Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to know why the numbers crossing in small boats has increased?

63 replies

Neededanewuserhandle · 27/03/2023 09:51

I have seen it argued that it's Brexit since we left the Dublin agreement that allowed us to return people to the EU. But we hardly ever used that - in fact the figures suggest we ended up with more people returned to us than we sent "back" to EU countries.

Of course it's hard to know the truth, but I find it hard to imagine that the people in the boats and the smuggling gangs have researched the provisions of the Dublin agreement.

The majority of boat arrivals are apparently from Albania - we have a formal agreement for returning them but it doesn't seem to be deterring people from coming.

AIBU to wish there was a way for ordinary people to get hold of the truth rather than partisan opinions from all sides dressed up as pretend facts?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
Angrycat2768 · 21/01/2024 09:43

Illegal migration has always been a dead cat argument to distract from far larger legal migration from outside the EU that the government always had control over but never wanted to do anything about. They know they have trashed technical education and training and have allowed businesses to import ready trained staff from abroad instead of investing in staff training and development for years. Not coincidentally because the profits their buddies can make would be impacted by them having to actually invest in training and development. Now we have stopped transient workers from the EU coming in to work in agriculture and sent back all the young people who were coming here from Europe to work mostly short term, we have a massive skills shortage and have to get people to come here from so far away they will not come unless they can bring their families. The government has no intention of doing anything about legal migration and no intention of spending the money wasted on Rwanda on speeding up the asylum system, and stopping criminal gangs using people as slaves in the UK. Because its easier to pander to Daily Mail and Telegraph readers by blaming other people for their own incompetence and lack of ideas. The people on small boats come here partly because the criminal gangs know that they can just make these people disappear into the Black economy, working on Cannabis farms, money laundering and prostitution and they are likely to get away with it. People who are trafficked do not suddenly find thousands of ££ they have to pay it back by working illegally for criminal gangs. Asylum seekers should be allowed or even compelled to work in shortage occupations. They aren't taking other peoples jobs, because the people who are from here aren't doing them. Keeping them in legal work hopefully keeps track of them and out of the clutches of the criminals who brought them here. That in itself would make trafficking less likely.

cakeorwine · 21/01/2024 09:36

Savedpassword · 21/01/2024 09:32

Why are Albanians risking their lives in small boats? What kind of war and persecution are young Albanian men fleeing from?

Numbers from Albania are massively down.
So not really relevant anymore.

Savedpassword · 21/01/2024 09:32

Why are Albanians risking their lives in small boats? What kind of war and persecution are young Albanian men fleeing from?

cakeorwine · 21/01/2024 09:31

There may well be an increase in asylum seekers who are working because the backlog has been massive and many people have been on the waiting list for over 12 months.

So to summarise:

1)People have a right to work if they have been on the list waiting for their case to be heard.

  1. This is not a new right. It has been around for ages.

  2. They are only allowed to work in occupations on the shortage list.

Did you know that @AliceA2021

cakeorwine · 21/01/2024 09:27

So when you say "Given the right to work", when do you think they were given this right?

And how does this link to the statement here:

"As a general rule, asylum seekers are not allowed to work in the UK. Some people think work should be allowed, at least after a period of (for example) six months waiting for a decision on an asylum claim."

Has this changed?

cakeorwine · 21/01/2024 09:25

AliceA2021 · 21/01/2024 09:17

@cakeorwine

This story about the hone office agreeibg the right to work was published this week.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/01/19/channel-migrants-given-right-to-work/

So you haven't answered the questions.

This is from 2022

Asylum seekers: the permission to work policy - House of Commons Library (parliament.uk)

People who have claimed asylum in the UK can apply for permission to work if they have been waiting 12 months for a decision, and they are not considered responsible for the delay.
If permission is granted, the person will be allowed to take up jobs on the shortage occupation list only. This mostly restricts them to highly skilled jobs that require formal qualifications (although social care work is now on the list). The courts have emphasised that there is, in principle, discretion to allow other types of work.
The Home Office is unable to provide data on the number of asylum seekers granted permission to work.

Can you tell me if that information has changed?

Oliotya · 21/01/2024 09:23

AliceA2021 · 21/01/2024 09:17

@cakeorwine

This story about the hone office agreeibg the right to work was published this week.

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/01/19/channel-migrants-given-right-to-work/

So why are you pointing fingers at people coming over in treacherous conditions and filling these roles, rather than at the government that has allowed these desperate staff shortages to occur? Why do you think Rishi is letting them work - because health and social care are totally and completely fucked otherwise.
Don't let this divisive xenophobic shit cloud over the real issues - 14 years of conservative rule. Say one thing, do another, hope nobody notices.

EasternStandard · 21/01/2024 08:35

Op it’s increasing generally. Look at trends across Med and Mexico to US

Policies will impact numbers but overall world events are increasing people movement and will continue with climate on top

cakeorwine · 21/01/2024 08:34

AliceA2021 · 21/01/2024 08:32

Thread police second point

Another reason is the news story I shared on my post is from the last few days so very relevant.

