Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why there is no support?

113 replies

drspouse · 27/03/2023 11:59

We have DS who is 11 and has ADHD and a lot of challenging behaviour and DD who is 8. DS is in a specialist school and though he likes a lot of aspects of the school he is still challenging there. He is actually probably better at home -though he is on a hair trigger at both places we find he settles down more easily at home.

We feel like the best ways to help DS are to work out what's an issue for him (but we do not remove everything that's causing him difficulty, partly because we can't - e.g. he slapped me because I turned on the wrong TV for him - I had no idea which one he wanted and I didn't have a problem with him watching the other TV, until he slapped me; and we also know that if he is learning a new skill he will resist as hard as possible but we are not doing everything for him for ever more, though he'd like that) and trying as hard as possible not to react to it.

DH struggles more than me with his behaviour in that he is more likely to be reactive but I can't help myself reacting sometimes and DD shrieks when he does anything to her (ranging from growling at her to attempting to strangle her). DS attacks me more than DH but DH is not exempt either. A few weeks ago we came back from holiday, we asked both DCs to help get bags in the house/sort out what they wanted for dinner/get plates etc. and DS broke a window and a mirror (and quite a few plates).

We called the Social Services emergency number, were told we'd get help and this help consisted of an email detailing the local self-referral for mental health support (we've both maxed out our annual allowance of this) and links to online support groups (for an 11 year old who isn't allowed on the internet on his own and who wouldn't know where to start with this kind of thing anyway, and who says he doesn't want any friends).

Last week he slapped me and pulled my hair when I told him about something we were planning, then threatened to throw a carving knife at me, we called the police who were honestly excellent and said we'd be escalated for additional help. We had a phone call and were told that one person (not two, so as not to overwhelm DS) would come round around tea time as this is a pinch point for us and we really need some advice on how to handle it.

What we got was Early Help were two people (sigh) came round and... you guessed it... gave us links to online groups, hilariously told us about a "group for 0-11 year olds with SEN" which I was slightly puzzled about in January as it meets at 1.30 on a school day so I rang up and they said "It's a typo, it's for 0-5". They are the third group to tell us about this "group". They said they can't give us any direct advice. They also suggested a parenting course!

Last time Early Help came round they suggested sticker charts and that we should "stick some house rules on the fridge". Oh, and a parenting course (we actually did one that was semi-helpful, directed at children with ADHD.)

Both DCs are adopted but when we have asked for help from the Adoption Support Fund it has either been things we cannot access or things we know DS won't participate in (e.g. parenting courses that we must both attend when we have no babysitting, but they won't accept us unless we both attend, or a therapy session on Zoom that would take DS out of school for a day a week and we'd both have to reduce our working hours just to do it).

I am currently seeing a counsellor privately and I try to do things that help me stay calm (mainly exercise/Pilates at the moment but I've also done a lot of mindfulness in the past). I'm doing better than DH at reacting to DS and I think this helps but I'm not perfect and I don't think DH feels able to help himself at the moment. DS knows which buttons to press (I'm going to break your glasses Daddy) and DH responds. I've asked DH not to even discuss what we are doing in front of DS because DS has the idea that Daddy would let him do what he wanted if it wasn't for stupid Mummy, but DH gets wound up too and tends to tell me I won't let him have any ideas (not helpful, DH, not helpful).

We've asked for mental health support for us (I think DH would do something that was "provided for him" but he doesn't have any confidence that a "mindfulness course" would help him or that he'd even be able to do it, and we've asked for direct advice in the home about how to deal with DS. We've also asked for respite. We are waiting for a disability team assessment but last time we asked we were told DS "isn't disabled enough".

How is there NOTHING for us? We are at the point where we cannot keep DD safe, and when DS is bigger then him attacking me will not just be annoying/causing bruises but actively unsafe. We can't even find anything that we can pay for (we are both professionals and we can pay for help in the home/courses/counselling/respite but can't find anything that helps, or any carers who can cope with DS). Being professionals seems to work against us TBH - we are supposed to be free to go to lots of parenting courses during school hours, and not to question what we are told, but if the social workers say "oh you should do this parenting course or go to this group" we are supposed to say "oh yes thank you we are much better now" but instead I look up the parenting course and find that it has no proven outcomes with children of his age with ADHD, or that the group isn't actually for his age, or in fact doesn't exist.

