Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WIBU to have had a go at my Mum for food shaming?

106 replies

MrsHughesPinny · 27/03/2023 12:01

My mother and I have always had a complex relationship. She’s very image conscious and I have pretty low self esteem when it comes to my appearance and relationships, but not in my working life, that’s the one place I feel confident.

We’re living together temporarily (I’m paying 50% towards bills, the folks are mortgage free) because I’m waiting for my new house to be finished and in the past month, I’ve had to ask her to stop with the negative comments and food shaming. I’m ashamed to say that this morning I completely went off at her.

She saw I’d had some toast last night, because she watches things like a hawk, down to slices of bread, and this morning said “I see you’ve been stuffing yourself with carbs again” I just went mad and told her I’ve repeatedly asked her not to say things like that. My weight is up and down a bit but I’m fit and healthy and I haven’t asked her for help or advice about it.

Here are some examples from just this month:

I showed her a lovely picture of my sister who has a busy job so we don’t see her much. Her first response to it? “God, she’s gone hell of a size!” She hasn’t.

DS15 - who is like a rake - was eating a normal sized bag of Maltesers and she said “pigging out again are we?” I pulled her up on it immediately because I don’t want DS exposed to that and she said she was just saying something normal and it’s not her fault that’s the way my “crazy brain heard it.”

I was about to go out to run some errands and got a can of pop out of the fridge to take with me. She said “stealing pop again, are you?” I said “given that I pay towards the bills no, but here, have it back.”

I made some breakfast (cereal) and went to sit down at the table with my computer to WFH and she said, I thought you said you were making an omelette for lunch, why are you eating cereal? Because it’s 8 a.m, not 1 p.m.

I’ve been NC with her before but it causes so much stress on the rest of the family I just try to suck it up but she really, really got to me this morning.

Am I being over-sensitive? How could I have handled this better? There’s such an atmosphere now.

OP posts:
DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 27/03/2023 20:38

How much longer have you got to be there OP?
Can you plan plenty of outings for yourself and DS?
I'd be eating out with him a few times a week so you can enjoy an unobserved meal.
Cinema Trips.
Just to break up the time you have to spend in conversations. Spending too much time together with out a break is what is making it feel worse.
Also.. can you watch an ipad in your room/or listen to podcast or have your nose stuck in a book to cut down on potential minefield conversations?
What about a weekend break somewhere?
That would definitely allow you time to breath a bit and make the time pass more quickly

MrsHughesPinny · 27/03/2023 20:20

@Ohyeahwaitaminute Blimey, steel yourself! I think I’d find that really hard. Trying out the local cuisine is one of my favourite parts of a holiday!

@kimchifix She is Aunty Val mixed with Horrible Grandma! That has just really cheered me up!

She’s acting as if nothing has happened this evening. Even berated me for “being antisocial” because I didn’t say much at dinner. Give me strength! 😭

OP posts:
Daffodilsandbeer · 27/03/2023 20:19

kimchifix · 27/03/2023 20:14

I feel sorry for your poor Dad. Why he hasn't left her yet is bemusing but at least you get to move out and keep her at arms length in a little while. She sounds absolutely awful. "Horrible Grandma".

Anyway, yes call her out on the food comments - what you eat is absolutely none of her business, it is a miracle you are sane growing up with that kind of parenting. Leave some flyers for therapists when you move out.

Seriously? How shallow are you? I don’t have an eating disorder but I know if I did, my husband wouldn’t leave me due to it . Good god

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 27/03/2023 20:18

HowcanIgetoutofthisalive · 27/03/2023 12:37

as @bumpytrumpy said. Every single time she says something about you eating something just keep repeating, ad infinitum: "As previously mentioned Mum, don't project your eating disorder onto me or DS".

And she KNOWS she's upsetting you each time but still says things. So rude. What you or your DS eats is of no concern to her or anyone else.

This and also what a good reply.

