Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Lack of independence in some adults

214 replies

Violaviolin · 28/03/2023 09:40

I am always amazed that some adults seem completely incapable of independence. The last week or so has shown up so many things.

  1. A friend saying her husband puts petrol in the car for her as she 'wouldn't know what to do.' She's been driving for over 10 years.
  1. A different friend saying there's 'no way she could fly by herself.' She's 36.
  1. Friends/family constantly having to check what partners are doing before agreeing to meet (not a childcare situation).
  1. Colleagues saying they can't drive to x and asking for a lift (miles out of my way) despite the fact they can drive and have a car. I'm nervous driving in cities but you just have to get on with it don't you.
  1. People who say they couldn't live by themselves.

AIBU that too many people lack independence?

OP posts:
icelolly12 · 28/03/2023 20:06

I do remember being very nervous about putting petrol in my car for the very first time. However, after doing it, I then never thought twice about it. I can't imagine owning a car and not being able to put petrol in it.. that would give me so much anxiety- I'd be constantly watching the gauge terrified I'd be stuck somewhere if I ran out. I do think many people state "anxiety" as a reason for never trying. Often the thought of doing it is far more anxiety inducing than just getting on with it and then it becomes second nature.

Some of these simple things can seem a lot more daunting than they are and if a woman has a domineering/"helpful" husband, they are really putting themselves in a vulnerable position by never at least learning how to do these basic tasks and always relying on their husband and then looking up to him and seeing him as some all important being because he does a few (basic) tasks that seem insurmountable.

One of my female relatives is like this- I don't think she's ever chosen a holiday never mind booked one. The destination will always be suggested by her dh and booked by him on a date chosen by him. He does the motorway driving. He does the food shopping and the cooking- and decides what they will have every single day without ever asking her what she might fancy. He deals with the bins, the garden and anything car related. As far as I can tell she does very little other than a bit of hoovering (when he tells her it's time to do so). The lack of agency would drive me insane. I do think part of it is his controlling nature- he likes the fact she relies on him and it makes him feel important and needed. I do wonder what she would be like if she'd never met him and married someone different or remained single.

In summary, I can't relate to helpless adults either.

CaptainCorellisXylophone · 28/03/2023 19:39

ComtesseDeSpair · 28/03/2023 09:59

And yes, some men do it with “not knowing” how to work the washing machine / sort out the children. But that faux helplessness is to their benefit, because somebody else (a woman) ends up doing the shit work. Whereas for women, it often puts them in a more vulnerable position, not a stronger one.

This is an important observation about the different effects of feigned helplessness between the sexes.

It has always been obvious to me when I think about them separately, but I'd never put them side by side like this.

Wishawisha · 28/03/2023 19:18

Oops I posted too early. Wheelie bins are really tall. Of course you have to lift the bin bag up?
Anyway whatever, it’s a job I do.. I just don’t see why people are angry about women who opt out of that job.

Wishawisha · 28/03/2023 19:17

Tescoland · 28/03/2023 17:31

I never in my life have seen anyone lift a bin bag up to shoulder high. Is it some industrial giant bin liner? 😅

The black bins open from the top and are pretty tall? It’s not

Montgolfiergray34 · 28/03/2023 18:48

Timesawastin · 28/03/2023 17:37

Oh for God's sake the utterly predictable "the very worst crime is judging other people even in the abstract"

It isn't.

It’s not the worst crime but it’s pretty unimaginative. Many people who don’t have one skill, spend time developing another. And other people, owing to a mh or other condition, or sheer lack of confidence, just find practical life harder and overwhelming and more difficult than the average person. Despite what people are saying on here, it’s often not something they can help, it just is… .

Lots of pps would automatically dismiss many people I know as “incompetent adults” because they can’t drive in a city or drain a blocked sink, but some of them where I live rurally are extremely creative and highly skilled writers, artists
poets, gardeners, musicians and craftsmen. Some of them are very practical in their own sphere of work too.

But by all means carry on judging and sneering and expressing faux concern - it obviously gives everyone a little filip about themselves - of which perhaps they are in need.

