Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If your DC failed their GCSEs what are they doing now?

139 replies

Amber53 · 27/03/2023 09:38

Posting here for traffic.

I’ve been scouring past MN threads about this subject and often wonder what the future held for the DC who didn’t do well.

Reason being, DS who has struggled with MH, suicidal ideation, diagnosed ADHD and in the ASD pathway, bullied, will most likely leave school without any GCSEs. He’s had an horrendous time throughout really.

My main objective is to work with him and help with his MH. Bottom line is, when he’s away from the school environment he’s a different person, so he’s currently doing online lessons. When in school his MH declines, so we’re thankful he only has weeks left.

I can’t help but worry about the future though without GCSEs. I keep this hidden from him of course, but as a parent it’s only natural to worry about these things.

Can I ask anyone who has been through similar how your DC are doing now? How did they navigate the next step?

As DC now have to continue their education, I just don’t know what we should be encouraging next. DS doesn’t really know what he wants to do. He said he’d just like to work, earn money. I think the reality might be easier said than done, although I understand this viewpoint as he’s had such a negative experience so far. Why would he want to go onto somewhere he thinks will be just the same I.e college, 6th form etc.

We are currently trying to apply for an EHCP, although it’s going to be a long battle judging by the many things I’ve read. Too late to help with the current secondary school situation but might help for the future?

If anyone could share their experiences or offer any help it would be much appreciated.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
VerityUnreasonble · 29/10/2023 18:14

I know this is an older thread with a nice update but to add a positive story...

I didn't sit my GCSEs at all, didn't get a single one, due to a number of things including MH.

I went back to college later, did an access course, went to uni - hated it! Got a job - who then paid for me to go back to uni, which I finished with a 1st.

At 16 or even 18 I was a mess. By 30 I was happily married, with 2 children and doing well in my career. My GCSEs absolutely did not define me.

Similarly my DD, did well at GCSE but found college really hard and didn't do well at all. She ended up taking a year out then doing a foundation year at uni and went on to get a 1st and a job she loves and is brilliant at.

KTC40 · 29/10/2023 17:59

I'm glad I found this thread, both my DDs have ASD (the eldest has an EHCP), the youngest has ADHD too, they are still young but I worry about their futures.

Thanks for sharing your stories Smile

Luckydog7 · 16/10/2023 08:45

My brother did terribly at gcse because if bullying, asd and awful dyslexia. Something switched in him at 18 and he blagged his way into a technical theatre degree in the strength of his design tech work and experience working behind the scenes at school plays.

He now travels internationally as a professional lighting tech working for big names in the music industry, can rewire any plug in the world and out earns the rest of the extended family in our professional middle class jobs.

Icepop79 · 16/10/2023 08:29

What a lovely update! Really glad he’s doing so well now.

TeenDivided · 16/10/2023 08:14

Fab update. Smile

Amber53 · 16/10/2023 08:11

I’m so pleased that this post is still running and helping others.

DS was totally let down by the school system.

DS ended up sitting just three GCSES. Maths, English Language and Science.

Despite having hardly any education (except online learning - self lead) he managed to pass his maths with a grade 4. Unfortunately he failed both science and English, science he would have passed last year but the grade boundaries shot up this year. He will resit his English.

He’s now attending college and is absolutely LOVING it! The course he’s taking has likeminded individuals and the course leaders treat them like adults. Totally different environment than the regimented school system. DS loves it so much that he wishes he was there five days a week rather than the three he’s currently there for. What a complete turnaround!

He’s made new friends, he’s been on days out with them and is loving college life currently.

As ever, I’m absolutely over the moon but still waiting for the ‘dip’. Not in a negative way but with the huge highs often follows a low, although I’m hoping that it won’t be a low, rather a settled existence, if that makes sense. DS’s ADHD means that the rush of the ‘new’ meeting new people etc, makes him thrive, it’s like he can reinvent himself and not be the ‘weirdo’ that some past lovely students painted him as.

Time will tell but currently we’re remaining optimistic for his future, although I won’t lie, I’ve been sad at his missed education and what he could have achieved with his GCSES, his potential wasn’t reached during school, hopefully College will help him to succeed where school couldn’t.

