Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What the heck is a grammer school?

511 replies

BlackBarbies · 27/03/2023 15:29

Posting here for traffic!

Born and raised in South West London and still live here now. I’ve never heard of a grammar school until joining MN a couple of years ago.

Is it a primary school, is it a secondary school? Is it private or public? If it’s public, then why is it called a grammer school? Is it only available for certain types of children or something? I literally have no clue what a grammer school is so I’m happy to be enlightened!

Also, are there any in SW London? I’m genuinely intrigued as to how I’ve never come across one before

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
WeDontTalkAboutBrunoNoNoNo · 29/03/2023 20:53

The stupid google comments are so annoying. Imagine snarking at someone about not knowing what grammar schools are yet clearly having no idea about how a discussion forum works.

@BlackBarbies IB is not widely used in your average state secondary school in the uk although a couple do offer it. PYP is equivalent to uk primary curriculum, MYP is equivalent to uk secondary curriculum and DP is equivalent to uk A Levels. I use the term equivalent loosely because they are very different curriculums! Commonly used in private international schools that don't offer the host country's local curriculum.

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 29/03/2023 20:49

What about the students who want to take a subject like food or technology a bit furher in life?

Yeah that is the problem with opting for an academic route so early. Some leave at yr8/9 for schools where that is encouraged more. And yes three languages can be a stretch, especially when trying to learn in fewer lessons than their peers down the road.

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 29/03/2023 20:46

Yes I should be clearer a broader range of 'academic' subjects but in less time so maybe six language lessons a fortnight across three languages, whereas the non grammars I know offer two MFL over six lessons.

It can be hard to do some subjects even at GCSE so whereas art, music and drama might be offered, food tech, textiles, PE GCSEs might not be offered at all. This may also be due in part to the sizes of the schools. There has been more restrictions on the expansion of grammar schools, so the year groups may be half the size of other secondary schools.

BlackBarbies · 29/03/2023 20:41

@Unexpecteddrivinginstructor @LimeCheesecake so an IB is an alternative to A Levels? I’ve never heard of IB before

OP posts:
BlackBarbies · 29/03/2023 20:39

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 29/03/2023 20:24

Some grammar schools push through the curriculum faster, especially in maths and some might take GCSEs a year early. There might be a broader curriculum, so maybe three MFL (modern foreign languages) rather than one or two. I think the rationale is that because they are all quite intelligent they can learn things faster. There may be less emphasis on technology subjects - food tech, textiles etc.

It can affect well being if towards the bottom of the class and there can be competition between the students. Teaching also moves quickly so if you don't understand something then it is easy to be left behind. Most students would be entered for higher level GCSE papers, where there is an option. Some children though thrive in the setting.

Ah I see. What about the students who want to take a subject like food or technology a bit furher in life? The focus may be more centred towards traditional subjects?

Studying three languages😅 that sounds crazy! I struggled to even pass French

OP posts:
LimeCheesecake · 29/03/2023 20:36

Quite a few state schools / colleges offer the IB, I’m in Kent and locally I know if one grammar and one comp who offer it instead of A levels.

Also OP, while most grammars here are single sex for year 7 entry, they are mixed for 6th form/year 12 entry. There’s often a lot of movement between GCSE and A level, and many children who didn’t go to grammar schools at aged 11, moved to one at 16 to do their A levels.

KittyMcKitty · 29/03/2023 20:30

@Unexpecteddrivinginstructor i would disagree with your comment saying grammars offer a broader curriculum. Yes they may offer more languages etc but essentially the curriculum is probably narrower and focussed on more traditional subjects.

There is also a move away from taking subjects early with most schools taking all GCSEs in year 11.

The GCSEs taken may also be more prescriptive. At my children’s school everyone took triple science and had to take at least one language, 2 x English and Maths (and depending on your set Ad Maths / Further Maths) + 3 more subjects - so a min of 10. Everyone sat Higher Tier in Sciences, Maths and Languages.

