Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to point out it is more likely for cancer to cause obesity than for obesity to cause cancer

84 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 27/03/2023 06:55

Cos I am so sick of smug ignoramuses being so superior and judgemental.

I was not overweight until I had cancer. I had a MBI of 22 until I had to start taking massive continuous doses of steroids alongside chemotherapy.

Obesity is a medical problem, Obesity does cause health problems. Obesity is a contributing factor to some cancers. The WHO estimates obesity is a contributary factor in around 3-4% of cancers. That all. And there is no way of knowing which individual cancers, that is a population level estimate. And it is a contributary factor, not a cause.

So can we ditch this attitude of "o well, you did this to yourself" every time people come across a fat person with cancer.

Thank you

OP posts:
pncr · 27/03/2023 09:46

@Stugs I can't walk. Not unless I'm in a pool. That's why I get pip.

Upsywavy · 27/03/2023 09:46

potniatheron · 27/03/2023 09:34

Having the time and resources and good health to be able to eat clean and exercise means you are privileged. It does not mean you are morally superior.

My view is that we should never judge when we see a person who appears unfit, overweight, out of shape whatever. There is a story behind every body. Slim and fit is a privilege. And luck.

You don't have to eat clean to maintain a healthy weight though, you can eat whatever as long as you maintain a calorie deficit.

Stugs · 27/03/2023 09:36

potniatheron · 27/03/2023 09:34

Having the time and resources and good health to be able to eat clean and exercise means you are privileged. It does not mean you are morally superior.

My view is that we should never judge when we see a person who appears unfit, overweight, out of shape whatever. There is a story behind every body. Slim and fit is a privilege. And luck.

Well, I'm not sure I totally agree- don't judge yes, but you don't have to buy chia seeds and expensive food to lose weight and walking is perfectly fine exercise.

Ariela · 27/03/2023 09:35

The point you are making is steroids can seriously impact your ability to keep to a reasonable weight. My best friend had acute kidney failure/sepsis and was put on steroids, despite not being able to eat for almost a month without being sick and loosing almost 2 stone her weight ballooned by almost 4 stone after due to the effect of the steroids. She's lost 2 stone, but never quite managed to get back to pre-steroid weight.
Nothing to do with cancer. It's the steroids.

potniatheron · 27/03/2023 09:34

Having the time and resources and good health to be able to eat clean and exercise means you are privileged. It does not mean you are morally superior.

My view is that we should never judge when we see a person who appears unfit, overweight, out of shape whatever. There is a story behind every body. Slim and fit is a privilege. And luck.

Barbecuebeans · 27/03/2023 09:30

SweetSakura · 27/03/2023 08:41

Oh I don't disagree.
I think the point is not that we shouldn't try and be healthy, but that we shouldn't blame or judge those who become ill.

We shouldn't judge or blame people for getting ill but we also shouldn't pretend that factors related to lifestyle are not relevant to illness just to be kind.

What is the point in pretending type 2 diabetes is not related to obesity in many cases? It is something that is in the control of many people. Not all, obviously, as some people are obese because of medical conditions. But if there are lifestyle factors, people should be aware of them.

The relationship between obesity and cancer is clearly complex. However the fact that there is a higher correlation of overweight and cancer diagnosis in Western countries, suggests there is likely to be a causation, as there is more obesity here. I don't see how pretending that is not the case helps anyone.

It doesn't mean that everyone with cancer is overweight or that if people who are overweight with cancer it does not follow that their cancer is caused by their size. It does however mean that it is one factor many of us can control in trying to prevent illness.

follyfoot37 · 27/03/2023 09:29

Nimbostratus100 · 27/03/2023 06:55

Cos I am so sick of smug ignoramuses being so superior and judgemental.

I was not overweight until I had cancer. I had a MBI of 22 until I had to start taking massive continuous doses of steroids alongside chemotherapy.

Obesity is a medical problem, Obesity does cause health problems. Obesity is a contributing factor to some cancers. The WHO estimates obesity is a contributary factor in around 3-4% of cancers. That all. And there is no way of knowing which individual cancers, that is a population level estimate. And it is a contributary factor, not a cause.

