Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lack of independence in some adults

214 replies

Violaviolin · 28/03/2023 09:40

I am always amazed that some adults seem completely incapable of independence. The last week or so has shown up so many things.

  1. A friend saying her husband puts petrol in the car for her as she 'wouldn't know what to do.' She's been driving for over 10 years.
  1. A different friend saying there's 'no way she could fly by herself.' She's 36.
  1. Friends/family constantly having to check what partners are doing before agreeing to meet (not a childcare situation).
  1. Colleagues saying they can't drive to x and asking for a lift (miles out of my way) despite the fact they can drive and have a car. I'm nervous driving in cities but you just have to get on with it don't you.
  1. People who say they couldn't live by themselves.

AIBU that too many people lack independence?

OP posts:
Crazyshihtzulady · 28/03/2023 11:49

Hbh17 · 28/03/2023 09:47

YANBU and, sadly, more often than not it's women who behave like this. Which gives the rest of us a bad name. What do these people think will happen if/when their partner or parents are no longer around? We all have to learn to do things alone & for ourselves, it's just basic stuff.

Why does it give the rest of us a bad name? we don't all have to be clones of each other because we have the same genitals!

Chessetchelsea · 28/03/2023 11:44

Learned female incompetence is exactly it.

The weirdest thing to me is when other people ACCEPT IT AS NORMAL. What’s that about? SIL who won’t drive. Or MIL who can’t possibly wield a paintbrush. It’s just accepted that they don’t do these things. They could if they wanted to!!!

JaneyGee · 28/03/2023 11:44

A lot of people like to keep others helpless and dependent. I've seen it time and again. Parents do it to their children, and husbands do it to their wives. They take over, and keep the other person ignorant, weak and helpless so that they'll never leave. My maternal grandfather did it to my grandmother. He ran all the finances, and got the shopping, because he had abandonment issues from childhood. My father was exactly the same. He would sulk like a child if my mum went anywhere. And I've seen parents do it to adult children. My ageing mum now does it to my adult brother to stop him leaving home.

Scalottia · 28/03/2023 11:35

YourApplePie · 28/03/2023 10:21

I'm fiercely independent but admit to becoming a passive 50s housewife on bin day because it's cold outside and rubbish is icky 😁

🙄

LivingDeadGirlUK · 28/03/2023 11:33

Is the driving thing from a culture of cars being a hobby for men when they first learn and women less so? I can't drive so never learned but when I was 16/17 the lads all used to be tinkering with the cars every weekend and driving around like idiots whenever they could, none of the women I knew who could drive did this.

My partner only learned to drive in his 30's and is very cautious. although having to do lots of long distance driving has helped. He would say he doesn't like driving on rural roads and we sometimes change our route so there are less non dual carriageways.

OttilieKnackered · 28/03/2023 11:31

I can’t put petrol in the car but then I can’t drive it either, which I know much of MN thinks is appalling. However, I do earn most of the money, organise our lives and rarely ask DP for a lift. But if i do, y’know, I’ve carried our child for 9 months. I think he can run me into town occasionally. We live in a city with good public transport so rarely an issue.

I think there is a bit difference between ‘I can’t do that’ and ‘I don’t usually do that.’ Eg DP takes the bins out 99% of the time and I cook 99% of the time but we’re both capable of the other. Even with driving, 99% of the time there’s another way for me
to get somewhere.

A good friend of mine, however, has never paid a bill or organised a mortgage etc. She has no idea how much her and her husband have in savings. If he was suddenly not there I would really worry about her ability to cope. I loved single/alone for a good 5 years and managed fine.

HikingforScenery · 28/03/2023 11:31

CoffeeCantata · 28/03/2023 11:22

Surfingthewaves · Today 09:51
Why can’t you all just accept that we’re all different? Humans can be quite complex with a mixture of strengths and weaknesses, we all have different skill sets. You come across as being superior to others because you can do all the things you’ve listed. Maybe you should focus on what improvements you can make on yourself rather than judging others.

I don't agree. I think OP is making a valid point. It's often (in my case anyway) just laziness. I'm pretty independent in many ways (driving and some DIY) but I do let my other half do lots of car stuff which I'm perfectly capable of, but just shirk. Things like maintenance and checking tyre pressures and oil. I once changed a tyre myself, but that was long, long ago and I have to admit I've become 'de-skilled' in things I used to do. I'm talking about the normal (non-technically-demanding) range of tasks, it's easy to sit back and let someone else do things and then when you're suddenly called upon to manage, you find it impossible.

My mother was always very capable and independent, partly by nature, but also because she lost her husband fairly early on and had to get on with it, but my poor MIL left absolutely everything to her husband and when he died she was helpless. I mean - she had never been anywhere (doctor's, dentist's or even down to the shop/supermarket) without him for 40-odd years. We were 250 miles away, so it was a nightmare. She didn't even know how to lock up the house etc, or pay a utility bill. She had passed her driving test when young but had never driven since marriage and of course couldn't just take it up again.

