Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What the heck is a grammer school?

511 replies

BlackBarbies · 27/03/2023 15:29

Posting here for traffic!

Born and raised in South West London and still live here now. I’ve never heard of a grammar school until joining MN a couple of years ago.

Is it a primary school, is it a secondary school? Is it private or public? If it’s public, then why is it called a grammer school? Is it only available for certain types of children or something? I literally have no clue what a grammer school is so I’m happy to be enlightened!

Also, are there any in SW London? I’m genuinely intrigued as to how I’ve never come across one before

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
spanieleyes · 27/03/2023 17:22

I attended a direct grant grammar school- in the dim and distant past! So it was a private school but the local authority paid for 20 places a year. That meant we had to sit the 11+. If we passed that, we sat the entrance exam. If we passed that, we sat the direct grant exam. If we passed that, we were interviewed by the Head. If we passed that, we got a free place! Some people dropped out at each stage, if you passed the entrance exam but not the grant exam you could still go to the school but only if you paid! Hundreds and hundreds of children initially applied, but were gradually whittled down!

My sons attended a more recent state grammar school, they passed the 11+ and scored enough to get a place.

Villssev · 27/03/2023 17:22

VeggieSalsa · 27/03/2023 16:20

Huddersfield Grammar is definitely a private school.

The clue is you have to pay for your children to attend.

Yes I was agreeing with you

WestendVBroadway · 27/03/2023 17:22

There are no grammar schools in my area anymore. They were changed to comprehensives in 1978 when I was due to take my 11 plus. I just remember my parents and teachers saying that the 11 plus and grammar schools were being abolished by the government. I actually assumed that this was a Country wide thing and not down to local councils. It was not until I was in my mid 20s and had an argument a discussion with a friend from up Country that I realised that the 11 plus and grammar schools still existed in other counties.

Cornwallinthesun · 27/03/2023 17:22

Oh my lordy this thread is scary!! 😂

garlictwist · 27/03/2023 17:21

Hbh17 · 27/03/2023 15:31

How can you not know?!
Secondary school if child passes 11 plus.
And it's "grammar" school.

I had also never heard of them until MN. They are not a thing where I live.

StarmanBobby · 27/03/2023 17:21

Very common in Northern Ireland, less so in England. None where we live nor in the area at all. I was surprised to discover they still existed in England when I started working in Education.

Fansandblankets · 27/03/2023 17:21

I’m surprised you’ve never heard of them if you live in or around London. I’m 51, grew up in South East London, took the 11 plus. If you passed you could go to grammar school or like in our school there were 3 bands, those that passed the 11+ were in too band.

SummerSazz · 27/03/2023 17:20

Ginmonkeyagain · 27/03/2023 16:17

Genuine question - how do these intensively tutored kids get on once they get to grammar school? Does the tutoring continue? They can be pretty unforgiving places to kids who can't keep up with the pace.

My DC go to a super selective grammar. passing doesn't guarantee a place, just the top 150 who pass and choose a place there - there are 5 grammars within reasonable distance (3 all girls, 2 mixed sex).

They both had a tutor from the start of Y5 and took the test at the start of Y6. Tutoring isn't all about intensive study but instead is:

  • give them experience of how to take an exam (they went to a rural primary where they didn't do any real exams).
  • Part of that is how to fill in a multiple choice paper (filling in the boxes)
  • part is how to allocate time to each section and move on if they couldn't answer it
  • the non-verbal reasoning paper is like. Foreign language if you've never seen it before so you need to understand the technique as to how to answer it
  • the paper includes curriculum from Y6 work but exam is taken in the sept of Y6 so they need help with this

I do think it's unfair that parents who can afford a tutor or have parents who can help with the above (me and my DC would have clashed if I'd tried) are able to give their DC advantage. But it doesn't mean they then struggle with the work

I wish the primary schools would give all children the help as above but apparently they aren't allowed to 🤨. So it is no longer a leveller for bright kids who come from poorer or unsupported households.