Thanks to each and every one of you for your supportive posts, and for those seeking support, I really hope this thread goes a little way in helping, to know that at least you’re not alone. 💐

OP posts:
Eddyraisins · 15/10/2023 10:20

middler · 15/10/2023 06:32

What a lovely helpful thread. As a teacher I have seen many students who are wonderful young people but they struggle with the system to be successful and it is great to hear about them succeeding by other routes. School is very much a one size fits all and being academic is not the be all and end all. I admire the training and expertise of my plumber and contractor as much as my dentist frankly. It's awful that the students who struggle often feel like failures until they can find a setting where they can succeed. Everyone being encouraged to go to college is a big mistake I think.

I agree what a lovely post.

middler · 15/10/2023 06:32

What a lovely helpful thread. As a teacher I have seen many students who are wonderful young people but they struggle with the system to be successful and it is great to hear about them succeeding by other routes. School is very much a one size fits all and being academic is not the be all and end all. I admire the training and expertise of my plumber and contractor as much as my dentist frankly. It's awful that the students who struggle often feel like failures until they can find a setting where they can succeed. Everyone being encouraged to go to college is a big mistake I think.

ElleCapitaine · 15/10/2023 04:19

I know this is an old thread but it’s striking how many people are saying their child has ADHD/ASD. I’m wondering if this is widespread and if our education system is not giving those young people the support then need.

Itsbritneybitch22 · 15/10/2023 03:27

Mines in 2nd year of college doing GCSEs alongside his level 3 course.

They all get there in the end and the colleges will accept them

Boomboom22 · 14/10/2023 22:59

I really wouldn't shy away from important conversations, the I'd never tell him statements concern me.
Why wouldn't you tell him you worry he would get bored of electrics? It's not a value judgement It's about understanding how he works and what would work for him. Be open I say, truthful but not judgemental.

tootiredtospeak · 14/10/2023 22:53

My DS ASD got bottom grades in everything ended up out of school and then in a special need college. He did a supported internship to get him into work and did a few placements at a supermarket and pub. He now works about 16hrs a week and has passed his driving test and has a car so that will open up some more opportunities. I am not sure what his potential is but he is doing so well and is managing his anxiety the best he ever has.

TheBlahWitchProject · 14/10/2023 22:40

I’m saving to read tomorrow as in a similar position x

Ohhelpicantthinkofaname · 14/10/2023 22:30

Allthecushions · 14/10/2023 21:52

This is such a wonderful thread. Two of my dds have asd and adhd (1 has incredibly complex needs and won’t take any exams) and the other struggles academically. So it’s really nice to hear that there are options out there if you don’t get your GCSEs.

This is so true. Getting decent GCSEs makes things easier but it’s really not the end of the road if you don’t.

undiagnosed adhd meant a tough time at school for me. Left school with 2 GCSEs. Worked in care, got level 3 qualifications x2 did functional skills and was later offered a degree apprenticeship in my 30s. Now a healthcare professional.

There are so many opportunities out there for people who struggled with conventional education due to one thing or another. lots of people who struggled in their teens to stick at it do very well as adults. Never give up.

Allthecushions · 14/10/2023 21:52

This is such a wonderful thread. Two of my dds have asd and adhd (1 has incredibly complex needs and won’t take any exams) and the other struggles academically. So it’s really nice to hear that there are options out there if you don’t get your GCSEs.

LimitIsUp · 06/08/2023 19:13

Mine got good GCSE's and grades ABC at A level but is working at Tesco (age 21) - she is ADHD and ASD and is working in a job below her 'potential' but part time Tesco is all she can handle (otherwise gets overwhelmed and burnt out)

JoGmum · 05/08/2023 22:14

Thankyou for this (old) thread…. my ds has no diagnosis but going into Y11 in Sept and has really struggled to focus and do any meaningful work. By the end of last term his concentration at all time low, mock grades poor and now found out he’s vaping 😞. I haven’t been on mumsnet for years but this could be a godsend for the coming year 🙏🙏🙏

Ozgirl75 · 29/03/2023 09:29

One of my close friends teaches adult maths and English to people who failed gcse but need it for work and firstly she’s lovely, and secondly, it’s very common, she says none of them can’t do it, they either were just not ready at 16, or didn’t associate studying with working, or are just really unconfident.
She gets them all through it.

Fidgety31 · 29/03/2023 08:55

My son got expelled from school due to their inability to cope with his severe adhd - so left with no GCSEs at all.
he went to college at 16 to do level one maths and English . Then stayed another three years to do level two and three childcare . Eventually started his degree - albeit a few years later than his peers - but is now a teacher .

He got on much better at college as they treated him differently . School was not for him !

Amber53 · 29/03/2023 08:24

@bloodywhitecat your post is one I meant to come back to also, there’s been so many fantastic stories.