Sometimes you have to make yourself get to grips with things - and I just mean things like life admin and knowing where the stopcock is...I realise some people will find challenging driving etc a problem.

Laziness isn’t lacking independence, is it? if they had to, they could?
I open jars just fine on my own. If DH or DC is there, I give it to them.
I agree with a pp. Some men love doing certain things for their wives because it makes them feel good. Some women just lean in to that.

SavBlancTonight · 28/03/2023 11:29

whattodo1975 · 28/03/2023 11:16

In fairness to men (they do all what you are saying) they never pull the "i cant drive to a place i dont know" card, i've alway been slightly fascinated as to why this seems a to be uniquely female issue.

I believe it's a complex societal issue. Boys, from a young age, are subtly taught that driving is dangerous and exciting and something they MUST learn. Girls less so (it's self perpetuating, of course - all those girls whose mothers don't drive much etc).

Then, when girls and boys are being taught, expectations are different. Both might be scared but the boys are expected to get on with it while girls are often allowed to be a bit more nervous and more accommodations are made for them.

And ultimately, the result is that boys learn to drive whether they're scared or not, and in the process learn to overcome those fears. And many girls don't.

Ask around your male and female friends. The kind of questions you can ask might be,
"where you scared learning to drive and did you feel you could admit it?"
"Were you encouraged to learn to drive or learn about cars from a young age?"
"When you were learning to drive, if you were nervous, what did your driving instructor do"
"Did your parents let you drive when you were a learner or did you have to wait for your lessons? AND did your parents encourage you to drive with them and not just with an instructor".
"How many lessons did it take you before you were driving fast enough to use 5th gear"
"Did you feel like learning to drive was something that was totally expected of you?"

In our family, learning to drive was considered an absolute necessity and there was no slack for any member of the family (2 girls, one boy). But I was very surprised to discover how many of my female friends' parents took a more casual approach. the boys all got their license within days of their birthdays... and certainly, that was the expectation in our house, but many of the girls took weeks or months before they got around to it. Not all, but a lot.

emituofo · 28/03/2023 11:26

Before I met my hubby I had been living abroad for 10 years, I learnt to speak English and finished my degree, I learnt to do everything myself because I had no families close by.

However since I had have been with my hubby, he took over a lot of responsibilities, ie filling up petrol, draling with bills, car maintenance etc, on the other hand I do all the shopping and cooking etc.

I dont think there is anything wrong with relying on each other for different things, we are a team. I do not need his permission to make decisions but for some decisions I would like to hear his opinions too.

donttellmehesalive · 28/03/2023 11:22

We had a new colleague join our team aged 22. She had to attend a training course that involved driving or taking the train. Her mum rang us to say it was an unreasonable request and that she wouldn't be doing it. When I think about helpless adults, this is the sort of thing that comes to mind.

HikingforScenery · 28/03/2023 11:22

whattodo1975 · 28/03/2023 11:16

In fairness to men (they do all what you are saying) they never pull the "i cant drive to a place i dont know" card, i've alway been slightly fascinated as to why this seems a to be uniquely female issue.

A close friend’s husband refuses to drive in our city centre. Another refuses to drive when they’re abroad. In both cases, their wives do the driving. It’s not uniquely a female issue.

CoffeeCantata · 28/03/2023 11:22

Surfingthewaves · Today 09:51
Why can’t you all just accept that we’re all different? Humans can be quite complex with a mixture of strengths and weaknesses, we all have different skill sets. You come across as being superior to others because you can do all the things you’ve listed. Maybe you should focus on what improvements you can make on yourself rather than judging others.

I don't agree. I think OP is making a valid point. It's often (in my case anyway) just laziness. I'm pretty independent in many ways (driving and some DIY) but I do let my other half do lots of car stuff which I'm perfectly capable of, but just shirk. Things like maintenance and checking tyre pressures and oil. I once changed a tyre myself, but that was long, long ago and I have to admit I've become 'de-skilled' in things I used to do. I'm talking about the normal (non-technically-demanding) range of tasks, it's easy to sit back and let someone else do things and then when you're suddenly called upon to manage, you find it impossible.

My mother was always very capable and independent, partly by nature, but also because she lost her husband fairly early on and had to get on with it, but my poor MIL left absolutely everything to her husband and when he died she was helpless. I mean - she had never been anywhere (doctor's, dentist's or even down to the shop/supermarket) without him for 40-odd years. We were 250 miles away, so it was a nightmare. She didn't even know how to lock up the house etc, or pay a utility bill. She had passed her driving test when young but had never driven since marriage and of course couldn't just take it up again.

Sometimes you have to make yourself get to grips with things - and I just mean things like life admin and knowing where the stopcock is...I realise some people will find challenging driving etc a problem.

Klunt · 28/03/2023 11:20

whattodo1975 · 28/03/2023 11:16

In fairness to men (they do all what you are saying) they never pull the "i cant drive to a place i dont know" card, i've alway been slightly fascinated as to why this seems a to be uniquely female issue.

