Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I do not understand snacks

392 replies

Yellowdaffodila · 27/03/2023 10:52

So I'm not from the UK and I hear and read about the snack thing all the time.
What is a snack? When I take my children out I'm asked to bring snacks. They will be home for food after our trip. They eat breakfast. Why a snack?

OP posts:
mewkins · 27/03/2023 11:55

ChickenDhansak82 · 27/03/2023 11:22

Snacks are things for toddlers who have little stomachs so need to eat little and often.

BUT... snacks are something parents keep giving to their kids as even though most kids 5+ can just eat 3 meals a day, parents can't deal with the tantrums so just hand snacks out to keep kids quiet! They then wonder why they don't eat so much at meals!

I have a friend who is always feeding her 7 year old snacks. All bloody day. When we go out, my 7 year old doesn't have or need snacks. My friend tells me that her daughter doesn't eat much at meals so NEEDS snacks...

So when I had my friend's daughter for an entire day, she gets no morning snack (she asked, I said no), and then unsurprisingly she ate all her lunch. She ate so much at lunch she then didn't even ask for an afternoon snack, then happily tucked into a huge tea.

I stopped snacks with mine age 5 and they eat so much better at meal times.

I think some parents just can't deal with a hungry child, except being a bit hungry is normal and ok!

I'm not sure that this is better is it? Obviously it is if the snacks are chocolate bars but I've never liked massive portions. Little and often us a perfectly valid diet.

Viviennemary · 27/03/2023 11:55

I presume you know what a sback is even if you don't eat between meals. Any smsll amount of food eaten between meals can be a snack.

AllTheDifference · 27/03/2023 11:55

It’s concerning how many people don’t ‘get’ or ‘understand’ snacking.

It really isn’t that complicated a concept. If you really really try to imagine a world where everyone is different, you might just comprehend the role of snacks in someone’s life.

BillyNoM8s · 27/03/2023 11:54

Yellowdaffodila · 27/03/2023 11:48

To people saying the snacks of Sri Lanka they are we call tourist snacks.
As a country we are poorer so those snacks for you would be meals for locals if meat based.

Maybe it is a money thing as well.

I think you're being absurd to assert that the snacks on sale in Sri Lanka are for tourists only...

ProbablyNotAGoodIdea · 27/03/2023 11:54

vivainsomnia · 27/03/2023 11:50

The problem with snacks is control. Healthy snacks are fine. The occasional non healthy one is fine too.

The main issue with kids who are used to snacks 2 to 3 times a day is when they get their own money and allowed out alone. They believe that snacks are ok if hungry and will think nothing of buying crisps, biscuits, bars etc...from the corner shop or eating a whole pack of biscuits coming home from school rather than the 2 or 3 they were allowed before.

Threads about teenagers eating all the snacks in the first few days of shopping are frequent enough.

Obesity is a massive issue and now it's affecting a forever increasing number of teenagers and kids. Snacks are a significant if not the main contribution of the problem.

And then there are kids who were never allowed snacks who when they get hold of their own money, go crazy for snacking and have no concept of what might constitute a healthy snack so eat a whole packet of biscuits because they never got taught to stop at one or two... You see how the best laid plans can backfire? Some kids will learn moderation and some won't, whatever their parents instilled from an early age. Parenting is complex, children are individuals and the same strategy won't work for all.

Emmamoo89 · 27/03/2023 11:53

BrightYellowDaffodil · 27/03/2023 11:40

Nah, just annoyance at those who seem to struggle with basic reading comprehension Smile

Nah I think you need a snack.

I'm hangry myself and not well.
What's your excuse?

workistoomuch · 27/03/2023 11:53

Whats wrong with snacking? I'm known for my snacking amongst friends and colleagues 🤣. I get so grumpy and even sometimes have out of body experiences if I go for too long without eating. I've got a bmi of 19, am active but don't ' exercise' and don't have to think about what I eat. I do tend to have small meals and hate feeling that stretched full feeling.

