Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What the heck is a grammer school?

511 replies

BlackBarbies · 27/03/2023 15:29

Posting here for traffic!

Born and raised in South West London and still live here now. I’ve never heard of a grammar school until joining MN a couple of years ago.

Is it a primary school, is it a secondary school? Is it private or public? If it’s public, then why is it called a grammer school? Is it only available for certain types of children or something? I literally have no clue what a grammer school is so I’m happy to be enlightened!

Also, are there any in SW London? I’m genuinely intrigued as to how I’ve never come across one before

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Boomboom22 · 27/03/2023 22:24

Actually the evidence shows that setting is bad even in maths. Only the brightest gain from setting. But I was 2nd set maths in a grammar and at gcse still bored. We did 12 and finished maths in yr10 so did stats too. It's tough, the most important thing is parents caring about education. It's not ability mixing that's the main problem but attitude to learning.
I still think setting is a good idea by yr9 or so though.

RampantIvy · 27/03/2023 22:14

It is pretty rural. Job opportunities round here aren't great, especially if you don't drive.

EffortlessDesmond · 27/03/2023 22:12

The school you are describing is not in a rural backwater @RampantIvy . Do you know what they are like for employment opportunity? You leave to get one locally. If yout get a public sector job, you are the elite.

EffortlessDesmond · 27/03/2023 21:58

Your experience and mine differ @RampantIvy . In the school where I did my PGCE (at 52, so old) 12 form entry per year, there was no streaming at all until Y10, at which point there were two top tier classes, X and Y. X and Y were the clever ones. Most achieved 10 A * GCSEs and went to RG universities.

JudgeJ · 27/03/2023 21:52

x2boys · 27/03/2023 20:32

What about the mediocre kids then or should we just ignore them?,Grammar education only ever favoured the very few.

Grammar schools took roughly 20% of the population and gave a very academic education to millions of working class children like me who would otherwise not be able to afford it. In my GS in the 1960s the vast majority were from working class backgrounds, in my own year I think there was a doctor's daughter and the son of an optician. Generally we went into jobs like teaching, medicine.
The 'medicocre' children went to Secondary Modern schools where they studied less of the very academic stuff that many complain about today, eg Algebra and those 'mediocre' children went into jobs in shops, offices, workshops. If they got good CSE results they could go to the GS for A levels.
The problem was that the GS's were too successful for the left who thought everyone should be taught the same, irrespective of their ability. The idea that spreading the clever children round to improve the rest was a joke, it could only go one way. It took years and years to debunk the nonsense of 'mixed ability' and now most schools stream/set for at least the core subjects.

RampantIvy · 27/03/2023 21:48

EffortlessDesmond · 27/03/2023 21:17

Very bright children are (generally) poorly educated in comprehensive schools IMVHO, especially in rural areas. They are held back to the class average, get bored to sobs, because the emphasis is all about getting the mediocre up to a grade 4 or 5. There's a huge emphasis on catering to low achievers, and much less on giving the genuinely clever kids the intellectual excitement they crave. I did my PGGE at 50 and loved teaching the top sets. So much fun, because they had ideas and opinions that would never ever occur to the rest. The assumption is that the very bright ones will find their way through the system, and TB fair with the help of their intelligent parents, they do. But the really clever kids, one or two per class in unstreamed years, would have flown in a more selective system.

I don't even know where to begin with this, quite frankly, offensive and ill informed post.

Our local state comprehensive in the nearest market town, with students travelling in from surrounding villages, performs well above average compared to other state comprehensive schools in England. 75% of the "not very bright" students achieved a grade 5 or higher in English and maths GCSE in 2022, and 55% of all A level grades were A/A* The school achieved an ALPS score of 2 in 2022 (ALPS scores are graded 1 - 9, 1 being the best and 9 being the lowest grade).

They set the children from year 7 in English and maths so that they don't put the bright children with the academically challenged.

Any decent comprehensive school will set for English and maths.