Do they actually want us to put DS in foster care? Is that what they think we should do? Or for a vulnerable 11 year old who needs a hug at bedtime to go to boarding school? Or are they going to wait till it breaks down even further and DD is actually hurt badly and then she will be removed?

Is there actually anybody that the current system helps? Does a parenting course and a sticker chart make a difference to any families who have a child older than a toddler? We aren't even in the worst possible situation - I know there are families with teenagers that are even harder to deal with and have much more power in the household, and children with much less manageable disabilities than our DS who need physical help, who don't sleep etc. etc.

Well done if you've made it to the end! If you have any experience at all of anything that ACTUALLY HELPS I'd love to hear it but if you are also in the same boat please feel free to vent as well.

OP posts:
Jellycatspyjamas · 29/03/2023 11:13

*Honestly, talking a child with ADHD and no insight through "why he did what he did" is a road to nothing. He has no idea, and the main answer is "because his brain is impulsive and it felt good at the time".

The conversation isn’t about “why he did what he did” though” there’s no point in asking a traumatised child why they did something, it’s too shaming for them to process. It’s talking through what happened, being curious with the child, sharing your observations, wondering aloud with them, having empathy for that feeling that it’s “more fun”, recognising that the fall out isn’t so much fun etc etc. Asking why is a hiding to nothing and is a reactive response.

I notice you consistently refer to his ADHD, understandably, but where do you see trauma playing a part? There’s lots of overlap in developmental trauma, ADHD, ASD etc because they all relate to neurodevelopment but different approaches work with each condition.

gamerchick · 29/03/2023 11:11

FannyPhart · 27/03/2023 12:18

I hate to say it but there seem to be an awful lot of obstacles being put in the way here? find it hard to believe it's humanly impossible arrange for someone a neighbour, friend, relative to babysit for an hour so you can both attend parenting classes together? It appears that's what is clearly needed.

Nice of you to offer yourself to babysit. How's that going?

drspouse · 29/03/2023 11:11

@Geneticsbunny we have been like this since he was about 3. OK, throwing scissors and knives is new but everything else has been the same.

OP posts:
drspouse · 29/03/2023 11:08

My sense is you feel worn out, and quite stuck which may be where the oppositional stance is coming from. You’ve rejected just about every suggestion made to you, I get it, it’s absolutely exhausting but if nothing changes, nothing changes.

I haven't seen anyone suggest anything to me that we haven't tried, but have been offered, except for things that fall under "fish oils". I've seen a lot of suggestions for things we have tried (like asking DS why he does things) that haven't worked and are unlikely ever to work with a child with ADHD.

We are pretty clear on what we think will help, but we aren't getting it.

OP posts:
drspouse · 29/03/2023 11:06

In your situation this morning, I would have kept your DS with me (or DH), supported him through the morning routine and, when things were calmer used PLACE principles to talk to him about what happened that he did whatever he did to your DD. The other parent can then help your DD work through her morning routine. Yes it takes time, but both your children will demand more of your time because they have complex additional needs.

Honestly, talking a child with ADHD and no insight through "why he did what he did" is a road to nothing. He has no idea, and the main answer is "because his brain is impulsive and it felt good at the time".
This is very WELL evidenced and I really don't think "why did you do that" is going to go anywhere with DS. You are right that this type of research is hard and in its infancy but there is a huge amount of research with ADHD to show children with the condition don't have insight.

We would generally keep them separate to get them ready, but DS was physically refusing to be separate because it's much more fun and rewarding for him to hurt DD and her to scream, and of course he's impulsive and can't stop himself from doing that, plus we'd told him not to be with her so obviously he MUST be with her and refuse to do what we say. We tried to separate them and he kicked me (see above). And, as I say, often DD will also refuse to be separate (usually refuses by shouting but sometimes by physically pushing herself back into the room where DS is).