DataColour · 27/03/2023 11:52

I grew up in Sri Lanka and there is very much a snack culture! There are most certainly not "tourist" snacks and I've not known anyone to eat them as a meal substitute! Sri Lankans are feeders and I was always offered snacks between meals.
What are "short eats" for? All those yummy pastry type things, sweet things, fruit with chilli and salt, too many to mention.
Perhaps your family culture is different.

Also, we are all slim in our family and we all snack.

escapingthecity · 27/03/2023 11:52

We eat breakfast at 7 and lunch isn't until 12. Tbh I need a snack with 5 hours between meals! Small tummies can't hold enough food to give them the energy they need for that long. My kids (4 and 1) are grumpy nightmares when they're hungry so I head that off by giving them things like crunchy red pepper, apples, rice cakes.

MadameOvary81 · 27/03/2023 11:51

There's a huge difference in snacking because you have to (blood sugars, after excessive exercise etc) and then mindless grazing for no other reason than boredom.

But really, who cares. We are all different. Some of us snack, some of us don't, some of us love three huge meals a day, some of us skip breakfast, some of us get up at midnight to raid the fridge. Just enjoy your life. It's bloody short.

SoftSheen · 27/03/2023 11:51

Not all children eat much breakfast or like big meals generally. Some children have an early breakfast before school and it's a long wait until lunch. Some children play lots of sports or have a long walk until school. Hence, they appreciate a piece or fruit or cereal bar mid-morning to tide them over. (Mine don't usually have a morning snack but always have something after school, and they definitely need it. Both slim).

vivainsomnia · 27/03/2023 11:50

The problem with snacks is control. Healthy snacks are fine. The occasional non healthy one is fine too.

The main issue with kids who are used to snacks 2 to 3 times a day is when they get their own money and allowed out alone. They believe that snacks are ok if hungry and will think nothing of buying crisps, biscuits, bars etc...from the corner shop or eating a whole pack of biscuits coming home from school rather than the 2 or 3 they were allowed before.

Threads about teenagers eating all the snacks in the first few days of shopping are frequent enough.

Obesity is a massive issue and now it's affecting a forever increasing number of teenagers and kids. Snacks are a significant if not the main contribution of the problem.

Lolloped · 27/03/2023 11:49

If an event says bring snacks usually it means there will be a break and the kids will be expected to have their own food and drink for this. If your kids don’t really eat between meals then send them with a tiny snack so they don’t feel left out but won’t spoil their meal. Bread sticks, fruit, cheese string, carrot sticks, sausage roll, rice cakes. I wouldn’t not send something as it’s just as much a social thing and I wouldn’t want my kids sitting round (or causing chaos) while everyone else eats.

TheOrigRights · 27/03/2023 11:49

I'm a snacker, or more accurately a grazer.
My Mum told me that she had to make sure I ate often otherwise I'd get very grumpy.
I am very slim.

Dammitthisisshit · 27/03/2023 11:48

I love Sri Lankan food and really want some now. For lunch, for a snack, I really don’t mind.

OP one of my DC turns into the devil child when hungry. It happens rapidly, especially after exercise. Feeding her before she becomes too angry makes the world a safer place. She’s not overweight and we generally give healthy stuff as a snack.

The other one doesn’t turn devil in the same way but is much happier between the tiny school lunch and teatime if she gets something.

Yellowdaffodila · 27/03/2023 11:48

To people saying the snacks of Sri Lanka they are we call tourist snacks.
As a country we are poorer so those snacks for you would be meals for locals if meat based.

Maybe it is a money thing as well.

OP posts:
mamnotmum · 27/03/2023 11:47

Also don't get it. We don't do snacks in our house.

Kids have breakfast. Lunch. Dinner. And if they want supper. I feel like I'm
Constantly feeding them - defo don't need to add any more feeding times in!

Sistanotcista · 27/03/2023 11:47

nc13467 · 27/03/2023 11:20

It's scientifically proven that it's healthier to eat little and often rather than 3 huge meals

Exactly this. Also, my DD doesn't eat breakfast - we leave home early for school, and it's just too soon after waking up for her to be hungry. She carries rice cakes and carrot sticks or an apple in her bag and has a mid morning snack instead. A lot healthier than the sugar laden cereals her breakfast eating companions have already consumed too.

