Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

ASD diagnosis rationing

43 replies

Blinkingstars · 27/03/2023 06:11

https://amp.theguardian.com/society/2023/mar/26/children-put-at-risk-as-nhs-autism-assessments-are-cut-back

A health board is so overwhelmed with requests for ASD assessments that they have decided to ration them only to vulnerable kids. AIBU to be utterly outraged? My child would not meet the criteria but to be undiagnosed still would have been devastating for her. The primary teacher would still be giving her a telling off for running distraught out of classes like music when the volume got too much. She’d still be not understanding why she feels she’d odd compared to others (her words).

we waited 3 years for diagnosis as it was, after being told by the school that they would not heed a private diagnosis just an nhs one. It’s appalling how underfunded CAMHS but this is the absolute final straw.

‘Children put at risk’ as NHS autism assessments are cut back | Autism | The Guardian

Health service managers in south-west England say new restrictions are needed because of a huge rise in waiting lists

https://amp.theguardian.com/society/2023/mar/26/children-put-at-risk-as-nhs-autism-assessments-are-cut-back

OP posts:
ThatsGoingToHurt · 27/03/2023 10:45

This concerns me massively as I am in neighbouring county. As schools are so overstretched they push back on offering any support as the child has no diagnosis (I know they shouldn’t but that had been the experience of my friends). EHCPs are meant to be needs based not diagnosis based but if you don’t have a diagnosis then the local authority will push back.

I can see that primary aged children will get suspended or expelled or refuse to go to school before a referral goes in. If this happens then one parent will have to give up work to support their child pushing the family into poverty.

stbrandonsboat · 27/03/2023 10:43

Tarantellah · 27/03/2023 10:40

Just proves the point though. Access to opportunities for autistic people helps them become independent and work. Without a diagnosis they wouldn’t be eligible for those opportunities. Only those from rich families (who could afford private diagnosis) would be able to access such opportunities.

This is true. We're not rich, but we have made big sacrifices to afford the assessments, medication and online learning. It's been a struggle. I feel very bad for poorer people who will receive no help whatsoever. It's an utter disgrace. ND people can and do contribute to society, but we need certain things in order to do so.

Tarantellah · 27/03/2023 10:40

stbrandonsboat · 27/03/2023 10:38

Mine don't claim benefits and probably won't need to. One is working already and paying back his student loan and the other his hoping to get into a university near home so he can continue to live with us. His diagnosis will form part of his application and will help him obtain a place due to that university's particular arrangements to help people like my ds.

Just proves the point though. Access to opportunities for autistic people helps them become independent and work. Without a diagnosis they wouldn’t be eligible for those opportunities. Only those from rich families (who could afford private diagnosis) would be able to access such opportunities.

stbrandonsboat · 27/03/2023 10:38

Mine don't claim benefits and probably won't need to. One is working already and paying back his student loan and the other his hoping to get into a university near home so he can continue to live with us. His diagnosis will form part of his application and will help him obtain a place due to that university's particular arrangements to help people like my ds.

SouthCountryGirl · 27/03/2023 10:37

You wouldn't do this for other conditions. So why is it somehow ok to do it with Autism?

Dinopawus · 27/03/2023 10:33

Tarantellah · 27/03/2023 10:19

Diagnosis does matter. It is used to gate keep services.
This.

If a child doesn’t have a diagnosis they don’t have access to opportunities and benefits claims. But autistic children become autistic adults who also don’t have access to reasonable adjustments at work, legal protection from discrimination, can’t apply for opportunities with “diversity criteria”, can’t claim PIP to support their needs, can’t access support services.

We are so lucky we were able to scrape together to pay to go privately but what about those who can't? Just another example of wealth disparity
If poor people can’t get autism diagnosis, publicly funded services which support autistic people will only be available to the rich who could afford to pay for diagnosis.

Sadly, this is so true. Of course children & adults with a diagnosis don't just claim benefits. With the right support, some (many) will go on to employment and become net contributors.

Or we can leave our heads in the sand and leave undiagnosed children to a lifetime of mental health challenges and a chequered employment history.

stbrandonsboat · 27/03/2023 10:32

It's always been rationed and parents have always been fobbed off and turned away from accessing diagnostic services. I have a ds who is 24 with ADHD and PDA who ended up with a severe anxiety disorder and eating disorder due to no help and we had to go private with ds2 who has Asperger's autism and who has needed medication for severe anxiety from age nine, he also couldn't attend secondary school and we had to pay for provision online. If we hadn't have had the money he wouldn't be here now.

This was under both Labour and Tory governments. Neither take ND seriously or take into consideration the serious impact of unidentified/untreated ND. Both my adult dcs are medicated and stable and have legal protections that come into play with having a formal diagnosis. They're also both achieving in their lives despite the terrible setbacks, but this is thanks to me and dh.

Dinopawus · 27/03/2023 10:26

Lucy7890 · 27/03/2023 07:46

' after being told by the school that they would not heed a private diagnosis just an nhs one'

If the assessment is NICE guideline compliant, they cannot do that so I would probably argue with this one. I'd keep looking for a reputable private practice that has multi disciplinary team completing assessments and raise this question with them. It may also help if some of the clinicians still work for the NHS.

Just about to make the same point. If Autism or ADHD diagnosis meets the ICD10 / DSM 5 criteria it is a valid diagnosis. Ignoring this would be disability discrimination.

