Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To suggest this event isn't suitable for DGD and DIL?

432 replies

MorrisCo · 27/03/2023 18:59

DH are celebrating a big wedding anniversary next month and a while ago discussed with DS and DIL we would like to do a lunch to celebrate and said it would be us, them plus their DD (4) our DGD and only grandchild.

The lunch is in a fairly nice restaurant and now I'm thinking about it I thought it could be more suitable for everyone to keep the occasion child free as DGD wouldn't enjoy the restaurant. I told DH I was going to suggest this to DS. It would mean DIL couldn't come to the meal either as we would be their only childcare for DGD so the meal would be me, my husband and my son. I was going to suggest a more child friendly celebration to include DGD on another day.

DH thinks it could cause offence but I think the occasion isn't suitable for a young child. WIBU to suggest a different separate event as well and keep the meal to just us three?

OP posts:
IhearyouClemFandango · 28/03/2023 19:13

And they're a family, she's paying too! I don't understand how you think your update makes it any better at all, in fact it's far worse.

IhearyouClemFandango · 28/03/2023 19:12

MorrisCo · 28/03/2023 13:15

I've taken what you've said in good grace. I'm not going to say anything to DS and DIL. I couldn't do the meal just me, DH and DS by the way because DS offered to pay for this meal for us for our anniversary so it's his gift.

I'm not a terrible MIL I did think I was being thoughtful trying to consider DGD.

That's even worse, he's paying and arranging but you want to decide the guest list and uninvite his family?! Bonkers.

Callingallskeletons · 28/03/2023 19:12

So 5 people and you’ve now decided 2 of them shouldn’t come???
I think YABVU and in all honesty if you were suggesting that to my DH our DC should be excluded I’d be fecking furious if he went too

pollykitty · 28/03/2023 19:07

WTF. I just cannot understand the way people think children will automatically ruin a ‘nice’ event. Are your family members feral? Weddings and wedding anniversaries are about family and friends, including children. I’ve actually never been asked to leave my kid at home but if I was it would be a big No Thanks, looks like I’m busy that day.

rogueone · 28/03/2023 19:01

MorrisCo · 27/03/2023 20:42

I've just finished going through the responses I'll try to answer the main points.

Firstly it's not a reverse. I'm not doing this to try and be away from my DIL and DGD I genuinely don't think DGD will be able to sit through the meal and it won't be fun for her.

Regarding my DIL we get in well enough but aren't that close and she doesn't let me see DGD that often so I don't feel as close to DGD either although I'd like to be. I was going to suggest a get together all of us as well as this meal so I'm not saying we don't want to celebrate with them, just the meal probably wasn't the best idea.

and that is why you cant exclude your DGD and her mother as the relationship will be fully ended

PippaF2 · 28/03/2023 18:58

My MIL booked a Michelin star restaurant for her anniversary and expected our 1yr old to be there.

She called the restaurant and explained a baby would be joining. She booked for a very early lunch on a weekday and asked for a table that was tucked away to not disturb other diners. Then said to us - oh well if the DGC acts up there are 4 adults to take her out for a stroll.

My MIL is nothing but 'family first'.

I think the idea of a putting together a pack with crayons and colouring books etc is an excellent idea that a pp mentioned.

Relax OP and go with the flow.

Daffodilsandbeer · 28/03/2023 18:53

It’s such a drip feed; the whole op is written like the op invited them and then decided it was not suitable for a small child

when in fact the son and daughter in law have invited them out and they are their guests and the op was considering telling them that the venue they chose was t suitable for their own child. So hopefully her son would just take her and her husband out and the daughter in law would need to stay home with the grandkid.

op, they decide what’s suitable for their kid. Not you.

Harrysmummy246 · 28/03/2023 18:49

And fwiw I was taken to France for my grandparents ruby wedding party in a nice hotel. As was dsis who would have been 2. We were taken to most of those things in nice restaurants and we behaved. That was what was expected

Harrysmummy246 · 28/03/2023 18:45

Yabu having not thought about it before suggesting and then excluding almost half of the original party.
Oh and 4year olds can behave in nice restaurants too with appropriate guidance, or a well timed trip to look at pictures on the way to the toilets etc.

My parents have always included Ds as their only grandchild

Daffodilsandbeer · 28/03/2023 18:44

MorrisCo · 28/03/2023 13:15

I've taken what you've said in good grace. I'm not going to say anything to DS and DIL. I couldn't do the meal just me, DH and DS by the way because DS offered to pay for this meal for us for our anniversary so it's his gift.

I'm not a terrible MIL I did think I was being thoughtful trying to consider DGD.

Oh god, I missed this, you do understand they are a family, so him and his wife are both taking uou as a gift. How could you even consider trying to get his wife and kid uninvited. That’s shocking.

nomoremerlot · 28/03/2023 18:34

MorrisCo · 28/03/2023 13:15

I've taken what you've said in good grace. I'm not going to say anything to DS and DIL. I couldn't do the meal just me, DH and DS by the way because DS offered to pay for this meal for us for our anniversary so it's his gift.

I'm not a terrible MIL I did think I was being thoughtful trying to consider DGD.

