Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What the heck is a grammer school?

511 replies

BlackBarbies · 27/03/2023 15:29

Posting here for traffic!

Born and raised in South West London and still live here now. I’ve never heard of a grammar school until joining MN a couple of years ago.

Is it a primary school, is it a secondary school? Is it private or public? If it’s public, then why is it called a grammer school? Is it only available for certain types of children or something? I literally have no clue what a grammer school is so I’m happy to be enlightened!

Also, are there any in SW London? I’m genuinely intrigued as to how I’ve never come across one before

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
MuddlerInLaw · 29/03/2023 08:46

If you're the child of immigrants with an obviously foreign surname that announces you're from a specific, despised immigrant group, or your skin colour isn't what might be called traditionally Anglo Saxon, you tend to have less sanguine ideas about your chances or your children's chances of non academic forms of intelligence getting them ahead in the UK.

Wonderfully well put, @mathanxiety.

CatkinToadflax · 29/03/2023 08:41

Grammar schools are state. They are not private.

I was brought up in Buckinghamshire and went to a grammar in the ‘90s. When we had our children we moved away from Bucks deliberately to get out of the grammar system. Our boys have very different needs to one another. DS2 would very likely have passed the 11+ and the grammar would have suited him. However DS1 was born extremely prematurely and has complex disabilities as a result. It isn’t just whether a child is ‘bright’ enough to attend a grammar school but also whether that style of education and that environment suits them. He wouldn’t have passed the 11+, but even if he had, it would have been the completely wrong environment for him.

There are some bizarre statements on this thread.

Weald56 · 29/03/2023 08:12

RampantIvy · 28/03/2023 22:39

No. If it’s private it’s not a grammar school.

Of course it can be.
Grammar schools can be state or private.

Not really - grammar schools were originally state funded schools designed to give a good education later, (after the 1902 Education Act), a 'secondary' education when only 'elementary' education was normally available to those who could not afford to pay (e.g. the vast majority). In theory the top 25% of the ability range would go to grammar schools, though now the % taken varies widely from less than 10% (so 'super' selective) to around 25%. The grammar school name is still used by some private schools (as mentioned earlier in this thread) and even comprehensive schools (I can think of one).

Villssev · 29/03/2023 08:03

x2boys · 29/03/2023 07:55

And what if it doesn't work out as anticipated and your child fails to.pass the eleven p!us?
it's not that I don't believe that people whi.live near Grammar,school area,s may t try to move to the area ,I just don't think people will moved miles across the country as@mathanxiety seems to.suggest ,this may blow your mind ,but many kids do ok in comprehensive schools too.

I promise you they do

we did
My closest friend did

if they fail, then we would have gone private but that would have considerably cut our budget for the property we bought.

my best friend would have sent to local comp. But it’s not great and she was very anxious before results!

x2boys · 29/03/2023 08:02

Bleachmycloths · 29/03/2023 07:59

I’m surprised anyone has to ask this question.

Why ?
has it escaped your notice that vast areas of the uk haven't had Grammar schools since the 1970,s🤔

CurlewKate · 29/03/2023 08:01

RampantIvy · 29/03/2023 07:46

mathanxiety doesn't seem to realise that you cannot make a silk purse out of a sow's ear.

It has nothing to do with poverty of aspiration. Some children simply do not have the academic ability.

It's not all to do with academic ability. It is mostly to do with privilege. Otherwise the cohort at grammar schools and the schools where "everyone else" go would reflect the catchment. Which they don't. Most grammar schools have a vanishingly small % of disadvantaged children, for example. So unless you believe that poor children are innately less clever than better off ones....

Bleachmycloths · 29/03/2023 07:59

I’m surprised anyone has to ask this question.

x2boys · 29/03/2023 07:55

Villssev · 29/03/2023 07:51

Don’t you believe @x2boys ?

