Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to point out it is more likely for cancer to cause obesity than for obesity to cause cancer

84 replies

Nimbostratus100 · 27/03/2023 06:55

Cos I am so sick of smug ignoramuses being so superior and judgemental.

I was not overweight until I had cancer. I had a MBI of 22 until I had to start taking massive continuous doses of steroids alongside chemotherapy.

Obesity is a medical problem, Obesity does cause health problems. Obesity is a contributing factor to some cancers. The WHO estimates obesity is a contributary factor in around 3-4% of cancers. That all. And there is no way of knowing which individual cancers, that is a population level estimate. And it is a contributary factor, not a cause.

So can we ditch this attitude of "o well, you did this to yourself" every time people come across a fat person with cancer.

Thank you

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
SchoolTripDrama · 27/03/2023 20:08

lljkk · 27/03/2023 09:09

can we ditch this attitude of "o well, you did this to yourself" every time people come across a fat person with cancer.

How many people have said that to you, OP ? About your body size and your cancer.

I'm pausing to think of people I know who had cancer in last 10 years...

plump aunt, heavy smoker (I blame the fags)
my 80yo dad, pudgy, (tiniest possible melanoma), I blame his age, redhead living in sunny place
80yo neighbour, trim (I blame his age)
50yo colleague, trim (she'd blame bad luck)
50yo friend, trim (he had a genetic condition that caused it)
DH elderly aunt, age 80+, trim (could blame her age, high salt diet?)
84yo uncle, trim ( I blame his age)
34yo friend, trim (she blamed chemicals she worked with)
~53yo local woman, trim, dunno what she would blame
2 x 40yo friends, veering towards pudgy (dunno what they would blame)

Only one of them was actually fat, and I'd blame her ciggies really

Wow! You're incredibly judgemental over people's sizes. Unbelievable

pncr · 27/03/2023 16:03

Greenolivetrees · 27/03/2023 14:17

So can we ditch this attitude of "o well, you did this to yourself" every time people come across a fat person with cancer.

I think that we need to ditch the idea that obese people did it to themselves to become fat. It's not an anorexics fault that they're thin: they have a mental health disease. It's not an obese persons fault that they're fat: they have a mental health disease.

Predominantly I'm not fat because of MH issues though. I'm fat because of steroids and an under active thyroid that doesn't meet the uk standard for medication.

lljkk · 27/03/2023 15:05

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

mondaytosunday · 27/03/2023 15:00

I know quite a few people who have had cancer, mostly breast cancer, but also lung, throat, brain, colon and stomach cancer. Not one was overweight before or during treatment, in fact most lost weight due to how ill the chemo made them feel.
That's not to say weight isn't a contributing factor - of course it is if repeated studies have indicated this is the case. But it's certainly not a given that you must be overweight to develop it.
But it is also common knowledge (I would have thought) that long term steroid use can lead to weight gain? Isn't it? Thing is, you can't walk around with a sign saying 'I'm not fat due to overeating I'm on steroids'. Less judgement all around is needed.

Greenolivetrees · 27/03/2023 14:17

So can we ditch this attitude of "o well, you did this to yourself" every time people come across a fat person with cancer.

I think that we need to ditch the idea that obese people did it to themselves to become fat. It's not an anorexics fault that they're thin: they have a mental health disease. It's not an obese persons fault that they're fat: they have a mental health disease.

Babysharkdoodoodood · 27/03/2023 12:16

randomrandomium · 27/03/2023 07:50

I was infuriated by some of the smug, condescending posters on that thread. I was size 12, didn't drink or smoke and exercised 4 days a week and then I got breast cancer. I am now overweight and unfit following major surgery, steroids, part way through chemo and struggling with depression but clearly it's all my fault for getting cancer because I am overweight???!! I'm glad those posters haven't had their lives blighted by cancer because it is truly shit - no one ever knows what other people are going through and the lack of compassion for others was extraordinary.

Yup. Me too. I'm a size 20 after all chemo and other drugs. The side effectevery single drug I'm on is weight gain.

I can't shift it.

Dinopawus · 27/03/2023 12:07

OP I'm sorry about your diagnosis and hope you make good progress.

I'm not in the habit of judging anyone's body size, but it's important to be honest with people.

We know skinny people who exercise can develop cancers, diabetes and other hideous conditions. But we also know that people who are overweight and obese are more likely to develop those conditions.

And as you and other posters have pointed out so eloquently, losing weight when you have an underlying health condition becomes a lot harder.