What can you tell us about when asylum seekers were given the right to work?
How long do they have to be waiting for their claim to be assessed before they can work?
What kind of work are they allowed to do?

AliceA2021 · 21/01/2024 08:32

BlindurErBóklausMaður · 21/01/2024 07:09

Any particular reason why a year old thread was bumped @AliceA2021 ?

Were the more recent ones not to your liking?

Thread police second point

Another reason is the news story I shared on my post is from the last few days so very relevant.

AliceA2021 · 21/01/2024 08:29

BlindurErBóklausMaður · 21/01/2024 07:09

Any particular reason why a year old thread was bumped @AliceA2021 ?

Were the more recent ones not to your liking?

It's relevant, was answered and I didn't see a more recent one. Is that OK thread police?

jasflowers · 21/01/2024 08:28

Neededanewuserhandle · 27/03/2023 09:51

I have seen it argued that it's Brexit since we left the Dublin agreement that allowed us to return people to the EU. But we hardly ever used that - in fact the figures suggest we ended up with more people returned to us than we sent "back" to EU countries.

Of course it's hard to know the truth, but I find it hard to imagine that the people in the boats and the smuggling gangs have researched the provisions of the Dublin agreement.

The majority of boat arrivals are apparently from Albania - we have a formal agreement for returning them but it doesn't seem to be deterring people from coming.

AIBU to wish there was a way for ordinary people to get hold of the truth rather than partisan opinions from all sides dressed up as pretend facts?

Well, if its nothing to do with Brexit, the timing of Brexit and vastly increased crossing is rather coincidental.

I think its a combination of factors, the biggest one being that since we left the EU, the French in particular have no real reason to stop them, we have no influence and we have left the real time agreements on Policing and criminal data sharing too, Brexit was always a Fuck Off to the EU after all.

Its funny too that Rwanda is supposed to be a deterrent (by sending just a few 100 there, out of 10s of 1000s) yet the Dublin agreement never was.....

X Ch migration is also a tool the Govt uses to beat Labour with, so in a way, higher numbers suits them.

Anyway, majority of people crossing channel are not from Albania, never was, max around 15 to 20%, far less now (Migration Observatory 2022) due to returns agreement.

cakeorwine · 21/01/2024 08:20

"Claiming asylum in a foreign safe country was never a 'game plan' yet as conflict encroaches and persecution persists, people find themselves with very few options."

If people have seen The Handmaid's Tale, at what point do you flee and how do you claim asylum?

I think we have been so so lucky not to have been invaded and to have lived under democracy. I don't think many people can really imagine the lives many people live in countries with civil war, repression etc.

I wonder if an ITV drama dramatising the lives of refugees fleeing countries today would have an effect. Or would it be dismissed as "woke" .

It is "them" and "us"

TheMotherSide · 21/01/2024 08:10

It'sGettingWeird "...we could set up ways for them to apply for asylum from their own Countries. At the moment they have to come here to apply. We could be processing applications before they arrive."
I've heard this suggestion before and I just can't wrap my head around how this is expected to work.
The asylum-seeking families I work with in my professional capacity are invariably fleeing persecution or are being displaced by war or other internal conflict, in many regions fuelled by a changing climate. The circumstances prior to leaving their country of origin were definitely not conducive to engaging with local services; often non-existent, corrupt or severely disrupted by conflict, in order to make remote applications for asylum. For many, the displacement has been gradual: they have had no intention to flee their homes despite advancing conflict or intensifying persecution, hoping it will somehow resolve or spare their family. When this has proven not to be the case, they have fled their homes to a neighbouring area in the hope it would be temporary, that conflict might blow over and they would be able to return home, and so becoming internally displaced in the process. Their situation worsens dramatically as they are already homeless and without resources before even leaving their country of origin. Claiming asylum in a foreign safe country was never a 'game plan' yet as conflict encroaches and persecution persists, people find themselves with very few options.

Menomeno · 21/01/2024 08:10

Oliotya · 20/01/2024 19:31

Of course those are problems, but they are not necessarily related to, or caused by specifically small boats migration. Its important not to conflate all migration with small boats migration.

Yes. I saw a statistic this week that of all migrants who have arrived in the UK in the past 12 months, only 6% arrived on a small boat. The vast majority are legal migrants.

cakeorwine · 21/01/2024 08:09

KinS24 · 21/01/2024 07:33

The OP is out of date. Numbers have dropped. Mainly because of the deal with Albanian government.
Would love to know how Civil Servants are ‘lining their pockets’ 😂.

  1. The increase is mainly because the ‘service’ was offered. The traffickers got organised and were able to exploit then create a demand for their services How else would a random young migrant from halfway across the world end up on a boat? The service is advertised widely across the world and there is a massive demand for it. Not just UK destinations of course.
  2. It’s entirely impractical to expect all destination countries to examine asylum claims for people abroad. For free? For everyone? There have been schemes to try and help specific groups in refugee camps but they can’t do much while the system is swamped with all the self selected people.

