Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that a three year jail sentence is unreasonable for the disabled pedestrian who was found guilty of causing the death of a cyclist

646 replies

DotAndCarryOne2 · 26/03/2023 20:30

The Sunday Times and The Guardian carried this story earlier this month and again today, as did GB News. Link is below. I just find it unbelievable that so much relevant information about this lady’s disability was either ignored or dismissed by the judge, and that she didn’t have adequate representation at sentencing.
https://www.google.co.uk/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=&ved=2ahUKEwjj6omaqvr9AhWJbcAKHVv9DMkQFnoECAkQAQ&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.independent.co.uk%2Fnews%2Fuk%2Fhome-news%2Fcyclist-manslaughter-auriol-grey-cambridgeshire-b2294507.html&usg=AOvVaw1yOHhh6F4zfEel6m4EMYpL

https://www.google.co.uk/url?sa=t&rct=j&q=&esrc=s&source=web&cd=&ved=2ahUKEwjj6omaqvr9AhWJbcAKHVv9DMkQFnoECAkQAQ&url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.independent.co.uk%2Fnews%2Fuk%2Fhome-news%2Fcyclist-manslaughter-auriol-grey-cambridgeshire-b2294507.html&usg=AOvVaw1yOHhh6F4zfEel6m4EMYpL

OP posts:
Thread gallery
16
DotAndCarryOne2 · 27/03/2023 14:03

freyamay74 · 27/03/2023 13:50

Healthy debate is one thing but unfortunately a few people have expressed the view that AG's disability automatically means the process must be flawed. Or that having a disability and being a nasty aggressive person can't co-exist. And that anyone who disagrees can't possibly have any knowledge or experience of the subject.

The fact there is an appeal (against the sentence, not the conviction) means nothing really... it's a fairly common procedure and I would have expected it in this case.

Where has anyone suggested that because there is a disability it ‘automatically’ means the process must be flawed ? Or that it’s not possible to be disabled and also be an awful person. I certainly haven’t. And I think you’ll find it’s the majority of posters who don’t support Grey who are intolerant and critical of those who do.

OP posts:
Ktime · 27/03/2023 14:00

DotAndCarryOne2 · 27/03/2023 13:54

If you scroll upthread to the link to The Times article you’ll find the same info I did. The appeal that’s being prepared is on a number of issues including whether procedures were followed and due consideration given to the evidence presented - which speaks to the safety of the conviction. The barrister us working pro bono so they clearly believe that something was amiss with her defence.

No, it doesn't Dot. The Times article also says "Last week, her legal team filed an appeal against her sentence.' No one is talking about appealing the conviction expect you.

freyamay74 · 27/03/2023 13:57

@ArcticSkewer she lied in the interview about her actions and what she had said. That's the thing that screamed out at me. Why would she lie in a police interview if she believed she'd done nothing wrong.

And yes, it was reported that a bystander told her to leave the scene because it was so horrific to witness and of course bystanders wouldn't for a moment believe anyone could be so callous as to have caused the incident. The lies about her actions and words are the aggravating issues though.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 27/03/2023 13:54

Ktime · 27/03/2023 13:45

You are wrong because you keep saying that she is appealing to 'ensure that the conviction was safe' but this is not what's happening. The Criminal Appeal Court has confirmed that Grey has lodged her application for leave to appeal against her sentence.

This is different to appealing the jury’s verdict, which is that she was GUILTY and which is not not being challenged.

If you scroll upthread to the link to The Times article you’ll find the same info I did. The appeal that’s being prepared is on a number of issues including whether procedures were followed and due consideration given to the evidence presented - which speaks to the safety of the conviction. The barrister us working pro bono so they clearly believe that something was amiss with her defence.

OP posts:
ArcticSkewer · 27/03/2023 13:51

I put a link to the Times Article but I can post another, plus just watched the initial police interview which I can link to if anyone wants to watch it.

I don't think she has a solicitor with her at that interview. I was surprised. So possibly just an appropriate adult, which can be a volunteer rather than someone who knows the person.

I noticed for example in the police interview when she is asked why she left the scene, she doesn't say that she was told to leave by a bystander, yet apparently that's what happened. A family member as appropriate adult might have been able to intervene and would certainly have got her a solicitor, if they had any sense.

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/4d1eb570-cb22-11ed-9386-0ff7738b71b1?shareToken=d1821a573e5f0a76932301f144788069

Branded ‘the pavement killer’, Auriol Grey should not be in jail for cyclist death, says her family

Shortly after the sudden death of his wife, Genny, Alisdair Luxmoore wrote to her elderly mother reassuring her that he would still care for Genny’s vulnerable sister, Auriol Grey.Typed on to A4 paper, a note outlining the future of the family’s affair...

https://www.thetimes.co.uk/article/4d1eb570-cb22-11ed-9386-0ff7738b71b1?shareToken=d1821a573e5f0a76932301f144788069

JackiePlace · 27/03/2023 13:51

I agree with you OP.
This won't be the first incident of this type. Something needs to be done about the ongoing conflict between pavement cyclists and pedestrians. Local authorities do nothing to police these cyclists... theyshould be identified and fined/barred from operating a vehicle!

freyamay74 · 27/03/2023 13:50

Healthy debate is one thing but unfortunately a few people have expressed the view that AG's disability automatically means the process must be flawed. Or that having a disability and being a nasty aggressive person can't co-exist. And that anyone who disagrees can't possibly have any knowledge or experience of the subject.

The fact there is an appeal (against the sentence, not the conviction) means nothing really... it's a fairly common procedure and I would have expected it in this case.

Ktime · 27/03/2023 13:45

DotAndCarryOne2 · 27/03/2023 13:17

Well you’re both wrong aren’t you ? The barrister is working pro bono on an appeal. That’s called FACT. Not CSI or any other fantasy, but fact. And you don’t know the first thing about me or what my profession is, so you’re in no position to comment are you ? Absolutely astounding that sp many people are wilfully misreading, misunderstanding or looking for things that just aren’t there, or are so wrapped up in their own versions of the events that they’re unwilling to look at the facts you so easily accuse me of not being interested in when it was the whole point of my post.

You are wrong because you keep saying that she is appealing to 'ensure that the conviction was safe' but this is not what's happening. The Criminal Appeal Court has confirmed that Grey has lodged her application for leave to appeal against her sentence.

This is different to appealing the jury’s verdict, which is that she was GUILTY and which is not not being challenged.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 27/03/2023 13:45

It will be the appeal judges who will decide, for a fact, if due process was or wasnt followed or if the judge did or didn't take her disabilities into account - not you, not the lawyers and not the press.

And not the wannabe judge, jury and executioners on MN either.

OP posts:
OneTC · 27/03/2023 13:44

I don't think there's really much healthy debate left in the topic.

I also wonder what people think the average prisoner is like in terms of intellectual and mental capacity, but that's a whole other thread. Whether you agree or disagree with people with low level MH issues ending up in mainstream prison is a separate issue. There's loads of people in prison with similar or less capacity than AG. rightly or wrongly this is how we currently deal with it as a society but I don't see widespread sympathy for prisoners in general.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 27/03/2023 13:41

Ktime · 27/03/2023 13:15

@DotAndCarryOne2 do you have a link to the newspaper report? Auriol clearly has someone with her in the interview room, I don't know who it is but I highly doubt the police would have refused to inform her family.

Also, my post was addressed to lovelysausage so not sure what you mean by "and if you haven’t read it on the thread, then I haven’t said it"?

I coudn’t provide a link to the newspaper article, as I pointed out at the start - its behind a paywall, but someone else has posted it upthread somewhere. And apologies - I replied to your post in error, and irritation to be honest.There are so many people starting their posts with ‘are you saying’ and ‘so what you’re saying is’ when people, including myself, are saying what they mean, not putting the intent of their wording up for debate. Sausage and any other poster showing support for Grey seem to have been driven off the thread now and it seems to me that the thread has degenerated to the point where anyone expressing a different POV is set upon. I seem to be universally regarded as the world’s worst for starting it, so it clearly hasn’t instigated the healthy debate I intended.

OP posts:
freyamay74 · 27/03/2023 13:27

If anyone hasn't watched clips of the police interview I'd recommend it. The level of manipulation is interesting... AG claims she 'can't remember' what she did, until the officer points out an enlarged freeze frame from the cctv showing AG's hand on the cyclist's jacket. Then she can't deny that she made physical contact. When the officer goes on to tell AG that her mouth is moving, indicating she was saying something, AG claims she said 'slow down.' Total lie. When the officer goes on to say the cctv actually has audio too, and plays it, where AG is clearly heard shouting 'get off the fucking pavement', she then says she doesn't know what she meant.

These are all aggravating issues which suggest a custodial sentence is entirely appropriate. AG could have chosen to be honest, which would likely have reduced her sentence going by sentencing guidelines. Instead she lied.

I have no sympathy for AG, and frankly whether the appeal is upheld or not, I think her life outside prison isn't going to be a bed of roses after what she's done. But however hellish it is, it's no doubt less hellish than what she's inflicted on the cyclist, her family, the car driver, her family, and anyone else who had the misfortune to witness such a horrible, frightening, totally avoidable death.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 27/03/2023 13:17

Ktime · 27/03/2023 12:54

She's not interested in facts, she's pumped full of her own importance talking about 'due process' and 'unsafe convictions', because she's watched a few episodes of CSI and thinks she's an expert.

Well you’re both wrong aren’t you ? The barrister is working pro bono on an appeal. That’s called FACT. Not CSI or any other fantasy, but fact. And you don’t know the first thing about me or what my profession is, so you’re in no position to comment are you ? Absolutely astounding that sp many people are wilfully misreading, misunderstanding or looking for things that just aren’t there, or are so wrapped up in their own versions of the events that they’re unwilling to look at the facts you so easily accuse me of not being interested in when it was the whole point of my post.

OP posts:
Ktime · 27/03/2023 13:15

@DotAndCarryOne2 do you have a link to the newspaper report? Auriol clearly has someone with her in the interview room, I don't know who it is but I highly doubt the police would have refused to inform her family.

Also, my post was addressed to lovelysausage so not sure what you mean by "and if you haven’t read it on the thread, then I haven’t said it"?

minou123 · 27/03/2023 13:14

DotAndCarryOne2 · 27/03/2023 12:32

So despite agreeing that the appeal will examine fairness and due process in the legal sense by scrutinising consideration of the evidence - in other words ensure that the conviction was safe - and given that that process has not yet started, you, as a lawyer, are glad she was convicted ? Ok then.

Right, so we've got there.

So, you understand that the appeal judges will examine fairness and due process in the legal sense by scrutinising consideration of the evidence and that the process has not yet started.

Bearing that in mind, how do you know, for a fact, that due process wasn't followed or the judge didn't take her disabilities into consideration?

Just because someone has appealed doesn't automatically mean the conviction or sentencing wasn't safe.

All it means us the defendant, and her lawyer, believe that due process wasn't followed.

I've posted this before on this thread, but I'll try again.
Wayne Couzens, the police officer who killed Sarah Everard, put in an appeal.

He was given a whole life sentence and he appealed stating that due process wasn't followed.

He is entitled to do that.
But, Just because he said (and his lawyer said) due process wasn't followed doesn't make it a fact.

The appeal judge reviewed all the evidence and decided the original judge made the correct decision.

The same process will happen with this case. The Appeal judge will review all the evidence and will decide if the original judge made the correct decision to sentence Grey to 3 years prison.
It will be the appeal judges who will decide, for a fact, if due process was or wasnt followed or if the judge did or didn't take her disabilities into account - not you, not the lawyers and not the press.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 27/03/2023 13:10

Ktime · 27/03/2023 12:26

How do you know the police didn't inform Auriol's family? Plus Auriol still spoke to her mum and had a friend, she lived alone, she was able to call her family if she wanted to. Are you saying Auriol was held in custody for an extended period prior to her sentencing?

According to the newspaper reports and from interviews with her family, they said police didn’t inform her family that she was in custody, even though they knew she had difficulties. And if you haven’t read it on the thread, then I haven’t said it. I don’t say things in order for people to interpret them as something else, and there are no hidden agendas.

OP posts:
Ktime · 27/03/2023 12:54

freyamay74 · 27/03/2023 12:37

@DotAndCarryOne2 you need to get your facts straight. No one is appealing against the conviction! She's rightly been convicted of unlawfully killing someone. It's the sentence she's appealing.

She's not interested in facts, she's pumped full of her own importance talking about 'due process' and 'unsafe convictions', because she's watched a few episodes of CSI and thinks she's an expert.

Dexy007 · 27/03/2023 12:50

Yes I am! Because I don’t want someone who thinks it’s ok to push someone into the path of moving traffic and then just pop off shopping after witnessing her being mowed down in society. I want them institutionalised with the care their apologists say they need and deserve (ahem) OR I want them locked up away from well meaning people. You can’t have it both ways OP - she’s a frightening menace and should be in care or in prison: either way following a guilty verdict. If you genuinely think the court didn’t take her disability into account then I’m glad there’s a process that can be followed but fuck no I don’t want Auriol wandering free. Lock her up!

ArcticSkewer · 27/03/2023 12:46

MichelleScarn · 27/03/2023 11:47

So the family who are now so concerned for her and telling everyone of her vulnerability, and are now saying theyve always said she needed intensive support but clearly had no contact with her until they were told by a journo she'd be arrested...
Why in those 3 weeks had they had no contact? Am assuming given their level of concern of her need they would have been in contact with police/ss with regards to concern for her due to no contact for such a period of time?

Her sister had just died of cancer before the incident itself, which she had been recently diagnosed with, leaving behind two young children. I expect her brother in law was busy bringing them up. Her mother is in her mid-eighties.

Many people in her situation are quite antisocial and difficult to stay in regular touch with. The Times article says she herself found it stressful as a change in her daily routine.

The family, now they know, are rallying round.

This was actually her second trial, the first couldn't reach a verdict.

I personally see it as another sign of her cognitive difficulties that she didn't reach out to family for help at any point.

freyamay74 · 27/03/2023 12:37

@DotAndCarryOne2 you need to get your facts straight. No one is appealing against the conviction! She's rightly been convicted of unlawfully killing someone. It's the sentence she's appealing.

DotAndCarryOne2 · 27/03/2023 12:32

Dexy007 · 27/03/2023 12:16

The KC is now acting pro bono - I doubt she would be doing this unless she thought the outcome unfair.

this is true, but can I please clarify one thing for those who seem to think disabled = can’t be a cunt. When we are talking about fairness here we are talking about due process in a legal sense. Was the right evidence taken into account and given adequate consideration.

lawyers don’t just do pro bono for ‘nice’ people or where they wished the outcome had been different. They also do it for cunts like Auriol. Even arseholes deserve legal representation. Murderers and rapists deserve representation even when every shred of evidence is stacked against them. That’s the hallmark of a law abiding society. Lawyers owe their duties to the court (ie the justice system) not their client. They want the best outcome for the rule of law, not the miscreant they represent.

im happy the case might go to appeal as a lawyer. On a personal level I’m glad Auriol was convicted. Foul woman

So despite agreeing that the appeal will examine fairness and due process in the legal sense by scrutinising consideration of the evidence - in other words ensure that the conviction was safe - and given that that process has not yet started, you, as a lawyer, are glad she was convicted ? Ok then.

OP posts:
Ktime · 27/03/2023 12:30

@DotAndCarryOne2

it’s now degenerated into a slanging match between a few aggressive posters and is serving no useful purpose for debate

Was it ever going to be a debate when you're shown pictures of signage showing it was shared path and refuse to acknowledge it, OP?

You engage selectively, when enough time has passed between posts you find uncomfortable and unable to answer.

Ktime · 27/03/2023 12:26

Lovelysausagedogscrumpy · 27/03/2023 11:25

But they are the facts. The barrister could only defend Grey on the information he was given. And there was no-one to advocate for her, and no one to support her at the sentencing hearing. Do you not think it odd that the police were aware of her difficulties enough to appoint an appropriate adult at the police interview stage, but that that didn’t seem to be followed through at other stages of the process ? Or that they didn’t think to inform the family so that they could make sure she was properly supported and represented ? The fact that ‘due process’ may not have been fairly applied to a vulnerable adult and that an unsafe conviction as a result of failings in that process has implications for us all, seems to have been lost in the scramble to label Grey as nothing more than a gobby cow who deserved what she got. I’m really troubled by this thread. Genuinely. Trial by social media at the hands of people who have little idea of how due process is supposed to work, no concept of how this woman has been failed, and even less knowledge of, or tolerance of mental health and cognitive issues. I’m out.

How do you know the police didn't inform Auriol's family? Plus Auriol still spoke to her mum and had a friend, she lived alone, she was able to call her family if she wanted to. Are you saying Auriol was held in custody for an extended period prior to her sentencing?

DotAndCarryOne2 · 27/03/2023 12:26

freyamay74 · 27/03/2023 12:15

It's not obvious that it was the wrong decision at all! Or are you now going to provide us with records from the charitable trust of their assessments and decision making process for AG?

Honestly, the way a few people are trying to deflect responsibility from AG and assuming anyone who disagrees has no knowledge or experience of disability or safeguarding is pretty staggering.

But carry on blaming everyone else rather than the woman who unlawfully killed another woman if it makes you feel better.

I came back to the thread in defence of @Fifi1010, who has been one of the voices of reason throughout. Been dipping in and out since starting the thread but haven’t commented until she was ripped to pieces for posting from obvious experience and reasoned argument. Had I realised that there were other threads on the subject I wouldn’t have started this one, and it’s now degenerated into a slanging match between a few aggressive posters and is serving no useful purpose for debate - which is the point of MN isn’t it ? But neither myself or others who have questioned the way due process has been applied to Grey are ‘blaming’ anyone else. That’s your interpretation. If - if, there has been a miscarriage of justice here, by way of any kind of failing of Ms Grey, then it’s in everyone’s interests to correct it. If we allow a different, inferior standard of justice to be applied to vulnerable people, no matter how small the failing it results from, then it has implications for us all. I have no clue as to why so many people on here seem to object to the desire of some to make sure that this conviction is safe and that justice has been served to the same standard as if applied to someone without the disability. That is in no way trying to excuse disabled people from being held accountable. But if you are going to put a vulnerable physically and mentally disabled person in prison, then you better damn well make sure that the process you used stands up to scrutiny.

OP posts: