Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

What the heck is a grammer school?

511 replies

BlackBarbies · 27/03/2023 15:29

Posting here for traffic!

Born and raised in South West London and still live here now. I’ve never heard of a grammar school until joining MN a couple of years ago.

Is it a primary school, is it a secondary school? Is it private or public? If it’s public, then why is it called a grammer school? Is it only available for certain types of children or something? I literally have no clue what a grammer school is so I’m happy to be enlightened!

Also, are there any in SW London? I’m genuinely intrigued as to how I’ve never come across one before

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
6
icelolly99 · 30/03/2023 23:31

I live in a county with lots of private schools and grammar schools. I went to my local grammar back when everyone did the test. There are 2 others walking distance from where I currently live. Children travel from all over to go to them - you don't have to live in the county to attend. Only one of my own kids passed the elective 11+ test and then still chose to attend the local comp instead. I think it's easy to forget not all areas in UK have grammar schools.

weirdoboelady · 30/03/2023 22:49

BlackBarbies · 30/03/2023 08:53

I did read your post! It just confused me so much that I needed to ask a simple question to try and understand it a bit more😅

😂SO sorry! I will try to be clearer in future. And can I say how much I have enjoyed your good-humoured and sensible posts here - it's been a really informative and entertaining thread. Friendly hugs!

CountingMareep · 30/03/2023 18:32

Villssev · 30/03/2023 18:24

And by her parents

To be fair, her mother died of cancer when we were still in sixth form, and her (relatively elderly) father was well meaning but ineffectual. Besides, in the early 80s a degree was still seen as the passport to high paid employment and discrimination was open and rife.

Villssev · 30/03/2023 18:24

CountingMareep · 30/03/2023 18:19

My sixth form friend was very poorly served by the school we both attended (then just a ‘good’ grammar, now a superselective). She was, looking back, almost certainly dyspraxic with very poor spatial abilities, and she could not master O level maths (CSE was not offered), despite being highly verbally intelligent. I also suspect she has a form of ASD. She did eventually get GCSE maths and science in later life (she wasn’t deemed bright enough for the O level sciences, which we were allowed, even encouraged (!) back then, to drop entirely). But between all that and a physical health condition, she has never had a paid job.

And by her parents

CountingMareep · 30/03/2023 18:19

My sixth form friend was very poorly served by the school we both attended (then just a ‘good’ grammar, now a superselective). She was, looking back, almost certainly dyspraxic with very poor spatial abilities, and she could not master O level maths (CSE was not offered), despite being highly verbally intelligent. I also suspect she has a form of ASD. She did eventually get GCSE maths and science in later life (she wasn’t deemed bright enough for the O level sciences, which we were allowed, even encouraged (!) back then, to drop entirely). But between all that and a physical health condition, she has never had a paid job.

MuddlerInLaw · 30/03/2023 17:37

I did Latin at my comp - but it was pretend Latin, mostly in English, maybe once a week. The independent school I moved to approached Latin like an Olympic sport - deadly serious, practised every day. I had a lot of catching up to do but left with an A at O’ Level. (Very proud moment!)

Sorry, no grammar school relevance!

NeverApologiseNeverExplain · 30/03/2023 17:30

I did Latin at comprehensive. It was in the 80s though!

thing47 · 30/03/2023 15:04

Sorry you're missing my point, I obviously wasn't clear enough.

What I meant was there aren't any subjects which DCs at comprehensive or secondary modern schools are forbidden to take. There may of course be restrictions based on what a school offers, but there aren't any subjects which pupils cannot take purely because of the type of school they are at, if that makes more sense.

Of course you are right to say that Greek is much less likely to be offered at a comprehensive (though DD2 did further maths at her not terribly good secondary modern, she took maths in Y10 and further maths in Y11, and she's not really a mathmatician, though she is a scientist).

Nonameoclue · 30/03/2023 14:57

It just varies so much. My GS educated children were not offered Latin or Ancient Greek. They were offered Media studies (at A level at least), DT, food tech, textiles. Possibly sociology, I can't remember as none of them did it.

ArdeteiMasazxu · 30/03/2023 13:27

@thing47 there are no GCSE subjects which are magically open to pupils at private or grammar schools but denied to those at a comprehensive or a secondary modern

Latin? Ancient Greek?

obviously the exam board wouldn't refuse to enter a non-privileged child, but I doubt many non-selective schools offer these subjects. Similarly but with a slightly higher chance that a few non-selective schools might offer them, perhaps Japanese, Mandarin, Futher Mathematics (for pupils who will get top grade easily for the normal maths) and less mainstream sciences like Astronomy.

But then again there are some subjects that exist as GCSEs that a lot of selective schools won't be teaching at all, e.g. Hospitality, Media Studies, Sociology.

ouchmyteeth · 30/03/2023 13:08

The ‘opportunity for clever kids from poorer backgrounds’ is def not true in my area. Local comp has 40+% kids on FSM, whilst the grammar school is 2%. Private tutoring is big business and can definitely coach more average children to pass, it’s well-known the grammar school is mainly middle-class wealthier kids, the disparity lives on.

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 30/03/2023 13:02

there are no GCSE subjects which are magically open to pupils at private or grammar schools but denied to those at a comprehensive or a secondary modern much though some parents might like there to be

I am sure that this varies between schools but our expeience is that there is less choice of MFL in secondary modern schools and less choice of technology subjects in grammar schools. With food security and obesity a growing concern, why should it not be a priority in all schools? For my dc so far this has not been an issue (hate food tech and MFL equally!), but dividing at 11 has reduced the choices available.

thing47 · 30/03/2023 12:16

@BlackBarbies there are no GCSE subjects which are magically open to pupils at private or grammar schools but denied to those at a comprehensive or a secondary modern much though some parents might like there to be.

FWIW DD2 went to a secondary modern and did a fairly academic set of GCSEs – science x 3, english x 2, maths, further maths, stats, history, Spanish, ICT and PE (too many but that's another story). Her brother, who was at a grammar school, took an almost identical list.

What about the students who want to take a subject like food or technology a bit furher in life?
Another good question. DH has a goddaughter who did food tech at GCSE and loved it, did a degree in it, then a PhD. Since leaving academia she has worked abroad for an international food advisory body and is about to move to The Netherlands to work for a well-known brewery company. No idea what she earns, but I don't think anyone could say she hasn't had an interesting career thus far.

Tofumammy · 30/03/2023 11:27

My husband and I both went to grammar schools in Northern Ireland- a long time ago! He was a teacher and taught in a direct grant school in NI (that was a public school which also functioned as a local grammar for boys who passed 11+ and no longer exist). He then taught in a grammar school in Kent and a public school in South West of England. For those who don't know; not all private schools are public schools, only those on HMC register. Our children went to state primary and two of them went to my husband's independent school, our youngest to local, good comprehensive. Our conclusion- a good comprehensive is best option. Our eldest and youngest both did well academically, our middle one disliked the public school, defected to the comprehensive but dropped out before completing A'levels. State educated one got good A' levels, a first class degree, a PhD and is a university lecturer ,similar for our eldest. Grammar school system in NI is very unfair and divisive. I know one family with five children, four got into grammar, one failed transfer test which was devastating for him.

BlackBarbies · 30/03/2023 08:53

weirdoboelady · 29/03/2023 19:41

My understanding is as follows.

Firstly, you may not know it but there are different GCSEs and A levels. Different exam boards, but the results generally count for the same (especially at GCSE level. I can imagine that there might be some A levels in specific subjects which are preferred by some professors interviewing people for admission to specific universities.)

Most grammar schools and public schools use the same exams as everybody else.

There are some schools which I think are all private but I'm not 100% sure, which use the International Baccalaureate system instead. And I know that at some private schools pupils can choose to do IB instead of the more normal exams. And I have just discovered there is an IB Primary Years Programme for children aged 3 to 12, so I suppose those children would bypass any local 11+ exams. I think the choice to do IB is usually at A level, though, and IB is accepted by UCAS for university entrance.

I am not aware of any other 'special' exams taken in private schools except the Common Entrance at around 13 years of age, which I have already mentioned.

I did read your post! It just confused me so much that I needed to ask a simple question to try and understand it a bit more😅

OP posts:
x2boys · 30/03/2023 07:55

Jarstastic · 29/03/2023 22:45

I don’t think that’s right, at least not across the board.
i had a slightly older friend who did O levels (I was at a grammar school in the second year of GCSEs and I believe prior to that it had been all O level at my school) at a comprehensive/secondary modern. I think she did all o levels or at least a majority so. She did A l vels still at the same school then went to Portsmouth Poly. But I don’t know when that was decided for her. I just don’t know when the decisions was made.

Actually don’t know why I didn’t ask him earlier but just did so. my DH went to a comprehensive in the last year of O levels, albeit in an area without grammar schools and he says they were streamed; Stream A, B, C. He was in A (and went onto a top tier university in the UK though he was in the minority even for his stream) but doesn’t remember when the streams came in. The streams were across all subjects.

(One of our DC is in a comprehensive and they are in sets in the core subjects and different ones eg top set for maths, middle set for English)

Im.around your age and went to.a comprehensive school,we had no Grammar schools,my sister who.is two years older than me was in the first cohort ,to sit GCSE,s in 1988,I think my school offered both O,levels and CSE,s prior to.the introduction of GCSE,s ,depending on what set/ stream you were.in we had had had three sets ,with set one being the most academic and set three, being the least ,I was slap.bang in the middle being in set two for everything.so maybe had I been a bit older I would have sat a mix of Olevels and CSE,s?

x2boys · 30/03/2023 07:42

Doone21 · 29/03/2023 20:15

Everyone in every type of school sits gcse and a levels. Some schools for special needs might not. Some schools offer more but yes it's all the same qualifications

Well they don't do they?
in all mainstream school,s pupils sit GCSE,s ,but certainly from 16 plus not every one sits A levels ( despite what mumsnet thinks ) many schools don't have sixth forms for a start ,my sons school.doesn't ,in my town we have a sixth form college offering A levels and then another college offering a wide variety of courses at all different levels .

RampantIvy · 30/03/2023 07:32

That's an excellent summing up @Unexpecteddrivinginstructor

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 30/03/2023 07:11

Streaming within a comprehensive is slightly different because usually it is possible to move between bands if a child is achieving much higher or lower than they did at school entry. In a grammar area it involves moving school, making new friends etc.

It has to be acknowledged too that the 11 plus is a test of prejudice. It is culturally biased, as most IQ tests are. It is a snapshot of one day in the life of a 10 year old. It also is prejudiced against anyone with a SpLd.

It is a blunt tool and not able to specifically identify the top X% of the cohort, it is designed to ensure that the bottom Y% of the cohort do not enter. If the cut off is say 20% then the school doesn't mind if Jonny comes who had lots of tutoring (which his parents will continue to pay for at GCSE) and is 'naturally' in the top 24% instead of Max who is in the top 18% but his grandparent died a couple of months ago, he now has to help get his younger siblings ready for school every day and his mum doesn't have the money for tutoring. The grammar school just want to ensure that Sam who is average at 50% of the population doesn't come because they think he will struggle. Max's school could appeal but maybe the head of Max's school thinks that the grammar school won't suit him and he would be better going to the local school with all his mates. Maybe they are right, maybe not, we will never know.

All grammar counties don't tend to have any greater academic attainment than counties with a comprehenisve system. If you live in a grammar county for other reasons then it can be hard not to go along with the system.

Tofumammy · 30/03/2023 00:02

Just checked- there are 66 grammar schools in Northern Ireland.

Tofumammy · 29/03/2023 23:54

Northern Ireland is only part of UK where they still have grammar schools in every county. Children do an 11plus type exam, called transfer test, in order to get in. The academic standard in theses chools is very high but opinion is divided. It does mean that primary Children are under a lot of pressure and there is a big educational divide; excellent exam results from grammar pupils but a higher percentage who fail to get any qualifications from some secondary schools.

weirdoboelady · 29/03/2023 23:27

BlackBarbies · 29/03/2023 20:41

@Unexpecteddrivinginstructor @LimeCheesecake so an IB is an alternative to A Levels? I’ve never heard of IB before

cries

You didn't read my post then?

NameInUseAlreadyAgain · 29/03/2023 22:49

DS did food tech at grammar school. Only subject he liked and excelled at. Now training to be a chef. If weren’t for that subject he may not have realised he was good at it. Only good thing to come out of his time there.

Jarstastic · 29/03/2023 22:45

Nonameoclue · 29/03/2023 22:14

At age 10, which is of course ridiculous. At secondary moderns they did CSEs -& at grammar schools they did O levels.

I don’t think that’s right, at least not across the board.
i had a slightly older friend who did O levels (I was at a grammar school in the second year of GCSEs and I believe prior to that it had been all O level at my school) at a comprehensive/secondary modern. I think she did all o levels or at least a majority so. She did A l vels still at the same school then went to Portsmouth Poly. But I don’t know when that was decided for her. I just don’t know when the decisions was made.

Actually don’t know why I didn’t ask him earlier but just did so. my DH went to a comprehensive in the last year of O levels, albeit in an area without grammar schools and he says they were streamed; Stream A, B, C. He was in A (and went onto a top tier university in the UK though he was in the minority even for his stream) but doesn’t remember when the streams came in. The streams were across all subjects.

(One of our DC is in a comprehensive and they are in sets in the core subjects and different ones eg top set for maths, middle set for English)

RampantIvy · 29/03/2023 22:44

😴