ProbablyNotAGoodIdea · 27/03/2023 11:46

My mum didn't understand snacks (obviously she did, but didn't approve of them!) so was very strict about not eating between meals. All very well intentioned, borne of love and concern. It worked great for my sister, instilling a sense of discipline and moderation around food and enjoyment of meals and delayed gratification. For me, it sparked secretive binge eating, self loathing and disordered attitudes to food that kept my weight yo-yoing from healthy to overweight to obese up and down for my whole life so far. Amazingly enough, a one-size-fits-all approach doesn't work

faffadoodledo · 27/03/2023 11:46

I think it's quite cultural. I remember living in the US, and snack time for pre schoolers was a thing. I carried snacks everywhere. When we moved back it definitely wasn't such a big thing. But that was 20 years ago, and we may well have converged somewhat!

ATerrorofLeftovers · 27/03/2023 11:46

vivainsomnia · 27/03/2023 11:10

Look OP, put simply, some people - and especially kids - need to eat more often than the typical 5ish hours between meals
No they don't. It's a habit brought from kids asking for them because they know they exist and parents reading this as a need rather than a want.

They are a major contributor to the obesity crisis.

It can be because parents are fully present with their child and attuned to their needs and moods. Those children who get tearful, grumpy, clumsy etc, and then perk right up after a snack? They had low blood sugar. The snack was needed to level it out and avoid an accident or a tantrum.

Some children get low blood sugar if there's too big a gap between meals and need a snack. They don't necessarily then eat the same sized meal as if they hadn't had the snack. Other kids can easily go without snacks, because their metabolism is a bit different. Because we're people, not robots, and not everyone's the same.

Not sure what evidence you have to prove a causal link between snacks and obesity. It depends very much on what you eat. A diet high in UPFs is likely to contribute to obesity. A few carrot sticks or an oatcake with hummus between meals? Not so much.

TheOrigRights · 27/03/2023 11:46

I found this on the web:

*What is the most popular snack in Sri Lanka?

Murukku is a crunchy snack popular in southern India, and Sri Lanka. Murukku's name derives from the Tamil word for "twisted” referring to its iconic spiral shape. Made from fried urad dal, you must try these crunchy, curry flavoured snacks.*

I haven't been to Sri Lanka, but have travelling around India and Nepal. On trains and busses and in cafes the people all around me would be eating peanuts, fruit, crisps, samosas.

The snacking culture seemed the same as it is in the UK.

Teder · 27/03/2023 11:44

It’s better for you to eat smaller meals/snacks throughout the day. I would feel sluggish and uncomfortable eating 3 meals a day and nothing in between. I prefer to eat less split into more meals.

HyggeTygge · 27/03/2023 11:44

The government give guidance on feeding your child when you have a baby.

There is a lot of emphasis in that on snacks when weaning. Usually stuff like fruit or a rice cake, bread sticks etc - presumably to increase the variety of food they are offered. For me this is where 'thinking about snacks' has come from.

My primary age kids get a snack on the way home from school, partly because it's a while until evening meal and I don't know how much lunch they have eaten. If they've had swimming they are starving and get grumpy.

BillyNoM8s · 27/03/2023 11:44

Yellowdaffodila · 27/03/2023 11:33

So to explain myself further I am from Sri Lanka. We do feed at school of course. Children get milk and then they eat together at the lunch stop.
They come home and after chores we eat with my husband at 7pm. My children do eat but maybe different. We eat a rice or oat breakfast but not crisp or sweets.
I hope that explains. We would not eat if not our meal.

Many children would chew their arm off if they had to go from school lunch to 7pm, unless they're particulalry well fed during the day.

Maybe your breakfasts and lunches are huge/filling.

It's usual to have fruit/yoghurt/cheese/raisins or something as a snack if waiting a long while til dinner.

If your kids are happy and healthy though, there's no issue.

It feels like you're making a subtle dig at how fat and greedy Brits are. I mean many are fat and greedy (and many aren't), but if that's what you want to say, then just say that.