Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think junk food tastes so much better than healthy food?

137 replies

Fifi1010 · 27/03/2023 15:06

Keep reading about all the debates about food , obesity etc. I used to be obese I had weight loss surgery a few years ago now my BMI is 21 from 41. I've lost half my body weight it's no issue staying slim as I physically cannot eat much even crappy foods . I eat a relatively healthy diet now because I need too or I will be malnourished.
.
I will say though in my obesity journey is it doesn't matter how much I educated myself about food , cooked healthy meals the allure of fatty burgers and junk was so tempting. I loved fatty food it tastes better. Even gourmet eating out I prefer rich sauces with fat.

I generally believe even with education , extra taxes some people will choose to eat shit food because it tastes so much nicer than 99 percent of healthy food.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Leftoverssandwich · 29/03/2023 23:28

I was taking about the previous posters exact burger, which had quite a lot of extras on it. A basic burger like you describe is even cheaper, of course it is, as I’ve already said. (Cheese is getting more expensive as we all know).

I’m not sure any more what point is being made? I foolishly popped up to say that the homemade burger as described really couldn’t be made for the same price. But I’m not about to say cooking at home isn’t cheaper than buying food in a lot of cases. I think we all agree that it’s about more than the cost of ingredients.

strivingtosucceed · 29/03/2023 22:34

Leftoverssandwich · 28/03/2023 16:41

I’m not sure how that burger can be cheaper than a Big Mac, which costs £4.99.

Two butchers organic beef burgers will be £3-4 depending on where you get them. That leaves you with everything else to get for under £2. It may end up cheaper if you’re making a few, but for one?

I can definitely make 4 burgers come out to a cheaper cost than 4 big macs, obviously the smaller the number of portions the less cost-effective it is.

4 brioche buns - £1.09
500g of 12% fat mincemeat - £2.90
3 onions - £1.10
Lettuce head - £0.70
= £5.79

Then the price goes up depending on which sauces you already have at home (or have left from previous takeaway visits).

Leftoverssandwich · 29/03/2023 17:24

Well, yes. Homemade food is almost always cheaper given economies of scale, ability to flex what you spend on ingredients, portion control etc. Unless you factor in time=money (or other non-cashable benefits). If you live alone though then that changes a bit and many of your ingredients wouldn’t keep so perhaps not the best example!

HungryMum101 · 29/03/2023 09:20

Leftoverssandwich · 29/03/2023 08:57

Per burger, yes. I said that it might work out for a number of them. But it very clearly is not cheaper for a single one.

This would make four burgers. As a parenting forum, it’s realistic to assume that a majority of people reading are in a family group and would make that kind of quantity.

But if you live alone and want to make yourself a single burger, buy the amount of mince you need and a bun loose, or freeze parts of larger packs for the next time you fancy a burger. It isn’t complicated!

Or if you don’t have time or can’t be bothered, just get the Big Mac.

But it comes back to the point that the cost of fast food is about convenience rather than the quality of the ingredients.

MadameSzyszkoBohusz · 29/03/2023 08:58

"Theres been a massive rise in posts by a anorexic posters in the last few weeks. I remember all the pro ana communities growing up and they were weirdly disingenuous like this. Some weird “I feel fat at a BMI of 19” posts appearing on style and beauty threads. I think posters like these are pretty ill actually. They need help."

I've noticed that too. I was on a thread yesterday about body shapes that don't suit our personal style, and someone came on to tell us that it was all to do with our weight and if we'd only get down to a BMI of 18-20, we'd look great in anything...

Leftoverssandwich · 29/03/2023 08:57

HungryMum101 · 29/03/2023 08:42

Ok - shopping list and maths:

  • 600g organic premium quality minced steak, £6.40, makes four burgers
  • Organic red onions, £2.60 per kilo
  • Pack of six organic brioche burger buns £4.20
  • Organic lettuce £2.20
  • Fresh organic herbs (coriander or parsley) £2.15 for 30g
  • 250g block of cheddar £3.85
  • Organic burger relish £3.19 for 125g jar
  • Jar of organic kimchi, £4.50 for 350g
  • Oil £3.50 for 500ml

Per burger cost:
minced steak £1.60
Bun = 70p
Lettuce = 30p
Onion ring = 7p
Herbs for burger = 35p
Slice of cheddar = 50p
Relish = 60p
Kimchi (or you could add a gherkin) = 63p
Oil = 10p
Hob to cook burger = 12p

Total per burger for premium, gastro pub quality = £4.97

Vs £4.99 for a Big Mac

Per burger, yes. I said that it might work out for a number of them. But it very clearly is not cheaper for a single one.

crossstitchingnana · 29/03/2023 08:56

Crisps just taste oily. Burgers are so unsatisfying.