LlynTegid · 28/03/2023 18:41

Apart from the third point (checking is not seeking permission) I agree with the OP. Though the degree to which people cannot live independently and the tasks they cannot do varies a great deal.

Cosyblankets · 28/03/2023 18:36

Seeingadistance · 28/03/2023 13:39

Thank you!

Yes, I've been thinking this all through this thread. What is the big deal about taking bins out?

I put a plastic bottle in the recycle bin outside on my way past when I took the dog out. Such a chore. That'll get me off the hook for cleaning or something for a week

begoneday · 28/03/2023 18:33

Yes ! I’m shocked at my female friends who birthed children but cannot/will not travel into London at night on the train, make decisions about days out without consulting their DH’s, pay for things with their own money (must consult DH and joint bank account ) These are not women in abusive or controlling relationships and are not struggling financially, they’re just joined at the hip to their partners .

lucylantern · 28/03/2023 18:32

Yes I totally agree with you OP. I find it a bit wearing when people behave like this, but obviously keep quiet.

I just don’t understand why people would be willing to restrict themselves like this.

pncr · 28/03/2023 18:28

I don't change tyres because I physically can't. That's why I pay aa membership.

pixie5121 · 28/03/2023 18:28

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request.

Skyrim40 · 28/03/2023 18:21

Christmas that was a bit stressful.

Skyrim40 · 28/03/2023 18:20

Trying to sort out mobile banking and a new phone and SIM card was abit trying today. 😅When my drains blocked at

IAteAllTheTomatoes · 28/03/2023 18:14

I've always had a "I'll give it a go, what's the worst than can happen mindset?"

I'll try most things, if I don't know how to do something, I'll.ask someone, google it YouTube video etc.

I think you just have to get on with it. I can't imagine not beng independent. Each to their own but I would find it hugely limiting & I would miss the freedom.

On a downside, it's often proven a challenge when dating. I think a lot of men prefer to feel needed more than wanted!

TokyoStories · 28/03/2023 18:00

I left home when I was 15 and had no support from family so I've had no choice but to be independent from a young age. I'm also single so I have to do 100% of everything all the time. To be honest I'm completely fed up and exhausted by it all, and envy friends who have parents or partners to do stuff for them. I would LOVE to get a lift somewhere instead of having to drive myself, especially when it's something stressful like a hospital appointment. If I don't know how to do something then I have to get on and learn how to do it otherwise it won't happen. If I ever meet somebody decent maybe I will turn into one of these helpless people, it sounds very appealing right now Grin

Blossomtoes · 28/03/2023 17:56

it’s because you don’t know how to do it properly

No, I know exactly how to do it, it’s because I don’t trust myself to do it properly. It’s different. I also have arthritis in my hands and I sometimes can’t even open a jar, let alone tighten screws on a wheel!

FictionalCharacter · 28/03/2023 17:50

Blossomtoes · 28/03/2023 17:39

I won’t change a tyre because I don’t trust myself to do it properly and it would be a danger to me and to other drivers. Last time I called the AA out to do it the guy congratulated me on being sensible.

I’ll do pretty much anything else but I’m being kinder to myself than I used to be. I’m visiting a friend a four hour drive away soon. I don’t want to drive y myself so I’m taking the train.

That’s sensible of you (the tyre) but it’s because you don’t know how to do it properly, not because you’re female. I’m happy to do it and have done it quite a few times. I got my first car when I was a teenager waaay back, learned to do basic car maintenance because I couldn’t afford to take it to the garage all the time, and was taught to change wheels properly by car mechanics who were family friends. But I also like to be independent.

stayathomer · 28/03/2023 17:47

Op a lot seems to irritate you about your friends!

FictionalCharacter · 28/03/2023 17:44

ComtesseDeSpair · 28/03/2023 09:56

I think the problem is that it isn’t “some adults” or that we’re “all different”: it’s that it’s almost invariably women who display this sort of helplessness and childlike dependency. How many men have you ever heard saying they wouldn’t know how to put petrol in the family car, or are nervous of driving on busy roads, or couldn’t travel on their own?