QueenOfThorns · 27/03/2023 21:47

x2boys · 27/03/2023 20:02

Well.exactly and I only know about them because we did the tri partite,system in history 😂and I was born in 1973 and this was the late 80,s!

Yes, I was going to say this - we were taught about grammar schools in history too! The teacher had a very negative view of them, and I’m pretty sure she never told us that they still existed in some areas.

Sadly, we had moved from a grammar school area before I was secondary age and I had to go to the local comp, which I hated. It might be better for the schools to have the clever kids in them, but you got picked on at my school if you were brainy. I would have loved to go to a grammar Sad

EffortlessDesmond · 27/03/2023 21:41

..some wouldn't know...

EffortlessDesmond · 27/03/2023 21:40

Selective education by ability works and benefits everyone. Not everyone is really totally equal, or we would all be drones. Treated and tested equally is the sorting hat. Some people love to puzzle out how to design benefits as fairly as possible, and some would know where to begin.

LIZS · 27/03/2023 21:33

Some private schools are Grammar in name, a legacy of abolition of 11+ in 1970s which then went independent to keep selective . Keir Starmer went to one such.

EffortlessDesmond · 27/03/2023 21:33

Failing to educate clever DC well is squandering talent. Look at the post-war politicians who came up through the grammar schools. Almost every Cabinet member, Tory and Labour alike, came through the 11+ and on to Oxbridge.

ConsuelaHammock · 27/03/2023 21:28

We have grammar schools in NI ( with exception of a few areas). Whilst I don’t necessarily think it’s a good system, it’s preferable to state versus private. There’s only one truly private school in NI. Lots of the grammars ask for voluntary contributions to fees.

EffortlessDesmond · 27/03/2023 21:26

@x2boys I think schooling impoverishes civil/civic society by choking off ability. If you would prefer good government, then in my opinion, you want the full range of opinion, from all classes and races and religions, from Eton to Edmonton.

EffortlessDesmond · 27/03/2023 21:17

Very bright children are (generally) poorly educated in comprehensive schools IMVHO, especially in rural areas. They are held back to the class average, get bored to sobs, because the emphasis is all about getting the mediocre up to a grade 4 or 5. There's a huge emphasis on catering to low achievers, and much less on giving the genuinely clever kids the intellectual excitement they crave. I did my PGGE at 50 and loved teaching the top sets. So much fun, because they had ideas and opinions that would never ever occur to the rest. The assumption is that the very bright ones will find their way through the system, and TB fair with the help of their intelligent parents, they do. But the really clever kids, one or two per class in unstreamed years, would have flown in a more selective system.

Impetusturn · 27/03/2023 21:15

My husband was a grammar school boy back in the 1960's in South Yorkshire. I have been pulling his leg about it for 46 years!

EpicChaos · 27/03/2023 20:59

@x2boys Mediocre kids were serviced well enough in comprehensives, they didn't lose out by not going to a grammar but the bright kids very definitely did.

x2boys · 27/03/2023 20:32

EpicChaos · 27/03/2023 20:29

Grammar schools were the greatest aid to social mobility for the poor working class, than anything else.
Once the middle class politicians realised that and some noisy middle class little darlings lost out, the ladder was pulled up and the doors firmly slammed shut.
No more local government jobs for the oiks, eh?!

@HurryShadow " Having said that though, there is the counter argument that if there weren't grammar schools, then the "clever" kids would be dispersed around the state comps and actually improve those schools. "

And the counter argument is a whole load of bollox, tbh. That was an excuse given at the time, iirc, however, what happened was, that it held back very bright kids, who were placed in classes where their needs were ignored in favour of extra effort being put into teaching the less academically able/ uninterested children, which resulted in bright kids failing to achieve their true potential.

What about the mediocre kids then or should we just ignore them?,Grammar education only ever favoured the very few.

EpicChaos · 27/03/2023 20:29

Grammar schools were the greatest aid to social mobility for the poor working class, than anything else.
Once the middle class politicians realised that and some noisy middle class little darlings lost out, the ladder was pulled up and the doors firmly slammed shut.
No more local government jobs for the oiks, eh?!