GemGemGemGemGemGem · 27/03/2023 11:50

I'm so sorry, but you're so wrong. You're quoting research over 10 years old from WHO. I work in cancer research and it is most definitely a leading cause, and only becoming more prominent as society gets heavier. I teeter between overweight and obese myself so I am not saying this from a judging viewpoint, just a factual one. Anyone who looks at someone with cancer and thinks, 'it's your fault because you're fat' is a disgusting person regardless!

MaireadMcSweeney · 27/03/2023 11:18

Nimbostratus100 · 27/03/2023 09:17

o rubbish

I am pointing out to you that any fat people with cancer you meat are more likely to be fat because they have cancer, rather than have cancer because they are fat.

nothing remotely misleading or dangerous

absolutely nowhere have I said being fat or having cancer is a good healthy thing to aspire to!

I am just pointing out that the amount of judgement poured onto our heads is a load of smug ignorant people who like to think of themselves as superior

That's not what you claimed in the OP though
You said that cancer is MORE like to to cause obesity than obesity is to cause cancer. This isn't a good statistic. I feel like you've just made it up to be honest. Your obesity was caused by your cancer treatment but to extrapolate that to a statistic the way you did is incorrect.

Wotnowconfused · 27/03/2023 11:15

Being overweight is not healthy in anyway and causes or initiates so many other underlying health issues.
Of course not everyone overweight can help it but in general it is caused but poor eating habits, an unhealthy diet and a sedentary lifestyle.
Obesity levels have accelerated across the Western world as diets have become more calorific and highly processed, jobs less labour intensive and lifestyles less and active. Look at the latest generation zipping about on e-scooters rather than expending energy.
The NHS is groaning under a population who have made poor lifestyle choices that have compounded their overall health.
Of course many ailments are not just from lifestyle but hereditary genes too but being healthy gives you a fighting chance.
OP I'm well aware of the affect steroids have on metabolism in your case but I'm sure you can request assistance from a hospital dietician to help you control you weight alongside your treatment and recovery back to good health.

coldmarchmorn · 27/03/2023 11:01

I am pointing out to you that any fat people with cancer you meat are more likely to be fat because they have cancer, rather than have cancer because they are fat

absolute nonsense I'm afraid, most people you meet who have cancer and are fat were fat before cancer. That doesn't mean it caused their cancer (you'd have no way of knowing though).

Mixedberrygenderfluidmuffin · 27/03/2023 10:57

Anyone who implies that it’s an individual’s own fault they have cancer, rather than bad luck, is obviously a twat.

That doesn’t negate the fact that obesity is never healthy, and is a major preventable risk factor for cancer, as well as many other diseases. We can all reduce our risk of getting cancer substantially by having a healthy lifestyle, but we obviously can’t reduce the risk to zero, and fit and slim people get cancer all the time.

I don’t think it’s helpful to assume obesity is entirely an individual responsibility though. We have chosen to order society and plan towns and cities so that it’s easy to be sedentary, and ultra processed, highly calorific foods are cheap and easily available. We can choose to change this, so we all lead healthier lives, but it requires government action to change policies, individuals and the NHS can’t do it.

AnneLovesGilbert · 27/03/2023 10:54

In a round about way you are actually judging yourself. It's as if you're saying "Yes, lm overweight, but it's not my fault. I'm not one of the geedy/lazy/undisciplined people.

That’s exactly how it comes across.

sausage767 · 27/03/2023 10:51

I can only speak for myself. I lost quite a bit of weight during chemo and radiation therapy as I was too sick to eat for several weeks.

What did distress me was people saying how ‘great’ I looked. I didn’t look great, I looked fucking horrible and sick, I was just skinny.

Beautiful3 · 27/03/2023 10:32

Steroids cause massive weight gain. Everyone I know who are on them, are now severely overweight.

GneissWork · 27/03/2023 10:31

CindersAgain · 27/03/2023 08:07

I think you’re quoting figures that were gathered in 2012. Here.
https://www.cancer.gov/about-cancer/causes-prevention/risk/obesity/obesity-fact-sheet

This was a global study and the developed world has a very different profile for the relationship between cancer and obesity.

I was going to say this.
The UK has a tiny population compared to the rest of the world.
The UK is fatter than the majority of the world.
The majority of cancers happen outwith the UK.
Therefore, someone like the WORLD health organisations data - taking into account the whole world - is not necessarily true in a “fat” country like the UK.

WandaWonder · 27/03/2023 10:25

Op all the information I have received over the years has said the opposite to you what you have, so far I have not seen any evidence that is so secret that doctors and the medical world are keeping hidden or are not aware about

I presume the world would know if you are right?

