Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

ASD diagnosis rationing

43 replies

Blinkingstars · 27/03/2023 06:11

https://amp.theguardian.com/society/2023/mar/26/children-put-at-risk-as-nhs-autism-assessments-are-cut-back

A health board is so overwhelmed with requests for ASD assessments that they have decided to ration them only to vulnerable kids. AIBU to be utterly outraged? My child would not meet the criteria but to be undiagnosed still would have been devastating for her. The primary teacher would still be giving her a telling off for running distraught out of classes like music when the volume got too much. She’d still be not understanding why she feels she’d odd compared to others (her words).

we waited 3 years for diagnosis as it was, after being told by the school that they would not heed a private diagnosis just an nhs one. It’s appalling how underfunded CAMHS but this is the absolute final straw.

‘Children put at risk’ as NHS autism assessments are cut back | Autism | The Guardian

Health service managers in south-west England say new restrictions are needed because of a huge rise in waiting lists

https://amp.theguardian.com/society/2023/mar/26/children-put-at-risk-as-nhs-autism-assessments-are-cut-back

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
TomeTome · 28/03/2023 13:14

Blinkingstars · 28/03/2023 11:50

I’m sorry, you can’t have chemo because you haven’t got dependant children. Is thus something you’d expect to hear? No. The diagnosis of autism is basic vital healthcare, not a ‘nice to have’ add on. It’s just outrageous.

I don’t know enough about chemo to make a good analogy but obviously not having access to health care is very worrying. However we are where we are and not in a world of plenty and limitless resources. We need to think hard about what we do with what we have. I think they are right to prioritise those in crisis right now, because anything else is unthinkable.

Train007 · 28/03/2023 12:06

I think people need to really open their eyes to health rationing! What is happening in SW is just a tip off the iceberg !
Soon it will cover all health conditions if we don’t keep our eye on the ball.
An example from me personally is that husband has now been refused referral to memory clinic (despite being told in 2018 that he had mild cognitive impairment ) because GP doesn’t in the 5 mins she spent with him feel his memory is bad enough!
Let’s wait now until he has full on dementia is how I have interpreted her decision!

SouthCountryGirl · 28/03/2023 11:58

TomeTome · 28/03/2023 10:17

We only have enough to help the most disabled by their autism and those that have reached crisis point. We have to do that then, because the alternative is NOT diagnosing the most disabled and vulnerable and using the resource elsewhere.

By the time they've reached crisis point they'll probably need mental health support on top which will cost the NHS more

Holly03 · 28/03/2023 11:56

It really is shocking. We have waited nearly 10 years and just got a diagnosis. My child was 1 when we started getting help and pushing for answers and now to be nearly 11 and heading to secondary school; he needed his dual diagnosis of autism and adhd to get the help he has needed for years. The system is broken. Parents are told it’s down to parenting in the early years and often left to just cope in between then after diagnosis there isn’t much support either. They are really letting families down, I don’t think my child would fit the criteria and it’s sad

Blinkingstars · 28/03/2023 11:50

TomeTome · 28/03/2023 10:17

We only have enough to help the most disabled by their autism and those that have reached crisis point. We have to do that then, because the alternative is NOT diagnosing the most disabled and vulnerable and using the resource elsewhere.

I’m sorry, you can’t have chemo because you haven’t got dependant children. Is thus something you’d expect to hear? No. The diagnosis of autism is basic vital healthcare, not a ‘nice to have’ add on. It’s just outrageous.

OP posts:
Jellycatspyjamas · 28/03/2023 11:25

We only have enough to help the most disabled by their autism and those that have reached crisis point.

But if they have to reach crisis point to even be eligible for assessment and then wait excessively long period for that assessment much less any kind of support and intervention that’s a lot of families living in crisis for long periods of time. Which raises the risk of longer term harm, poor mental health and ultimately potential suicide.

We can’t look down the road and predict those who will reach crisis point, so surely early assessment and intervention makes much more sense even from a resource issue instead of constantly fire fighting.

Random789 · 28/03/2023 11:09

But TomeTome, we don't know who the most disabled are until they are assessed (and, if appropriate, diagnosed). The bureaucratic process of deciding who goes where on a waiting list isn't the same as an assessmnet of need.
(Hercules, many thanks x)

TomeTome · 28/03/2023 10:17

We only have enough to help the most disabled by their autism and those that have reached crisis point. We have to do that then, because the alternative is NOT diagnosing the most disabled and vulnerable and using the resource elsewhere.

