Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

People assuming new fathers are a bit useless

354 replies

AlmostaMamma · 27/03/2023 23:27

Has anyone else noticed this?

I’m currently extremely pregnant and the comments from friends/family/acquaintances/colleagues regarding having a newborn have been fascinating.

“You’ll want to batch cook, as you won’t be able to cook anything for the first few weeks.”

“Make sure you stock up on XYZ, as you won’t be feeling up to doing any laundry.”

“You won’t be feeling up to any housework, but you’ll be too tired to notice the mess.”

Also lots of stuff about having to deal with everything for the newborn by myself.

I have a husband. He’s a competent adult (I wouldn’t have married him otherwise) who is capable of household chores and generally does more of them than I do. This will not change post birth. And, apart from me being the one who breastfeeds, we’re going to be splitting infant care pretty evenly.

It’s 2023, so presumably this isn’t a massively unusual state of affairs. So why do people say this nonsense? It was mildly amusing to begin with, but it’s starting to make me tetchy.

OP posts:
troppibambini6 · 28/03/2023 13:59

Hmm I'm a bit on the fence here.
I have six kids and the support I found more valuable from dh was him doing the winding, giving a bottle, nappy changes and getting involved with the babies or helping the other kids. I didn't want him taken away from those jobs and his chance to bond with the babies because he was cooking.
Getting organised before the baby comes makes sense for both of you. Also I actually didn't mind going and folding some washing or having a tidy up will dh had the baby. It can be nice just to have a little break from keeping a small human alive for ten minutes. Although not the most exciting break.

noidea555 · 28/03/2023 13:48

BasicDad · 27/03/2023 23:58

Being out and about with a baby on your own without mum either involves women (not all, but enough) approaching to make sure you're OK, or fawning over you like looking after a baby is a super human feat for a man. Most mean well despite it being unintentionally patronising, so I laughed it off.

This was 11 years ago, but I'd guess not much has changed.

My kids do an activity on a saturday morning, quite often I will take them out an hour beforehand leaving their mum at home and me and kids go out for breakfast before the activity. All very nice.

As we go to same places quite often i know for a fact that staff/customers all think i am a divorced dad just because i am out somewhere on my own with the kids.

Abouttimemum · 28/03/2023 13:47

I agree with you, but when DS was born he had to be held morning, noon and night so (after the first two weeks) when DH came home from work he would basically take DS from me so I could take care of myself (shower etc) and then we’d both pretty much go to bed / share shifts holding DS through the night. So neither of us had the time or energy for cooking or cleaning and the like. He did actually batch cook (he does all the cooking on our house) thankfully which was a godsend.

it only lasted a couple of months while we got DS through silent reflux issues, but it was pretty brutal to be honest. And then we were just back to sharing all the home and childcare load.

elm26 · 28/03/2023 13:41

Good luck to you too @AlmostaMamma, exciting times! 💕

AlmostaMamma · 28/03/2023 13:40

Lizzt2007 · 28/03/2023 13:21

They can now, that was t always the case and us relatively recent. Many people commenting may not have had that choice and may not know it's now available.

This is very true.

OP posts:
AlmostaMamma · 28/03/2023 13:39

@LuckyDonna and @LadyJ2023 Excellent advice. Thank you. 😊

OP posts:
Maray1967 · 28/03/2023 13:38

AlmostaMamma · 28/03/2023 11:13

Lovely lovely MIL, is that you? 😂

Definitely not - no DIL yet!! DS (22) has a long term girlfriend who is lovely but not living together yet.
Glad to read you have a great MIL, Almost a mama. Mine did a great job training both of her DS to be hands on dads. Both DH and BIL can be untidy but when DC were young they were both great at pulling their weight.

JenniferBarkley · 28/03/2023 13:36

We plan on enjoying it, but thank you.

GrinGrinGrinGrinGrin

In all seriousness OP, the enjoyable moments are wonderful, but (especially in the first year) a lot of it is thankless drudgery, there is literally nothing enjoyable about an inconsolable baby or sleep deprivation.

AlmostaMamma · 28/03/2023 13:34

bumblebee1401 · 28/03/2023 13:26

Just because a man can put a wash load on or whip up a fresh batch of chilli con carne, doesn't necessarily make him a good dad.

Bring a good or equal partner and a good or equal parent are not the same thing.

There's an air of superiority about your post tbh. All these silly women who have set the bar so low, and here you are, before you actually have the child, having it all figured out! Amazing. What about women who enjoy doing the majority of domesticated tasks? Are they stupid because they don't crack the whip as soon as their partners are home from work? It's not all black and white OP.

Maybe just wait and see how things are. Parenting is great but it's also relentlessly hard and changes you.

Hope it all goes as well as you've planned, OP.

Just because a man can put a wash load on or whip up a fresh batch of chilli con carne, doesn't necessarily make him a good dad.
Bring a good or equal partner and a good or equal parent are not the same thing.

