Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lack of independence in some adults

214 replies

Violaviolin · 28/03/2023 09:40

I am always amazed that some adults seem completely incapable of independence. The last week or so has shown up so many things.

  1. A friend saying her husband puts petrol in the car for her as she 'wouldn't know what to do.' She's been driving for over 10 years.
  1. A different friend saying there's 'no way she could fly by herself.' She's 36.
  1. Friends/family constantly having to check what partners are doing before agreeing to meet (not a childcare situation).
  1. Colleagues saying they can't drive to x and asking for a lift (miles out of my way) despite the fact they can drive and have a car. I'm nervous driving in cities but you just have to get on with it don't you.
  1. People who say they couldn't live by themselves.

AIBU that too many people lack independence?

OP posts:
Naunet · 28/03/2023 12:58

Hbh17 · 28/03/2023 09:47

YANBU and, sadly, more often than not it's women who behave like this. Which gives the rest of us a bad name. What do these people think will happen if/when their partner or parents are no longer around? We all have to learn to do things alone & for ourselves, it's just basic stuff.

No it’s not, you just notice it more when it’s women. Plenty of men claim they can’t work a washing machine, cook or parent their own children.

Klunt · 28/03/2023 12:56

Our bin has to be wheeled down a load of steps so deffo a man’s job here!

Trollsinmyeggbox · 28/03/2023 12:56

I'm really independent. I got ran my home, finances, cars, kids, bins etc when I was married and continued to do it when I got divorced. My partner now - of ten years - is capable but I still generally run things, he wouldn't know how much the utility direct debit is or which company the car insurance is with, I know more about car maintenance and am the one who drives when we go away.

But.

Behind closed doors I'm quite submissive and this does go into some of the day to day interactions at home. Part of liking playing a more submissive woman role in the relationship is because technically I know I'm not. At all!

SilhouettesOnTheShade · 28/03/2023 12:55

Surfingthewaves · 28/03/2023 09:51

Why can’t you all just accept that we’re all different? Humans can be quite complex with a mixture of strengths and weaknesses, we all have different skill sets. You come across as being superior to others because you can do all the things you’ve listed. Maybe you should focus on what improvements you can make on yourself rather than judging others.

Agreed.

SavBlancTonight · 28/03/2023 12:55

@Cosyblankets I wouldnt' say bins are a huge issue, but they do take time.

Inside, all recycling is added to one bin (except food recycling which goes in a caddy). At least once a day (it's a bit frightening how quickly it builds up), DH goes outside and separates the contents of the inside bin into the various bins we have for different types of recycling - glass, paper, plastic etc. This is not a big job but does take a few minutes at least.

On bin day, he then moves all the bins from the side of the house to the front. Again, not a big job, but does involve a bit of fiddling about and careful movements as there's not a lot of space to get out etc so it's not a 10 second job either. and it's irritating. He then brings them all back a bit later. Now and again he cleans them out or gets onto the council to order a new one.

It's not a massive job, I agree. And definitely less effort than the endless cooking and shopping I seem to do. But it is more than just throwing a glass bottle in a bin after I've finished the wine! Grin

coldmarchmorn · 28/03/2023 12:53

You said the only thing to do with a bin is to put it out once a week. That's obviously not true, which you appear to know.
So that was a rather silly think for you to say.

Cosyblankets · 28/03/2023 12:51

coldmarchmorn · 28/03/2023 12:37

You wheel it to the right place once a week? You don't put anything in it? You don't have 4 different bins and need to sort everything into those 4 bins? You don't need to clean them?

Do you have a magical bin that just takes trips to the kerb once a week with no other input from anyone?

We put rubbish in it on a daily basis. General stuff goes in the kitchen bin. When that's full someone puts it in the outside bin.
Recycling goes in the recycle bin outside on a daily basis. As a box or whatever is empty or a bottle etc it goes in the bin outside.
Garden stuff goes in the garden bin as the grass is cut.
I'm cooking at the min as I'm typing. I'm using something in a plastic box. When I've used the food in the box I will put it in the right bin
I don't understand what I'm doing that others are not doing.
I'm not saying we never dispute who does what housework but the bin is a non issue

Crazyshihtzulady · 28/03/2023 12:49

PrehistoricGarbageTruck · 28/03/2023 12:10

Well y'know some of us aren't raging feminists with a point to prove, we're just doing our best to get by in life.

The postet you were replying to explained why it would be impractical to rely on her partner and runs the risk of leaving her unable to do things if something happens to him. Yet you interpreted this as making some theoretical point?

Um no, I read it just fine thanks.

Maybe you need to go back and re-read it yourself?