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 29/03/2023 20:28

Some state schools offer the IB for sixth form. It is a broader sixth form curriculum than the standard 3 A levels.

I think it is really good that you are asking these questions @BlackBarbies shows you are still questionning and will seek out the education which will suit you babies when the time comes. Life would be boring if we didn't keep learning.

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 29/03/2023 20:24

Some grammar schools push through the curriculum faster, especially in maths and some might take GCSEs a year early. There might be a broader curriculum, so maybe three MFL (modern foreign languages) rather than one or two. I think the rationale is that because they are all quite intelligent they can learn things faster. There may be less emphasis on technology subjects - food tech, textiles etc.

It can affect well being if towards the bottom of the class and there can be competition between the students. Teaching also moves quickly so if you don't understand something then it is easy to be left behind. Most students would be entered for higher level GCSE papers, where there is an option. Some children though thrive in the setting.

Doone21 · 29/03/2023 20:15

Everyone in every type of school sits gcse and a levels. Some schools for special needs might not. Some schools offer more but yes it's all the same qualifications

BlackBarbies · 29/03/2023 19:44

KittyMcKitty · 29/03/2023 19:32

They sit GCSEs in exactly the same way (both in the grammar my children go to and the one I work in) - a grammar school is no different from any other state school.

some private schooos sit IGCSEs and some schools do other types of exams.

The only difference with exams you’ll get potentially in a grammar is that they will do traditional type subjects and just GCSE’s and A levels (as opposed to BTech’s).

Ahh right I completely get what you mean. So a grammar school and a typical secondary are exactly the same it’s just that the kids will have to sit an 11+ exam in year 6 to be able to get in to a grammar school. They also rarely do BTEC subjects during the sixth form years. That makes complete sense.

@Nonameoclue thanks for your comment too. I’ve never heard of iGCSEs before so that’s another new thing that I’ve learned. Yep the national curriculum. I definitely should have known that the whole country has to follow that🫣

OP posts:
weirdoboelady · 29/03/2023 19:43

Sorry, your question actually asked about the end of y11. There is an IB Middle Years Programme for students aged 11 to 16.

weirdoboelady · 29/03/2023 19:41

My understanding is as follows.

Firstly, you may not know it but there are different GCSEs and A levels. Different exam boards, but the results generally count for the same (especially at GCSE level. I can imagine that there might be some A levels in specific subjects which are preferred by some professors interviewing people for admission to specific universities.)

Most grammar schools and public schools use the same exams as everybody else.

There are some schools which I think are all private but I'm not 100% sure, which use the International Baccalaureate system instead. And I know that at some private schools pupils can choose to do IB instead of the more normal exams. And I have just discovered there is an IB Primary Years Programme for children aged 3 to 12, so I suppose those children would bypass any local 11+ exams. I think the choice to do IB is usually at A level, though, and IB is accepted by UCAS for university entrance.

I am not aware of any other 'special' exams taken in private schools except the Common Entrance at around 13 years of age, which I have already mentioned.

BlackBarbies · 29/03/2023 19:33

EffortlessDesmond · 29/03/2023 17:29

[Applause] for @BlackBarbies. It's really vanishingly rare to encounter an OP who is genuinely seeking information and inviting a range of opinions. I am sure that you will find your DC schools to suit their abilities and temperaments, and I hope that this thread will have helped you formulate what will make them the best choices.

Thank you! I really hope so too. Surely MN is about learning things that will make a difference to your kids lives and asking questions.

I ask a question and apparently I’m trying to start a debate and whatnot. I really have learned a lot

OP posts:
Nonameoclue · 29/03/2023 19:33

Everyone does GCSEs. As grammar schools are state schools they follow the national curriculum. A few might do the odd iGCSE (international GCSE). Same for private schools, although more of the have tended to do iGCSEs.

KittyMcKitty · 29/03/2023 19:32

BlackBarbies · 29/03/2023 19:28

Now this question is for those who have genuinely helped me and not those taking the piss or accusing me of a troll!