OP posts:
Geneticsbunny · 29/03/2023 11:00

I think our issue is due to decentralised council funding which has led to lower income for councils and has allowed the government to shift blame to the councils when things go wrong. The councils still have a legal requirement to do loads of stuff like guarantee school places and resources for disabled kids but can't access any extra money on top of what they are given.
There is no overnight respite at all for any disabled children in our region and hasn't been since the beginning of COVID and this is not likely to change soon.
We were offered occasional foster care for overnight respite and accepted it but are still waiting for a match. Foster care is a good solution for some families. I wouldn't totally discount it.

Jellycatspyjamas · 29/03/2023 10:57

Everything you look at is going to have various degrees of evidence. The reality is this area (understanding developmental trauma) is a relatively new area of research and a very complex one. As with all psychology it’s very difficult to run randomised controlled trials because you’re working with peoples psyche, which has long lasting effects for better or worse, so ethically it’s tricky. Add in to that the fact that different people respond differently to interventions, have different degrees of trauma, and in complex cases there are often issues around exposure to drugs and alcohol in the womb affecting brain development and you’re not likely to get consistent results across a population of people who have been exposed to developmental trauma.

So, if you’re looking for gold star, works every time interventions, you’re not going to get that. Because people don’t work that way.

Its about developing a tool kit of various approaches and seeing what works in your family situation. So therapeutic parenting isn’t a golden bullet but does give you a framework for interacting with your child, DDP isn’t perfect but has excellent outcomes for children with attachment difficulties.

In your situation this morning, I would have kept your DS with me (or DH), supported him through the morning routine and, when things were calmer used PLACE principles to talk to him about what happened that he did whatever he did to your DD. The other parent can then help your DD work through her morning routine. Yes it takes time, but both your children will demand more of your time because they have complex additional needs.

It’s hard because you constantly need to flex your parenting approach to meet your child’s needs in a way that they can tolerate. What works one day may not the next because your child is in a different place. It means having lots of tricks up your sleeve, and learning through trial and error, it also means reading and training - you might get one or two things from each approach that work for you.

My sense is you feel worn out, and quite stuck which may be where the oppositional stance is coming from. You’ve rejected just about every suggestion made to you, I get it, it’s absolutely exhausting but if nothing changes, nothing changes.

Geneticsbunny · 29/03/2023 10:55

You are in crisis. None of you are in a place where any sort of therapy or behaviour plan will work. You all need a break so you can recharge and then get yourselves in a place where you feel well enough to start working out what might help.

I signed myself up for a triple p course for parents of kids with disabilities and a week later my son had a catatonic breakdown and completely lost the ability to talk. I don't think I really believed how bad it had got and I was too unwell (mental health stress and anxiety) to be able to see that I couldn't fix it myself.

drspouse · 29/03/2023 10:38

We have both had all the therapy we're entitled to under the local NHS Care trust (I think that will be your IAPT). I think DH is asking if he can be referred again. I will make sure he mentions the magic "breakdown of placement" words. I have however heard horror stories from parents who say they didn't want foster care but that's all they were offered when they got to this situation.

And obviously, yes, but to be frank I don't think there was much better care before the Tories because all the stuff that we are offered is useless, e.g. parenting courses that are sold as a commercial package to LAs and where the only research is conducted by the original sellers of the package. These are all the same things that were offered before the Tories.

Though on the respite issue I think the Tories can be blamed for Brexit and chucking all the carers out of the country/making Little Britain types think they can abuse Eastern European families and get away with it so they all left of their own accord.

I looked up DDP and therapeutic parenting (recommended by PPs) and they are both at the level of fish oils in terms of effectiveness and evidence. I know I'm being just as oppositional as my DS but I really don't think there is much point in spending weeks or months trying to do some kind of therapy which ultimately isn't going to make a difference (and might make things worse).

OP posts:
Geneticsbunny · 29/03/2023 10:25

In answer to you original question, because of the Tory government who think that the poor and vulnerable should just be able to sort themselves out...

Geneticsbunny · 29/03/2023 10:22

In terms of respite we get 3 days a week in school holidays and every other Saturday for 5 hours at a local Sen club and ten hours a week of direct payments. It has taken 6 months to find carers for the direct payments but we now have a bank of 4 people we can use so that we have cover. It means my son can have a social life and we get a break.

