Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want to know why the numbers crossing in small boats has increased?

63 replies

Neededanewuserhandle · 27/03/2023 09:51

I have seen it argued that it's Brexit since we left the Dublin agreement that allowed us to return people to the EU. But we hardly ever used that - in fact the figures suggest we ended up with more people returned to us than we sent "back" to EU countries.

Of course it's hard to know the truth, but I find it hard to imagine that the people in the boats and the smuggling gangs have researched the provisions of the Dublin agreement.

The majority of boat arrivals are apparently from Albania - we have a formal agreement for returning them but it doesn't seem to be deterring people from coming.

AIBU to wish there was a way for ordinary people to get hold of the truth rather than partisan opinions from all sides dressed up as pretend facts?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
5
TheMotherSide · 21/01/2024 14:07

"It's always interesting to see what's left out of a story..." Absolutely, Cake.

jasflowers · 21/01/2024 13:13

People who have left war zones, travelled through ME or Africa, risked death crossing the Mediterranean, come up through Europe and then crossed the channel are not going to be deterred by the 1 or 2% chance that they will be sent to Rwanda (if they ever will be)

Where the UK houses migrants and the length of time they are held waiting for a decision is pretty dire, yet that doesn't seem to deter.

Plus Rwanda has some pretty serious issues of its own with refugees fleeing from CAR, over 130k in camps.

HardcoreLadyType · 21/01/2024 12:39

cakeorwine · 21/01/2024 08:20

"Claiming asylum in a foreign safe country was never a 'game plan' yet as conflict encroaches and persecution persists, people find themselves with very few options."

If people have seen The Handmaid's Tale, at what point do you flee and how do you claim asylum?

I think we have been so so lucky not to have been invaded and to have lived under democracy. I don't think many people can really imagine the lives many people live in countries with civil war, repression etc.

I wonder if an ITV drama dramatising the lives of refugees fleeing countries today would have an effect. Or would it be dismissed as "woke" .

It is "them" and "us"

See also Prophet Song, this year’s Booker Prize winner.

jgw1 · 21/01/2024 11:52

EasternStandard · 21/01/2024 11:45

I think people are missing what’s going on elsewhere, it’s not just here

Look at news today from Germany and protests

I thought this would surface about a year or so ago and it will continue to increase

@EasternStandard the question is what the UK government and others could do to ensure that people did not become migrants, do you have any thoughts on that?

jgw1 · 21/01/2024 11:50

lollipoprainbow · 21/01/2024 11:43

Don't be too concerned about housing lists. There are over a million empty homes in the UK, that if the government wanted to could house a lot of people.

Not this crap again.

You have something against facts?

EasternStandard · 21/01/2024 11:45

I think people are missing what’s going on elsewhere, it’s not just here

Look at news today from Germany and protests

I thought this would surface about a year or so ago and it will continue to increase

lollipoprainbow · 21/01/2024 11:43

Don't be too concerned about housing lists. There are over a million empty homes in the UK, that if the government wanted to could house a lot of people.

Not this crap again.

cakeorwine · 21/01/2024 11:25

jgw1 · 21/01/2024 11:22

Surely asylum seekers working is some kind of strange deadcat story, since Sunak has announced that he has cleared the backlog and so there aren't any who have been waiting for a decision for 12 months and so elligible to work?

It's always interesting to see what's left out of a story and the facts that are left out to generate a reaction.

I don't think many people know the true scale of refugees around the world.

jgw1 · 21/01/2024 11:22

cakeorwine · 21/01/2024 11:11

"Channel migrants have been quietly given the right to work in sectors including care, construction and agriculture and can still retain access to state-subsidised bed and board under a Home Office scheme."

You do know that :

  1. They were given this access a long time ago.
  2. It is for people who have been waiting for over 12 months.
  3. It is for shortage sectors

So maybe they should clear the backlog and then either grant or refuse asylum. And if it's refused, people should be sent back.

Surely asylum seekers working is some kind of strange deadcat story, since Sunak has announced that he has cleared the backlog and so there aren't any who have been waiting for a decision for 12 months and so elligible to work?

jgw1 · 21/01/2024 11:19

EasternStandard · 21/01/2024 10:49

If you want numbers to fall deterrent is pretty much it - if people can think of another then fine

If not numbers will keep going up. Also fine if people want that

Not saying either way has to be wanted, but the basic issue is easier - higher numbers, harder / deterrent - fewer

@EasternStandard couldn't one consider what was causing people to migrate and look at policies that reduced the need for them to?

jgw1 · 21/01/2024 11:16

PTSDBarbiegirl · 21/01/2024 09:54

Disagree that it's not a problem. People dying on these trips in overcrowded tiny boats is a problem. I'm concerned about conditions here in UK. Housing lists, benefits clamp down, poverty, crime, drug abuse, homelessness, mental health crisis and drug crime is at epidemic levels in UK cities. I wonder why anyone thinks this country can accommodate any migrant who cannot fund their own migration without relying on the state. A pp mentioned annual migration filling Old Trafford, as if that's managable!!!! Where do these people go? Who funds their housing, health care, food bills, schooling? It's just not practical. When you see the poverty already here it doesn't inspire encouraging more. Let's get an international operation to monitor who buys, sells these boats, who arranges initial transport from countries like Albania.