So can we ditch this attitude of "o well, you did this to yourself" every time people come across a fat person with cancer.

Thank you

Steroids also make you gain weight, so not necessarily the cancer that 'causes obesity'.

I am pointing out to you that any fat people with cancer you meat are more likely to be fat because they have cancer, rather than have cancer because they are fat
Rubbish statement

Cyclingforcake · 27/03/2023 09:28

The other thing about some cancers is that it is proven that exercise after diagnosis can improve survival and tolerance to treatment. So increasingly people with cancer are being offered exercise and nutrition programs. This is not a judgement on their weight/lifestyle/motivation but part of their treatment.

Upsywavy · 27/03/2023 09:21

I am pointing out to you that any fat people with cancer you meat are more likely to be fat because they have cancer, rather than have cancer because they are fat.

Disagree with the first part, most people with cancer who are fat are more likely to have been overweight prior to diagnosis statistically; but this doesn't mean they have cancer because of this. What you're saying is sort of true and untrue at the same time- just because someone is fat is doesn't mean this contributed to their cancer and no of course people shouldn't judge, but it's not the case that everyone is slim beforehand and only becomes overweight following treatment.

Surely the message is that whilst weight can in some cases heighten the risk (although we shouldn't judge still of course and it's often more complex than that and only a small % of cases), we should face the reality that it can be a factor and support people in general to aim for a healthy weight.

Stugs · 27/03/2023 09:21

Tbh I've got other things to think about rather than seeking out fat people with cancer and then judging them.

Nimbostratus100 · 27/03/2023 09:17

ScentOfAMemory · 27/03/2023 09:11

Dangerous idea to be promoting OP.
And factually totally incorrect.

o rubbish

I am pointing out to you that any fat people with cancer you meat are more likely to be fat because they have cancer, rather than have cancer because they are fat.

nothing remotely misleading or dangerous

absolutely nowhere have I said being fat or having cancer is a good healthy thing to aspire to!

I am just pointing out that the amount of judgement poured onto our heads is a load of smug ignorant people who like to think of themselves as superior

OP posts:
ScentOfAMemory · 27/03/2023 09:11

Dangerous idea to be promoting OP.
And factually totally incorrect.

lljkk · 27/03/2023 09:09

can we ditch this attitude of "o well, you did this to yourself" every time people come across a fat person with cancer.

How many people have said that to you, OP ? About your body size and your cancer.

I'm pausing to think of people I know who had cancer in last 10 years...

plump aunt, heavy smoker (I blame the fags)
my 80yo dad, pudgy, (tiniest possible melanoma), I blame his age, redhead living in sunny place
80yo neighbour, trim (I blame his age)
50yo colleague, trim (she'd blame bad luck)
50yo friend, trim (he had a genetic condition that caused it)
DH elderly aunt, age 80+, trim (could blame her age, high salt diet?)
84yo uncle, trim ( I blame his age)
34yo friend, trim (she blamed chemicals she worked with)
~53yo local woman, trim, dunno what she would blame
2 x 40yo friends, veering towards pudgy (dunno what they would blame)

Only one of them was actually fat, and I'd blame her ciggies really

Stugs · 27/03/2023 08:57

SweetSakura · 27/03/2023 08:50

You're missing the point and you know you are

Am I? I don't think so?

Devoutspoken · 27/03/2023 08:56

Stugs is not m8ssing the point

Plingston · 27/03/2023 08:55

I don't doubt that obesity can be a contributing factor for developing cancer but it doesn't seem to apply to most of the people I see on the chemo ward. m currently receiving cancer treatment and I am 34 with a BMI of 21. Absolutely no lifestyle factors for my cancer whatsoever. It's just bad luck. Sometimes healthy people say really ignorant things to me. I think they're trying to reassure themselves that it wouldn't happen to them so it must be something I've done. I've also become extremely unfit due to the treatment being horrific and meaning that I can't move very well. The idea that I can exercise during this treatment is laughable - i can barely walk most of the time. I keep searching for some kind of NHS scheme I can be referred to to get back to normal fitness levels afterwards but can't find anything.

