Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How much arguing it too much for kids?

30 replies

sopra · 27/03/2023 13:47

I come from a very toxic household. My parents fought all the time. Screaming / occasional violence / horrible name calling/ threats of divorce / leaving my mum on the street with nothing/ telling her she's worthless etc etc. you name it, I heard it.

I remember feeling very anxious and scared when I would see / hear these arguments. My parents never even tried to hide this ( it feels like )..

Anyhow. I am married now. I have little kids. Life is stressful. I can't work out how much arguing is normal ? How about shouting ?

You could argue that the fact I ask this question means it's too much. But I didn't have a normal experience.

How often do normal people shout at each other or fight in front of their kids ? How will it affect them in later life ? My kids are 3 and 1.

OP posts:
Emilyanna · 27/03/2023 13:54

We have never raised voices to each other, or argued in a negative way. If we disagree, we wait until we're calm and we're alone and discuss how we can compromise/do better.
That is the only acceptable amount of arguing and shouting in a respectful relationship.
BUT people are human, and fail sometimes! If you accidentally shout in the heat of the moment, just apologise for shouting and suggest talking about it later. This is a good thing to show your kids.
(note for the above to work I'm assuming your relationship is not in any way abusive and that you are both relatively decent people who want to make the relationship work)

Wishawisha · 27/03/2023 13:54

How often do normal people shout at each other or fight in front of their kids ?
Never.

They see us bickering, sure, but it’s good natured most of the time and sometimes (rarely) I might be a bit upset and I’m sure the DC pick up on it - then we’ll sort it out privately. I can’t imagine shouting at each other though.

JassyRadlett · 27/03/2023 13:51

To be honest, when our kids were your age we were really, really scrupulous about keeping arguments out of their earshot.

They're school age now and we'll disagree in front of them - not frequently but we will show grumpiness or unhappiness. We got a bit more lax on this during the pandemic but to be honest I think it would have happened anyway and it does kids that age no harm to see that people can disagree more or less civilly and resolve it.

Full on shouting - temper-losing shouting? Still never in front of the kids. And once in a blue moon in general. I don't lose my temper and shout at people at work, I treat my husband with the same respect.

I occasionally shout at the kids but only when speaking normally has failed - it's a conscious decision deployed when it's required!

LuvSmallDogs · 27/03/2023 13:51

Our old neighbours used to shut the kids in the house and sit outside in their car to scream at each other, so if you drive then I guess you could do that?

LuvSmallDogs · 27/03/2023 13:50

We don't fight in front of the kids. I mean, I guess there's "bloody hell babe, where have you put the pasta?!" "oh did I put it in the wrong cupboard hang on" crap, but nothing personal. We don't fight often anyway.

Swipe left for the next trending thread