I am in a grammer school county. And many parents move here, rent as close as possible, tutor and then take the test. Once in, buy nicer property further out.
Pretty much what we did! 😂

And what if it doesn't work out as anticipated and your child fails to.pass the eleven p!us?
it's not that I don't believe that people whi.live near Grammar,school area,s may t try to move to the area ,I just don't think people will moved miles across the country as@mathanxiety seems to.suggest ,this may blow your mind ,but many kids do ok in comprehensive schools too.

Villssev · 29/03/2023 07:52

RampantIvy · 29/03/2023 07:46

mathanxiety doesn't seem to realise that you cannot make a silk purse out of a sow's ear.

It has nothing to do with poverty of aspiration. Some children simply do not have the academic ability.

Exactly

and then is nothing wrong with that. They will have different strengths

Villssev · 29/03/2023 07:51

x2boys · 29/03/2023 07:40

Yeah right 🙄

Don’t you believe @x2boys ?

I am in a grammer school county. And many parents move here, rent as close as possible, tutor and then take the test. Once in, buy nicer property further out.
Pretty much what we did! 😂

RampantIvy · 29/03/2023 07:46

mathanxiety doesn't seem to realise that you cannot make a silk purse out of a sow's ear.

It has nothing to do with poverty of aspiration. Some children simply do not have the academic ability.

x2boys · 29/03/2023 07:40

mathanxiety · 29/03/2023 03:11

You can do what my immigrant relatives did and move into a grammar area - into a grotty bedsit initially, then a small flat, then a small house - then make sure your children apply themselves in primary school and get in.

Yeah right 🙄

x2boys · 29/03/2023 07:38

mathanxiety · 29/03/2023 03:26

You can absolutely make sure your children will get in. You encourage them to focus on their schoolwork, you make sure they are reading way beyond what's expected in school, you chat woth them about what they're reading, you buy books and read them yourself, you spend time with your children doing mental arithmetic, you make sure they're working ahead in maths, you make them learn a musical instrument and play a sport. You chat with them about their struggles and you encourage them to persevere.

Do you think children arrive at age 10/ 11 with a chance to get into a grammar school or a bursary at an independent school straight out of thin air? That it's all natural intelligence and no parental input day after day for years and years?

I'm not talking about hothousing here. I'm talking about parents quietly making sure their children are prepared for the exam, and equipped with the focus and the mindset to succeed once they get to the school that will launch them into university.

What a load of bollocksnot everyone is academic 🙄

Boomboom22 · 29/03/2023 07:32

1 more, whilst most are single sex 3 I can think of are mixed. One in Canterbury, one Cranbrook and one faversham.

Boomboom22 · 29/03/2023 07:31

2 points about kent test. It's not compulsory, you sign your kid up to it. Not a year in advance, in the June of yr5 and they take the test in September Yr 6.

RampantIvy · 29/03/2023 07:03

I can't believe the people sneering, not everyone is lucky enough to have the best education.

I am not reading sneering in this, just how divisive the current grammar school system is. To write off a child at 10 or 11 is very divisive. At least they all get to sit GCSEs now. Back in my day you couldn't take O levels in secondary moderns, just CSEs.

Children from poorer families simply don't have the means to pay for the intense tutoring that happens, so you generally find that it is children from wealthier families who end up in grammar school. Inequality at its finest.

I'm very glad that we have no grammar schools in our county.

Doone21 · 29/03/2023 06:47

Grammar schools have fallen in and out of fashion over the years. They are considered better for academically gifted children as they work at a faster pace with a high workload so tend to have much more focus on getting those exam results.

Selection is because children not suited to this will not do well there and will hold brighter kids back by slowing down lessons.

It's considered a good alternative to fee paying schools (private) but you won't get free school bus entitlement as that only applies to your nearest secondary school. Uniform can be a little more than other schools but only because you have to buy a blazer and lots of sports kit.
They still have free school meal entitlement and other financial help for trips though.
You have to apply to sit 11+ at least a year in advance (although mine did a late entry). If you want to pick a Grammar school it's a good idea to phone them for a chat about deadlines and preparing for 11+ because they don't all use the same exam board and you'd want to practise 11+ papers for the correct one.
Hope that helps. I can't believe the people sneering, not everyone is lucky enough to have the best education.

