Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What the heck is a grammer school?

511 replies

BlackBarbies · 27/03/2023 15:29

Posting here for traffic!

Born and raised in South West London and still live here now. I’ve never heard of a grammar school until joining MN a couple of years ago.

Is it a primary school, is it a secondary school? Is it private or public? If it’s public, then why is it called a grammer school? Is it only available for certain types of children or something? I literally have no clue what a grammer school is so I’m happy to be enlightened!

Also, are there any in SW London? I’m genuinely intrigued as to how I’ve never come across one before

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
mathanxiety · 29/03/2023 22:42

The assumption that some kids are bright and some are not is one that leads you down a very dangerous path.

It couldn't possibly be that certain ethnic and racial groups and income levels / free school meals status are intellectual and certain ethnic and racial groups and income levels/ fsm determination are not.

When you look at the breakdown of GCSE results on a national level, it would be best not to jump to conclusions about natural levels of intellect. That way, you can avoid racial stereotyping.

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 29/03/2023 22:33

@BlackBarbies Ebacc - English Baccalaurate not to be confused with the IB. The Ebacc is something dreamt up by government to encourage schools to ensure that children have a broad education to 16. It is based on GCSEs but is used for school level league tables. Some schools care about it more than others

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 29/03/2023 22:25

The GCSEs taken may also be more prescriptive. At my children’s school everyone took triple science and had to take at least one language, 2 x English and Maths (and depending on your set Ad Maths / Further Maths) + 3 more subjects - so a min of 10. Everyone sat Higher Tier in Sciences, Maths and Languages.

They may have their eyes on the Ebacc and league tables. Interestingly some of the super selectives offer more flexibility, they don't care about league tables because children will come anyway. My child in a non grammar school had the fewest free choices for GCSE. Still expected to do ten as standard.

I think it highlights that there are substantial differences between grammar schools so it is hard to generalise.

mathanxiety · 29/03/2023 22:23

RampantIvy · 29/03/2023 07:46

mathanxiety doesn't seem to realise that you cannot make a silk purse out of a sow's ear.

It has nothing to do with poverty of aspiration. Some children simply do not have the academic ability.

You're saying the schools with the worst results are full of thick kids.

The lowest attaining cohort in the English education system is working class white boys. Are you absolutely sure they're not academically inclined, or are schools failing them in some very important amd fundamental ways, or is their home environment giving them messages about working class white male identity that are working against school?

Bear in mind that the sisters of these working class white boys (and the RC white working class boys and their sisters in NI) tend to do better.

The concept of a stratification of intellect leads to meek acceptance of the class system and the power structure of the UK. It's something that obviously benefits those at the top.

Nonameoclue · 29/03/2023 22:14

Jarstastic · 29/03/2023 21:23

When would the decision have been made for pupils at secondary moderns and comprehensives under the O level/CSE system?

At age 10, which is of course ridiculous. At secondary moderns they did CSEs -& at grammar schools they did O levels.

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 29/03/2023 22:11

Jarstastic · 29/03/2023 21:23

When would the decision have been made for pupils at secondary moderns and comprehensives under the O level/CSE system?

My grammar school did not offer CSEs so it was a case of do well enough at O level or fail. The secondary moderns I think did a mixture of a subjects available at O level but some just CSE. The school you went to age 11 affected which exams you could take at 16. Without O levels it was harder to access A levels and degree. Now with GCSEs it is much easier to move on to A level whichever school you were at.

LadyIckenham · 29/03/2023 21:52

@KittyMcKitty Very different where we are but then it never ceases to amaze me how much people set their stalls out for a grammar at an early stage.

nervous234 · 29/03/2023 21:50

Thanks for starting this thread, OP - I knew what a grammar school was (only found out recently as I'm central London with very young children so no experience). This has been so helpful.

KittyMcKitty · 29/03/2023 21:38

@LadyIckenham the grammar my children attend and also the one I work at (both Bucks) have very few students from independent schools - the vast majority are from Bucks primaries (plus the few 11+ tourists who move into the area).

Sport is good because Bucks has some excellent clubs (eg Marlow Hockey Club) where a great many children play from a very early age.

EffortlessDesmond · 29/03/2023 21:37

@Jarstastic , probably as late as Easter before the exams were being set. Teachers would have wanted to know who was as good as they thought, and who was blagging it, before sixth form. There would always be kids who were only just beginning to hit their stride at 15, and some who were turning away from education.

permitholder · 29/03/2023 21:29

Also OP, with London state schools, never assume your kids will get into the school (or several schools) nearest to you because very often, there is no such thing as 'just go to your local school.' London is too densely populated and, although the borough legally has to find a school place somewhere for your child, it could easily be in the opposite side of the borough and / or involve a convoluted journey passing many other (oversubscribed) schools en route. For the most popular schools (particularly primaries) catchment areas may be limited to one or two streets.