Upsywavy · 27/03/2023 10:22

Iwantmyoldnameback · 27/03/2023 09:51

Yep like you could choose to have your 1000 calories (or whatever you set yourself) in sweeties or wine or pastry, remain slim and still have health issues. But it's ok because you don't look fat!

Carrying excess weight puts extra stress on the body regardless of any other issues caused by diet, so yes ideally to be a healthy weight and healthy overall a diet compromised mainly of fresh, unprocessed foods is ideal; but the post was insinuating that you'd only be able to be a healthy weight if you could afford to eat clean which isn't true. We need to separate how fat looks to the effect is has on people.

JudgeRudy · 27/03/2023 10:21

I'm not sure of the exact stats and I guess it's very difficult to separate correlation from cause, however your title is misleading. Cancer is more likely to cause weight loss. Chemotherapy may well cause weight gain (steroids are well know for increasing appetite and giving you a puffy face). I'd also say the majority of obese people are overweight because they take in more calories than they need.
I often hear people say they have put on weight because they can't exercise (illness, age, trauma etc)....then they need to eat less. For the majority of people it really is that simple however simple is not easy.
In a round about way you are actually judging yourself. It's as if you're saying "Yes, lm overweight, but it's not my fault. I'm not one of the geedy/lazy/undisciplined people."
I think obesity is a very complex matter and we (medical and lay person) are only just appreciating how big a part psychology pays.
When I see someone overweight I generally think "l wonder if you're unhappy and what brought you to this point".

Upsywavy · 27/03/2023 10:20

TobeLeRone · 27/03/2023 09:57

There are many women for whom this isn’t the case. Hormone imbalance, stress, menopause, all can affect weight and how well or efficiently you can lose weight.

I ate at a calorie deficit for months at one point in a bid to lose weight, I lost 6 pounds in total, it took around 4-5 months, then weight started creeping on, I was strict (and starving and miserable).

Calorie deficit does not work for all, and when it doesn’t it’s used as yet another stick to beat women with because we’re obviously lying about what we’re eating.

I was responding to the suggestion that you must be able to afford to eat clean to be a healthy weight which is untrue.

TobeLeRone · 27/03/2023 09:57

Upsywavy · 27/03/2023 09:46

You don't have to eat clean to maintain a healthy weight though, you can eat whatever as long as you maintain a calorie deficit.

There are many women for whom this isn’t the case. Hormone imbalance, stress, menopause, all can affect weight and how well or efficiently you can lose weight.

I ate at a calorie deficit for months at one point in a bid to lose weight, I lost 6 pounds in total, it took around 4-5 months, then weight started creeping on, I was strict (and starving and miserable).

Calorie deficit does not work for all, and when it doesn’t it’s used as yet another stick to beat women with because we’re obviously lying about what we’re eating.

Iwantmyoldnameback · 27/03/2023 09:51

Upsywavy · 27/03/2023 09:46

You don't have to eat clean to maintain a healthy weight though, you can eat whatever as long as you maintain a calorie deficit.

Yep like you could choose to have your 1000 calories (or whatever you set yourself) in sweeties or wine or pastry, remain slim and still have health issues. But it's ok because you don't look fat!

potniatheron · 27/03/2023 09:47

Stugs · 27/03/2023 09:36

Well, I'm not sure I totally agree- don't judge yes, but you don't have to buy chia seeds and expensive food to lose weight and walking is perfectly fine exercise.

I hear you and I can only speak for myself and my own experience of life, which is that I'm fit and able to run daily and eat well now, BECAUSE I am fortunate enough that my mental and physical health is good right now and I am earning well.

These things have not always been the case in my life and my body reflected it. Mental ill health, abusive relationships, addiction, lack of money and time can all seriously impact one's ability to prepare / buy good food or even to go for a walk...if you've been there you know.

Don't judge is all i would say.

TobeLeRone · 27/03/2023 09:46

But I’m pretty sure that the vast majority of people who are overweight basically eat too much ie more than they’re burning off.

I’m changing my mind about that, the vast majority of people I know who are morbidly obese have obvious issues that have caused this (some of them following cancer diagnosis and treatment) Yes they eat too much, but this is a symptom rather than the problem itself, but most of the time this is not acknowledged at all. If you’re fat and at the drs you’re considered to be a lazy overeater with no willpower, even if it’s clearly known that the obesity had a medical cause, and even if the dr is being kind while they tell you you’re fat.

I am morbidly obese, I was diagnosed as diabetic, put on metformin and dropped 2 stone in a month - until I was on a drug that supported leptin and insulin I didn’t realise that I never felt full, so I fully consider that my obesity is down to a medical issue that went undiagnosed for decades because it’s easier to diagnose someone as fat than to look for an underlying cause.