Don't be too concerned about housing lists. There are over a million empty homes in the UK, that if the government wanted to could house a lot of people.

jgw1 · 21/01/2024 11:14

EasternStandard · 21/01/2024 08:35

Op it’s increasing generally. Look at trends across Med and Mexico to US

Policies will impact numbers but overall world events are increasing people movement and will continue with climate on top

@EasternStandard are there any policies that the UK could adopt and encourage other countries to adopt that might reduce the number of people forced to migrate?

cakeorwine · 21/01/2024 11:11

"Channel migrants have been quietly given the right to work in sectors including care, construction and agriculture and can still retain access to state-subsidised bed and board under a Home Office scheme."

You do know that :

  1. They were given this access a long time ago.
  2. It is for people who have been waiting for over 12 months.
  3. It is for shortage sectors

So maybe they should clear the backlog and then either grant or refuse asylum. And if it's refused, people should be sent back.

Home Office earmarks £1.1bn to manage arrival of Channel migrants

Official documents reveal Government anticipates that small boats will continue to arrive up to 2034

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/12/11/home-office-1bn-manage-arrival-channel-migrants/

EasternStandard · 21/01/2024 10:49

AliceA2021 · 21/01/2024 10:45

No point in Rwanda, government should attempt to get some of the wasted money back

If you want numbers to fall deterrent is pretty much it - if people can think of another then fine

If not numbers will keep going up. Also fine if people want that

Not saying either way has to be wanted, but the basic issue is easier - higher numbers, harder / deterrent - fewer

AliceA2021 · 21/01/2024 10:45

No point in Rwanda, government should attempt to get some of the wasted money back

Oliotya · 21/01/2024 10:44

PTSDBarbiegirl · 21/01/2024 10:34

Oliotya, I don't 'expect people not come because there is poverty here' but I do believe that people who cannot support themselves should not be encouraged to come here at the moment as it's not practical re issues I mentioned. The areas people are housed into are rife with social problems as it is, adding to it is not practical or responsible. Perhaps governments can work more efficiently on foreign policy to encourage and sanction countries who abuse human rights to stop, thus making the environments safer and healthier for people in it.

Well yes, but they aren't are they? Worry more about why that is, than the relatively insignificant number of small boats refugees.

AliceA2021 · 21/01/2024 10:44

My point was this news encourages people to make the journey. This story was published 19th January 2024

"Channel migrants have been quietly given the right to work in sectors including care, construction and agriculture and can still retain access to state-subsidised bed and board under a Home Office scheme.
Nearly 16,000 asylum seekers, including those who crossed the Channel in small boats, have been allowed to work in a single year, according to data obtained under Freedom of Information (FOI) laws.
They have been allowed to work in occupations in which there are recognised staff shortages, and are paid 80 per cent of the going pay rate.
The migrants forgo their £49.13 a week state subsistence allowance if they earn more than that, but can negotiate with the Home Office to remain in asylum accommodation as long as they pay a contribution towards the cost.
On Friday night, Nigel Farage, the former Ukip leader, and Tory MPs critcised the scheme, warning that it could act as a “pull factor” to encourage migrants to come to the UK illegally.
Mr Farage told The Telegraph: “This is a disaster. Once the traffickers can advertise jobs and free board, even more will want to come. Rwanda is completely irrelevant in comparison to this.”

Scrap rules allowing foreign workers to be hired for 20pc less, No 10 urged

Migration Advisory Committee calls for the abolition of the rules to encourage companies to recruit British staff

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/10/03/employers-recruiting-foreign-workers-below-market-rate/

EasternStandard · 21/01/2024 10:41

Although this is an old thread, just realised

EasternStandard · 21/01/2024 10:38

Neededanewuserhandle · 27/03/2023 09:51

I have seen it argued that it's Brexit since we left the Dublin agreement that allowed us to return people to the EU. But we hardly ever used that - in fact the figures suggest we ended up with more people returned to us than we sent "back" to EU countries.

Of course it's hard to know the truth, but I find it hard to imagine that the people in the boats and the smuggling gangs have researched the provisions of the Dublin agreement.

The majority of boat arrivals are apparently from Albania - we have a formal agreement for returning them but it doesn't seem to be deterring people from coming.

AIBU to wish there was a way for ordinary people to get hold of the truth rather than partisan opinions from all sides dressed up as pretend facts?

Just from your op the Albania numbers are down hugely because people get sent back and traffickers won’t bother to sell the U.K. as an option anymore

It’s the most effective and then a sliding scale to how easy it is. The easier it is for traffickers the higher numbers, at about £100k per boat it’s big business.