I haven't gained weight during treatment but I am going to experience early menopause, so I'm expecting to gain weight. I'm dreading dealing with people's reactions to that, to be honest. My own dad made a rude comment about an overweight person in a mobility scooter the other day - along the lines of them needing the scooter because they're fat. I pointed out that it's quite likely they became overweight because of their mobility issues. He did seem to take it on board though.

hattie43 · 27/03/2023 08:52

@KittyAlfred

No it was a general discussion about cancer not a specific cancer .
The risk factors I was asked on my first appoint.
Did I have a family history of cancer
Did I smoke
How much alcohol did I drink
Have I ever been exposed to asbestos.
Nothing about weight .

SweetSakura · 27/03/2023 08:50

Stugs · 27/03/2023 08:46

Sorry to be pedantic but the treatment causing obesity isn't the same as cancer causing obesity.

You're missing the point and you know you are

Stugs · 27/03/2023 08:46

Nimbostratus100 · 27/03/2023 08:44

I didn't say it caused obesity for everyone and I didn't say it causes obesity at every stage

But the treatments for cancer do cause massive weight gain for many people

Sorry to be pedantic but the treatment causing obesity isn't the same as cancer causing obesity.

Nimbostratus100 · 27/03/2023 08:46

Fairyliz · 27/03/2023 07:44

But every single person I’ve ever met with cancer I knew before, so I would know if they were overweight before.

Surely people with cancer don’t go around informing complete strangers about it, they would tell family, friends, colleagues.

If you are a woman, and bald, basically everyone who comes across you, knows you have cancer

OP posts:
Nimbostratus100 · 27/03/2023 08:44

Strictly1 · 27/03/2023 07:43

I’m really sorry for the position you’re in but you’re not right. Cancer has made the people I’ve loved skeletal. This doesn’t prove that this is the case for everyone, just like you having put weight on doesn’t prove it for everyone. I question for Stats from WHO.

I didn't say it caused obesity for everyone and I didn't say it causes obesity at every stage

But the treatments for cancer do cause massive weight gain for many people

OP posts:
SweetSakura · 27/03/2023 08:44

Chesneyhawkes1 · 27/03/2023 08:28

I was just under 8 stone and training for a marathon when I got diagnosed with cancer.

I put on just over a stone during treatment. Steroids, lack of running and chemo made me only fancy eating beige food.

Treatment ended and within 4 weeks I was back to my normal weight thankfully. I think a lot was steroid based.

I commented on the other thread. People with cancer and other illnesses/disabilities, are not responsible for their weight gain - it's a by product of what is going on in their life.

However I'd guess the majority of the British public don't have these issues.

Interestingly as a newly large person I have found other larger people opening up to me and it is amazing how many do have stories of being fit and healthy before cancer or other illnesses (and resultant medication) caused them to gain weight and /or be unable to exercise.

Although equally even those who are obese purely due to lifestyle I don't think deserve judgement. It's just the flipside of anorexia surely and yet people with anorexia don't face the same level of judgement

KittyAlfred · 27/03/2023 08:44

Everyone knows that people can be overweight for a variety of reasons - steroids, other drugs, physical disabilities, endocrine disorders, disordered eating due to mental health problems etc, so of course clinicians should bear this in mind when discussing weight issues.

But I’m pretty sure that the vast majority of people who are overweight basically eat too much ie more than they’re burning off.

The perception of obesity is not helped by the fact that many overweight people delude themselves about why they’re the weight they are. I’ve been a yo-yo dieter for 40 years, so I know that if I eat too much I gain weight, and if I stick to a diet I lose weight. I can tell myself I’m sticking to a diet, but if I’m sneaking calories here and there, then I won’t lose weight. As a GP I’ve seen hundreds of overweight people in my career, and only a tiny minority will actually say “yeah I eat too much”. All the others will blame time, exercise opportunities etc, or will simply say they genuinely only eat 500 calories per day, when they clearly don’t.

SweetSakura · 27/03/2023 08:41

Devoutspoken · 27/03/2023 08:31

Sweetsakura, surely that's stating the obvious, of course its not all about lifestyle but given the odds, we may as well do what we can

Oh I don't disagree.
I think the point is not that we shouldn't try and be healthy, but that we shouldn't blame or judge those who become ill.