So for those that go to grammar schools, do they still do GCSE’s or do they complete a different type of exam at the end of year 11?

Writing this has just made me think, what about those that go to private school? For some reason I just assumed that those in private school sit different exams. I mean, you have a paid education and you sit the same exams as us commoners. Surely not?!

They sit GCSEs in exactly the same way (both in the grammar my children go to and the one I work in) - a grammar school is no different from any other state school.

some private schooos sit IGCSEs and some schools do other types of exams.

The only difference with exams you’ll get potentially in a grammar is that they will do traditional type subjects and just GCSE’s and A levels (as opposed to BTech’s).

BlackBarbies · 29/03/2023 19:28

Now this question is for those who have genuinely helped me and not those taking the piss or accusing me of a troll!

So for those that go to grammar schools, do they still do GCSE’s or do they complete a different type of exam at the end of year 11?

Writing this has just made me think, what about those that go to private school? For some reason I just assumed that those in private school sit different exams. I mean, you have a paid education and you sit the same exams as us commoners. Surely not?!

OP posts:
TheOriginalEmu · 29/03/2023 19:15

Hbh17 · 27/03/2023 15:31

How can you not know?!
Secondary school if child passes 11 plus.
And it's "grammar" school.

Because in lots of parts of the country they were abolished years ago thankfully.

BlackBarbies · 29/03/2023 19:13

permitholder · 29/03/2023 15:42

Hi OP. As explained, grammar schools have been largely abolished these days. There are some local authorities that have kept the 11 plus system - ie. parts of Kent, Essex, Buckinghamshire, Lincolnshire and Wirral (?). In addition there are some other grammars dotted around - eg. in Devon and some parts of London. I think there are about 220 grammars across the entire U.K. (so not many in the scheme of things).

Don't be confused by schools that have become private, but just retained the name "grammar" - eg. Kingston Grammar. Also some comprehensives may have done the same.

Basically, "grammar" just means children have to pass an 11 plus exam to get in. But not all grammars are equally selective - eg, the ones in Lincolnshire may take up to 50% of local children, whereas somewhere like Tiffin in Kingston will only take about 5%. How selective a school is will be reflected in exam results.

If you are in Brixton, the nearest grammars would be those in the Borough of Sutton (Wilson's and another one, I think)? But I think you need to live in Sutton Borough to apply. Apart from this there is Tiffin Girls and Tiffin Boys in Kingston - these are so-called 'superselectives' with no catchment area. In North London there are a couple of other very selective grammars - The Latymer School ( not to be confused with Latymer Upper in Hammersmith which used to be a boys grammar, but is now a superselective co-ed independent day school) and Queen Elizabeth School. There may well be a couple more.

Grammars are not the only form of selective state schools. Have a Google about Brampton Manor in East London - a very selective state academy that gets more than any other school (including Eton etc) into Oxbridge every year. I think there is another similar school in that area as well.

Other schools are faith schools and have their own form of selection which may well involve some nonsense about which children were baptised as quickly as possible after birth; or who has shown up to help with church raffles etc.

Don't just 'chuck' your kids in any old school. London is not like other parts of the U.K. and people outside London don't always fully understand this. Some schools are rife with stabbings and all kinds of antisocial behaviour and this is why so many families make the decision to go private / move out / move to certain catchment areas. In London, many of the best schools in the U.K. are in proximity to some of the worst. The gulf is huge and reinforced by the fact that those who can will inevitably seek better / safer options for their kids. It's all very well people in the suburbs and country pontificating - how many children have been stabbed at their local schools?

Anyway, good luck.

This was very informative, basically a conclusion of what many people have said.

Now, Brampton Manor is something that I’ve heard of!! Every year (since I left school in 2015), Brampton Manor post’s peoples A Level results on Twitter and will say what uni they’ll be going too. Every single year, there’s so many students going to Oxford, Cambridge etc. I always remember the name because so many black students get into Russel Group Unis which makes me so proud. So wait are you saying Brampton Manor is a grammar school? I just assumed it was a standard secondary?