LadyIckenham · 29/03/2023 21:25

My experience of Bucks is that sports is good in grammars due to all the children coming from prep schools where they have greater provision than state primaries. This is also reflected in local rugby clubs.

There are many children who do sports in out of school clubs but this is also the case at our local upper.

I have one, soon to be two, at grammars. The one currently there feels very strongly that they should be abolished in light of the attitudes of certain of her classmates....

Jarstastic · 29/03/2023 21:23

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 29/03/2023 21:06

Everyone should take GCSEs but perhaps in comprehensives and secondary moderns more take the foundation level. This is a paper where the maximum grade is 5.

And this decision might not be firmly made until March of yr11. Whereas in the old system of CSE and O levels that decision might be effectively made at age 11 with grammars offering only O levels.

When would the decision have been made for pupils at secondary moderns and comprehensives under the O level/CSE system?

boys3 · 29/03/2023 21:21

@BlackBarbies you may find this - HOCL Grammar Schools in England, published a couple of weeks ago, of interest, though I'd recommend skipping through the more tedious bits.

https://commonslibrary.parliament.uk/research-briefings/sn07070/

However it reinforces some of the excellent points made on this thread, and debunks most of the more ill-informed ones.

However your thread title might have better started with "why" rather than "what"

The first Blair government introduced the School Standards and Frameworks Act, sections 104 to 109 of which

make provision for parental ballots to determine whether particular grammar schools or groups of grammar schools should retain their selective admission arrangements. A ballot can only be held if at least 20% of eligible parents have signed a petition requesting a ballot.

There has been one ballot - way back in the early 2000s - in Ripon, which failed.

Grammar opponents would argue that the ballot system set out by the Act is highly flawed. An argument that is not without basis. However a removal method does exist.

The wider public seem a bit "meh" about it all, The report linked above references a YouGov survey from last September.

  • 26% of respondents held a ‘positive view’ about grammar school selection,
  • 23% of people held a ‘negative view,
  • 23% wanted to maintain the status quo,66 and
  • 28% were not sure.

The age group most likely to hold a ‘positive view’ were those aged over 65 (39% reported this view in September 2022 compared with just 14% of 18-24 year olds).

Broken down by location, people living in the South of England (excluding London) were the most likely to hold a ‘positive view’ (33% reported this view in September 2022 compared with just 16% of people in Scotland).

permitholder · 29/03/2023 21:16

All schools do GCSEs OP. Depending on the school / student ability they may take anything between 8 and 11 GCSEs as standard. The only variation is that there are different exam boards eg. AQA, Edexcel, Eduqas and schools can choose the board for each subject in the school depending on the curriculum that they prefer. But all GCSEs are marked between grades 9-1, with 4 considered a 'pass' (equivalent to the old 'C' grade). 7 is an A, 8 is an A star and 9 is a high A star.

At 16-18 it is either A-levels, or the IB (International Baccalaureate - but it's only really international schools and some independent schools that offer this). Otherwise, there are other courses like T-levels, BTECs etc.

Brampton Manor is not a grammar (I don't think so anyway). I think it's what is called an Academy. The thing is, it's a very large, selective school and they only take students who are academically able in the first place (there is an entrance exam). My DC is at Cambridge and has met loads from Brampton who report that they get identified for the Oxbridge track pre-GCSE and then EVERYTHING is geared to this. Apparently they go in at 6am sometimes for extra classes - this kind of thing- and it's very much a hothouse, in this respect. The school has links with certain Oxbridge colleges and will pull certain strings. Students are 'advised' what subjects to apply for; what colleges may be more promising for them, etc. Also, although the school will get about 60 into Oxbridge which is astonishing on the face of it, this is actually 'only' about 10-20% of a very large year group and, in this respect, is a similar (perhaps lower) success ratio than the top independent 'super-selective' schools like Westminster or St Paul's School etc.

There are other Academy schools too (though perhaps none so academic as BM). They are state funded but have freedom to set their own selection criteria (eg, they are not always required to only accept from a specified catchment). The London Free School in Hammersmith is an example - it was set up by some guy who had a vision for a state school that taught more traditional subjects like Latin and Greek.

Pertinentowl · 29/03/2023 21:16

My sisters kid just got into all the ones you mentioned, so she’s just joined the WhatsApp groups for parents, and she’s really gobsmacked at the parents coming from private schools. They are obsessed. I don’t see how they have saved money if they have paid for six years of private schools already. Also the school with the highest number of acceptances was a state school. But yea there’s a lot of talk about tutors and clubs and music and all the bells and whistles that they feel they have to provide in order for their kid to get in and maintain being in one.

Depends on the kid. This one gets through a powerful amount of work. But I wouldn’t call her particularly street smart and she might get gobbled up in a school that isn’t academic enough. That would have been awful for my boys though, they wouldn’t have stood the pressure.