This has nothing to do with my post. DH and I have exactly as much experience of being parents as each other. We hope we’ll be good ones, but time will tell

Amazing. What about women who enjoy doing the majority of domesticated tasks? Are they stupid because they don't crack the whip as soon as their partners are home from work? It's not all black and white OP.

What about them? I haven’t suggested that anyone ‘crack the whip’ or rearrange their sharing of domestic labour in any way. I’ve explicitly stated that’s none of my business.

Maybe just wait and see how things are. Parenting is great but it's also relentlessly hard and changes you.

We plan on enjoying it, but thank you.

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 28/03/2023 13:33

FawnFrenchieMum · 28/03/2023 00:19

I think the fact that he gets 12 weeks paternity makes a massive difference here as well. Most men are back at work full time after 2 weeks, some of that 2 weeks was likely spent in the labour and maternity wards as well. So chances are that housework, home cooked meals etc ARE going to suffer in those households mainly because both adults are over stretched and over tired.

It does. Mine went back to work the day he collected us from hospital.

Lizzt2007 · 28/03/2023 13:31

bumblebee1401 · 28/03/2023 13:26

Just because a man can put a wash load on or whip up a fresh batch of chilli con carne, doesn't necessarily make him a good dad.

Bring a good or equal partner and a good or equal parent are not the same thing.

There's an air of superiority about your post tbh. All these silly women who have set the bar so low, and here you are, before you actually have the child, having it all figured out! Amazing. What about women who enjoy doing the majority of domesticated tasks? Are they stupid because they don't crack the whip as soon as their partners are home from work? It's not all black and white OP.

Maybe just wait and see how things are. Parenting is great but it's also relentlessly hard and changes you.

Hope it all goes as well as you've planned, OP.

That isn't what she's saying at all. She isn't judging how other people run their lives, she's cross because she's getting unsolicited 'advice' based on their partners and their lives. That advice doesn't take into account the relationship she has with her partner at all. It may not work out how she's hoping, but then it might. Being subject to shed loads of unsubstantiated opinions , especially from people who know them is ridiculous.

bumblebee1401 · 28/03/2023 13:26

Just because a man can put a wash load on or whip up a fresh batch of chilli con carne, doesn't necessarily make him a good dad.

Bring a good or equal partner and a good or equal parent are not the same thing.

There's an air of superiority about your post tbh. All these silly women who have set the bar so low, and here you are, before you actually have the child, having it all figured out! Amazing. What about women who enjoy doing the majority of domesticated tasks? Are they stupid because they don't crack the whip as soon as their partners are home from work? It's not all black and white OP.

Maybe just wait and see how things are. Parenting is great but it's also relentlessly hard and changes you.

Hope it all goes as well as you've planned, OP.

2023a · 28/03/2023 13:26

pjani · 28/03/2023 12:44

@2023a The advice the OP received was like this:

“You’ll want to batch cook, as you won’t be able to cook anything for the first few weeks.”

“Make sure you stock up on XYZ, as you won’t be feeling up to doing any laundry.”

I can and do read this as 'you' plural and it was absolutely correct in our situation. You (new mum and dad) might not be in a state to cook or do laundry with a newborn. Neither of us were!

I will however completely agree that un-asked for, well-meaning advice is annoying and people should cut it out.

But I think the advice could be taken, not as meaning 'men are crap' but more 'babies are all-encompassing'. I would still say to the OP, feel free to tell people to lay off the advice as you're finding it unhelpful.

The laundry query included ‘does he know how’. It was clarified in the comments. To me, that suggests a far more ‘men are crap’ than ‘babies are all encompassing’ slant to the conversation.

Lizzt2007 · 28/03/2023 13:21

BarbaraofSeville · 28/03/2023 07:52

The men who are back at work after 2 weeks only because they've chosen not to take the shared parental leave that they're entitled to.

Fathers don't have to go back to work so quickly, they choose to. Any new father can take the same 12 weeks that the OPs DH is taking.

They can now, that was t always the case and us relatively recent. Many people commenting may not have had that choice and may not know it's now available.

LadyJ2023 · 28/03/2023 13:10

Why don't you sit back stop listening to utter rubbish or reading it and enjoy your own experience soon to be a mum and dad. Nobody's experience is the same.we have 4 under 2 and everything has been done evenly not that I'm that bothered but it's nice to have your other half help out even after work never needs asked. So enjoy your time and make your own new memories

WeWereInParis · 28/03/2023 12:46

The men who are back at work after 2 weeks only because they've chosen not to take the shared parental leave that they're entitled to.

My DH would have absolutely loved to take more than 2 weeks leave. But financially it wasn't possible. I got full pay for 6 months, then SMP. And he is the higher earner, so it wouldn't have made sense for us to lose that salary.

LuckyDonna · 28/03/2023 12:46

My advice OP, is never listen to anyone. (Including me probably lol). I didn't. I just did everything my way, followed my instincts and it all turned out fine.

