Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What the heck is a grammer school?

511 replies

BlackBarbies · 27/03/2023 15:29

Posting here for traffic!

Born and raised in South West London and still live here now. I’ve never heard of a grammar school until joining MN a couple of years ago.

Is it a primary school, is it a secondary school? Is it private or public? If it’s public, then why is it called a grammer school? Is it only available for certain types of children or something? I literally have no clue what a grammer school is so I’m happy to be enlightened!

Also, are there any in SW London? I’m genuinely intrigued as to how I’ve never come across one before

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Lincslady53 · 28/03/2023 08:03

We had 5 children in our working class family in the 50s and 60s. As others have said, every child took an exam at age 10/11 those who passed went to the grammar schools the rest went to a secondary modern school. The grammar schools were more academic, but we were streamed at the grammar school, and the lower streams did more vocational classes, woodwork and metalwork for the boys, home economics for the girls. Our local boys grammar was part boarding school too, with a lot of the boarders having military families overseas. Of our 5 siblings 4 went to the grammar school. 2 of those went onto uni, at a time when a small proportion went to uni. 1 became a company director, 2 became scientists working for the MOD and I was one of the first A level management trainees with a large retailer and then ran my own business. My brother who didn't go to grammar trained as a plumber and finished his working life as a milkman. The grammar system has been much criticised, but it gave 4 working class oiks the opportunity to have interesting careers. If you watch the film 'If' with Malcolm Mcdowell that was very like the boys grammar in our town in the 60s. The girls grammar was a little more modern.

RampantIvy · 28/03/2023 07:46

but why did you not Google this instead of losing your tag at people on mumsnet?

Probably in response to some of the rather unpleasant replies on this thread. A quick Google will give the bare facts, but other posters' experiences have been very helpful.

MyopicBunny · 28/03/2023 07:46

RampantIvy · 28/03/2023 07:22

Is it really necessary to sneer and make snarky comments to the OP?

You can't post any thread on Mumsnet any more without people being nasty. It's pathetic tbh.

FluffyMochi · 28/03/2023 07:46

Trixiefirecracker · 28/03/2023 07:28

Surely that’s just a bad school? Not all schools are created equal, the same can be said of private schools and comprehensives? I had a shit experience in my comp, awful but wouldn’t avoid sending kids there unless I looked at the school individually and made that choice.

It was one of the best state schools in the area and was regularly oversubscribed due to its attainment.

I definitely wished I'd stayed private though personally.

CryHavok · 28/03/2023 07:33

BlackBarbies · 28/03/2023 04:17

Doing your homework when it comes to the grammars and public schools and the best independents is how you give your children an opportunity.

My kids are 11 months old and 22 months old. Why on earth do you think I’d be ‘doing my homework’ on secondary schools when they’re not even in nursery yet? Please be serious.

Have you never stopped to ask yourself how many alumni of prep schools and schools like Eton have been Prime Minister or held ministerial posts over the last 250 years? Have you ever asked what this says about British society and its education system?

No. Considering that I didn’t even know what a prep school was until this thread, I can’t say that I’ve ever stopped to ask myself these questions. Why on earth would I sit down and think about Eton and over private schools? I genuinely have no interest in these things at all. Sorry but I can’t even take your responses seriously, you and I are from different worlds mate

You say you’ve not been interested until now, which is fair enough, but why did you not Google this instead of losing your tag at people on mumsnet?

Trixiefirecracker · 28/03/2023 07:28

FluffyMochi · 28/03/2023 07:23

I went to a grammar school from year 7 through to year 13 and was told by my head of 6th form that they were surprised any university would touch me with such horrific grades!

I got into an RG university with AAC grades.

If I ever have children, I would want them to have an English education over the system of the country I'm in now, but I'd sooner send them private than to a grammar. A grammar education is not worth the destruction in one's self confidence and self worth.

Surely that’s just a bad school? Not all schools are created equal, the same can be said of private schools and comprehensives? I had a shit experience in my comp, awful but wouldn’t avoid sending kids there unless I looked at the school individually and made that choice.

FluffyMochi · 28/03/2023 07:23

MyopicBunny · 28/03/2023 04:31

Getting told we were mentally deficient and a drain on society if we dared get a fail grade that was a B! I will never send my children to a grammar school if I have them.

I've seen this first hand in one of my relatives who is sitting GCSEs. She studies constantly and feels bad if she's not studying.

I went to a grammar school from year 7 through to year 13 and was told by my head of 6th form that they were surprised any university would touch me with such horrific grades!

I got into an RG university with AAC grades.

If I ever have children, I would want them to have an English education over the system of the country I'm in now, but I'd sooner send them private than to a grammar. A grammar education is not worth the destruction in one's self confidence and self worth.

RampantIvy · 28/03/2023 07:22

Is it really necessary to sneer and make snarky comments to the OP?