I think the key is not to buy into a sunk cost fallacy and if you get a place try and keep it at all costs if it’s not working for your kid. I hope they let them transfer to state if they have to

KittyMcKitty · 29/03/2023 21:09

I think the key thing is that no two state schools are the same irrespective of whether they are grammar, upper (previously secondary modern) or comprehensive.

as I’ve said previously I live / work in Bucks which is 100% selective so no comprehensive schools.

The grammars are a mix of mixed sex and single sex (my children attend mixed sex) and the Upper schools are mixed sex.

Some observations on the schools in Bucks. The grammars in general offer a far superior music provision - at my children’s school music is a v popular gcse and also popular A levels. There are many choirs / orchestras/ ensembles. The local upper school (a very good school) does not offer the same level of opportunities - there are many arguments as to why this may be - upper schools having a broader range of abilities and grammars being full of middle class kids whose parents can affford to pay for music lessons etc being the most common.

Sport in the grammars in Bucks is also at a higher level then in some (not all) Uppers in the county - again this may be down to the relative affluence of the parents and children being members of outside sports clubs from a young age.

My childrens school also offers dance (and drama) to A level and has many students at a high level who go into specialist education post A level (the same with music and conservatoires).

The downside is my children did not have the opportunity to do things like food tech / textiles / media etc or DT beyond GCSE.

Lastlid · 29/03/2023 21:09

BlackBarbies · 29/03/2023 19:28

Now this question is for those who have genuinely helped me and not those taking the piss or accusing me of a troll!

So for those that go to grammar schools, do they still do GCSE’s or do they complete a different type of exam at the end of year 11?

Writing this has just made me think, what about those that go to private school? For some reason I just assumed that those in private school sit different exams. I mean, you have a paid education and you sit the same exams as us commoners. Surely not?!

Yes. They sit the same exams as the commoners. A levels, o levels and baccalaureate.

WeDontTalkAboutBrunoNoNoNo · 29/03/2023 21:08

The IB itself is not an alternative to A Levels, the Diploma Programme if the IB is.

LimeCheesecake · 29/03/2023 21:06

Yep the IB/ international baccalaureate is an international alternative to A levels, usually 3 at higher level (same as A level) and another group of subjects studied at a lower level, but not sure how many lower. It’s studied in many other countries so helps that it’s easily convertible to local qualifications by employers /unis wanting to compare, if that makes sense.

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 29/03/2023 21:06

Everyone should take GCSEs but perhaps in comprehensives and secondary moderns more take the foundation level. This is a paper where the maximum grade is 5.

And this decision might not be firmly made until March of yr11. Whereas in the old system of CSE and O levels that decision might be effectively made at age 11 with grammars offering only O levels.

Jarstastic · 29/03/2023 21:02

Some private schools are selective some aren’t. Part of what you are paying for is small classes, a longer school day and peers who are encouraged at home.

Jarstastic · 29/03/2023 20:58

OP if either of your children is doing well academically by Y3 it is worth looking at grammar schools in Sutton borough and Kent. If you start early with extra help they have a chance of getting in. I know a child from south east London who got into a Kent grammar.
I believe there are 2 tests for Kent depending on part of Kent. This child didn’t have tutoring but did have a lot of practice with a parent using books. Non Verbal Reasoning particularly needs practice. There is also an online platform called Atom Learning.

From your user name and your recent posts I’ve gathered you are black. I mentioned in an earlier post I was on a train north through Kent recently, the amount of children who got on after school at Tunbridge Wells and Tonbridge who got off at London Bridge (presumably to change trains) and a lot of them were black.

Everyone should take GCSEs but perhaps in comprehensives and secondary moderns more take the foundation level. This is a paper where the maximum grade is 5. I don’t know when these came in. When I was taking GCSEs everyone did the same paper. this higher and foundation papers seems more similar to the O level and CSE system and at that point if you did the latter university maybe even A levels weren’t the track they were on.

You can also go across education areas (counties or boroughs depending on where people live) and can go into a grammar school at sixth form. People who couldn’t get in at 11 may get in at this point.

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 29/03/2023 20:57

The International Baccalaureate ibo.org is a broader, but still very academic alternative to A levels. Not offered at any of my dc's schools, so I am not an expert. There are options, but generally they continue with at least maths and English plus often a language, science and other subjects, some they do in more depth plus there is a community service aspect I believe. Would maybe suit an academic all rounder.

Another aspect is that many grammar schools are single sex at least to 16. Often with mixed sixth forms when there might also be movement between schools.

WeDontTalkAboutBrunoNoNoNo · 29/03/2023 20:56

@BlackBarbies sorry just realised I used a bunch of acronyms which mean nothing if you've never heard of them!

IB= International Baccalaureate
PYP=Primary Years Programme
MYP= Middle Years Programme
DP= Diploma Programme

PYP, MYP and DP are the different phases of the International Baccalaureate

Swipe left for the next trending thread