You can stop traffickers completely but Albania is possible as its status is different.

PTSDBarbiegirl · 21/01/2024 10:34

Oliotya, I don't 'expect people not come because there is poverty here' but I do believe that people who cannot support themselves should not be encouraged to come here at the moment as it's not practical re issues I mentioned. The areas people are housed into are rife with social problems as it is, adding to it is not practical or responsible. Perhaps governments can work more efficiently on foreign policy to encourage and sanction countries who abuse human rights to stop, thus making the environments safer and healthier for people in it.

Oliotya · 21/01/2024 10:27

PTSDBarbiegirl · 21/01/2024 09:54

Disagree that it's not a problem. People dying on these trips in overcrowded tiny boats is a problem. I'm concerned about conditions here in UK. Housing lists, benefits clamp down, poverty, crime, drug abuse, homelessness, mental health crisis and drug crime is at epidemic levels in UK cities. I wonder why anyone thinks this country can accommodate any migrant who cannot fund their own migration without relying on the state. A pp mentioned annual migration filling Old Trafford, as if that's managable!!!! Where do these people go? Who funds their housing, health care, food bills, schooling? It's just not practical. When you see the poverty already here it doesn't inspire encouraging more. Let's get an international operation to monitor who buys, sells these boats, who arranges initial transport from countries like Albania.

When I said it's not a problem, I meant its not a problem the government is motivated to solve. TBH I thought that would obvious.
"Housing lists, benefits clamp down, poverty, crime, drug abuse, homelessness, mental health crisis and drug crime is at epidemic levels in UK cities", absolutely none of which small boats migration is responsible for.
I do agree that more needs to done to prevent human trafficking, but expecting people not to come because there is poverty here isn't the solution, because relatively speaking, there absolutely isn't poverty here. Rather than pointing fingers at refugees, you should be asking why the government isn't doing about it.

jasflowers · 21/01/2024 10:09

PTSDBarbiegirl · 21/01/2024 09:54

Disagree that it's not a problem. People dying on these trips in overcrowded tiny boats is a problem. I'm concerned about conditions here in UK. Housing lists, benefits clamp down, poverty, crime, drug abuse, homelessness, mental health crisis and drug crime is at epidemic levels in UK cities. I wonder why anyone thinks this country can accommodate any migrant who cannot fund their own migration without relying on the state. A pp mentioned annual migration filling Old Trafford, as if that's managable!!!! Where do these people go? Who funds their housing, health care, food bills, schooling? It's just not practical. When you see the poverty already here it doesn't inspire encouraging more. Let's get an international operation to monitor who buys, sells these boats, who arranges initial transport from countries like Albania.

Agree on more police cooperation but who killed that stone dead? I find it incredible that no one (appears) to look at who is importing these boats & engines into Europe, where are they being sold and to whom?

As for the rest of your post, the amounts spent on x ch migrants is peanuts in terms of addressing Housing, crime, homelessness, NHS, Social care etc etc.

Easy thing to blame migrants for our woes instead of 14 years of Austerity plus the 750k legal migrants coming here are putting real strains on the UKs crumbling infrastructure.

cakeorwine · 21/01/2024 10:02

"Where do these people go?"

Most stay in neighbouring countries.

The Islamic Republic of Iran and Türkiye each hosted 3.4 million refugees, the largest populations worldwide.
Germany was third with 2.5 million, followed by Colombia with slightly less than 2.5 million, including other people in need of international protection.
Pakistan hosted 2.1 million refugees.
Islamic Republic of Iran 3.4 million
Türkiye 3.4 million
Germany 2.5 million
Colombia 2.5 million
Pakistan 2.1 million

So where should "they" go when they are fleeing war and repression?

Where would you go?

PTSDBarbiegirl · 21/01/2024 09:54

Oliotya · 20/01/2024 19:11

Because the reasons that people come over on small boats are complex, and haven't changed just because legislation has.I don't know what kind of "truth" you're looking for beyond the statistics. Small boat arrivals are relatively very few, and our economy is currently reliant on migration. Essentially, it's not really a problem, so they don't need to solve it.

Disagree that it's not a problem. People dying on these trips in overcrowded tiny boats is a problem. I'm concerned about conditions here in UK. Housing lists, benefits clamp down, poverty, crime, drug abuse, homelessness, mental health crisis and drug crime is at epidemic levels in UK cities. I wonder why anyone thinks this country can accommodate any migrant who cannot fund their own migration without relying on the state. A pp mentioned annual migration filling Old Trafford, as if that's managable!!!! Where do these people go? Who funds their housing, health care, food bills, schooling? It's just not practical. When you see the poverty already here it doesn't inspire encouraging more. Let's get an international operation to monitor who buys, sells these boats, who arranges initial transport from countries like Albania.