Villssev · 29/03/2023 05:54

My relatives and friends and I talk about our lives and our children's lives, and we compare and contrast our experiences and observations across three education systems.

when do you find the time @mathanxiety ? You seem to be on mumsnet posting long posts all day every day with many threads on the go!!

mathanxiety · 29/03/2023 04:54

thing47 · 28/03/2023 09:07

@RampantIvy I don't think that particular poster will be back for a while as she appears to live in the US, judging by her username and the timing of the majority of her posts. Don't you just loved being lectured about your country's education system by someone who doesn't live here and doesn't appear to know anything about how much it varies from area to area? 😂

Prior to having DCs most people I know live where they live for reasons of either work or family/friends. For example we moved to our current area pre-kids to support my dying MIL; turns out it's a grammar school area but I had no idea about that when we moved here because schools weren't on my radar then (wasn't even sure I could have kids). I'm pretty sure grammar schools weren't mentioned on the estate agents' literature!

I do live in the US, but as I stated, I have relatives and friends in the UK, people from several different generations. My relatives and friends and I talk about our lives and our children's lives, and we compare and contrast our experiences and observations across three education systems.

And LOL, but it is very clear that I know far more about how the UK works than many posters here do, in particular how the education system is the major prop of the class system, functioning as it does to produce an elite (accepted because of a notion of 'natural intelligence') and a massive number of educational casualties. A bonus for the elite is the number of people who are completely lacking in curiosity about how their own country works.

The fact that grammar provision varies from area to area is not an excuse for knowing nothing about how the elite achieved its current shape and form and how the non-comprehensive school pipeline continues to produce future Tory PMs and leaders in the realms of finance and law and medicine.

mathanxiety · 29/03/2023 04:21

MyopicBunny · 28/03/2023 04:55

@mathanxiety your sentiments don't make sense. Some children aren't bright enough to get into super selective schools but that does not exclude them from having a well paid career. I know many examples who earn more than people who went to university.

There are different kinds of intelligence. And you seem to be saying that anyone with any sense should be trying to get their children into one of less than 200 schools in the UK for them to do well in life which is a very narrow perspective.

Have you ever heard of the signs in boarding house windows of yore that read "No Blacks, No Dogs, No Irish"?

If you're the child of immigrants with an obviously foreign surname that announces you're from a specific, despised immigrant group, or your skin colour isn't what might be called traditionally Anglo Saxon, you tend to have less sanguine ideas about your chances or your children's chances of non academic forms of intelligence getting them ahead in the UK.

The idea that you'll find your place and do ok is one that comes from a place of privilege, both class-based and educational.

There are lots of people who are ready and willing to tell you what your place is and keep you firmly in it if you're not what they consider a traditionally British person.

My friends who arrived in the UK in the 80s and had children in the 90s and beyond didn't find things had changed all that much from the era of the boarding house signs.

The RC community in NI, which found itself discriminated against in significant ways, responded by focusing on education and sending children to university. Even today, working glass protestant boys have the lowest level of academic attainment in NI. It is simply not possible that these boys all have a different form of non-academic intelligence. The culture of a community matters, and its level of engagement with the education system too.

The idea that there are separate forms of intelligence only feeds the very quaint notion that the power elite of the UK have a God-given right to be where they are and do what they do by dint of their special academic intelligence. Regardless of how often it's claimed that all the different forms of intelligence are equal, the fact remains that certain forms seem to result in being funneled into certain schools and universities and on to certain careers.

They happen to be the careers where capital and power are concentrated. You don't have to be an immigrant to be concerned about the almost complete exclusion of people from backgrounds outside of the traditional prep-public/ grammar/ independent-route into law, finance, medicine, and the upper echelons of politics. As seen here, it's something that has gone unnoticed, but it's the 800lb gorilla in the room.

There are very few people who are so thick that they couldn't do well academically if pushed and encouraged and properly taught. Giving up on children shouldn't be an option. It happens across the board in English schools, beginning with setting in primary schools.