We have same with MIL - thinks everyone should thinner than thin, and probably wouldn't even be satisfied with that.
My DS still remembers when she forced a pudding on him, and he had to stand and reach over to get it from her and she commented "Why aren't you on a diet DS? " it's the tone it's said in that is particularly wounding. He was shocked at the way she said it - a boy who exercises nearly every day and plays 3 team sports. My other relative has had stand-up fights with her for comments to her DDs

But she won't change and they are all terrified to say anything.

kimchifix · 27/03/2023 20:14

I feel sorry for your poor Dad. Why he hasn't left her yet is bemusing but at least you get to move out and keep her at arms length in a little while. She sounds absolutely awful. "Horrible Grandma".

Anyway, yes call her out on the food comments - what you eat is absolutely none of her business, it is a miracle you are sane growing up with that kind of parenting. Leave some flyers for therapists when you move out.

Ohyeahwaitaminute · 27/03/2023 20:09

I totally sympathise @MrsHughesPinny my mother is JUST like that.

She equates peoples size to…. I don’t know….but there is massive judgement going on in her head. She definitely comes from the generation where women especially were judged on their size. She often completely overdresses IMHO for stuff, but I don’t comment. If thats what makes her feel comfortable, I’m fine with that.

Ive struggled with my weight for the best part of 35 years. Eating out with her is some kind of competition on how little she can eat, while she fixates on my plate. We had a pub lunch for her birthday; I ordered baked cod with some mash and vegetables. I had an evening class that night, so had a ‘good’ lunch. I don’t really eat on that particular night due to timing.

She toyed with a starter of scallops… but then ate two bread rolls and all the butter, but not without commenting on what I’d eaten.

I’m off on holiday with her soon; more of a duty kind of thing, rather than actively wanting her to come. The eating bit is going to be a nightmare, and some of the retorts that others have come up with will be useful!

In fact, I’m thinking of having a chat with her before we go - otherwise we could end up having a massive bust up.

MrsHughesPinny · 27/03/2023 19:37

@Willmafrockfit Unfortunately, this issue has been going on to varying degrees since I was about 11. Same with my sisters. Appearance definitely correlates with value in her mind.

@SteveBuscemisRheumyEye I do usually work in the office and she works outside the home too. That day I was staying in to wait for a delivery for my Dad because my job is the most flexible.

OP posts:
CharlotteStreetW1 · 27/03/2023 19:35

I think I'd be giving her the gimlet eye and saying "I think we all know I'm not the one with the food issues..."

Your living situation sounds totally logical BTW, if not ideal.

SteveBuscemisRheumyEye · 27/03/2023 19:23

Have you tried sitting her down properly to talk about it and how it makes you feel?

Also, you mentioned wfh. I'd be getting with someone around a lot, can you go into the office?

Willmafrockfit · 27/03/2023 18:31

perhaps you and your ds are getting on her nerves?
she is not used to having you there?

anyway, not much longer now op, good luck
it is Her issue, dont make it yours.

MzHz · 27/03/2023 18:25

And I speak as one who HAS gone NC with her parents for exactly this kind of thing.

life is better without them

GinIronic · 27/03/2023 18:15

You know that the clock is ticking and by the summer you will be moving soft furnishings around your beautiful new home and this will be semi forgotten - or it will remind you to avoid the Poisonous One. In the meantime, smile and nod and whisper "fuck off Mother " under your breath and imagine a pillow over someone's face until the legs stop kicking........

saraclara · 27/03/2023 18:13

How about pretending you haven't heard her? Studious (and very obvious) ignoring drives people nuts. They much prefer you to rise to the bait.

LovelyBranches · 27/03/2023 18:12

It’s too late to be able to move out now because it’ll be tough to find somewhere for such a short space of time, and moving twice in a few months will be a huge hassle so you are probably going to have to put up and shut up.

However, I totally sympathise with you and I really think diet culture did a number on a generation of women who were valued and judged by their proximity to thinness. My mother feels like she is being loving by ‘saving’ people from the indignity of being fat, but has never once stopped to examine her own behaviour and why she responds to things as she does.