@HurryShadow " Having said that though, there is the counter argument that if there weren't grammar schools, then the "clever" kids would be dispersed around the state comps and actually improve those schools. "

And the counter argument is a whole load of bollox, tbh. That was an excuse given at the time, iirc, however, what happened was, that it held back very bright kids, who were placed in classes where their needs were ignored in favour of extra effort being put into teaching the less academically able/ uninterested children, which resulted in bright kids failing to achieve their true potential.

x2boys · 27/03/2023 20:02

BlackBarbies · 27/03/2023 19:48

Especially when my mum was born in 1977 and I was born in 1999😅

Well.exactly and I only know about them because we did the tri partite,system in history 😂and I was born in 1973 and this was the late 80,s!

BlackBarbies · 27/03/2023 19:48

x2boys · 27/03/2023 19:37

Whilst do I do what a Grammar school is they haven't had them in my town or surrounding towns since the 1970,so it's quite easy for the majority of the UK not to know what they are 🙄

Especially when my mum was born in 1977 and I was born in 1999😅

OP posts:
x2boys · 27/03/2023 19:42

CatkinToadflax · 27/03/2023 19:02

DS2’s school is private and teaches Latin. Sounds like I need to phone up and get them to change its name to Town Grammar School instead of just Town School. 🤦‍♀️

I went to a grammar school. It was and still is a state school. Absolutely baffled by the few posters still insisting that their private schools are grammars, as opposed to having historically been grammars and have retained the name whilst now being private schools.

The private school.next to my comprehensive school was called Town,s name Grammar school
state Grammar school,s were phased out in the 1970,s in my town and in most towns in the UK

x2boys · 27/03/2023 19:37

Hbh17 · 27/03/2023 15:31

How can you not know?!
Secondary school if child passes 11 plus.
And it's "grammar" school.

Whilst do I do what a Grammar school is they haven't had them in my town or surrounding towns since the 1970,so it's quite easy for the majority of the UK not to know what they are 🙄

HuggingtheHRT · 27/03/2023 19:19

The main point is that they select based on ability. Kids can opt to take an exam at 11 and the 'best' ones get skimmed off and given a place at a grammar.

Mumsnet raves about them. I think they perpetuate inequality for all the reasons mentioned by others - I.E rich families paying for tons of tuition to get their kids through the tests.

The two nearest grammars to me feel like quite toxic places. All the girls I know who've been there have come away with huge mental health/self harming issues. The boys grammar was flagged as having issues with bullying and safeguarding recently...

Boomboom22 · 27/03/2023 19:14

Just to confuse things even more, academisation means some grammars are academies as well as some comps. Plus free schools but they can't be grammars unless an extension but in a new town 🤣

Direct grant don't really exist now but academies are quite similar. The la is therefore not responsible For most schools although admissions are coordinated.

Some grammars have their own test that you can take if local instead of the 11+ or kent test. Eg shepway has a test so you can enter the Folkestone grammars through the kent test or the shepway test, but only for locals.

Also many comps have a grammar stream. Essentially top set that are taught a faster paced curriculum but in a comp.

Frazzledmum12 · 27/03/2023 19:13

My son transferred from doing yrs 7-11 at the local comp (as he refused to do the 11+) to the local grammar to do his A Levels. If I had my way he would have stayed where he is. He did amazingly well in his GCSE's because the comp put so much work into each and every student. They used to call themselves 'a grammar school for all'. The amount of extra lessons etc put on to help them through their exams was first class. The grammar school did nothing. It feels a bit like well you are clever, get on with it. My son's old school did get a fair bit of media coverage with the previous head for being quite strict, but he did better in his exams than most of his friends that went to the grammar school. He only left his old school to be with his mates and because the grammar takes football quite seriously (his greatest passion)
Just to add that being a grammar doesn't always mean a better education