I am saying that unless you occupy a place of considerable privilege in the UK, you should be actively focusing your child's attention on their academic performance and doing whatever it takes to keep your child from becoming one of the huge number of academic casualties the system as currently constituted is designed to create.

BadNomad · 29/03/2023 04:20

In Northern Ireland we still have many grammar schools because we did not follow the rest of the UK in getting rid of the grammar school system.
We have "controlled grammars" and "voluntary grammars". Some voluntary grammars are private fee-paying independent schools. Some are boarding schools.

At primary level, we have prep schools (fee-paying independents schools) and feeder schools. Feeder schools are linked with, but not part of, certain grammar schools. Pupils from feeders will get more "points" when their linked grammar schools are selecting pupils. These primary schools are very popular and oversubscribed, so people usually have to start planning from birth on how to meet the admissions criteria.

Grammar schools are all very academic. Their goal is to send people to university, rather than into the workplace at 18-years-old. Something like 43% of children here go to grammar school.

I got in to mine via the 11+ with no tutoring or practice (just naturally smart). But I had a terrible experience because I had undiagnosed ASD and ADHD when I started and the school didn't know how to handle it so we pretty much just gave up on each other. They liked academic children who could keep up with no fuss. I would like to think things have improved since then.

mathanxiety · 29/03/2023 03:34

x2boys · 28/03/2023 10:18

There are supermarkets in every town ,village ,city in the country ,the same can't be said for Grammar school.,,I would have to travel 20,30,40, miles to find one ,depending on direction ,whereas I can walk to at least five different supermarkets,and even people who live in very rural.areas that have to.travel to.supermarkets ,everyone knows what they are as everyone has to eat ,it's not really the same at at all.

Let's expand that - there's only one London, one Liverpool, one Manchester, one Birmingham, one Glasgow, one Belfast - so it would be perfectly reasonable to not know anything about any of those places. They might be as far as fifty miles away, too. Who knows, who cares?

mathanxiety · 29/03/2023 03:29

Mumclub · 28/03/2023 19:34

For context in Yorkshire there are 6 grammar schools in total compared to Kent which has more than 30…. It’s quite obviously why some people might of never heard of them.

It is indeed quite obvious why some people might never have heard of them, and it's not because there are not a lot of grammar schools.

mathanxiety · 29/03/2023 03:26

x2boys · 28/03/2023 08:56

You can research all.you want but it a a bit presumptuous to.buy a house in a Grammar school.area on the assumption that your not yet born children will.pass the eleven plus ,it's a bit pointless if they don't isn't it ?
and there are so.few Grammar school,areas left any way ,there assent been a Grammar school system.in my town and surrounding towns since the 1970,st
there are some Good schools and not so.Good schools just like everywhere.

You can absolutely make sure your children will get in. You encourage them to focus on their schoolwork, you make sure they are reading way beyond what's expected in school, you chat woth them about what they're reading, you buy books and read them yourself, you spend time with your children doing mental arithmetic, you make sure they're working ahead in maths, you make them learn a musical instrument and play a sport. You chat with them about their struggles and you encourage them to persevere.

Do you think children arrive at age 10/ 11 with a chance to get into a grammar school or a bursary at an independent school straight out of thin air? That it's all natural intelligence and no parental input day after day for years and years?

I'm not talking about hothousing here. I'm talking about parents quietly making sure their children are prepared for the exam, and equipped with the focus and the mindset to succeed once they get to the school that will launch them into university.

mathanxiety · 29/03/2023 03:11

x2boys · 28/03/2023 09:53

Well you can't if you don't live in a Grammar school area,of which there are very few ,and if you live in a Grammar schoil area ,you can't just assume your child will.get in they have to.pass the eleven plus.

You can do what my immigrant relatives did and move into a grammar area - into a grotty bedsit initially, then a small flat, then a small house - then make sure your children apply themselves in primary school and get in.

Swipe left for the next trending thread