My friend is terrified of driving and so is her boyfriend. They have about a 5 mile radius from their house that they travel to and that’s it. They’ve not once come to visit me since I moved 45 minutes away!

whattodo1975 · 28/03/2023 11:16

ComtesseDeSpair · 28/03/2023 09:59

And yes, some men do it with “not knowing” how to work the washing machine / sort out the children. But that faux helplessness is to their benefit, because somebody else (a woman) ends up doing the shit work. Whereas for women, it often puts them in a more vulnerable position, not a stronger one.

In fairness to men (they do all what you are saying) they never pull the "i cant drive to a place i dont know" card, i've alway been slightly fascinated as to why this seems a to be uniquely female issue.

HikingforScenery · 28/03/2023 11:16

I thought you were actually going to give actual examples of lack of independence.
I can do all the things you included in your OP. Go me?

None of those reflects whether someone i’d i dependent or not. Just your bar.

sheeeeeeshh · 28/03/2023 11:14

DigitalTranny · 28/03/2023 09:51

I love nothing more than doing things myself and being independent. To be so dependent on others would be the death of me.
I know a woman who completely relies on her husband to put the rubbish sacks from their house outside which literally takes 1-2 minutes and no heavy lifting is involved whatsoever. She never does it herself, saying it’s a man’s job 🙄

Well it's not a nice job. So let him crack on 🤷🏻‍♀️

MrsRinaDecker · 28/03/2023 11:14

I dunno, I live alone with my dc, have flown alone with and without them, drive on motorways when I need to, but I panic in medical appointments and need someone with me to take notes / remind me to ask questions. On the other hand, my mum is great with doctors, confident to speak up about (for example) bad service, but never learned to drive. We’re all different 🤷‍♀️

sheeeeeeshh · 28/03/2023 11:13

I mean checking in with your partner about diary dates is just courteous imo.

But agree that the other things are odd.

Catspyjamas17 · 28/03/2023 11:13

coldmarchmorn · 28/03/2023 10:50

Oh please! Men do it to, just with different things! Men who can't work a washing machine, don't know how to cook, can't look after children, can't change a nappy, don't understand romance, who can't shop on their own, for even their own clothes.

There are men like this, there are women like this. Learned helplessness, weaponised incompetence, manipulative neediness. It's not a female only thing, by a very long shot.

Yes, quite.

OnaBegonia · 28/03/2023 11:10

@thefamous5
I don't particularly like going out without him
Why is this?

Catspyjamas17 · 28/03/2023 11:10

I mean, the bins are my husband's job in our house. I never do it because I just don't like it. That doesn't mean I'm dependanton him to do it. If he decides to leave me tonight, I'm sure I will be quite capable of putting the bins out this week...

Yes quite. Perhaps men get the bin job as they do bugger all else.

Wishawisha · 28/03/2023 11:09

BubziOwl · 28/03/2023 11:02

I mean, the bins are my husband's job in our house. I never do it because I just don't like it. That doesn't mean I'm dependant on him to do it. If he decides to leave me tonight, I'm sure I will be quite capable of putting the bins out this week...

Yes what’s wrong exactly with not wanting to put the bins out and giving that task to someone who is willing to do it? I say this as someone who puts the bins out at least 50% of the time. But if I decide tomorrow that I don’t want to do it I don’t see who that impacts other than DH?

I clean my own windows rather than employ a window cleaner. I don’t know exactly why I do this but I quite enjoy the task and I don’t like dirty windows so like doing it often rather than waiting. Should I look down on people that have never cleaned a window? Conversely, I don’t have any interest in ever learning how to mow the lawn. If DH left me or died I would probably pay someone to come round and do it from time to time. Imagine the outrage!!!

Badleg85 · 28/03/2023 11:09

Yanbu. I have friends like this and it drives me mad. But interestingly my husband also has learned incompetence. If I died everything admin wise would fall apart

I see a lot of women stop driving and going places alone and I think it's so sad. To limit yourself like that. When I got my new car there was no spare wheel, just the puncture repair kit but I didn't know how to use it, after a bit google I decided to order myself a spare wheel and jack etc so that I could change a wheel if far from home rather then use the repair stuff. Friends were shocked and suggested they'd all just ring their husbands or the AA. Made no sense to me

LexMitior · 28/03/2023 11:07

@Oopswediditagain2023 - that transmission of mother anxiety to a child is a real issue. It affects children badly and it's not funny to have mothers still controlling their children by introducing anxieties to them. It's not parenting kids but putting blockers and obstacles in their way.

Heinzbakedbeans · 28/03/2023 11:06

Some things are anxiety - lots of people don't like flying/driving.

I've been told numerous times that I'm 'brave' because I take my young dcs on trains/buses and around London all on my own. Not sure how that's brave - if I didn't use public transport we'd never go anywhere without DP due to my fear of driving 😜 (I have dyspraxia and find driving so bloody difficult and genuinely think I'm a danger to others)