Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lack of independence in some adults

214 replies

Violaviolin · 28/03/2023 09:40

I am always amazed that some adults seem completely incapable of independence. The last week or so has shown up so many things.

  1. A friend saying her husband puts petrol in the car for her as she 'wouldn't know what to do.' She's been driving for over 10 years.
  1. A different friend saying there's 'no way she could fly by herself.' She's 36.
  1. Friends/family constantly having to check what partners are doing before agreeing to meet (not a childcare situation).
  1. Colleagues saying they can't drive to x and asking for a lift (miles out of my way) despite the fact they can drive and have a car. I'm nervous driving in cities but you just have to get on with it don't you.
  1. People who say they couldn't live by themselves.

AIBU that too many people lack independence?

OP posts:
ItsCalledAConversation · 28/03/2023 17:15

Yes, it’s pathetic to not be able to do simple things like filling up a car alone. It’s also dangerous.

People who aren’t good, competent, confident drivers shouldn’t be on the road, end of story.

GalileoHumpkins · 28/03/2023 17:11

Surfingthewaves · 28/03/2023 09:51

Why can’t you all just accept that we’re all different? Humans can be quite complex with a mixture of strengths and weaknesses, we all have different skill sets. You come across as being superior to others because you can do all the things you’ve listed. Maybe you should focus on what improvements you can make on yourself rather than judging others.

👏

Wineloffa · 28/03/2023 17:08

The thing about driving anxiety is that avoidance only feeds into and makes it so much worse. When I started driving 14 years ago, I absolutely hated it and would have done anything to avoid it. I was anxious, shaky, scared but I knew I wanted to be able to drive to see my parents whenever I wanted (300 mile round trip mostly on motorway) and the only way I could do it was to force myself to do it! And everytime I did it, it got a little easier and now I fly up and down the motorway with confidence.

For people who are scared of motorways, try doing a few trips at 6am at weekends when the road is quieter. Stay in the left hand lane and use Google maps if you’re afraid of getting lost. It gets easier, honestly..

My mother doesn’t drive as she’s too anxious and my sister will only drive within a 5km radius of her house so I’ve seen how their lives are restricted and how they rely on others for lifts. It’s not great.

Last year, I took my teenage DD to New York for a few days. We had the most amazing time, it was fabulous. I was telling my friend about it and she said she’d be too scared to travel to New York without her husband.. 🙄

1offnamechange · 28/03/2023 16:33

coldmarchmorn · 28/03/2023 12:37

You wheel it to the right place once a week? You don't put anything in it? You don't have 4 different bins and need to sort everything into those 4 bins? You don't need to clean them?

Do you have a magical bin that just takes trips to the kerb once a week with no other input from anyone?

The poster already said they/their dp wheels it out so no idea where your sarky 'does it take itself to the kerb' comes from
As for the rest - everywhere in the UK recycles differently, lots of places don't have 4 bins or need sorting. In my house we have recycling/food/normal and people put the item in the right bin as they go along, so there's no 'job' of sorting them needing doing. full bin liner comes out of indoor bin and into outdoor bin. New bin liner in indoor bin. Repeat for food bin. Recycling just goes straight out in the liner.

Once collection has taken place I move the 2 outdoor bins back about half a foot to where they are kept.
Whole process takes 3 mins max once a fortnight.
And no, I've never cleaned my outside bins!

I agree with @coldmarchmorn - "Bins" are barely a chore, if they are they are the easiest one going! People who let men get away with that as one of 'their' jobs and think it in anyway is equivalent to cooking or cleaning several times a day have screwed themselves over!

thing47 · 28/03/2023 16:10

Never fully understood the driving in new places thing

I'm not very keen on driving to or in places I don't know @SquashPenguin , I'll try to explain my thinking. I get nervous about getting lost, I don't have a great sense of direction in a car and if I don't know the town I find it hard to re-orientate myself. I also get worried that because I'm hesitant and/or trying to read road signs I am delaying others and causing them to lose patience with me. I don't get any enjoyment from driving as an activity (which I know lots of people do), so for me it's all about a means of getting somewhere and if that goes wrong, it causes me stress. That said, I still do it because my desire to see friends/go to a gig/watch the DCs play sport etc overrides my fear of driving to new places.

