying they’re in abusive relationships but are scared to leave because they wouldn’t know the first thing about living alone and have no idea what the family finances look like “because hubby has always done our banking / sorted out insurances”?

Sure, for some people it may be anxiety or mental health problems; but that alone doesn’t explain why the different incompetences are quite so gendered.

How is it not the same thing? Women not being able to put in petrol or drive places, or deal with bills, its to get him to do it for them. If these are things that make them more vulnerable, that's there fault for causing the issue, in the same way that men who get an easier life by letting wifey do the kids stuff are at risk of losing a relationship with the children later on.

Violaviolin · 28/03/2023 10:57

Kernackered · 28/03/2023 10:53

Lol, you literally started a confrontational thread! 😆 Was there any need? Are you feeling a bit defensive because you're no good at plumbing? It's OK, I'm not really judging you.

My thread isn't confrontational at all. Not being defensive at all. No I can't do plumbing. I am sure the vast proportion of the population can't either. I can do basic plumbing things like re pressurising my boiler etc and I'm sure I could do more if I really wanted to. If I needed to learn, I would.

OP posts:
pncr · 28/03/2023 10:56

Why are you ignoring sensible comments op?

I'm a single parent of 20 years. I had to do stuff on my own.

Anxiety at menopause is very common.

Why are you so scathing? Is it better for me to take a cab or would you prefer I drove and had a panic attack on a busy motorway?

LexMitior · 28/03/2023 10:56

Strategic helplessness can be very controlling in practice. It can be an effective way of not doing something which you then have to do their order.

That can be a function of anxiety but also, it can be done to ruin otherwise relaxing times for other people.

Strategic incompetence is pretty clear because that person won't make a decent effort to try. Those people are tiresome and at worst, controlling.

coldmarchmorn · 28/03/2023 10:55

Violaviolin · 28/03/2023 10:46

But why? Partners aren't joined at the hip or certainly shouldn't be. If I want to go out with friends then I will. I don't need permission.

Of course you don't need permission. But do you not talk to each other about what you're doing? If you both just do whatever you want, without any conversation, what about clashes? What about children or dogs or work etc?

It's really not weird to check in with your partner about your schedules!

allthebestmumsusethefword · 28/03/2023 10:54

*disabilities

Kernackered · 28/03/2023 10:53

Violaviolin · 28/03/2023 10:44

Is there any need to be so confrontational?

Lol, you literally started a confrontational thread! 😆 Was there any need? Are you feeling a bit defensive because you're no good at plumbing? It's OK, I'm not really judging you.

donttellmehesalive · 28/03/2023 10:53

I think there's a distinction between people who know they've got a problem and are trying to address it, through medication or counselling or just pushing themselves out of their comfort zone sometimes, and those who just resign themselves to never doing the things that a nt, independent adult should be able to achieve. I don't understand the second group at all but know lots of them.

ComtesseDeSpair · 28/03/2023 10:53

coldmarchmorn · 28/03/2023 10:50

Oh please! Men do it to, just with different things! Men who can't work a washing machine, don't know how to cook, can't look after children, can't change a nappy, don't understand romance, who can't shop on their own, for even their own clothes.

There are men like this, there are women like this. Learned helplessness, weaponised incompetence, manipulative neediness. It's not a female only thing, by a very long shot.

Men do do it too - but as you acknowledge, with men it’s usually cleaning / shopping / childcare: basically “not knowing” about things which mean they get an easier life because mummy or wifey does all the shit work. With women it’s more often not driving / not being involved with or having access to family finances / not going out alone: things which make them more reliant and thus more vulnerable. How many women post on MN saying they’re in abusive relationships but are scared to leave because they wouldn’t know the first thing about living alone and have no idea what the family finances look like “because hubby has always done our banking / sorted out insurances”?

Sure, for some people it may be anxiety or mental health problems; but that alone doesn’t explain why the different incompetences are quite so gendered.

allthebestmumsusethefword · 28/03/2023 10:53

Some people can't 'just get on with it' and have anxieties and/or hidden siabilities, by their very nature you won't necessarily aware of. No need to change those people or 'nudge' them along as a pp mentioned. Just let them be 🌸

SpaceOP · 28/03/2023 10:52

I don't really care if people choose not to do certain things because they have a partner to do it for them. I do have very little sympathy if they refuse to learn how to do those things when heir partner isn't there or, on a more day to day basis, if they refuse to even try new things. My mum was a baker and loved making cakes. My dad loves eating cakes and never baked. Now he has taught himself a few basic things as she's no longer there to do it for him.

MIL once made us all return from a day out because she absolutely refused to check in for her flight online via a phone. She insisted it had to be done via her computer at home. Possibly, that's a slightly different thing - fear of new things, but her refusal to even attempt it, even with us helping, made me so mad.

coldmarchmorn · 28/03/2023 10:50

ComtesseDeSpair · 28/03/2023 09:56

I think the problem is that it isn’t “some adults” or that we’re “all different”: it’s that it’s almost invariably women who display this sort of helplessness and childlike dependency. How many men have you ever heard saying they wouldn’t know how to put petrol in the family car, or are nervous of driving on busy roads, or couldn’t travel on their own?

I don’t know whether it’s learned behaviour, because some women think that it’s feminine to be naive or that men find helplessness attractive, but it’s behaviour which really limits many women’s lives, not just a cute quirk.

Oh please! Men do it to, just with different things! Men who can't work a washing machine, don't know how to cook, can't look after children, can't change a nappy, don't understand romance, who can't shop on their own, for even their own clothes.

There are men like this, there are women like this. Learned helplessness, weaponised incompetence, manipulative neediness. It's not a female only thing, by a very long shot.