Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask you to tell me how I should split childcare with DH! We can't agree!!!

179 replies

Questionnn · 27/03/2023 12:57

DH and I are in disagreement over a fair way to divide child caring responsibilities between us, so would like to ask you wise MNs how you would divide it if this was in your household?

Dh has a 'big job' and I have just returned from mat leave to a PT role, previously worked FT.

Dh and I split weekends so each gets a day - one of us Saturday and one of us Sunday. On 'our day' at weekend, we are not responsible for the baby eg feeds, nappy changes etc and have the opportunity of a lay in etc.

On Dhs 'day' he chooses to get up early to go to a hobby he could do at a different time but likes to miss the traffic so leaves house at 7.30am. I don't have any hobbies so on my 'day' choose a lay in or to leave house early with him to take baby out for the morning so we are back in time for baby's lunch and nap. I will also do a bit of housework and cook dinner.

Can you tell me who you think should do

  1. bath and bedtime
  2. night time wakings
  3. sorting baby in the morning

for each day...

Monday- DH works from home 9-6. I am at home all day with baby.

Tuesday and Wednesday - DH is at work, leaves for train 6.20am and gets back 7pm. He doesn't see baby at all.
I get baby up and sort us both, do nursery drop before going to work, then collect baby. One week I have short shifts so have about 2 hours to myself to do housework etc each day, one week I work all day. I do bath and bedtime.

Thursday - DH is at work, leaves for train 6.20am and gets back 7pm. He doesn't see baby at all. I am at home all day with baby, do bath and bedtime.

Friday - DH works from home 8-5/9-6. DH drops baby to nursery for 8am, comes home and picks baby up from nursery after he finishes wfh. I have to leave at 8am for work and get home around baby's bath and bedtime.

Weekends we each get a day off.

OP posts:
GiltEdges · 27/03/2023 13:58

Tarantellah · 27/03/2023 13:54

On the days you don’t work, you should look after the baby during the day. On the days you do work, the baby goes to nursery. All mornings and evenings and weekends should be split 50/50.

And for the posters asking why things need to be so rigid, it’s probably because the DH is a lazy twat who doesn’t do his share in a more natural arrangement. The only way for mum to have her fair share of rest and not end up doing everything is to be firm about what days and times are Dad’s responsibility.

And if you're right, what exactly would be the point in staying in a relationship with such a useless man? Maybe some of us can't imagine doing so, hence the question.

ktitten · 27/03/2023 13:57

givemushypeasachance · 27/03/2023 13:11

So are you asking who should be doing those things every day?

You've said your husband works away all day and never even sees the baby Tue/Wed/Thu so he's ruled out on those days - except possibly for overnight waking duty. And according to your weekend splitting system are you saying when it's "your day" you have zero baby responsibilities, so Sat and Sun are already split up?

If so, you would just be asking who should do what on Monday and Friday. And Monday you're home and he's WFH, so more on you I'd imagine but he could contribute a bit. And Friday he's WFH and you're out working, so shared but more emphasis on him.

Maybe I've not understood correctly though. Is your weekend splitting system not as strict as it initially sounded?

If I had to choose this seems the most sensible tbh but the whole thing seems kinda bonkers to me.

I mean just as an example - Monday is your day bc you've been at home all day while he's working but what if he's been sat in meetings all day while you've had a shit day (baby teething or something idk) you'd think in a marriage you'd both just work it out as you go so everyone feels supported and nobody feels hard done by. I can't imagine going through life raising a family like this...

Tarantellah · 27/03/2023 13:56

sevenbyseven · 27/03/2023 13:54

This set-up wouldn't have worked for me at all, and sounds a bit unusual. For us, weekends are family time when both parents look after the baby / kids. Obviously if you find a different set-up that works for you, that's fine, but I'm not sure this really is working.

DH and I always took the approach that there’s no point in us both being miserable and tired. If we take turns looking after the baby separately then we both get a rest. If we look after the baby together then nobody gets a rest.

sevenbyseven · 27/03/2023 13:54

This set-up wouldn't have worked for me at all, and sounds a bit unusual. For us, weekends are family time when both parents look after the baby / kids. Obviously if you find a different set-up that works for you, that's fine, but I'm not sure this really is working.

Tarantellah · 27/03/2023 13:54

On the days you don’t work, you should look after the baby during the day. On the days you do work, the baby goes to nursery. All mornings and evenings and weekends should be split 50/50.

And for the posters asking why things need to be so rigid, it’s probably because the DH is a lazy twat who doesn’t do his share in a more natural arrangement. The only way for mum to have her fair share of rest and not end up doing everything is to be firm about what days and times are Dad’s responsibility.

GiltEdges · 27/03/2023 13:53

Agree with a PP, it's all very transactional. I don't know any other couples with DC who take a day each at the weekends to the extreme you do. Alternating lie ins maybe, although personally I don't subscribe to this either.

Why not just go ahead and split properly, then you'll each get alone time when your DC is with the other parent? No complicated calculations over what's fair on any given day.

Purplecatshopaholic · 27/03/2023 13:49

Golly that sounds rigid. What about a bit of flexibility, some mucking in, and some family time? You should be doing more baby/house stuff as you are PT to his FT, but you both actually sound really anti-parenting in general. Or are you trying to be structured because he wouldn’t step up otherwise?