HerculesMulligan · 28/03/2023 10:12

Random789 · 28/03/2023 07:48

"Just read the criteria, when my dd was diagnosed, communication difficulties was a criteria for diagnosis, it's a key feature of autism so makes sense that kids being assessed have key traits"

Communication difficulties are among the criteria for diagnoses, but autism is varied, and these difficulties aren't always present to a degree that meets the threshold. So there is nothing sensible about making them a criterion for even getting assessment.

When my son was assessed (by the NHS), the finding was that his very good language skills had masked the extent of his autism. That made life very much harder for him because other people could not very easily see the awful difficulties he faced.
That article only specifies three of the assessment criteria, but since it mentions that he risk of death by suicide is greater for autistic people without intellectual disability, I'm gathering that the effect of the criteria combined is to make it harder for higher functioning people to access help.
This was my son's situation. I believe he was much more profoundly disabled than his presentation suggested. And that contributed an extra level of suffering and need. And he did in fact kill himself.

Random, I am so, so sorry for your loss. What a devastating thing to happen.

Random789 · 28/03/2023 07:48

"Just read the criteria, when my dd was diagnosed, communication difficulties was a criteria for diagnosis, it's a key feature of autism so makes sense that kids being assessed have key traits"

Communication difficulties are among the criteria for diagnoses, but autism is varied, and these difficulties aren't always present to a degree that meets the threshold. So there is nothing sensible about making them a criterion for even getting assessment.

When my son was assessed (by the NHS), the finding was that his very good language skills had masked the extent of his autism. That made life very much harder for him because other people could not very easily see the awful difficulties he faced.
That article only specifies three of the assessment criteria, but since it mentions that he risk of death by suicide is greater for autistic people without intellectual disability, I'm gathering that the effect of the criteria combined is to make it harder for higher functioning people to access help.
This was my son's situation. I believe he was much more profoundly disabled than his presentation suggested. And that contributed an extra level of suffering and need. And he did in fact kill himself.

Busybody2022 · 28/03/2023 07:16

Thriwit · 27/03/2023 21:14

My DS was assessed privately a couple of years ago (we couldn’t wait on the NHS list any longer, he was refusing school, self-harming etc). I had 1.5 hours talking to them about him, then 2 people spent 2-3 hours each (on separate occasions) talking to and playing with him, and another visited him at school to see him there and talk to his teachers. I felt that it was a very thorough assessment, and their report was very detailed.

I know there are some very dodgy-looking “assessments” available privately (although I’ve mainly seen them for adults - an hour zoom meeting, for example), but there are some private assessments which really are thorough.

This sounds similar to the private assessment my DS is in the middle of.

90 minute initial appointment with a Paediatrician (also works at our NHS CDC)

90 minute HL SALT assessment

90 minute clinical psychologist assessment

Further 90 minute appointment with Paediatrician

Outcome 60 minute appointment.

£2550 which is painful. Our NHS equivalent is all squeezed into a few brief appointments.

Thriwit · 27/03/2023 21:14

Redraddisho27 · 27/03/2023 20:59

We are going through NHS Child Development Centre for suspected autism for two of my children. There is NOTHING thorough about it. Each of them have had two (30 minute) meetings with one paediatrician, BOSA (playing games for 40 mins with a Speech Therapist looking for patterns of speech) and filling in the forms twice... all this has taken place over 3/4 years that apparently counts as a thorough examination of whether they are autistic or not. Currently as it stands by Summer (one last 30 min meeting to say if they are or aren't) i think one will get diagnosed and one won't. The one that won't i can fully imagine having a breakdown in a few years! I wish i had gone private.

My DS was assessed privately a couple of years ago (we couldn’t wait on the NHS list any longer, he was refusing school, self-harming etc). I had 1.5 hours talking to them about him, then 2 people spent 2-3 hours each (on separate occasions) talking to and playing with him, and another visited him at school to see him there and talk to his teachers. I felt that it was a very thorough assessment, and their report was very detailed.

I know there are some very dodgy-looking “assessments” available privately (although I’ve mainly seen them for adults - an hour zoom meeting, for example), but there are some private assessments which really are thorough.

Redraddisho27 · 27/03/2023 20:59

gogohmm · 27/03/2023 08:50

Just read the criteria, when my dd was diagnosed, communication difficulties was a criteria for diagnosis, it's a key feature of autism so makes sense that kids being assessed have key traits. When did that change?

I live in that area, theres people talking about it, though as the head of my local school said, it's amazing how many kids of wealthier families have a diagnosis currently compared to the ones she's really concerned about! She's convinced that the pushy parents get a diagnosis because they think it's going to get extra time in exams ... I'm not convinced it is that simple but something is afoot.