Geneticsbunny · 29/03/2023 10:19

@drspouse I was you about 18 months ago. Unfortunately it will take time to get help. It took me a while but there are "special magical words" that you need to use with social care so that they understand how bad the situation is. I only got help after I rang the emergency social care line and said that we were in "crisis" and at "immediate risk of family breakdown". In your case I would also use "immediate break down of adoption".
I also went to the GP and self referred to iapt (our local NHS mental health service). In the end my iapt counsellor intervened on my behalf to get us some urgent school holiday respite. We are almost at a level where I feel safe with our respite provision but we still have no overnight care.

drspouse · 29/03/2023 10:10

@cansu we have lots of ideas, but we don't know if we are putting them into practice effectively. That's why we want someone on the ground to tell us what's going wrong. As I say, to me it looks like DH is more reactive than me. But maybe I'm wrong. Maybe we are both a bit reactive but he's less reactive overall and I'm just not seeing it. Maybe we are reacting in the wrong way, but we should be reacting a bit. We have no idea.
This morning's example: DS came downstairs when I was there with DD, and either hit her or pulled her hair the second he stepped off the bottom step. I am not sure which as I didn't see it. I told him to go back up and wait till she was ready to go out. He kicked me. DH got upset about being late (I rarely care about being late but it stresses DH).

I told DH not to worry and I'd stay upstairs with DS while DD got ready. DD and I got ready and were about to go out when DS came down and waved a heavy bowl as if to throw it at me. I told him not to threaten us and he threw scissors at me. I sent him back up again (actually I had to physically escort him that time).

Thing is, I don't know if I was being over-reactive in sending him back upstairs (and should have just ignored him/sent DD outside and passed her her coat and shoes, well, except that DD never listens when we tell her to go out of the room to get out of the way so she would actually have stood downstairs shouting NO NO NO and not either getting ready or getting out of the way 🙄) or if DH was being over-reactive in worrying about being late and telling me NOT to send him back upstairs, and he should have just not said anything.

I really, really don't think a boarding school will do anything other than expose him to bullies (and remove all his academic boosting and activities that we do with him) and decrease his sense of wellbeing which will make him more aggressive. When he was being bullied at school it was definitely bad for his home behaviour. It might be a solution when he's 13 or so and needs a more academic school but a very young 11 who still takes teddies to bed, watches Cbeebies and needs a hug is going to be eaten alive in an SEMH residential school with children who are at school 52 weeks of the year because they have been removed from violent and neglectful homes.

We are just waiting to hear from the disability team about an assessment. We are not confident though that there will actually be anyone who could provide respite, because we have the money to pay for it but can't find anyone.

OP posts:
cansu · 28/03/2023 20:01
  1. What makes you think there is a practitioner or professional out there that can come to your house and teach you how to deal with your ds? I have dealt with behaviourists, psychologists, psychiatrists, OTs, SALTs and mental health workers. None have had any better ideas really than what I could find from googling and reading etc.
  2. Respite should be provided. Get a social worker. Write to Children and Young People's services and request it. I did this with ds. He eventually got some. You need it.
  3. Consider a school with weekly boarding. It will give you the break you need and will allow you a family life with your dd. It could also be positive for ds if you find the right place. No it isn't what you want, but it might be what you all need.

At some point, you have to look at the reality of your situation.
You have a child with complex needs and challenging behaviour. You have tried everything and nothing really helps enough for you. He is aggressive towards you. He damages things. He is hard work. I get it. I was in a similar situation. Something had to give. In many cases there is little that works. You do have to accept, muddle on and take the least worst option at the time. This is probably where Yvonne Newbold is coming from.

Tietheapron · 28/03/2023 13:29

She’s answered that very clearly …

OriginalUsername2 · 28/03/2023 13:28

Autienotnautie · 28/03/2023 05:40

Let me guess . Training to be a counsellor? It's not the op's job to plan a support system for disabled children in the uk. Op has asked for help. There is no help.

Huge leap there!?