So DS had offered to pay for a meal for the five of you, you are then going to dictate that it's just for the three of you?

Fuck me, that is bad!

You do realise that it's not a case of him "having to go because he's paying", it'll be a case of him withdrawing his gift and telling you to fuck off.

londonrach · 28/03/2023 18:32

Change it to a more suitable venue. Surely dil and dgc are important members of your family. Yabvvvvu

Scotland32 · 28/03/2023 18:30

Eek! My middle names are practically Child Free and yet even I think YABU. It’s the retracting of the invitation and the (even if unintentional) exclusion of the DIL that seem rude.
That said, if you do go ahead, surely they could find a babysitter so DIL can join? 4 year old DGD won’t even know what she is missing.

Daffodilsandbeer · 28/03/2023 18:30

I also don’t get the dated sexism you display op; the wife doesn’t let you see the grandkid. The wife has to stay home. The wife will struggle during the meal with the kid. The wife won’t enjoy it as she’s caring for the child.

what about your son. Isn’t he the father, an equal parent and equally responsible for his child. Doesn’t he let you see her more often. Why’s it all his wife’s fault . The person who decides on how often you see her is your son.

do you genuinely believe the sexist shit you’re writing, or are you desperately trying to justify doing a shitty thing and disinviting your daughter in law and your own grandchild so you can get a lunch just with your son ans husband?

Twentyfirstcenturymumma · 28/03/2023 18:28

This is a terrible idea. You should all go to the nice restaurant as planned. Take plenty to interest your dgc
A small child should be able to enjoy a nice sounding outing too, get her interested in the food too

Lizrachal · 28/03/2023 18:28

YABU! Book a family friendly restaurant you see excluding DIL and DGD from the family. Can you go to nicer restaurant just you and DH

Mummadeze · 28/03/2023 18:27

I would be offended if I was the DIL, depending on how you worded it. But if you said ‘are you sure it won’t be too boring for DGC, I won’t be offended if you want to come on your own’ to your son, there is a chance she might take the opportunity to opt out.

Shinyandnew1 · 28/03/2023 18:25

I'm not a terrible MIL I did think I was being thoughtful trying to consider DGD

Thoughtful?! By uninviting her and her mother?!

Your son and has wife have offered to take you out for lunch for your birthday and you want one of them not to come-this is bizarre!

Who chose this restaurant, @MorrisCo ? Either it’s you and you have bizarrely deliberately chosen somewhere you think your only grandchild won’t like. Or your son/DIL chose the venue and they think their child will be fine.

Which is it?

SarahsHoneydew · 28/03/2023 18:23

Can’t imagine how that conversation would go with your son to basically say his wife and child are no longer invited because you’ve changed your mind! Awkward to say the least and - he might not want to go without them!

niugboo · 28/03/2023 18:21

MorrisCo · 28/03/2023 13:15

I've taken what you've said in good grace. I'm not going to say anything to DS and DIL. I couldn't do the meal just me, DH and DS by the way because DS offered to pay for this meal for us for our anniversary so it's his gift.

I'm not a terrible MIL I did think I was being thoughtful trying to consider DGD.

You were going disinvite your DIL from the gift from your son and her?! It was pretty awful to be begin but that’s another level.

AlinaRawlings · 28/03/2023 18:16

MorrisCo · 27/03/2023 18:59

DH are celebrating a big wedding anniversary next month and a while ago discussed with DS and DIL we would like to do a lunch to celebrate and said it would be us, them plus their DD (4) our DGD and only grandchild.

The lunch is in a fairly nice restaurant and now I'm thinking about it I thought it could be more suitable for everyone to keep the occasion child free as DGD wouldn't enjoy the restaurant. I told DH I was going to suggest this to DS. It would mean DIL couldn't come to the meal either as we would be their only childcare for DGD so the meal would be me, my husband and my son. I was going to suggest a more child friendly celebration to include DGD on another day.

DH thinks it could cause offence but I think the occasion isn't suitable for a young child. WIBU to suggest a different separate event as well and keep the meal to just us three?

Very odd thing to do. Invite them then just decide actually grandchild and DIL can’t come but still invite your son? Why not just have the meal with your husband then do something else with extended family. If you do this you’ll be in for a world of shit!

whynotwhatknot · 28/03/2023 18:16

oh god it gets worse ytoure not even paying?

if you think the gc would struggle talk to your son dont just say they cant come

PalominoUK · 28/03/2023 18:14

How do you think children learn how to behave and be familiar with such places?
You are their guests, as I understand it, so they should be aware of how their daughter will behave so she won't show them up.
Just chill and enjoy the time with your multi generational family 😊

claire2273 · 28/03/2023 18:10

I think the fact you said ‘she doesn’t let you see dgd’ says it all really. Your son is her parent as well and is just as capable of arranging to see you as your dil is.

Vynalbob · 28/03/2023 18:09

Can't believe anyone would think you're reasonable.

Like others have said meal for 2
Then meal for 5 kid friendly is an okay change anything else you're sticking two fingers up to your DIL and even your DGD
If I was your son & you suggested it I'd take offence on their behalf (presuming he doesn't just say yes 2u)