My DD's diagnosis was very thorough, took multiple visits and reports from various professionals, whereas now it seems you can pay privately and it takes a couple of hours, makes me suspicious that autism is being diagnosed when it's actually more complicated

We are going through NHS Child Development Centre for suspected autism for two of my children. There is NOTHING thorough about it. Each of them have had two (30 minute) meetings with one paediatrician, BOSA (playing games for 40 mins with a Speech Therapist looking for patterns of speech) and filling in the forms twice... all this has taken place over 3/4 years that apparently counts as a thorough examination of whether they are autistic or not. Currently as it stands by Summer (one last 30 min meeting to say if they are or aren't) i think one will get diagnosed and one won't. The one that won't i can fully imagine having a breakdown in a few years! I wish i had gone private.

Ontheperiphery79 · 27/03/2023 20:30

It's not only North Somerset/Bristol/South Glos; I believe similar has happened in an area of Yorkshire.

Blinkingstars · 27/03/2023 20:27

Why wait for kids to be in crisis? Every area of kids mental health they just wait until the very worst possible crisis for the kid before they actually do anything. The trauma for the child is massive, and then it also affects the rest of the family. ‘A stitch in time’ applies so much here

OP posts:
Ontheperiphery79 · 27/03/2023 19:30

I live within this area and it's been a fucking shambles.
My DC (twins, 5) were just about to be referred and I was waiting for the school to complete their part of the referral.
The school's SENDco had no prior knowledge of the change in rhe referral criteria (which was March 1st). The service provider, Sirona, demonstrated an outrageously badly inadequate roll out of information (and predominantly after the event).
I found out by chance from Community Paeds and it was me who informed our school's SENDco, who then spread the word amongst her SENDco network.
As we missed the cut off for referral through the old system, neither my twin DC meet the new referral criteria. Nor do I have the financial privilege of being able to go private.
I feel defeated, but still tirelessly advocating on behalf of my DC, including transferring Twin 2 to another school in area from next term.
It doesn't feel hopeless as such, as I will keep fighting for my daughters, but as a long term physically unwell AuDHDer, I only have so much fight in me as a financially disadvantaged and somewhat socially isolated solo parent.

Whatafustercluck · 27/03/2023 19:04

Savemyseat · 27/03/2023 12:29

It’s also hard at schools. Support is meant to be based on need but it’s often not the case- they take a diagnosis much more seriously but getting that diagnosis is so hard
we did get told through we had paid for them to write what we asked for !!! I pointed out that the diagnosis was based on the same criteria and assessments the nhs do and by a consultant who also works in the nhs …

We made this point exactly in a meeting earlier with dd's school. I asked if she's on the school SEN register and they said no, they prefer a diagnosis. I said that was unlikely to happen in the time she has remaining at infants. Thankfully our case worker from the LA pushed back on that too and they've agreed to add her.

Blinkingstars · 27/03/2023 16:38

stbrandonsboat · 27/03/2023 12:04

If they could sort out the behavioural chaos in schools, ND students might be better able to cope. Schools are just bear pits now driven by cruelty - bullying by other students - noise and social confusion.

My first secondary school - back in the 80s - was well run, quite old fashioned and the other students were normal young people as opposed to the bullying psychopaths we have now. Yes there was the odd bully, but nothing they did was extreme or unmanageable. I then had to leave that school due to moving and the next school was a complete contrast. It was poorly run by some trendy liberal, bullying was rife to the point of an English teacher ending up in tears once and I fell apart. Ended up with school phobia/refusal.

ND students cope better in a well controlled, calm atmosphere where the other students aren't permitted to step out of line. There are other elements which help, but which people pour scorn on now, so they aren't coming back unfortunately and I'm not referring to corporal punishment before anyone wonders.

100% this. My child would be fine in mainstream schooling if there was a basic control of low level poor behaviour - she’d love it - but hates school because she gets bullied all day every day for being different. The school does nothing.

OP posts:
Savemyseat · 27/03/2023 12:29

GreenistheGrass · 27/03/2023 12:24

It's disgraceful, and will only increase bigotry.

There was an awful thread just yesterday on "commonplace things you wish weren't socially acceptable" that devolved into several posters ranting that people who seek diagnoses for conditions like this are just attention-seeking naval gazers who are stealing NHS resources from people with real conditions.

There's some disgraceful attitudes in the world towards neurodivergence.