Boonata · 27/03/2023 13:48

Your situation reminds me of a married couple I knew who on an evening out for a meal, the husband would lend the wife 50p so she could have a dessert as she was short of cash that night; the money being repaid to him later.

Couldn't argue it wasn't fair but what a miserable couple they were. Still married after 35 years but both as sour faced as they come.

CleaningOutMyCloset · 27/03/2023 13:46

Can't you have your day off when your dh is in the office (or he changes his wfh day, that way your dh can do a drop off or pick up when he's wfh.

Dh does drop off and pick up when wft
You do drop off and pick up when dh is in the office

Bedtime and bath, dh does it when he's wfh and you do when he's in the office

So that's

Dh 2 days of drop off and collection, bed and bath
OP 3 days of drop off and collection, bed and bath

You both get the option of a lie in or hobby in the weekend, outside of hobby or lie in you both do 50/50

Snorlaxing · 27/03/2023 13:42

Some of those jobs can be done by 2 people or the other does something cleaning related while the other does childcare. For example if your h eats breakfast with baby then you can get showered and changed then take over so he can go up to his work room.
Similarly the person not doing bath and bed could clean the kitchen or one parent does bath and the other bed.

Lcb123 · 27/03/2023 13:41

seems a weird set up for parents who are together. Fair enough each gets a lie in at the weekend (or chose to go out for a hobby), but it reads like you both just want time on your own with out each other or baby! Just organise it as you go, surely it changes weekly with different plans

LaughingSomnambulist · 27/03/2023 13:38

What a bizarre way to live. You need to break it down this far and have assigned days where you will refuse to get involved if it isn’t your day. This isn’t a family. I don’t know what you are but you’re not a family.

If you need to be this transactional then you’re not suited. It shouldn’t need to be like this to ensure both of you do your share.

gamerchick · 27/03/2023 13:36

BernadetteIsMySister · 27/03/2023 13:28

Do you both hate parenthood? It seems like you're both constantly waiting to 'log off' and just pass the chore of parenting back and forth between you like a hot potato.

I kind of got that impression. Pretty sure it's just to make it "fair', its just coming across as a bit weird.

Theelephantinthecastle · 27/03/2023 13:36

As I understood it, you are doing everything child related on 3 weekdays plus one weekend day, so I think your DH doing drop off and pick up on the Friday and also bedtime on Monday and one weekend day seems about right. It's less than you but you are part time

Night wakings should be 50:50, in my view.

Wnikat · 27/03/2023 13:35

I know the baby years are tough but I never considered bath and bedtime a chore. Not until I had the second one. Don’t either of you like being parents?

Jackiebrambles · 27/03/2023 13:33

This is so weird! I too wonder if you are trying to regiment this because when left ‘loose’ he didn’t do enough?

Bear in mind that a lot of kids only want mum if you are anywhere in the vicinity. Mine still do. So you saying ‘No it’s not my day to get you a snack, ask daddy’ is unlikely to work!’.

mynameiscalypso · 27/03/2023 13:33

We're another family that just makes it up as we go along. We don't have set times or days and generally do whatever works best on a day to day basis. At the moment, I do more of the childcare because DH is extremely busy at work and that's fine. A couple of weeks ago, I was away on a business trip so DH had to to everything. It all evens out because neither of us are twats.

riotlady · 27/03/2023 13:32

This sounds like a really miserable way to live tbh.

Gincan · 27/03/2023 13:30

Similar to pp, we just muddle along in no set pattern....if DP has to get up early for a train then I sort DC, if I've been working late and am tired then DP will sort them in the morning. If he has a lay in at the weekend the he'll make up for it by watching them for a couple of hours so I can go out or whatever.

Can't you just take it as it comes?

Aquamarine1029 · 27/03/2023 13:30

Sorry, but your marriage sounds miserable. It sounds like you're creating a work rota for employees, not enjoying and coping with family life as a couple.

Snorlaxing · 27/03/2023 13:30

I think that the current system will fall apart as the baby becomes a toddler. You can't say "It's Sunday so Daddy will make you breakfast" when your child has a preference for you to do it.

Ex and I had a lie in each which meant breakfast and entertaining the child quietly but apart from that it was all hands on deck.

Lazyladydaisy · 27/03/2023 13:30

I'm assuming you feel that more is falling to you because of your new part time working status...I feel the same way and it can be a bit annoying.
However, I just can't grasp the 'your day, my day' thing. You're a family...a team. You should be wanting to spend time together.
Even if it works for you now, it won't when your child is older...a two year old won't understand 'Sorry, its not my day!'

Sugarfree23 · 27/03/2023 13:29

Op where is your family time?

Our house tends to be very fluid, LO needs a bath and dishwasher needs emptied (Or other household job) Who's doing what?

DH is normally up before me, so weekend is often, DH moaning 'you get him I got up first yesterday'

BernadetteIsMySister · 27/03/2023 13:28

Do you both hate parenthood? It seems like you're both constantly waiting to 'log off' and just pass the chore of parenting back and forth between you like a hot potato.

Daffodilsandbeer · 27/03/2023 13:28

Wow that’s really weird. You treat caring for your kid like a chore. Like hoovering or dusting.

I get a lie in each but past that I cannot get my head round how you both are fighting not to spend more time caring for your child than you individually need to.

Swipe left for the next trending thread