It was a genuine question. What does she want that she’s not getting?

drspouse · 28/03/2023 13:14

Millie2008 · 28/03/2023 00:03

Have you read "the explosive child" by Dr Ross Greene? I'm starting to use the approach and am feeling really hopeful...

I have been looking at this method for a while - I wouldn't say I followed it faithfully. However I see the same problems as with the Yvonne Newbold approach, with children allowed to spend all day all weekend in bed with no clothes on, gaming, because the parents don't want to put demands on them.
We have used the questioning approach reasonably successfully to help DS to tell us what exactly is the problem with something he can talk calmly about (e.g. to do swimming 1:1 he asked if we could be there too, and we started off being on the side of the pool and gradually withdrew).
I also know that research isn't on the side of this approach (the low demand approach) - for ADHD, doing everything for your child long term doesn't help (it's called parental accommodation) and on a personal level, I just can't cope with doing everything DS would like us to do for him.

To take just a small example, he's asked for a hot water bottle as has DD for most nights recently. DD quickly moved to filling her own but DS was insisting forcefully that he couldn't do it. When I said I would show him how he got cross (and this is one of Dr Greene's "can't do it not won't" indicators that you are supposed to listen to) but now a couple of weeks on after some coaching he's doing his own. He also recently decided he wants us to dress him but after a couple of rounds of "we'll get out quicker if we do" we decided he'd been having us for a pair of mugs, he got very cross but we just walked off and he now occasionally says "I'm not going to school, you'll have to dress me" but has given up on thinking we will.

OP posts:
Autienotnautie · 28/03/2023 05:40

OriginalUsername2 · 27/03/2023 12:26

What would support actually look like to you?

Let me guess . Training to be a counsellor? It's not the op's job to plan a support system for disabled children in the uk. Op has asked for help. There is no help.

McGonagallshatandglasses · 28/03/2023 04:15

I hear you say that you could bluff your way to an ASD diagnosis, but don't think it's a factor.

But if they won't properly support him with only the adhd diagnosis and he doesn't have either a diagnosis of an attachment disorder or ptsd that might be what you need to do.

Adhd when not compounded by other issues does not look like the situation you are describing.

I've been near breaking point too, and my children aren't adopted. They are mine. And I attachment-parented. And still we've needed help.

I would definitely tell any authorities that the adoption is at risk of breaking down without help. Your need for regular respite so you can spend time with your younger child is palpable.

RobertaFirmino · 28/03/2023 01:00

What if you called their bluff? Rang SS and told them you can't cope anymore and you need to relinquish DS? Something tells me that the support you need would magically appear. I don't mean this disrespectfully btw, it just seems obvious that once DC are placed with adoptive parents or kinship carers, SS basically wash their hands of any further support, esp. for caregivers.

Millie2008 · 28/03/2023 00:03

Have you read "the explosive child" by Dr Ross Greene? I'm starting to use the approach and am feeling really hopeful...

drspouse · 27/03/2023 22:59

I got him a nice natural deodorant stick because he wouldn't have stood for a smelly one and he already likes stick sun cream etc. and now I think he's going to use the whole thing up (and it's ££) in the first week!

OP posts:
BlackeyedSusan · 27/03/2023 22:48

Bless him. You are doing well with hair cuts! Bribery is quite useful. We are currently at the Lynx phase. A lot better than the post football musty whiff...known by parents of teenage boys everywhere

Consequences don't work that well for autism either, sometimes. (Does for one, not the other) Mine could earn back whatever was lost, otherwise there was no point being good and the rampage would continue or the absolute devastation at having made a mistake would continue. (Both autistic)

Quite a lot of overlap between the two conditions.

9 was the worst age here. Things have improved since.

drspouse · 27/03/2023 22:11

Oh and @BlackeyedSusan I just bought him some deodorant... Yep he's 11.

OP posts:
Spendonsend · 27/03/2023 21:58

My DH went with the total nervous breakdown option. I wouldnt say he was calm in a zen wat but so depressed he stopped reacting to anything at all.

I am sorry to hear things are still tough. I wish I had solutions but I can only agree that there isnt much support/any and services send you in circles or just to websites of generic advice.