Tarantellah · 27/03/2023 10:19

Diagnosis does matter. It is used to gate keep services.
This.

If a child doesn’t have a diagnosis they don’t have access to opportunities and benefits claims. But autistic children become autistic adults who also don’t have access to reasonable adjustments at work, legal protection from discrimination, can’t apply for opportunities with “diversity criteria”, can’t claim PIP to support their needs, can’t access support services.

We are so lucky we were able to scrape together to pay to go privately but what about those who can't? Just another example of wealth disparity
If poor people can’t get autism diagnosis, publicly funded services which support autistic people will only be available to the rich who could afford to pay for diagnosis.

ooherrmissus14 · 27/03/2023 10:02

This is my local area. We paid privately to get my daughter assessed in September due to the waiting list being so long. It's sad to think that now she wouldn't even make it onto the waiting list. She is coping relatively well at the moment but I know that going to secondary school this September will be a massive trigger for her. She possibly would meet their criteria at this point as she is likely to be at a crisis point but , if we had followed the nhs route, would then still have a long wait to get diagnosed. There is absolutely no preventative planning here and it will affect the mental health of hundreds of young people and their families. I don't blame Sirona (who provide the assessments on behalf of the LA) but the funding has been shaved away consistently over a number of years meaning they now have to make these awful decisions. We are so lucky we were able to scrape together to pay to go privately but what about those who can't? Just another example of wealth disparity ☹️

gogohmm · 27/03/2023 08:50

Just read the criteria, when my dd was diagnosed, communication difficulties was a criteria for diagnosis, it's a key feature of autism so makes sense that kids being assessed have key traits. When did that change?

I live in that area, theres people talking about it, though as the head of my local school said, it's amazing how many kids of wealthier families have a diagnosis currently compared to the ones she's really concerned about! She's convinced that the pushy parents get a diagnosis because they think it's going to get extra time in exams ... I'm not convinced it is that simple but something is afoot.

My DD's diagnosis was very thorough, took multiple visits and reports from various professionals, whereas now it seems you can pay privately and it takes a couple of hours, makes me suspicious that autism is being diagnosed when it's actually more complicated

Saniflo · 27/03/2023 08:35

It is disgusting. We had to go private with our 2 children for an ADHD and ASD diagnosis. Best decision we ever made, but I know some people can't afford that.

DropItRound · 27/03/2023 08:01

This is appalling.

My DD was diagnosed 8 years ago and the wait times were months, rather than years. It's devastating families are going through this and then to add further gatekeeping is immoral.

I work in the field if autism and have recently started working for a private company that does (NICE compliant) autism assessments. This company shouldn't exist. It should have no place in our society. Unfortunately it's inundated with referrals 😞

BlueyDragon · 27/03/2023 07:53

DD’s diagnosis only came after she reached crisis point. And only because we arranged and paid for it. Even in crisis we were still facing a 3 year waiting list. The state of CAMHS is utterly utterly scandalous and this policy is only tinkering with the edges. More money is desperately needed and less compartmentalised thinking.

Lucy7890 · 27/03/2023 07:46

' after being told by the school that they would not heed a private diagnosis just an nhs one'

If the assessment is NICE guideline compliant, they cannot do that so I would probably argue with this one. I'd keep looking for a reputable private practice that has multi disciplinary team completing assessments and raise this question with them. It may also help if some of the clinicians still work for the NHS.

ArdeteiMasazxu · 27/03/2023 07:27

yanbu this is a huge issue

I was eventually successful getting an assessment for DC at about age 12 after more than 2 years on the waiting list, at the time there was no crisis but I recognised the warning signs and a I had a friend at school who had gone undiagnosed until a mental health crisis and suicide attempt at 16, I knew how important it was to provide early help. fast forward a couple of years and even with the diagnosis in place we don't have plain sailing and there are lots of things that are overwhelmingly stressful but at least with a diagnosis we have a good idea of why and what mitigations to try, and without a diagnosis we would be in real trouble. this policy is so wrong, and is going to cause a massive spike in the kinds of crisis situations that are now being defined as the minimum threshold. the budgets need to be urgently increased because early diagnosis is vital to give parents the tools and information they need to prevent such failures happening in the first place.

Busybody2022 · 27/03/2023 07:11

It's awful and it worries me hugely this will give the green light for other trusts to follow.

My DD would have met the criteria as her placement broke down and we were on a CIN due to risk of family breakdown. We had already been in the system a year by this point awaiting assessment. She went from clearly autistic but a very happy child to in significant crisis in less than 6 months. Luckily already being on the list meant she got her diagnosis quite quickly once crisis point happened. Only having a referral accepted at the point of crisis and then starting the wait would have been unimaginable.

My younger child wouldn't meet the criteria, he's 6. Has expressive language on a par with 3-4 year olds and doubly incontinent. The fact he wouldn't be eligible to me is mind-blowing.

Diagnosis does matter. It is used to gate keep services. It is important for kids who need lots of extra help to know why they need extra help or you will end up with undiagnosed kids with huge amounts of support and clearly different with no understanding of the why on earth they have the help. The harm on a child's self esteem in that position is high.

Awful policy. Absolutely defies the entire principle of early intervention and support.

Swipe left for the next trending thread