Your DS sounds amazing and has achieved what he set out to do. This would probably be DS’s dream job, being able to handle birds of prey on a daily basis!

Could I ask which route he went down to become a falconer?

OP posts:
Dancingbea · 29/03/2023 07:24

I think this will be such an important thread to so many people. my ds (Asd with probable adhd) did get the 5 simply because we focused solely on 5, incl. English and maths, and last year they got pre information for the exams - some of which was more helpful than others.
it wasn’t enough to do a levels at his quite academic school and realistically the amount of intensive support to just scrape those 5 (one only became a pass on a re-mark) meant there’s no way he would have been able to do them independently. I felt sad about that because history was one thing he really enjoyed and was the only one he got a 6 in - but even that required lots of drilling on the large parts of the syllabus he wasn’t interested in and I suspect that would have been worse at a level. He wasn’t bothered though did want to stay at sixth form, was terrified of starting again at college and school finally offered him some poorly thought through b techs (it’s an a level kind of school). It really didn’t work out and he left just before half term but on his own terms and I think he felt fine about it.
he really just wanted a job! He has now started an apprenticeship as a trainee chef in a chain and although we aren’t completely clear what’s going on with it (because unlike school we aren’t told anything and he is quite secretive about it) he seems to be getting on with it, is happy and relaxed. It’s actually a level 2 so no need for the 5. It’s funny because he is completely fearless about walking into a job (I was so proud of the way he just went for interviews with no stress at all, polite, confident) where in a school and college environment he was anxious, on edge and defensive. Although he did have friends at school he said he just finds the fact that unlike school at work no one is all teamed up and competitive (he has not yet experienced offices politics 😂) much easier to deal with - as an autistic kid he finds the rule of adults much more predictable and easier to deal with I guess.
It’s the start of the journey for him and I imagine there will be lots of bumps on the way.
I was really quite academic myself and ostensibly now very successful in a job I am passionate about - but it’s also incredibly stressful - his ambitions are different and he has said to me on a number of occasions - I love you mum but I am not you, I don’t want the things you wanted, I just want to make a bit of money, not loads and have my (insert obsessive interest).
I just think there are many life paths - and this is as much a learning process for me about challenging my own prejudices and beliefs on what success is - as it is for him.
x

garlictwist · 29/03/2023 04:52

bloodywhitecat · 27/03/2023 10:10

DS did badly, ASD, dyspraxia and dysgraphia made school life difficult. He always said he was going to be a falconer and he is, he now manages a falconry centre and does public displays at country shows. He still can't hold down a conversation mind you but he can talk for hours about nature. He now talks about doing an OU degree at some point, possibly in archeology, another passion of his.

Wow what an interesting job he has! You must be very proud of him.

TheCatterall · 29/03/2023 01:00

@Amber53 my youngest was home educated throughout his high school years due to severe mental health issues and a suicide threat/attempts at age 10. He didn’t sit GCSEs (did some adult literacy and numeracy certificates as part of a college course for home educated young people) as I’d rather he was happy and healthy and doing anything rather than stressed out and suicidal.

he’s now 23, definitely happy and healthy. He does freelance graphic design, photography and videography work. He’s written courses on professional esports strategy that brings in some money. Does bits and bobs as opportunities arise.

we looked at online and community courses that were accredited and some that weren’t. over his school years we did hundreds of MOOC courses. He reached out to people that inspired or interested him for feedback, experience and shadowing them.

I support and encourage him to think outside the box on how to turn passions and interests and existing skills into money making opportunities.

Could your son get some work or do something from home AND find an online course that’s accredited and fulfils any educational requirements? Open University have various levels of modules and units - so you can pick and mix what interests you.

Confusedmeanderings · 29/03/2023 00:39

Not my DC, but my DH. His experience is obviously a long time ago, but might help you to feel more hopeful for the future. He hated school and left with one CSE in technical drawing (I did say it was a long time ago!). He failed everything else. He did various low level jobs until aged 30 he decided to give education another go. He did English and Maths at evening class and then was made redundant so went back to college and did an access to further education type course. After that he went to university and got a degree in archaeology. He was an archaeologist for a while, then he went on to become a lecturer in computing at degree level. He is proof that its never too late!

Sideorderofchips · 28/03/2023 21:52

I did OK at gcse but fucked up my a levels and never completed my nursing diploma. Had mental health problems and a breakdown

I'm now a secondary school science technician and working towards higher level teaching assistant