These people are coming from FRANCE.

Edited

Do you know how many refugees there are in the WORLD?

There have been an increase in wars, conflicts. Syria, Afghanistan.

Most people stay in countries next to the one they flee from.

The numbers coming here are a tiny tiny tiny fraction of the total.

Refugee Statistics | USA for UNHCR (unrefugees.org)

https://www.bing.com/ck/a?!&&p=c71574873be37e14JmltdHM9MTcwNTc5NTIwMCZpZ3VpZD0zZDNhMWEyZC1kNDBjLTZlOGEtMDZkNS0wOWE1ZDUzYzZmMDcmaW5zaWQ9NTc0OA&ptn=3&ver=2&hsh=3&fclid=3d3a1a2d-d40c-6e8a-06d5-09a5d53c6f07&psq=unhcr+statistics&u=a1aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cudW5yZWZ1Z2Vlcy5vcmcvcmVmdWdlZS1mYWN0cy9zdGF0aXN0aWNzLw&ntb=1

cakeorwine · 21/01/2024 08:05

AliceA2021 · 20/01/2024 18:58

Well since they are being given the right to stay here and work, why wouldn't they come? That what economic migrants want

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2024/01/19/channel-migrants-given-right-to-work/

They have had the right to work, if their case has not been resolved for a year, and only in shortage occupations for ages.

But I guess you forgot to mention that?

Kitanai · 21/01/2024 07:44

To be honest the boat crossings are a drop in the ocean compared to the real problem, which is unsustainable LEGAL migration.

I’m an immigrant, and even I can see that the amount of low skilled workers, students and all their dependants is far too high for UK infrastructure to keep up with.

It also seems like a bit of a stupid solution to the problem it is supposed to be a solution to, an aging population. Birth rates are going down because the standard of living is so much worse now for everyone, gp surgeries, hospitals, schools and housing cannot cope. I know the argument is that the high level of immigration is needed to fill jobs at these places…to cope with the demand high levels of immigration are causing. These people are all bringing dependents, and having on average more children, so are adding far more pressure to the system than they release.

And these people are all going to age to, so what do we do then?

Vettrianofan · 21/01/2024 07:41

I find Migration Watch UK website great for information on numbers crossing. It's updated regularly.

jgw1 · 21/01/2024 07:40

KinS24 · 21/01/2024 07:33

The OP is out of date. Numbers have dropped. Mainly because of the deal with Albanian government.
Would love to know how Civil Servants are ‘lining their pockets’ 😂.

  1. The increase is mainly because the ‘service’ was offered. The traffickers got organised and were able to exploit then create a demand for their services How else would a random young migrant from halfway across the world end up on a boat? The service is advertised widely across the world and there is a massive demand for it. Not just UK destinations of course.
  2. It’s entirely impractical to expect all destination countries to examine asylum claims for people abroad. For free? For everyone? There have been schemes to try and help specific groups in refugee camps but they can’t do much while the system is swamped with all the self selected people.

These people are coming from FRANCE.

Edited

@KinS24 I think most people are aware that those crossing the Channel start the crossing in France, it is after all the country that is nearest the UK across the Channel.

Are you aware that UK and international law (the latter at the insistence of the UK) is very clear that transit through a third country should have no impact on someone's claim for asylum?

jgw1 · 21/01/2024 07:38

heartofglass23 · 21/01/2024 05:59

What's the point in us having an army if they can't stand along our coast and defend our borders?

We should be bringing asylum seeking women & children directly from war torn areas and refusing to let these gangs of young men land.

@heartofglass23 would you be so kind as to show us where in UK and International law it says that young men do not have the same rights to apply for asylum as any other group?

Thanks.

KinS24 · 21/01/2024 07:33

The OP is out of date. Numbers have dropped. Mainly because of the deal with Albanian government.
Would love to know how Civil Servants are ‘lining their pockets’ 😂.

  1. The increase is mainly because the ‘service’ was offered. The traffickers got organised and were able to exploit then create a demand for their services How else would a random young migrant from halfway across the world end up on a boat? The service is advertised widely across the world and there is a massive demand for it. Not just UK destinations of course.
  2. It’s entirely impractical to expect all destination countries to examine asylum claims for people abroad. For free? For everyone? There have been schemes to try and help specific groups in refugee camps but they can’t do much while the system is swamped with all the self selected people.

These people are coming from FRANCE.

jgw1 · 21/01/2024 07:18

heartofglass23 · 21/01/2024 05:59

What's the point in us having an army if they can't stand along our coast and defend our borders?

We should be bringing asylum seeking women & children directly from war torn areas and refusing to let these gangs of young men land.

You'd best let the government know that there are gangs of young men trying to land, last time I checked the government's figures showed that somewhere about 75% of asylum seekers were being given leave to remain in the UK on first deicision, a proportion that will rise on appeal.

BlindurErBóklausMaður · 21/01/2024 07:09

Any particular reason why a year old thread was bumped @AliceA2021 ?

Were the more recent ones not to your liking?