I am actually divorced now, many years later, but not because my ex was any different after kids but for very different reasons.
It sounds like you've actually had a number of conversations with your DH, which many of us (me included) don't/didn't.

thecatsthecats · 28/03/2023 12:45

I'm currently pregnant, and my husband is entirely supportive, proactively does a fair share of tasks already.

But we still also rely on batch cooking, tactical laundry plans and a cleaner. Maybe we're both a bit crap as opposed to it being confined to one gender. But we're not assuming that we'll get any better when there's a tiny screaming human in the house.

We are absolutely planning to stuff the freezer with batch cooking, prep as much laundry, and make life as simple as possible.

pjani · 28/03/2023 12:44

@2023a The advice the OP received was like this:

“You’ll want to batch cook, as you won’t be able to cook anything for the first few weeks.”

“Make sure you stock up on XYZ, as you won’t be feeling up to doing any laundry.”

I can and do read this as 'you' plural and it was absolutely correct in our situation. You (new mum and dad) might not be in a state to cook or do laundry with a newborn. Neither of us were!

I will however completely agree that un-asked for, well-meaning advice is annoying and people should cut it out.

But I think the advice could be taken, not as meaning 'men are crap' but more 'babies are all-encompassing'. I would still say to the OP, feel free to tell people to lay off the advice as you're finding it unhelpful.

BertieBotts · 28/03/2023 12:42

IME we were both exhausted and burnt out from caring for the baby so we were both lacking in energy to cook, clean etc.

It wasn't because I was expected to do all that stuff and I couldn't because I was looking after the baby. Even with 2 adults and 1 baby it was a lot. DH took 5 months off with DC2 and 4 months with DC3 (DC1 had a different dad, he took 1 week).

AlmostaMamma · 28/03/2023 12:40

elm26 · 28/03/2023 12:35

And to answer PP's, I know that what I'm expecting to be hard will actually be 1000x harder than we can imagine when we are sleep deprived, in the trenches of feeding, nappies, settling a crying baby but it makes me feel calmer knowing I have a team mate who will be there with me through it.

The bar is so low for some women.

Exactly this. Congratulations on your pregnancy and I hope everything goes fabulously for us both. 💗

OP posts:
AlmostaMamma · 28/03/2023 12:39

Saying both parents will be exhausted and should prepare for it (great advice) is entirely different from assuming the man can’t cook or do laundry, so the woman should prepare accordingly.

Honestly, this on repeat to all the people saying it’s good advice. We are preparing for most eventualities (we’re people who like a plan), while being cognisant of the fact that we can’t plan for everything.

Advice to batch cook or stock up on stuff is great advice and very welcome. It’s the ‘as he obviously won’t be able to do XYZ’ and ‘can he do laundry properly’ that has accompanied said advice that’s irritating.

OP posts:
elm26 · 28/03/2023 12:38

NowThatsWhatICall22 · 28/03/2023 12:08

The post from @Squamata is so spot on. Do come back to this thread after your partner returns to work at the end of those 12 weeks (which will go quicker than any time you’ve ever experienced and be grateful that you’re not looking at just two weeks before you’re left alone, post op and probably without a lovely DM or DMiL on your doorstep for support).
Read your own comments again then and you’ll maybe understand why some folk are pushing back at your initial post.

You’re about to change your lives in such a way that you will look back and crave these days when you were free both mentally and timewise enough to post such a confident message about your relationship on Mumsnet.

This is really unfair.

I don't think OP has implied she thinks it'll be a walk in the park when her partner goes back to work.

It's funny how nobody mentions all the lovely things about having a baby, it's all so negative.

elm26 · 28/03/2023 12:35

And to answer PP's, I know that what I'm expecting to be hard will actually be 1000x harder than we can imagine when we are sleep deprived, in the trenches of feeding, nappies, settling a crying baby but it makes me feel calmer knowing I have a team mate who will be there with me through it.

The bar is so low for some women.

elm26 · 28/03/2023 12:31

I agree OP.

My DH is hands on with housework, I don't have to ask him to chuck his work stuff on a wash, hoover, wipe toilet down, spray shower door etc etc because he just does it if he notices it needs doing/I haven't got round to doing it.

I'm 31 weeks pregnant and have similar things said to me. My DH cooks a few nights a week too as he enjoys it. He's been more hands on than ever since I've been pregnant due to hyperemesis and some days I can't get out of bed due to nausea let alone lug the hoover round.

He is half of a household, he lives here too. On my good days (not feeling so sick) of course I do this, more often than not his clothes are washed and dry before he has a chance to do them, his lunch is made for the following day etc but if it's not, he does it.

It makes such a difference to life and your relationship when you're equals and in a team. My Grandmother thought it was most strange that DH did my laundry sometimes, or changed our bed. She couldn't get her head around it lol.

I'm so glad I don't have to worry about this when baby is born, I can't imagine wondering how on earth I'm going to hoover after vaginal birth or a c section when I've got a dog who's hair gets everywhere, or if I'm going to live in dirty clothes for a couple months if I haven't got the energy to wash, dry and fold laundry.