SavBlancTonight · 28/03/2023 12:43

yeah, around here bins are an endless task. And yes, DH absolutely has to do it becuyase I do all the cooking and most of the post-dinner tidying up and quite frankly, that more than trumps his 10 minutes a day on bins (he does actually do plenty overall, but bins is one of the few tasks he takes on 100% and that he absolutely has to do and that can't just be ignored or delayed like with other tasks he might do side eyes the bedding that needs changing)

FriendofSmaug · 28/03/2023 12:43

As a guy agree that men often get encouraged to drive - at my school all the boys started driving lessons as soon as they could and it was socially v difficult to opt out of the process even though I was nervous of cars from outset. I had a really rocky start to driving - while learning I crashed my step mother's car (in an accident that was 100% my fault) and had driving lessons for a year before the instructor would let me take the test (and after I passed he said he was certain I would fail). Having passed my stepmother would not let me drive her (repaired) car saying that the test instructor had his opinion of my driving and she would stick with hers. So I did not have a car for about five years and developed a real fear of driving such that I thought I might never drive again. Eventually I got a car, took some refresher lessons (instructor said I should never have passed my test) and one of the most satisfying things of my life was sticking with it for the next 30 years (accident free) and doing some seriously long journeys (I have driven London to Scotland alone several times). If one finds something really difficult and scary, the mental reward for getting even moderately good at it over time can be huge.

coldmarchmorn · 28/03/2023 12:37

Cosyblankets · 28/03/2023 12:36

What's the obsession with bins on MN ?
it's really not a job! You just wheel it to the right place once a week or whatever. It's 2 minutes tops. In our house it goes a bit like this...
Have you put the bin out or shall I do it?
I put it out this afternoon.
....
That's it! Whoever thinks about it does it.
It's really not a thing

You wheel it to the right place once a week? You don't put anything in it? You don't have 4 different bins and need to sort everything into those 4 bins? You don't need to clean them?

Do you have a magical bin that just takes trips to the kerb once a week with no other input from anyone?

Cosyblankets · 28/03/2023 12:36

What's the obsession with bins on MN ?
it's really not a job! You just wheel it to the right place once a week or whatever. It's 2 minutes tops. In our house it goes a bit like this...
Have you put the bin out or shall I do it?
I put it out this afternoon.
....
That's it! Whoever thinks about it does it.
It's really not a thing

RampantIvy · 28/03/2023 12:30

My SIL has this learned helplessness, and always gets someone else to do things for her. When she needed her driving licence renewing recently, she was told (I can't remember who by) to just do it online. "Oh no, I'll get my son to do it". The son actually said "mam, you need to get out of your comfort zone sometimes", and she was extremely offended.

If I had been there I would have shown her how to do it.

She now complains that she is lonely because whenever anyone visits her she asks them to do things for her that she is perfectly capable of doing herself, so she gets fewer visitors now.

RemoteControlDoobry · 28/03/2023 12:25

I had to learn to do a lot of things for myself when I divorced. Some of those things I got used to like putting fuel in the car and driving within the local area. I will still only drive long distances at the weekend because I don’t like lorries and I don’t like to be in any situation where I have to trust other road users….I like full control of my car at all times. I flew once on my own in my twenties and I was so scared that I wet myself.

I was probably an extreme case because I’m autistic and only realised at the age of 42. But you remind me of my ex husband in that you don’t understand what it’s like to be so anxious about doing something alone that you can’t function. I would love to be more like you but my body reacts automatically.

FellPuck · 28/03/2023 12:20

I do agree with you, and find it hard to understand why others allow their worlds to become so small, in some cases.

I had a partner once who had a fear of taking train or plane journey to other places - that's not inherently an issue, but it is an issue that he didn't attempt to get any help to solve the problem. I couldn't accept being in a monogamous relationship with someone who has choosing to be that limited in their life, as by extension he was going to limit me as well.

I do get anxiety sometimes about driving to new places but I push through it because I refuse to be confined to my town, that's really no way to live. Similarly, certain car maintenance tasks I had no idea how to do initially, but I get out my phone, look it up on Youtube, and then crack on - or pay someone to do it.

It's ok not to know how to do important things, but I find it hard to respect people who know that they have a knowledge gap and do nothing about it.

ComtesseDeSpair · 28/03/2023 12:18

Montgolfiergray34 · 28/03/2023 12:05

Finally, the voice of reason ^ , totally agree and I would add that the desperation displayed on this thread for everyone to be like everyone else, and do everything the same, is surely a form of anxiety in itself?

“Anxious” is an odd word for it, I don’t get anxious over strangers; but yes, I do find it concerning that many women opt out of things like finances and self-transportation, and that this generally seems to be accepted and defended, when we know quite how many women are stuck in unhappy relationships or get shafted during divorce.