It’s also hard at schools. Support is meant to be based on need but it’s often not the case- they take a diagnosis much more seriously but getting that diagnosis is so hard
we did get told through we had paid for them to write what we asked for !!! I pointed out that the diagnosis was based on the same criteria and assessments the nhs do and by a consultant who also works in the nhs …

GreenistheGrass · 27/03/2023 12:24

It's disgraceful, and will only increase bigotry.

There was an awful thread just yesterday on "commonplace things you wish weren't socially acceptable" that devolved into several posters ranting that people who seek diagnoses for conditions like this are just attention-seeking naval gazers who are stealing NHS resources from people with real conditions.

There's some disgraceful attitudes in the world towards neurodivergence.

Savemyseat · 27/03/2023 12:08

I dont think it’s a new thing more that this is the first time the truth has been told.

My ds had 4 referrals put in over 6 months (2x HV, 1xSALT , 1xGP) all rejected. He is severely autistic and we had to go private . We aren’t in the SW, the reasons given for rejecting the referrals were not acceptable either .

stbrandonsboat · 27/03/2023 12:04

If they could sort out the behavioural chaos in schools, ND students might be better able to cope. Schools are just bear pits now driven by cruelty - bullying by other students - noise and social confusion.

My first secondary school - back in the 80s - was well run, quite old fashioned and the other students were normal young people as opposed to the bullying psychopaths we have now. Yes there was the odd bully, but nothing they did was extreme or unmanageable. I then had to leave that school due to moving and the next school was a complete contrast. It was poorly run by some trendy liberal, bullying was rife to the point of an English teacher ending up in tears once and I fell apart. Ended up with school phobia/refusal.

ND students cope better in a well controlled, calm atmosphere where the other students aren't permitted to step out of line. There are other elements which help, but which people pour scorn on now, so they aren't coming back unfortunately and I'm not referring to corporal punishment before anyone wonders.

Whatafustercluck · 27/03/2023 11:15

As a parent of a so-called "high functioning, fine at school" 6yo trying desperately to get support for our dd who has been school refusing since Feb half term, this makes me so angry, sad and frustrated.

We had our EHCP needs assessment turned down on Thursday last week. Despite clear evidence of masking, in girls in particular, the LA insist on insinuating it's the parents' fault by pointing out inconsistencies between home and school behaviours and using that as the reasoning behind turning down our application.

We'd been warned that the default position for most LAs is to reject an EHCPNA, saying that 98% of SEN children's needs can be met within existing SEN funding envelopes. It's clear to every parent living through this, that without an EHCP many schools cannot adequately meet children's needs.

We've jumped through hoops, done all the parent led behavioural modification stuff, have a 12yo son who is thriving and liked by everyone. Dd has high levels of school based anxiety and sensory processing issues. Her whole day at school is spent keeping in all her worries, to the point where she simply breaks down and avoids clothing altogether. But she's 'meeting expectations', or at least was before she started refusing to go to school.

We've spent 3 months trying to get the final piece of evidence we need for a neurodevelopmental assessment via CAMHS. And then there's a two year wait. No assessment, no EHCP in the meantime, one of us facing the prospect of having to give up work. It's the shittiest of shit situations - and many people have it even worse than us. At least our dd sleeps well, so we get a break then. Loads of parents don't have the time, the remaining energy, the knowledge or the skills to navigate such a complex myriad of pathways, professional services, regulations and rights. The system is desperately broken, fundamentally flawed. We have a last resort of paying to go private. Most don't even have that option. It's an absolute shambles and a disgrace.

LakieLady · 27/03/2023 10:45

MH serviTeh ces for children are appalling imo.

A friend's son has been under CAMHS for almost 6 years. He's been out of school for approx 5 of those years, save for a couple of sessions at a "teaching and learning unit" that was woefully inappropriate for him. She has tried and tried to get help for him, but whenever she spoke to CAMHS, their response was that "He's not Tier 3, so there's a long wait".

He shows many signs of ASD, along with a whole raft of other MH issues, eg PTSD, social anxiety disorder, general anxiety disorder. He will only leave the house on very rare occasions, because he can't bear people "looking at" him. He has had no meaningful input from CAMHS in all that time, just 2 online therapy sessions, which he really struggled with because he is hearing impaired.

Friend was at the GP the other day for a physical health issue and the doctor asked about her MH. She completely lost it, broke down, and told the GP everything that had been going on. GP said she was going to speak to CAMHS, and within days friend had had a call from a psychiatrist and he now has an appointment and has been referred for autism assessment.

The whole system is totally fucked up. And it's a false economy, because the lack of appropriate input for children means more of them end up having lifelong struggles with their MH.

Swipe left for the next trending thread