Also on the flip side, I am ultra confident on trains or the London tube, for example. I've lived within an hour's journey of London most of my life and have been travelling there on my own since my early teens. I have no nerves whatsoever about having to change train or tube lines numerous times. I am also perfectly happy flying on my own and have done so for both work and pleasure.

So I'm not a nervous traveller per se, I just don't much enjoy driving. Does that help?

Conkersinautumn · 28/03/2023 16:10

I think it's more the attitude of independence. If I'm faced with something I'm not sure about I will just look up how to do it. Some people will ask for help first. If something scares me I will avoid it for a bit but I feel like I have to overcome it or go without. I don't think it's always a strength. At all.

Bookist · 28/03/2023 15:07

I really don't have any time or patience for those who daren't drive in a new place, or daren't travel alone, or are too nervous to be alone in their house overnight. I guess they must have reasons for this behaviour but I refuse to enable them {glares hard at MIL}. It's my private opinion that living like this is only living half a life.

OverUnderBackwardsForwards · 28/03/2023 14:49

I’m late 30s and finding myself agreeing with all points. I’m pretty ashamed about how bad I’ve got, actually.

I have lived alone when younger but hated it. When my husband isn’t here now, I can’t sleep. I feel my mental health declining when he goes away for long stretches for work. My anxiety starts going up. If I had to do it again though I would get on with it.

I barely drive anymore. It stresses me out too much. I’ve been like this for as long as I remember. I avoid driving to the point I feel like a prisoner in my own home sometimes.

I have never flown alone and can’t imagine coping well with it. But if I had to, I would. As long as I could ask people what I needed to do and where I needed to go.

i used to do petrol fine but haven’t for years cus we barely use our car and when it needs petrol my husband takes it and fill it up in an evening when it’s quiet (local station gets v busy) this is just something he’s always done.

I do have pretty bad anxiety and am planning to talk to the doctor about it as it’s getting worse. I often wonder if I’m already perimenopausal.

In fact, somebody just knocked on my door to try and sell me new doors and windows - it was five minutes ago and I’m still feeling jittery about it. I should forget about it but my brain is replaying the convo. I feel like I’ve let the guy down. He looked let down. should I have said something else etc etc. Yet really, he was quite pushy and wouldn’t let me end the convo, was intruding on my afternoon, made my dog bark and nearly woke my sleeping toddler.

Wishawisha · 28/03/2023 14:35

Seeingadistance · 28/03/2023 13:39

Thank you!

Yes, I've been thinking this all through this thread. What is the big deal about taking bins out?

I’m assuming it’s taking the bin bag from the kitchen bin and taking it outside and depositing it in the black bin? Or the recycling from wherever you keep your recycling into the recycling bin? Rather than just moving the bin to the road on bin day.

Because yes that’s not my favourite job. The bin bag can be heavy and smell and I have to lift it to shoulder height (where I notice the smell and weight more) to put into the black bin. Sometimes I find the food waste bin really quite revolting.

I do take the bins out personally but I don’t mock women that have decided to divide up household chores and opted out of this one. There are other jobs I’ve opted out of (eg mowing the lawn, though weeding I do) because I simply don’t want to do them. And so what? I doubt there is any able bodied woman that couldn’t take the bins out were she unexpectedly widowed, but if she gets out of a job she hates for a few more decades then this is nothing to do with the rest of us? Why would I care?

SquashPenguin · 28/03/2023 14:02

I’d love it if my partner put fuel in my car, I find it the most tedious chore ever. But I also fill up 4 times a week so I doubt he’d be overjoyed by the idea 😆

Never fully understood the driving in new places thing, each to their own. I’ll happily drive anywhere (hence the 4 tanks a week) but if people would rather not go somewhere or get five trains it doesn’t make much difference to my life.