If somebody would prefer not to fly, that’s less of an issue, it’s not essential to do: although in the case of my former MIL, refusal to travel alone because her husband always booked the tickets, carried the suitcases, booked the early morning cab, arranged the transfers, exchanged the travel money etc has left her unable, out of fear of getting it wrong, unable to see her children and grandchildren as often as she’d like.

theemmadilemma · 28/03/2023 12:18

As a single mother from a small family my mother raised me to be fiercely independant around those types of things. (I'm 47.)

Not sure how to do that? Read up on it, figure it out, get it done. Nervous? Well, no choice, gotta get on with it, no one else to rely on.

Crazyshihtzulady · 28/03/2023 12:14

Champagneforeveryone · 28/03/2023 11:00

I have a colleague who has "blue jobs and pink jobs". I was so taken aback by that when she told me that I was genuinely speechless. The funny thing is she seemed really proud of it and like it was funny 😲

The other one that gets me is when you see the threads on here where there's a spider or mouse in someone's house. The endless comments about burning the house down, moving to the next county etc just baffle me. These are grown ass women who want to be taken seriously in life and treated equally to men 🙄

You can roll your eyes as much as you like but some people have a genuine phobia of the things you scoff at....

PrehistoricGarbageTruck · 28/03/2023 12:10

Well y'know some of us aren't raging feminists with a point to prove, we're just doing our best to get by in life.

The postet you were replying to explained why it would be impractical to rely on her partner and runs the risk of leaving her unable to do things if something happens to him. Yet you interpreted this as making some theoretical point?

Montgolfiergray34 · 28/03/2023 12:05

Wishawisha · 28/03/2023 11:04

I actually do disagree with you.

One of the liberating things about becoming an adult, having people in my life that I chose to be there and having enough money to be able to delegate the tasks I find hard or don’t want to do is that I can pick and choose what I do in my life, within reason. Is the friend who doesn’t put petrol in her own car hurting anyone? Maybe your friend who doesn’t fly alone has considered flying alone and decided … shock horror… what she doesn’t want to?

I’ve flown alone lots in the past but not in the past 10 years or so and now I don’t fly for work and have a family and go on holiday abroad max once a year, I can quite plausibly see that I’ll never fly alone again. That’s fine. Why is that an issue?

Between DH and I we have delegated tasks, things he does and things I do. It makes us both happier.

This reminds me a bit of the stupid “snack” thread - as an adult I rarely eat 3 square meals a day. I just graze all day long. Is that … a problem to anyone? Why can’t we just live our adult lives as we want?

Finally, the voice of reason ^ , totally agree and I would add that the desperation displayed on this thread for everyone to be like everyone else, and do everything the same, is surely a form of anxiety in itself?

Crazyshihtzulady · 28/03/2023 12:03

FiveShelties · 28/03/2023 10:49

I would hate to think I had to rely on my DH to fill my car up with fuel, or that I could not fly alone or order a drink in a bar.

I travel regularly between NZ and UK and would not think twice about hiring a car in both countries, filling it up with petrol and driving to a restaurant to order a meal and a drink.

How awful to be dependent on my DH for things which I can do and what happens if I am dependent and then something happens to him?

How can women claim to be equal and yet need a man to do these simple things?

Well y'know some of us aren't raging feminists with a point to prove, we're just doing our best to get by in life.

Crazyshihtzulady · 28/03/2023 11:53

You seem to really analyse others and look for ways to judge them.

It doesn't affect you so what's it to you?

Crazyshihtzulady · 28/03/2023 11:52

ComtesseDeSpair · 28/03/2023 09:56

I think the problem is that it isn’t “some adults” or that we’re “all different”: it’s that it’s almost invariably women who display this sort of helplessness and childlike dependency. How many men have you ever heard saying they wouldn’t know how to put petrol in the family car, or are nervous of driving on busy roads, or couldn’t travel on their own?

I don’t know whether it’s learned behaviour, because some women think that it’s feminine to be naive or that men find helplessness attractive, but it’s behaviour which really limits many women’s lives, not just a cute quirk.

Well I don't drive at all because I accept that I'm too scatty to drive and would hate it....Nothing to do with trying to be "cute/quirky".....

YourApplePie · 28/03/2023 11:51

Scalottia · 28/03/2023 11:35

🙄

Find me anyone who wants to go outside in sideways rain and haul around wheelie bins. It's a hill I'm willing to die on.

inamarina · 28/03/2023 11:51

TinaTeaspoons · 28/03/2023 09:48

We all have our different anxieties.
I wouldn't like flying alone but loved living alone when I had the opportunity.

This. Everyone is different and people might also change throughout life.
I used to fly alone fairly frequently and loved it. Haven’t been on a plane since Covid and now I definitely feel nervous about it, but I would manage.
Lived alone for a while and realised it wasn’t my thing, so I rented a flat with a friend.
I don’t drive as it causes me huge anxiety, but I’m planning to work on it.

Swipe left for the next trending thread