Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to point out it is more likely for cancer to cause obesity than for obesity to cause cancer

84 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 27/03/2023 06:55

Cos I am so sick of smug ignoramuses being so superior and judgemental.

I was not overweight until I had cancer. I had a MBI of 22 until I had to start taking massive continuous doses of steroids alongside chemotherapy.

Obesity is a medical problem, Obesity does cause health problems. Obesity is a contributing factor to some cancers. The WHO estimates obesity is a contributary factor in around 3-4% of cancers. That all. And there is no way of knowing which individual cancers, that is a population level estimate. And it is a contributary factor, not a cause.

So can we ditch this attitude of "o well, you did this to yourself" every time people come across a fat person with cancer.

Thank you

OP posts:
Mistyontheroof · 27/03/2023 07:48

I know what you mean @Nimbostratus100 It's like when surveys get done about health and exercise. Conclusion always being that if you exercise you'll be healthy. Not taking into account that if a person isn't healthy, they aren't likely to do as much exercise.

There is often confusion between causation and correlation imo

Of course being overweight isn't healthy, and we know exercise is good for a body, but as you say certain drugs can increase your weight (really sorry about your diagnosis and wishing you all the best!)

Certain diseases and disabilities preclude exercising ( getting through the day can be hard enough!) So unless a research allows for this, it's tempting to then think that it's lack of exercise causing the problem, not that the problem means the person can't exercise.

Upsywavy · 27/03/2023 07:48

You are incorrect but I agree people shouldn't judge. There is a line between educating the population on the health benefits of maintaining a healthy weight and that includes some possible outcomes, and blaming individuals for their cancer and saying its their fault.

Chickenly · 27/03/2023 07:48

Fairyliz · 27/03/2023 07:44

But every single person I’ve ever met with cancer I knew before, so I would know if they were overweight before.

Surely people with cancer don’t go around informing complete strangers about it, they would tell family, friends, colleagues.

I met lots of people while I was having cancer and after having cancer, and it comes up as a topic of conversation really very often.

Also keep in mind that weight gain is a direct symptom of some cancers but the NHS refuse to accept it as one because of the stigma surrounding weight gain.

Stugs · 27/03/2023 07:46

Nimbostratus100 · 27/03/2023 06:55

Cos I am so sick of smug ignoramuses being so superior and judgemental.

I was not overweight until I had cancer. I had a MBI of 22 until I had to start taking massive continuous doses of steroids alongside chemotherapy.

Obesity is a medical problem, Obesity does cause health problems. Obesity is a contributing factor to some cancers. The WHO estimates obesity is a contributary factor in around 3-4% of cancers. That all. And there is no way of knowing which individual cancers, that is a population level estimate. And it is a contributary factor, not a cause.

So can we ditch this attitude of "o well, you did this to yourself" every time people come across a fat person with cancer.

Thank you

I don't think anyone with any humanity would think an obese person had given themselves cancer, but there's no doubt that being obese is a risk factor.

Also getting drug levels right is harder when people are obese, according to my dbros consultant.

Fairyliz · 27/03/2023 07:44

Nimbostratus100 · 27/03/2023 07:38

The WHO says that in around only 3-4% of cancers is obesity likely to be a contributary factor

contributary factor, not cause.

ANd you have no idea if the people you meet with cancer were obese before hand, or whether the cancer treatment has caused weight gain

But every single person I’ve ever met with cancer I knew before, so I would know if they were overweight before.

Surely people with cancer don’t go around informing complete strangers about it, they would tell family, friends, colleagues.

SweetSakura · 27/03/2023 07:43

Agreed. I was slim all my life. Slim and very fit and a very healthy eater.

Then I developed a rare autoimmune neuro-muscular disease. It's stopped me exercising and means I need a high dose of steroids. I have ballooned, I don't recognise my face. I still eat carefully.

I am sick and tired of the judgement and sense people feel i have morally failed in some way and don't deserve health care.

Strictly1 · 27/03/2023 07:43

I’m really sorry for the position you’re in but you’re not right. Cancer has made the people I’ve loved skeletal. This doesn’t prove that this is the case for everyone, just like you having put weight on doesn’t prove it for everyone. I question for Stats from WHO.

Nimbostratus100 · 27/03/2023 07:38

The WHO says that in around only 3-4% of cancers is obesity likely to be a contributary factor

contributary factor, not cause.

ANd you have no idea if the people you meet with cancer were obese before hand, or whether the cancer treatment has caused weight gain

OP posts:
manontroppo · 27/03/2023 07:32

https://www.cancerresearchuk.org/about-cancer/causes-of-cancer/bodyweight-and-cancer/how-does-obesity-cause-cancer

Obesity is the second biggest cause of cancer. It doesn’t cause all cancers, nor does everyone who is obese get cancer.

Obesity also makes it harder for cancer to be treated, as obese patients are less fit. Around 2/3rds of cancer patients have surgery, which is made significantly more challenging if the patient is obese.

I’m very sorry for your diagnosis, but obesity is a serious, significant and actionable risk factor for cancer.

How does obesity cause cancer?

Overweight and obesity is the second biggest cause of cancer in the UK. Keeping a healthy weight reduces the risk of 13 types of cancer.

https://www.cancerresearchuk.org/about-cancer/causes-of-cancer/bodyweight-and-cancer/how-does-obesity-cause-cancer

Swipe left for the next trending thread