I don’t know whether it’s learned behaviour, because some women think that it’s feminine to be naive or that men find helplessness attractive, but it’s behaviour which really limits many women’s lives, not just a cute quirk.

Exactly. And as you say in the next post, the things men decide they’re incapable of (like operating a dishwasher, somehow a mystery to some men who are still able to do complex responsible paid work), work to their advantage. The things women believe they can’t do are limiting.
This bollocks doesn’t happen in our household so my kids haven’t grown up believing women can’t do manly jobs like changing car wheels or fixing bikes, and men have to be looked after by women because the Y chromosome prevents them being able to cook or clean the toilet.

Blossomtoes · 28/03/2023 17:39

I won’t change a tyre because I don’t trust myself to do it properly and it would be a danger to me and to other drivers. Last time I called the AA out to do it the guy congratulated me on being sensible.

I’ll do pretty much anything else but I’m being kinder to myself than I used to be. I’m visiting a friend a four hour drive away soon. I don’t want to drive y myself so I’m taking the train.

Timesawastin · 28/03/2023 17:37

Surfingthewaves · 28/03/2023 09:51

Why can’t you all just accept that we’re all different? Humans can be quite complex with a mixture of strengths and weaknesses, we all have different skill sets. You come across as being superior to others because you can do all the things you’ve listed. Maybe you should focus on what improvements you can make on yourself rather than judging others.

Oh for God's sake the utterly predictable "the very worst crime is judging other people even in the abstract"

It isn't.

Tescoland · 28/03/2023 17:31

Wishawisha · 28/03/2023 14:35

I’m assuming it’s taking the bin bag from the kitchen bin and taking it outside and depositing it in the black bin? Or the recycling from wherever you keep your recycling into the recycling bin? Rather than just moving the bin to the road on bin day.

Because yes that’s not my favourite job. The bin bag can be heavy and smell and I have to lift it to shoulder height (where I notice the smell and weight more) to put into the black bin. Sometimes I find the food waste bin really quite revolting.

I do take the bins out personally but I don’t mock women that have decided to divide up household chores and opted out of this one. There are other jobs I’ve opted out of (eg mowing the lawn, though weeding I do) because I simply don’t want to do them. And so what? I doubt there is any able bodied woman that couldn’t take the bins out were she unexpectedly widowed, but if she gets out of a job she hates for a few more decades then this is nothing to do with the rest of us? Why would I care?

I never in my life have seen anyone lift a bin bag up to shoulder high. Is it some industrial giant bin liner? 😅

Cosyblankets · 28/03/2023 17:27

Wishawisha · 28/03/2023 14:35

I’m assuming it’s taking the bin bag from the kitchen bin and taking it outside and depositing it in the black bin? Or the recycling from wherever you keep your recycling into the recycling bin? Rather than just moving the bin to the road on bin day.

Because yes that’s not my favourite job. The bin bag can be heavy and smell and I have to lift it to shoulder height (where I notice the smell and weight more) to put into the black bin. Sometimes I find the food waste bin really quite revolting.

I do take the bins out personally but I don’t mock women that have decided to divide up household chores and opted out of this one. There are other jobs I’ve opted out of (eg mowing the lawn, though weeding I do) because I simply don’t want to do them. And so what? I doubt there is any able bodied woman that couldn’t take the bins out were she unexpectedly widowed, but if she gets out of a job she hates for a few more decades then this is nothing to do with the rest of us? Why would I care?

If your bin is so big that it's heavy, if your bin is so big that it's taken so long to get full that it's smelly, if you need to lift it to shoulder height..... you need a smaller bin in your kitchen!

ItsCalledAConversation · 28/03/2023 17:20

I met someone (a school mum) the other day who won’t talk to people she “doesn’t know”, won’t walk her dog alone, won’t go anywhere alone in the dark, besides the fact she’s pathetic, I feel sorry for her really as in my eyes she’s not behaving like an adult. More like a teenager still living at home. I suppose a lot of people never evolve beyond that mentality.

America12 · 28/03/2023 17:17

YANBU It's ridiculous.

Swipe left for the next trending thread