My DC are thriving in an all girls school so I feel very lucky they have had this (privileged) opportunity.

Dixiechickonhols · 27/03/2023 17:20

slamfightbrightlight · 27/03/2023 17:10

Only 75% of places fill (pass and catchment guarantees a place) 25% bus in from surrounding areas.

This just seems like madness - why not marginally expanding the admission criteria to allow more local children to attend 🤯 I know the single sex grammar I attended has since had to become mixed sex in order to fill places which just seems like a real loss for local girls.

Lots of new houses being built but they’ve expanded school size again. I suspect eventually there will be less out of catchment.
The out of catchment children are taken in score order. They are often prepped from a very young age as their local options are poor.
In catchment there’s outstanding none selective options with great results so lots of parents don’t bother putting children in for it.

slamfightbrightlight · 27/03/2023 17:20

I hadn’t realised the Latin connection to the definition of grammar until today. We did do Latin but not all the grammars around us did.

YoungMotherHubbardsDog · 27/03/2023 17:20

OhVicIveFallen · 27/03/2023 17:07

Yep, the middle class twattery on this thread is off the fucking scale.

Ditto for the thickpiece twattery - jealous of those who have brains and want to make the best of themselves.

BlackBarbies · 27/03/2023 17:20

Atteloiv · 27/03/2023 17:16

Hey OP 👋

I’m guessing you’re relatively young compared to a lot of us 😬 if being from Brixton means you don’t know the other areas of London so well? I’m from East London but have moved all around North London, South London, Kent and other cities, I think it’s unusual to stay in one place well into adulthood, which may be why people are a bit surprised. It’s nice you are obviously happy where you are.

But yes I had no idea grammar schools existed until I moved to kent and I was like whaaaaaat I thought this was a 1970s thing.

Can’t be arsed to read the whole thread, but for what it’s worth…

Schools can be private, aka independent, or state. Some very old posh private schools are called ‘public’ schools because they come from an era when private tutoring was the norm for the rich. (But in American movies a ‘public school’ means it isn’t private, lol).

Private schools don’t have junior/ secondary, they are instead called Prep for age 7-11/13 and Senior for the older years.

Grammar schools are a kind of state school that was invented to give clever children who can’t afford private school a place where they could get a fast-paced ambitious education in a quiet hard-working environment. For a while, this worked. In the 1950s-1990s, if you were a bright kid in a grammar area, your state school teacher would quietly give you a bit of 11+ exam practice as extra classwork and if you were bright you’d get into grammar school. This genuinely enabled some children of low income working class families to get into universities/ high paid jobs they wouldn’t otherwise have had a chance at. Some of those children grew up to be Tory politicians and they think grammar schools are brilliant.

But, there were problems. It was divisive for families: if one child passes the exam and the other is less bright or just sick on exam day and fails, they go to different schools, are given different opportunities, and worst of all the jealousy and resentment forever poisoned a lot of sibling relationships.

Another problem was that, as private school costs got higher and higher compared to middle class incomes (fees being mostly driven by overseas students particularly from Russia and China being prepared to pay anything for a UK private education, and austerity etc holding down UK incomes), and grammar schools got more similar to some private schools, the UK middle class began to realise that it made more sense to spend ££££ on grammar school exam preparation and buy a house in a grammar area than it did to spend £1million on secondary school fees for 4 kids.

At the same time, the government banned state primary schools from helping children to prepare for the grammar school exam. 🤔 Not sure why.

So, currently grammar schools are for the children of families who can afford to buy a house at an inflated price to be in the right area AND can afford to pay for lots of private tuition and/or a prep school.

And children from state primary schools have very little chance of passing the grammar school exam unless their parents are prepared to spend a lot of money/time on tutoring and exam practice.

🤷‍♀️ Funny old world

And quite a few kids at grammar school have a horrible time because of the constant pressure.

🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️ Not sure what I think about it, I was a clever kid in a rough noisy comp and would have thrived at a grammar school but never mind.

Great post! Thanks for the detailed breakdown

OP posts:
TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 27/03/2023 17:20

Orangepolentacake · 27/03/2023 17:15

What? Are these real places? “Nonsuch”?? 😂

Henry VIII had a palace there which was all fanciful and decorated, hence the name.

coldmarchmorn · 27/03/2023 17:19

NeverApologiseNeverExplain · 27/03/2023 17:01

Nope, those all just have “Grammar” in the name. And are in Ireland so of course they don’t meet the definition of grammar schools in the English educational system!

Who said they did? You said "there isn't ONE definition of grammer schools that includes fee-paying" You didn't say IN England.

Turns out when you remember that other places exist, you realise other definitions exist! They are grammar schools, and they are fee paying.

BlackBarbies · 27/03/2023 17:19

BlackBarbies · 27/03/2023 17:17

Haha no just the names of the grammer schools in South London. Another thing that I’ve learned today

Just spelt grammar wrong again, Jesus

OP posts:
LakieLady · 27/03/2023 17:19

slamfightbrightlight · 27/03/2023 15:34

Also, confusingly, we have a school near us with Grammar in the name which is actually a fee-paying school.

So do we! It's prefaced with the word "Old" though, to ensure that everyone knows it was founded in 1512 and make it sound posher.

.

BlackBarbies · 27/03/2023 17:17

Orangepolentacake · 27/03/2023 17:15

What? Are these real places? “Nonsuch”?? 😂

Haha no just the names of the grammer schools in South London. Another thing that I’ve learned today

OP posts:
BlackBarbies · 27/03/2023 17:16

sunshinesupermum · 27/03/2023 17:10

SW = Brixton, Streatham, Croydon. Also Wandsworth, Putney, Wimbledon, Balham, Tooting, Clapham, Battersea, Earslfield, Southfields etc

Putney, Wimbledon, Earslfield and Southfields seem so far away!! But I do consider the other places to be SW London tbh!

OP posts:
Lordofmyflies · 27/03/2023 17:16

We have a grammar school within 10 miles of us which both my kids attend. They went to a state primary. In year 5, when talk of secondary school options arose and having viewed the local comprehensives and the grammar, they had a preference for the grammar. I bought the CGP books from amazon and worked through them with them. They sat the exams and were offered a place.

You don't have to pay for a tutor. You don't have to be local. Kids travel 90 mins each way by travel to go to school. I feel you do need to be proactive as a parent - no one tells you about admission criteria, paper etc. You need to research it yourself. Primary assumed children would filter into the local comp and weren't much help.

Atteloiv · 27/03/2023 17:16

Hey OP 👋

I’m guessing you’re relatively young compared to a lot of us 😬 if being from Brixton means you don’t know the other areas of London so well? I’m from East London but have moved all around North London, South London, Kent and other cities, I think it’s unusual to stay in one place well into adulthood, which may be why people are a bit surprised. It’s nice you are obviously happy where you are.

But yes I had no idea grammar schools existed until I moved to kent and I was like whaaaaaat I thought this was a 1970s thing.

Can’t be arsed to read the whole thread, but for what it’s worth…

Schools can be private, aka independent, or state. Some very old posh private schools are called ‘public’ schools because they come from an era when private tutoring was the norm for the rich. (But in American movies a ‘public school’ means it isn’t private, lol).

Private schools don’t have junior/ secondary, they are instead called Prep for age 7-11/13 and Senior for the older years.

Grammar schools are a kind of state school that was invented to give clever children who can’t afford private school a place where they could get a fast-paced ambitious education in a quiet hard-working environment. For a while, this worked. In the 1950s-1990s, if you were a bright kid in a grammar area, your state school teacher would quietly give you a bit of 11+ exam practice as extra classwork and if you were bright you’d get into grammar school. This genuinely enabled some children of low income working class families to get into universities/ high paid jobs they wouldn’t otherwise have had a chance at. Some of those children grew up to be Tory politicians and they think grammar schools are brilliant.