Trollsinmyeggbox · 28/03/2023 13:56

@Naunet ok 🙃

Seeingadistance · 28/03/2023 13:39

Cosyblankets · 28/03/2023 12:36

What's the obsession with bins on MN ?
it's really not a job! You just wheel it to the right place once a week or whatever. It's 2 minutes tops. In our house it goes a bit like this...
Have you put the bin out or shall I do it?
I put it out this afternoon.
....
That's it! Whoever thinks about it does it.
It's really not a thing

Thank you!

Yes, I've been thinking this all through this thread. What is the big deal about taking bins out?

PleaseJustText · 28/03/2023 13:36

I love flying alone and enjoyed living alone. I wouldn't drive in a city though. I hate driving in new places and cities are too stressful. I'd have to find a way by public transport instead.

CoffeeCantata · 28/03/2023 13:33

PrehistoricGarbageTruck · Today 12:10

Well y'know some of us aren't raging feminists with a point to prove, we're just doing our best to get by in life.

I don't think you need to be a 'raging feminist' to want to be competent as a adult. I don't want to do women down, but (I'm sure due to cultural conditioning) it is often women who find excuses to duck out of doing certain things, and I include myself in that (changing the oil and checking tyres etc).

I can't sympathise with the young woman mentioned by a pp who wouldn't/couldn't get her act together for independent travel - train or car - for her job. That's just not acceptable if you're an adult in a job where it's necessary.

Slightly off topic, but linked, having read some of the responses here: one school I worked in asked for staff to 'go along and support' Y10 girls who were scheduled to have injections that day. I asked what sort of support was needed, assuming the students in question had some disability or condition which required it and was told 'oh, no - all the girls - they are in tears and some are hysterical'. These were 15 year-old girls - I'd have been much more sympathetic had they been 5! Talking to other staff members it seems the girls had simply been conditioned to think that it was 'feminine' and 'cute' to make a drama about such a routine thing (and my God, injections now are NOTHING like they were when I was that age!! You hardly know they've touched you). Apparently, they got a lot of attention from the boys by weeping so ostentatiously.

This is how it starts!

reddwarfgeek · 28/03/2023 13:30

YANBU, I totally agree! I grew up with my mum depending on my dad for everything, she never paid a bill or booked anything in her own name. Even now, she can do anything simple like open the car boot, change a lightbulb, never learnt to drive, the list goes on.

I know lots of people who won't drive on motorways.

Several friends (who are 'gobby' in other ways) won't ring up restaurants and taxi ranks.

My partner will always get me to get the door to a neighbour, take a parcel round, or a takeaway delivery.

I don't know what the issue is at all.

Montgolfiergray34 · 28/03/2023 13:27

ComtesseDeSpair · 28/03/2023 12:18

“Anxious” is an odd word for it, I don’t get anxious over strangers; but yes, I do find it concerning that many women opt out of things like finances and self-transportation, and that this generally seems to be accepted and defended, when we know quite how many women are stuck in unhappy relationships or get shafted during divorce.

If somebody would prefer not to fly, that’s less of an issue, it’s not essential to do: although in the case of my former MIL, refusal to travel alone because her husband always booked the tickets, carried the suitcases, booked the early morning cab, arranged the transfers, exchanged the travel money etc has left her unable, out of fear of getting it wrong, unable to see her children and grandchildren as often as she’d like.

Well your concern for other less independent women than yourself is admirable, and your frustration with your former mil are both valid. But it doesn’t actually help them does it, or change anything?

I am getting old now but I have arrived at the view that you help people more by accepting them for who they are.

I don’t know. I think society is made up of a mix of personalities and characters for good reason. We need the solid stay at homers just as much as we need the go out and getters and doers. Both have different skill sets and both are valuable.

Lcb123 · 28/03/2023 13:24

I wouldn’t judge individual situations but YANBU. I also hate this need to constantly tell friends and family what you’re doing every day.

IslandMeat · 28/03/2023 13:24

I think it's normal and good to need each other, it's only a problem if it's affecting your quality of life or causing problems or resentment to other people. Life is give and take and some people like having companionship and their love language is doing things for each other or times spent together. It's not good for humans and communities to be too independent and solitary.
I feel good when I do something for my DH who in theory can learn to do himself but if I do it for him it gives him an easier life and it's one less skill he doesn't have to spend time to learn. When he does things for me, I love him even more for it. It shows me he cares and wants to support me if I'm nervous about something. I like being needed and I appreciate being helped out.

Surfingthewaves · 28/03/2023 13:23

I think the only point is why does op even care enough about what other people do or don’t do to have an opinion? I couldn’t care less if someone chooses to drive or pay bills or whatever- why would I? Because I don’t judge others.

ridemesideway · 28/03/2023 13:17

My mother is totally overwhelmed by basic things since my dad (who did all the small jobs) died. I get calls bemoaning how the lightbulb has gone in the bathroom and she needs someone to change it, or she can’t change the clock on her microwave. She won’t even try.
My sister has decided that she no longer likes driving much so these trivial jobs fall to me. It’s frustrating.
Funnily enough my parents used to scoff at me for being so independent as a child and then when I grew up.

Horizons83 · 28/03/2023 13:15

I would be curious to know how many of these incapable people are in long term relationships and have been from an earlier age. I was entirely single (not even a date) until my mid 30s, and so inherently I am sure I was more independent as I didn’t really have an option.

Now I’ve been in a relationship for 10 years and I’ve noticed there are tasks I automatically delegate to my husband and therefore have lost the confidence in doing them (eg can’t remember the last time I put air in my car tyres). The realisation has made me uneasy and I’m going to make more of an effort to get back to my old ways!

LoobyDop · 28/03/2023 13:04

I was about 37 when I moved in with my husband, I’d have had a pretty limited life if I couldn’t manage basic tasks on my own. The one thing I can think of where I thought “I wouldn’t have been able to do that” was a couple of years ago on holiday, when we stayed in a place with the steepest hills and sharpest hairpin bends I’ve ever seen. I definitely would have beached and bumped a couple of times if I’d had to drive. But I would have done it. Just quite possibly with a lot of hyperventilating and a lost deposit on the hire car.

The over-thinking and over-complication of domestic chores like putting the bins out on MN always amuses me.

Cosyblankets · 28/03/2023 13:02

@SavBlancTonight we don't bother with an inside bin for recycling, we just put it in the outside one straight away so it doesn't build up.
General rubbish is in a bag that we just lift out and put in outside bin.

Naunet · 28/03/2023 13:00

Behind closed doors I'm quite submissive and this does go into some of the day to day interactions at home. Part of liking playing a more submissive woman role in the relationship

sexist, offensive bullshit.

booksbooks8 · 28/03/2023 12:59

You are entitled to your opinion.
However, it seems that you haven't grasped the reasons why some adults live, either through choice or not, in a different way to the one you deem appropriate.

I might deduce from this that you possibly prioritised becoming what you call a "competent adult" above other things, and therefore didn't develop, either by choice or by nature, a deeper understanding of other people.

Society has evolved so we aren't completely independent one from another. The fact that some people are in a position where they feel they have to know how to do "everything" is neither positive nor negative, rather a side effect of not having, or not wishing to have people they can rely on around them.

Are you saying that being completely self sufficient is the only way to live? Is the aim to always have money which can be exchanged for services the top tier, or is being independently competent in every single field more worthy?

Looking down on others, who for whatever reason live differently to you, and then accusing them of not adapting to the way of life you presume to be superior, is really tiresome.
Your "lifestyle" is of equal value to anyone else's, not more. If a woman wants to live as a 1950's housewife she is in no way less than you, or is she responsible for the "struggle" in society.

Individualism is not seen as the perfect way to live in many countries, but it's not about being right or wrong, it's about respecting other people's choices.

Swipe left for the next trending thread