Try and find ways of eating when she’s not around if you can, and then when you move into your new house you can eat in peace.

Willmafrockfit · 27/03/2023 18:05

her language sounds dreadful.
how much longer do you have to stay with her?

MzHz · 27/03/2023 18:03

Have only read OP, but fuck that! Of course YANBU!you’ve gone NC before and for good reason. Fuck what the rest of the family think/say. They need to “get it” and if they don’t get it, they can ftfo too.

life is too short to put up with this and watch her do it to your kids too

Lateliein · 27/03/2023 17:21

Mil is like this

As a similar height to her, she is very competitive with under eating and dress sizes. When I lost weight for my wedding she was raging 😂

Now I'm probably about a size bigger than her and she loves it. Part of me wants to lose a couple of stone just to piss her off again. Probably need a healthier incentive than that though? !

Tinkerbyebye · 27/03/2023 16:16

You have a choice. Each time she says something you state that’s rude please don’t do it again and walk away and out of the room

or find air bnb and move there for a few weeks

MrsHughesPinny · 27/03/2023 15:55

Goodness! Some strong opinions about my living situation!

@SlouchingTowardsBethlehemAgain At no point did I say I hated her. I find some of her behaviours incredibly challenging and I am not the only one. Even her friends have pulled her up on the things she says about people. It’s not limited to body shape/size. She often says mean things about people’s dress, hair, makeup etc too.

@rookiemere The NC was a fair while ago and I thought our relationship had improved sufficiently/boundaries were in place.

Thanks again to everyone who has offered a helpful suggestion. I’ve calmed down a bit now, I just find her saying these sorts of things really triggering and while I’ve been trying to ignore the comments it all built up this morning and the steam had to escape!

I am advocating for my son, and have told him in no uncertain terms that she is in the wrong.

OP posts:
jannier · 27/03/2023 15:46

I think I'd just keep saying "why did you never seek help over your distorted ideas around food mum?"

Calmdown14 · 27/03/2023 14:36

People are very quick to jump on 'fat shaming ' but don't have much sympathy the other way.

Your mum has disordered eating. It's not really her fault either. Just do as your dad says and ignore her. People who eat like this just see things differently . Viewed through the lens of necessity, most eating is greed (except most of us eat for some sort of enjoyment).

Just tell her you are looking after your bone health and change the subject. She might be wrong but you're not going to change her so getting frustrated will only hurt you

Conkersinautumn · 27/03/2023 14:30

I'd look her straight in the eye and tell my dc to carry on. I'd do that a couple of times, so she can't deny these moments in the future. then suggest she come for a walk with you and talk to her about her eating disorder and whether she has discussed it with her gp. Older women do need to be very careful to eat a great balance of food due to thinning bones etc. Anyone overly wary of a true balance is putting their health ay a high risk. Tell your dad you plan to as well. Essentially a mini 'intervention'. But then if you've been NC in the past maybe she's just not worth engaging with.

SunshineLollipopsAndRainbows · 27/03/2023 14:27

Aquamarine1029 off of?!

Antiquiteas · 27/03/2023 14:27

rookiemere · 27/03/2023 14:19

I couldn't live with my DPs and they're pleasant enough people.
Why you thought this would work out when you already went NC for some time is anyone's guess.

Trying a different tack, after your jibe about the OP living ‘rent free’ in her parents’ home went wrong?

Her dad insisted, he obviously wanted to help her out after her divorce.

Lheuredubebe · 27/03/2023 14:22

Lollipop180 · 27/03/2023 14:16

Just move out.

This type of comment isn't helpful. I had the same comments when I was in a similar situation. I'm not sure where you live, but I don't know of anywhere that'll accept a 1-2 month rental super last-minute, that's if you even have the money to do so in the first place.

OP I'd just buy my own food, keep it separate and completely ignore any comments. Don't even respond, it's not worth it. I'd also buy a calendar and tick off the days til I could move! Good luck :)