But, there were problems. It was divisive for families: if one child passes the exam and the other is less bright or just sick on exam day and fails, they go to different schools, are given different opportunities, and worst of all the jealousy and resentment forever poisoned a lot of sibling relationships.

Another problem was that, as private school costs got higher and higher compared to middle class incomes (fees being mostly driven by overseas students particularly from Russia and China being prepared to pay anything for a UK private education, and austerity etc holding down UK incomes), and grammar schools got more similar to some private schools, the UK middle class began to realise that it made more sense to spend ££££ on grammar school exam preparation and buy a house in a grammar area than it did to spend £1million on secondary school fees for 4 kids.

At the same time, the government banned state primary schools from helping children to prepare for the grammar school exam. 🤔 Not sure why.

So, currently grammar schools are for the children of families who can afford to buy a house at an inflated price to be in the right area AND can afford to pay for lots of private tuition and/or a prep school.

And children from state primary schools have very little chance of passing the grammar school exam unless their parents are prepared to spend a lot of money/time on tutoring and exam practice.

🤷‍♀️ Funny old world

And quite a few kids at grammar school have a horrible time because of the constant pressure.

🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️🤷‍♀️ Not sure what I think about it, I was a clever kid in a rough noisy comp and would have thrived at a grammar school but never mind.

TulipsLilacs · 27/03/2023 17:15

StuffyHuffyPuffy · 27/03/2023 16:55

I was definitely like you once! I had no idea about this all. Turned out that I actually lived in catchment for one. I was quite 'bright', on the top tables at school etc. I recall a day where the other 5 children at my table (in Year 6) were discussing how the exam went. I didn't hear the words 'eleven plus' but that essentially was the process and exam they'd been through. My mum was totally oblivious, but she was busy working, so there would have been no time to prep me anyway.

In the London Borough I grew up in the whole class took the test in school time (in 1981) We also practised the tests in class so no need for parents to prepare you. I no longer live there but i gather that's changed now though.

PleaseJustText · 27/03/2023 17:15

Glad you asked the question. They don't exist where I grew up and don't exist where I live.

Orangepolentacake · 27/03/2023 17:15

HealthyFats · 27/03/2023 15:33

In SW London- Nonsuch, Wallington, Tiffin.

What? Are these real places? “Nonsuch”?? 😂

Dixiechickonhols · 27/03/2023 17:15

BlackBarbies · 27/03/2023 16:27

Prep schools are private (fee-paying) primary schools. So parents will pay for private primary schooling in the hope their child will pass the 11+ and save them the cost of private secondary schooling.

@slamfightbrightlight ahh that makes complete sense. However, if parents can afford fee paying primary schools then aren’t grammer schools a step down in comparison to a private secondary school? Or is a private school and grammer school meant to be on the same sort of level?

So many questions because I genuinely find this so interesting😅 literally don’t know a thing about this sort of stuff

In our area the state grammar is the most academic option / its results are near top in league tables. So if you have an academic child aiming for top results then it’s usually the preferred choice.
The private schools tend to cater for the ok academically, results aren’t a patch on grammar - even if they have admission tests they aren’t as rigorous.
Parents do pay for private primary with a view to state grammar. The private primary’s focus on nailing basics - grammar, punctuation, maths that will help pass and in later years will usually do verbal reasoning, formal practice exams etc. Primary is half the price of secondary.

BlackBarbies · 27/03/2023 17:15

Showersugar · 27/03/2023 17:04

Mumsnet really is a fucking cesspit these days. A young woman asks a perfectly innocuous question and a load of snotty, needlessly rude bastards pile on for no reason.

Haha I know, it’s slightly strange! There have been loads of comments giving really in depth explanations so I’m focusing more on those ones. I’ve also learnt how to spell grammar correctly so it’s not all bad😬

OP posts: