Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my landlady is being weird?

199 replies

TwentyTeens · 26/03/2023 22:22

I've lived here for 8 years and she's visited once near the start of my tenancy.
Yesterday she suddenly messaged me out of the blue wanting to "drop in" in a few days to see the house and "catch up"

Unfortunately I have a chronic pain condition and am currently feeling terrible and definitely not up to visitors, so I asked if we could postpone and offered to send photos and said I could manage a phone call if she needed to talk to me in the meantime
She agreed to this and I sent pics and video of the house which she seemed happy with.
I then asked what it was all about as I was a bit concerned and when did she want to phone me.
She said again that she wanted to "catch up" and also do a rent review. But didnt answer about calling me.

Ok so fair enough about the rent. I was actually expecting it this year and I told her I was happy to discuss it on the phone as soon as she liked since I really have no idea when I'll be well enough to see her.

I assumed she would want to get this sorted asap and, as I told her, I might be ill for a month or more. Not that I'm anxious to have my rent increased lol. But I'm looking at it from her viewpoint.

However, she has ignored that message and not got back to me.

I don't understand this. It's as if she doesn't want to discuss this on the phone. We usually message but have spoken on the phone before so I don't think it's that.

I understand that she wants to come round and I won't have a problem with this when I'm feeling better. But in the meantime...

And what does she mean by "catching up"?
I mean she's a nice woman and a decent LL and we get on ok but we aren't "friends"
There is nothing about the house I need to discuss and I'm sure she isn't remotely interested in the minutae of my life and I'm certainly not interested in hers.
Just seems an odd way to phrase it.

So AIBU to think she's being a bit weird? Or a bit funny with me?

Or am I being paranoid or am I missing something?

Any landlords on here who can perhaps give me some insight?

OP posts:
FannyPhart · 27/03/2023 08:24

How do we know inspections haven't been put off with excuses the last 7 years?

TommyNever · 27/03/2023 08:26

pixie5121 said:
"OP is sick, so it's not a suitable time! Not sure what part of that is so hard to understand?"

Whether the tenant is ill or not shouldn't really make any difference. Property inspections can take place without the tenant in attendance. All the owner or agent has to do is schedule a time and if the tenant is absent or otherwise unable to come to the door, the owner or agent has a key and can let themselves in.

CaveatmTOR · 27/03/2023 08:29

Very few LLs would evict due to untidiness or even a bit of dirt. It's the fabric of the building and if it can be brought back to how it was within the value of the bond they hold, that is of interest. That's all I have been interested in as well as scoping out if the tenant is happy and likely to stay or whatever.

One of my tenants moaned about a massive tree that wasn't even in the garden. I paid £330 to have it taken down as well as everything else incumbent on a LL and she still damaged my property as she left. The more I did for her, the more she wanted. Some people want a concierge, not a LL.

It really has to be a two way street and a lot of private LLs are working on tiny margins. The UK would be fucked without them.

Seymour5 · 27/03/2023 08:32

@TwentyTeens If your home needed an urgent repair, how would you deal with tradesmen coming in whilst you are unwell? I think you could be risking a change of relationship with your landlord by taking the stance you have. I hope I’m wrong, but if she has to go to the lengths and expense of a court order just to do a basic inspection, then you may en up facing a section 21. I hope you and she can come to an agreement re an inspection.

LumpyandBumps · 27/03/2023 08:38

BreadPittt · 27/03/2023 08:17

If you've rented same property for 15 years or so and landlord then wishes to sell, do they have to sell with said tenant as a sitting tenant? ie tenant can't be evicted?

If a correct Assured Shorthold tenancy is in place the tenant never becomes a sitting tenant who can’t be evicted.
Some tenancies prior to the change in rules sometime in the late 1980’s do give sitting tenant rights.
Some landlords will market the property subject to an existing Assured Shorthold tenancy, so the tenant can remain even when they are not a ‘sitting tenant’ - this doesn’t prevent the new owner from taking eviction action though.

TommyNever · 27/03/2023 08:38

The LL sounds negligent in this case as apparently she hasn't had a peep at the place for eight years. In eight years there may well be things that need repairing or replacing by now, so it's certainly in the interest of the tenant for the owner to visit.

I get the impression that the tenant is worrying simply because the owner taking an interest in the place is such a novelty, but there needn't be cause for alarm.

LennyCrabbitz · 27/03/2023 08:41

"Again, quote the legislation that allows this, or be quiet."

Fucking hell 🤪

KnittingNeedles · 27/03/2023 08:42

The LL sounds negligent in this case as apparently she hasn't had a peep at the place for eight years.

Landlords really can't win. No inspection for 8 years means that she is negligent and letting the OP live in a dangerous slum, wanting to do an inspection is an outrageous request which must be fought through the courts.

LennyCrabbitz · 27/03/2023 08:42

"Legality is all that matters" 🤓

Someone have one too many last night @VeniVidiWeeWee 🤪

Daffodilsandbeer · 27/03/2023 08:45

Op it appears you don’t live there alone, you’ve at least one daughter living there, how many of you live there?

TommyNever · 27/03/2023 08:53

KnittingNeedles · 27/03/2023 08:42

The LL sounds negligent in this case as apparently she hasn't had a peep at the place for eight years.

Landlords really can't win. No inspection for 8 years means that she is negligent and letting the OP live in a dangerous slum, wanting to do an inspection is an outrageous request which must be fought through the courts.

No-one mentioned dangerous slums, but government Tenancy Acts usually ensure that regular property inspections are actually a legal obligation for the owner, for the tenant's sake as much as the owner's.

DuchessOfMuck · 27/03/2023 08:54

I think this is very simple. The question you should be asking is do you like living there? Sorry if this sounds harsh. Look

If you don't give the opportunity for the LL to visit, it would raise suspicions about the state of the property and she might feel another more amiable tenant might be easier than court ordered inspections etc.

I think you should arrange a time with the LL when someone else is there, maybe a carer. It's annoying and the last thing you need when you're ill but its just one of those things you have to do

loislovesstewie · 27/03/2023 08:57

Well, being practical about it, unless the landlord visits you won't know what she is planning. If there have been no upgrades to the property she might be planning those. She might want to check it's not a pig sty, she might be planning to sell. That's just conjecture. In my opinion a landlord should do regular, planned inspections to ensure the property is not deteriorating. I understand that you have a health issue but please, just arrange the inspection. You are just putting off the inevitable.

MarchMadness23 · 27/03/2023 08:58

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at poster's request.

@pixie5121 I didn't say it was exactly the same thing. I said I understood how uncomfortable it is, but that life goes on around us, even when we are chronically ill.

there's nothing to suggest the LL doesn't believe the OP, you're just stirring. A LL isn't going to evict a long standing, good tenant, because it's a bit messy or not immaculate.

saraclara · 27/03/2023 09:01

It isn't 'your' property if someone else is paying to live in it.

Whose is it then, @pixie5121 ? Because somehow, magically, it becomes the landlord's when something goes wrong and needs fixing. Or the mortgage on it needs paying. Or it's found to be unsafe.

ScentOfAMemory · 27/03/2023 09:08

RichardHeed · 27/03/2023 07:44

Unfortunately, in the current rental market, if the landlord says jump, you say how high

As you can see by the disgusting attitudes of the PPs here. It’s funny isn’t it, the landlord hasn’t have a flying fucking about visiting the property in 7 years, now OP must bend over backwards to accommodate said shitty, negligent landlord, while battling a chronic condition (which said PPs clearly have no fucking clue about, grim) and it is OP that is in the wrong. 30 days to give OP a chance to come out the other side isn’t being obstructive ffs! She isn’t refusing an inspection, simply asking for a little bit of time to get better and allow a proper inspection and a chat.

Do you know how demeaning and dehumanising it would be to drag a friend over and hide under the covers while she pokes around? No, we don’t treat people like this!!! A simple reasonable adjustment given OPs current health condition.

If this happened every 6 months people might have a point about op being obstructive but to, at the first hurdle say things like OP is a red flag is fucking vile.

Projecting much.
Neither the OP, or any previous posters (apart from the Very Angry On All Threads one and her sidekick) have said anything like what you've said is happening.
The OP sounds reasonable enough. The LL sounds reasonable enough.

Winesflowinglikeglue · 27/03/2023 09:13

Check your tenancy agreement. You should make every effort to allow your LL access. It probably won't take her very long to inspect the property and you could just stay in one room when she does?

Queenofscones · 27/03/2023 09:14

alwayscrashinginthesamecar1 · 26/03/2023 23:57

I'm really surprised that landlords need a court order to inspect their houses, no wonder they are selling up! Here in Australia its pretty standard to get an inspection every three months. It is a huge pain as they can be pretty strict (I got a breach once for some weeds in the garden), but you get used to it and it means that properties are kept in good order. It is a good incentive to buy though!

They don't. They're legally entitled to inspect and if anyone had ever read their tenancy agreement properly they'll see that the landlord or the landlord's agent are entitled to enter and inspect the property at intervals, after giving the tenant notice.

OP, here are some possibiities:
She herself may have been ill or so tied up by caring or work commitments she's been unable to make the time to come and visit in the past.
She may be coming to see what needs doing in the house. She may want to improve things for you — discuss a new kitchen or bathroom or electrical work or improvement to the roof or heating system — to keep the property in good order and make it more comfortable for you to live there. Also, the standards landlords and certificates landlords are supposed to meet have changed in the last seven years and she may need to talk to you about improvements you will be unhappy with. For example, if the electrical system needs testing and replacing, that can be disruptive.

I think responding that you're too unwell and need a month or more before seeing her might ring alarm bells. Would that month be used to clear up the garden and tidy the place up and try and make good all the damage done over the last few years? Not saying that you've done any damage, but that may be what she's thinking. If the place is in good order, have your carer there to let her in and show her around and have a brief face-to-face.

meg54 · 27/03/2023 09:17

Landlord of 25 years standing here, and quite shocked at some of the information the OP is being offered from both sides of the fence.

OP.
You say that the LL "suddenly messaged you out of the blue yesterday", yet you think this is a bit weird after 8 years? and asking strangers online for insight? Within 24 hours?
Your LL has said it is to catch up and have a rent review.
You have told her you are unwell, and may not feel better for sometime, but again, as she has not responded within 24 hours she's ignoring you? Even after you told her of your illness - could she be wary of making your condition worse by visiting?

There could be many reasons the LL wants to visit in person.
The catch up could be her insurance policy requires visits regularly.
As it's her house she may be looking to improve something, after 8 years does anything need replaced/updated/thrown out, redecorated.
It could be new legislation that you need to be aware of, or any of a multitude of things involved in running a house. Or just a peek to see if it's being well maintained.
So I don't think your LL is being weird or funny with you.

You obviously have a mutual respectful working relationship with her.
I would recommend you contact her to discuss the rent review and offer to proceed without a personal visit, and when you feel up to it agree a date for a face to face visit.
Good luck and I hope your health improves soon.
MEG.
PS. I have never visited a tenant whose house was not a damn sight cleaner or tidier than my own!

justasking111 · 27/03/2023 09:21

@TwentyTeens can another adult arrange to let her in for the inspection. It's quite normal. When we do it are looking for problems, leaks, damp, blown double glazing, decorating, carpeting. Anything that needs fixing outside, fencing, roof tiles, etc. It's the fabric of the building that's important for both of you.

In Wales you'll be signing a new contract.

Daffodilsandbeer · 27/03/2023 09:22

Landlords only need a court order if a tenant refuses access. A court order is simply the court enforcing the landlords rights to access their property. It’s not a court case to decide if they should or should not access.

the legal costs associated with it are usually ordered by the court to be paid by the tenant but it is usually legally advised to go straight for eviction instead and follow that notice process as if you need to get a court injunction to enter it’s highly likely you want to evict anyway due to the refusal.

so to clarify if a tenant refuses access, as much as you can go for a court order and the client will need to pay for it in the end, irs normally legally advisable not to bother, just to serve notice instead and follow that process, as if that goes to court to evict the client has to normally pay costs also.

caringcarer · 27/03/2023 09:26

I'm a LL with 8 houses to let. I only inspect houses once a year when I call around for tenants to sign new rental agreement. If everything looks ok in lounge I don't intrude into bedrooms. I know I probably should but my tenants have mostly been with me lots of years so I trust them. However if when I wanted to drop by to get new agreement signed I was put off for over a month I'd be a bit suspicious. Can't you have a friend or your dd there to let LL in? The LL obviously wants to talk with you in person. If you have not had a visit before in 8 years I think you are being unreasonable and I think a court would agree.

caringcarer · 27/03/2023 09:31

I wanted a face to face with my tenants last when I wanted to have new laminate flooring downstairs and I wanted to give them a choice of which one they wanted and when would be convenient for maintenance person to come. If they refused to let me come to show them options I'd simply pick one myself then they'd lose their choice. If you have not had an inspection in 8 years surely it is time for LL to redecorate. I redecorate my properties every five years.

thethinendofthewedge · 27/03/2023 09:34

I think it's reasonable to want to see a property in person as photos or film footage don't always give the full information. If I was a LL I'd want to see the place myself or have a reliable agent do it for me. I imagine your LL has been very relaxed and trusting about your tenancy but maybe something has changed. She might be considering selling up or some major works but doesn't want to tell you yet and prefers to discuss things in person.

I think you need to invite her round as soon as you're up to it then both you and the LL will be reassured. I presume you want to stay living there.

Ariela · 27/03/2023 09:39

It may just be she is thinking after 7 years a rent increase might scare you off. And perhaps she wants to discuss with you in person as she is grateful to have such a reasonable tenant for so long - as opposed to put it up w/o explanation and risk you leaving