A good, well cooked and healthy meal is divine. I love, and I mean LOVE salads.

HungryMum101 · 29/03/2023 08:42

Ok - shopping list and maths:

  • 600g organic premium quality minced steak, £6.40, makes four burgers
  • Organic red onions, £2.60 per kilo
  • Pack of six organic brioche burger buns £4.20
  • Organic lettuce £2.20
  • Fresh organic herbs (coriander or parsley) £2.15 for 30g
  • 250g block of cheddar £3.85
  • Organic burger relish £3.19 for 125g jar
  • Jar of organic kimchi, £4.50 for 350g
  • Oil £3.50 for 500ml

Per burger cost:
minced steak £1.60
Bun = 70p
Lettuce = 30p
Onion ring = 7p
Herbs for burger = 35p
Slice of cheddar = 50p
Relish = 60p
Kimchi (or you could add a gherkin) = 63p
Oil = 10p
Hob to cook burger = 12p

Total per burger for premium, gastro pub quality = £4.97

Vs £4.99 for a Big Mac

MarieRoseMarie · 29/03/2023 08:27

Also she really really really clearly can’t cook.

“Making a curry from scratch” - stirring in a jar of “Thai green curry” from tescos into a cup of cream. Look at me mum, I’m a real chef 🙄

MarieRoseMarie · 29/03/2023 08:23

Okunevo · 28/03/2023 15:42

It is odd that they keep interchanging fat and junk when numerous people have explained that's not what junk is. It does sound very disordered.

Exactly! If the post was “crisps and chocolate taste good”, then fine. But the post is “chicken thighs and olive oil are junk food because they are high in fat and they just keep ignoring any pushback.

Theres been a massive rise in posts by a anorexic posters in the last few weeks. I remember all the pro ana communities growing up and they were weirdly disingenuous like this. Some weird “I feel fat at a BMI of 19” posts appearing on style and beauty threads. I think posters like these are pretty ill actually. They need help.

Leftoverssandwich · 28/03/2023 16:41

HungryMum101 · 27/03/2023 22:08

I was responding to the original poster’s question, that in my opinion, a burger made with good quality ingredients tastes better than a McDonalds one.

Time and cost is irrelevant to that question, but since you bring it up, a home made burger to that spec is still a bit cheaper than a Big Mac. What the fast food delivers (IMO) is the convenience of not having to cook.

I’m not sure how that burger can be cheaper than a Big Mac, which costs £4.99.

Two butchers organic beef burgers will be £3-4 depending on where you get them. That leaves you with everything else to get for under £2. It may end up cheaper if you’re making a few, but for one?

Titsywoo · 28/03/2023 16:37

Hmm not really. I used to think that but after suffering from stomach issues for the last few years I am far more tempted by salad with some nice chicken and flatbread than an indian takeaway. There aren't many junk foods I like now more than the homecooked meals I make. Maybe it's an age thing! Your taste buds do change with age after all.

midlander79 · 28/03/2023 16:30

I like both, to be fair. I love fatty salty stodgy foods but I also love crispbreads and home made salsa/guac and salads with seeds, oil dressings and olives.

WalkingOnTheCracks · 28/03/2023 16:26

@FrozenGhost

Of course high fat/sugar food tastes good to us, our desire to eat it is what has kept us going over a million years - evolution hasn't caught up with our current food environment.

There's an argument to say that evolution never will catch up with it. Evolution only cares about reproduction, and the harm done by eating a lot of high fat and sugar tends not to be fatal until well after breeding age.

One could say that if we all stopped breeding with people who overdo the Mr Kipling's, then we might select out the genes that push people towards that. But we'd have to do it for hundreds of generations - and we change our idea of 'breedingly attractive' constantly, and from culture to culture.

Though obviously those of us who use chicken breasts to make curry are doomed.

FrostyFifi · 28/03/2023 16:10

FrozenGhost yep literally what is meant by living in an obesogenic diet. We're surrounded by all the foods we're hard-wired to prefer as they have the highest energy content, whereas we're no different genetically from our ancestors who would largely have lived with food scarcity.

FrozenGhost · 28/03/2023 16:08

Of course high fat/sugar food tastes good to us, our desire to eat it is what has kept us going over a million years - evolution hasn't caught up with our current food environment.

I'm not sure why people are so keen to deny this simple fact. Threads on here go for pages and pages about how if only people could be educated, have more money, learn to cook, not see advertising, if only they had the right parents or the right set of knives, then all obesity problems would be solved. These have an effect yes but the bottom line is these foods are delicious. Thats why people want to eat them.

FrostyFifi · 28/03/2023 16:02

@W0tnow same in terms of what I have in the house. I think unfortunately that any sort of eating out, processed or convenience food will most likely contain it, or almost all. Hopefully that's okay if you mostly eat at home but some people consume it day in and day out.

W0tnow · 28/03/2023 15:59

FrostyFifi · 28/03/2023 15:53

Well a curry full of coconut cream or ghee is fatty and junk you don't need it

No, these are healthy fats and you do need fat in your diet, you'd die without it and you need it to absorb nutrients.

What is junk is ultra-processed foods, sugars, refined carbs and seed oils.

I totally agree and I think it’s catching on but it’s a slow process. I will never ever have seed oil in my house again. Though it is ubiquitous in the restaurant industry so difficult to avoid, sadly.

FrostyFifi · 28/03/2023 15:53

Well a curry full of coconut cream or ghee is fatty and junk you don't need it

No, these are healthy fats and you do need fat in your diet, you'd die without it and you need it to absorb nutrients.

What is junk is ultra-processed foods, sugars, refined carbs and seed oils.

FrostyFifi · 28/03/2023 15:52

I completely disagree but I don't think food with a decent fat content is junk food, far from it, as long as it's healthy fat and not horrible cheap seed oils.

Okunevo · 28/03/2023 15:42

MarieRoseMarie · 28/03/2023 13:43

OP seems to have some disordered eating ideas but seems very stubborn about it. Fat isn’t bad. High fat foods aren’t bad. Chicken thighs are healthy. There’s something very disingenuous and silly about pretending that chicken thighs are “junk food”.

Also by curries I assume she means Thai green curry or something very basic like that because adding “extra” cream/ ghee to most indian curries just sounds disgusting.

It is odd that they keep interchanging fat and junk when numerous people have explained that's not what junk is. It does sound very disordered.

MarieRoseMarie · 28/03/2023 13:43

WalkingOnTheCracks · 28/03/2023 09:48

I think I’m going to start a separate thread in which to collect clips of people staggering, shocked, to the open window to get some air, gasping ‘everyone does x - i’ve never even heard of anyone doing y’….

This one’s going straight in.

Everyone uses chicken thighs over breasts to make curry. I’ve never even heard of making curry with breasts.

I shall be nippong down The Red Fort later, to ask them what they’re doing with all their thighless chickens.

OP seems to have some disordered eating ideas but seems very stubborn about it. Fat isn’t bad. High fat foods aren’t bad. Chicken thighs are healthy. There’s something very disingenuous and silly about pretending that chicken thighs are “junk food”.

Also by curries I assume she means Thai green curry or something very basic like that because adding “extra” cream/ ghee to most indian curries just sounds disgusting.

PussBilledDuckyPlait · 28/03/2023 12:25

To a point. I tend to crave variety. After Christmas and eating lots of rich food, I find myself wanting light things such as salad. When I'm trying to eat healthily in the long term, I find myself craving junk food but if I give in and have it, I soon get fed up of it. Junk food is more-ish while it's being eaten and tempts you to overeat, but can get get monotonous like anything else if you start having it too often.

SallyWD · 28/03/2023 12:05

Fifi1010 · 28/03/2023 09:20

I don't agree I could add all the seasoning and combinations in the world to a low fat lean meal but it still wouldn't taste as good as a meal with higher fat. I can cook lots of things high fat is divine to me.

Sorry but you're confusing high fat with unhealthy. Often high fat foods are healthy. I eat a lot of fats. I drizzle most of my meals with extra virgin olive oil. Yes olive oil is high calorie but it's certainly not unhealthy. It's one of the healthiest things you can eat, full of anti-oxidants and has anti-cancer properties. Likewise I go for whole milk over semi-skimmed because it's healthier. Yes it has more fat but I've read it's more nutritious. I've read studies on the positive health benefits of whole milk compared to cow's milk.
I often add a handful of nuts to meals. It seems you'd see this as unhealthy because they're calorific. But nuts aren't unhealthy. They're extremely good for you.
In my mind, unhealthy food is food which lacks nutrients and doesn't have a positive effect on the body - haribos, fizzy drinks etc. These foods don't taste good to me anyway.

Phoebo · 28/03/2023 11:28

squishee · 28/03/2023 10:27

Most moreish foods apparently have roughly the same carb-fat-protein ratio as breast milk.

www.donteatforwinter.com/breast-milk-vs-junk-food/

Wow, so interesting!