MyopicBunny · 28/03/2023 04:55

@mathanxiety your sentiments don't make sense. Some children aren't bright enough to get into super selective schools but that does not exclude them from having a well paid career. I know many examples who earn more than people who went to university.

There are different kinds of intelligence. And you seem to be saying that anyone with any sense should be trying to get their children into one of less than 200 schools in the UK for them to do well in life which is a very narrow perspective.

Limetart · 28/03/2023 04:42

mathanxiety · 28/03/2023 04:11

That's my point - there is indeed a limited number of grammars, ditto public schools, and top independent schools.

So you end up with an elite. The elite is composed of people who have been told from an early age that they deserve more than the rest when it comes to opportunity and the good things in life. They also believe they deserve to lead, because they're smarter than the rest. Self-fulfilling prophecies are the strong point of the English and Welsh system. The system exists to reinforce the existing hierarchy.

You don't need to know anything about individual schools in order to understand the overall system, what its role is in the wider society, how it operates, and the effect it has on the winners and the losers alike.

Have you never stopped to ask yourself how many alumni of prep schools and schools like Eton have been Prime Minister or held ministerial posts over the last 250 years? Have you ever asked what this says about British society and its education system?

There's a limited number of grammar schools because Labour changed them in favour of comprehensives.
In 1968 when I passed for grammar most children took the eleven plus.
There were 1200 grammar schools in England and Wales at the time.
Working class dc were given a chance to better themselves through a grammar school education.
We live in a more equal society now so grammar schools are not necessary but they had there place at a time when class defined your future regardless of academic ability.
Oh and even in the 60's parents tutored their dc to pass, I had to do a test paper weekly at home age 10. Tutoring dc only gives them the advantage of time and familiarity with the test.
You still have to understand the questions and answer correctly.

mathanxiety · 28/03/2023 04:32

BlackBarbies · 28/03/2023 04:17

Doing your homework when it comes to the grammars and public schools and the best independents is how you give your children an opportunity.

My kids are 11 months old and 22 months old. Why on earth do you think I’d be ‘doing my homework’ on secondary schools when they’re not even in nursery yet? Please be serious.

Have you never stopped to ask yourself how many alumni of prep schools and schools like Eton have been Prime Minister or held ministerial posts over the last 250 years? Have you ever asked what this says about British society and its education system?

No. Considering that I didn’t even know what a prep school was until this thread, I can’t say that I’ve ever stopped to ask myself these questions. Why on earth would I sit down and think about Eton and over private schools? I genuinely have no interest in these things at all. Sorry but I can’t even take your responses seriously, you and I are from different worlds mate

I am being 100% serious here.

You need to know all this stuff when you have children, and I honestly believe the sooner you start, the better. My relatives and friends didn't have children when they first emigrated to the UK but moved to areas with grammars as soon as they could. You can be sure that other people are observing, researching, and using the system to benefit their children.

It's quite astonishing to me that you seem to know so little about your own country's history and social organisation. I'll put that down to the curriculum in the schools you attended - but are you not at all curious on a personal level about the fact that a huge number of people with similar accents seem to gravitate toward one particular political party and seem to dominate Cabinet positions when in government? Same goes for all the plummy accents among political journalists? How could that have happened?

MyopicBunny · 28/03/2023 04:31

Getting told we were mentally deficient and a drain on society if we dared get a fail grade that was a B! I will never send my children to a grammar school if I have them.

I've seen this first hand in one of my relatives who is sitting GCSEs. She studies constantly and feels bad if she's not studying.

BigChesterDraws · 28/03/2023 04:28

Anything else you’d like us to Google for you?

MyopicBunny · 28/03/2023 04:26

Grammar schools are really only found in the bigger towns like London and Birmingham. My cousin went to Latymer.

Some grammars are selective and some are super selective. To get in, a child needs to be tutored no matter how bright they are, really. Because primary schools don't teach things like verbal reasoning.

mathanxiety · 28/03/2023 04:19

Boomboom22 · 27/03/2023 22:33

Highly differentiated teaching maybe. Prof Jo Foaler is the maths expert on setting. But diff is going out of fashion again so who knows!

My DCs never experienced setting in their US elementary school. It's perfectly possible to differentiate successfully. They were placed in different math tracks in high school, at age 14.

BlackBarbies · 28/03/2023 04:18

@mathanxiety ^

OP posts:
BlackBarbies · 28/03/2023 04:17

Doing your homework when it comes to the grammars and public schools and the best independents is how you give your children an opportunity.

My kids are 11 months old and 22 months old. Why on earth do you think I’d be ‘doing my homework’ on secondary schools when they’re not even in nursery yet? Please be serious.

Have you never stopped to ask yourself how many alumni of prep schools and schools like Eton have been Prime Minister or held ministerial posts over the last 250 years? Have you ever asked what this says about British society and its education system?

No. Considering that I didn’t even know what a prep school was until this thread, I can’t say that I’ve ever stopped to ask myself these questions. Why on earth would I sit down and think about Eton and over private schools? I genuinely have no interest in these things at all. Sorry but I can’t even take your responses seriously, you and I are from different worlds mate

OP posts:
mathanxiety · 28/03/2023 04:11

BlackBarbies · 27/03/2023 16:34

Well seeing as there’s only 163 grammer schools in England, I wouldn’t compare that to not knowing how this country works. The closest grammer school is 1hr 10mins away so not sure why/how I’d know of it’s existence?

I’m 23 years old and I went to an Academy in Westminster. We hardly spent our time in the playground talking about grammer schools that were all the way in Kingston and Sutton. We didn’t even know these places existed!

Not sure why people are so snarky because I haven’t heard of something that’s common to other people. Round here you either go to a standard secondary school or an Academy. That’s it

That's my point - there is indeed a limited number of grammars, ditto public schools, and top independent schools.

So you end up with an elite. The elite is composed of people who have been told from an early age that they deserve more than the rest when it comes to opportunity and the good things in life. They also believe they deserve to lead, because they're smarter than the rest. Self-fulfilling prophecies are the strong point of the English and Welsh system. The system exists to reinforce the existing hierarchy.

You don't need to know anything about individual schools in order to understand the overall system, what its role is in the wider society, how it operates, and the effect it has on the winners and the losers alike.

Have you never stopped to ask yourself how many alumni of prep schools and schools like Eton have been Prime Minister or held ministerial posts over the last 250 years? Have you ever asked what this says about British society and its education system?

mathanxiety · 28/03/2023 03:57

TheCountessofFitzdotterel · 27/03/2023 16:35

Any more than say not knowing how the benefit system works if you have never had to claim benefits? How the public transport works in a city you never go to? How private healthcare works when you will never be able to afford it?
We all have different life experiences and need to know different things accordingly.

My life experience has mostly been in Ireland and the US, and my Irish-UK relatives' and friends' life experience was entirely in Ireland until they moved to the London area and figured out how the system worked. When I moved to the US, I figured out the education system and organised my life to maximize my children's chances of attending great schools, then figured out how they could get into great universities.

There are hundreds of thousands of immigrants from all over the world who end up in the UK and make it a priority to figure out how the education system can be used to best benefit their children. Many of these people don't even speak English as their first language.

It boggles the mind that people who are born and bred in the UK don't understand how the education system gives some kids a chance and keeps it from others. Doing your homework when it comes to the grammars and public schools and the best independents is how you give your children an opportunity.

You learn how to navigate the benefits system pretty darn quick if you need it, and the same goes for public transport - it really doesn't take that long to figure out busses and trains and routes and tickets. People from all over the world visit London and New York and Tokyo and Rome every year and manage to get around these cities on public transport. There are maps. There is information on fares. Why would you figure out private health insurance unless it struck you as something you needed? But if you did need it, you'd figure it out. It's not rocket science. Other people manage to do it.

If you have children in the UK, knowing how the education system works and understanding its role in maintaining or disrupting the social hierarchy is vital. You're missing a huge part of your understanding of British life, and you're sending your children off into life without a road map if you don't understand the education system.

FluffyMochi · 28/03/2023 02:03

Real grammar schools are state schools and do not charge a single penny in fees. They do have exam regulated entry so only the best test takers can gain admission.

I went to a grammar school and it was the most toxic environment I've ever been in. Getting told we were mentally deficient and a drain on society if we dared get a fail grade that was a B! I will never send my children to a grammar school if I have them.

Doganimal · 28/03/2023 01:01

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

thing47 · 27/03/2023 22:54

This issue is @EpicChaos and @EffortlessDesmond that who's to say the brightest DCs at 10 will be the brightest at 16 or 18, or 21?

10 is much, much too young to make the decision as to who are the 'brightest', especially when it is judged by a non-curriculum based test taken on a random day at the start of Y6. It would actually be quite difficult to come up with a more crap system than that one if you tried.

Boomboom22 · 27/03/2023 22:33

RampantIvy · 27/03/2023 22:27

Actually the evidence shows that setting is bad even in maths.

I don't understand how not setting would work. All the children would work at a different pace so there would be a lot of bored pupils if they have to wait for the others to catch up.

Highly differentiated teaching maybe. Prof Jo Foaler is the maths expert on setting. But diff is going out of fashion again so who knows!

CryHavok · 27/03/2023 22:27

Google is free

RampantIvy · 27/03/2023 22:27

Actually the evidence shows that setting is bad even in maths.

I don't understand how not setting would work. All the children would work at a different pace so there would be a lot of bored pupils if they have to wait for the others to catch up.

Swipe left for the next trending thread