Yep, my school had quite a few stabbings unfortunately. It differently makes sense to think of schools and consider relocating instead of just putting up with whatever’s near you

OP posts:
BlackBarbies · 29/03/2023 18:59

Villssev · 29/03/2023 15:38

So why some people are trying to shoot me down for finally showing an interest,

Cut yourself some slack OP. You have babies not a 10/11 year old with a school preference form due in!!

Honestly😂

OP posts:
RampantIvy · 29/03/2023 17:37

Hear hear @EffortlessDesmond.
I was told I couldn't have children and when I finally had DD I had no idea about the school application process, and had no-one I could ask as I was new to the area and everyone else I knew had much older children.

I spend more time on the higher education threads now but, apart from a handful of superior posters who criticize your DC's choice of university (and they can be extremely snobby) most posters don't sneer at you for not knowing stuff.

EffortlessDesmond · 29/03/2023 17:29

[Applause] for @BlackBarbies. It's really vanishingly rare to encounter an OP who is genuinely seeking information and inviting a range of opinions. I am sure that you will find your DC schools to suit their abilities and temperaments, and I hope that this thread will have helped you formulate what will make them the best choices.

RampantIvy · 29/03/2023 15:57

Thank you @Weald56 and @NeverApologiseNeverExplain I didn't know that all grammar schools were state schools.

You are right @CurlewKate privilege does come into it. I was responding to mathanxiety's incorrect assumption that all children can apply themsleves to get a place at grammar school.

permitholder · 29/03/2023 15:42

Hi OP. As explained, grammar schools have been largely abolished these days. There are some local authorities that have kept the 11 plus system - ie. parts of Kent, Essex, Buckinghamshire, Lincolnshire and Wirral (?). In addition there are some other grammars dotted around - eg. in Devon and some parts of London. I think there are about 220 grammars across the entire U.K. (so not many in the scheme of things).

Don't be confused by schools that have become private, but just retained the name "grammar" - eg. Kingston Grammar. Also some comprehensives may have done the same.

Basically, "grammar" just means children have to pass an 11 plus exam to get in. But not all grammars are equally selective - eg, the ones in Lincolnshire may take up to 50% of local children, whereas somewhere like Tiffin in Kingston will only take about 5%. How selective a school is will be reflected in exam results.

If you are in Brixton, the nearest grammars would be those in the Borough of Sutton (Wilson's and another one, I think)? But I think you need to live in Sutton Borough to apply. Apart from this there is Tiffin Girls and Tiffin Boys in Kingston - these are so-called 'superselectives' with no catchment area. In North London there are a couple of other very selective grammars - The Latymer School ( not to be confused with Latymer Upper in Hammersmith which used to be a boys grammar, but is now a superselective co-ed independent day school) and Queen Elizabeth School. There may well be a couple more.

Grammars are not the only form of selective state schools. Have a Google about Brampton Manor in East London - a very selective state academy that gets more than any other school (including Eton etc) into Oxbridge every year. I think there is another similar school in that area as well.

Other schools are faith schools and have their own form of selection which may well involve some nonsense about which children were baptised as quickly as possible after birth; or who has shown up to help with church raffles etc.

Don't just 'chuck' your kids in any old school. London is not like other parts of the U.K. and people outside London don't always fully understand this. Some schools are rife with stabbings and all kinds of antisocial behaviour and this is why so many families make the decision to go private / move out / move to certain catchment areas. In London, many of the best schools in the U.K. are in proximity to some of the worst. The gulf is huge and reinforced by the fact that those who can will inevitably seek better / safer options for their kids. It's all very well people in the suburbs and country pontificating - how many children have been stabbed at their local schools?

Anyway, good luck.

Villssev · 29/03/2023 15:38

So why some people are trying to shoot me down for finally showing an interest,

Cut yourself some slack OP. You have babies not a 10/11 year old with a school preference form due in!!