Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry about free speech at universities

189 replies

ChristinaXYZ · 26/03/2023 14:42

Despite the various moves by the government to supposedly protect free speech and normal academic deabte the situation on the ground does not seem to change at all.

In the last week Claire Fox was disinvited from Royal Holloway for a deabte on free speech I believe - incredible as that may seem. Some students want to hear what she had to say and had invited her but got 'strong-armed' out of it by the students' union and then failed by the university admin who should have backed free speech.

And before people say it can't be that bad, Claire Fox's was disinvited after liking a Ricky Gervias joke - going on his social media profile that means millions and millions of us are also not fit to speak to university students!

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/03/22/chilling-truth-cancellation/

Today this:

"Dr John Armstrong, a scholar at King's College London (KCL), applied to carry out a survey of elite athletes and volunteers on whether trans women, who are born male, should compete in women's track and field categories and whether they felt they could express their views.

However, the university's ethics panel rejected his application last week citing equality and diversity concerns, in what has been labelled an attack on academic freedom."

Further in the article it goes on to say:

"Dr Armstrong told The Telegraph: "They appear to be trying to prevent me from using the concept of sex at all. I am not misgendering any individuals, I am just accurately using the terms male and female.

"I’m being blocked from conducting research and it’s impacting upon my academic freedom.

"No serious work has been done by the various federations to try to find out the opinions of people in athletics, both at the grassroots and elite athletes.
"By refusing to allow people to conduct research that doesn’t meet certain activist viewpoints, that undermines the credibility of research in general.""

You can read much more here https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/03/26/transgender-athlete-research-rejected-professor-called-trans/

What it must be like to study and work in this kind of cloistered enviroment with a kind of inquisition checking up on whther you have transgressed I can't imagine. there must be hundreds of little choices staff and students make every day to conform - changing what they say,m what they write, the topics they're prepared to research. All the little chilling-effect ramifications that never make the headlines.

And if you think your family is woke enough for your teens to pass the purity tests when they get to unviersity - you're wrong. You can't feed this monster to pacify it. If wants bigger and bigger sacrifices and keeps changing the rules.

I just wish the governemnt would do more. Much more. And now.

The chilling truth about my cancellation

I wasn’t the victim when a university vetoed my talk. It was the young people failed by snowflake adults

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/03/22/chilling-truth-cancellation

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
ItsMeAgainYesHowDidYouGuess2 · 26/03/2023 19:56

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

lazycats · 26/03/2023 19:55

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

This is the lamest gotcha ever, have more respect for yourself. Lots of non-lesbians have been de-platformed. Your one-track mindedness is laughable.

NotTerfNorCis · 26/03/2023 19:54

She was disinvited. It doesn’t matter why.

If the pressure had come from men's rights activists rather than trans rights activists, would you still say that?

ItsMeAgainYesHowDidYouGuess2 · 26/03/2023 19:54

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Sqqueeeeeeee · 26/03/2023 19:53

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

How does being disinvited not change the fact she was invited? It literally couldn’t change it more. In fact, it completely reverses it. It’s like saying “the fact she died doesn’t mean I didn’t save her life”, like, it really really really really does change it.

ManipulatorPedipulator · 26/03/2023 19:51

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

She was disinvited. It doesn’t matter why. The people who run the place said they didn’t want her there - that’s their right. Part of wanting freedom of speech is that you have to accept it applies to things you don’t want to hear. You clearly don’t want to recognise that.

lazycats · 26/03/2023 19:50

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

ItsMeAgainYesHowDidYouGuess2 · 26/03/2023 19:47

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

ManipulatorPedipulator · 26/03/2023 19:35

Newrumpus · 26/03/2023 18:46

Have you read the OP. She was invited. She didn’t turn up unannounced with a loud speaker.

Have you read the OP? She was disinvited.

ChristinaXYZ · 26/03/2023 19:33

lailamaria · 26/03/2023 16:53

freedom of speech doesn't entitle anyone to speak publicly without consequences the majority of students didn't want to hear the transphobic rhetoric when they likely have trans students attending the university, it's democracy, if those students want to listen to that conversation they can go to another one of her talks outside of the university, i'm sure you'd complain if a trans woman was to go in a give a talk and you'd be happy if the students who wanted to listen to her were as you put it 'strong armed' out of it

Setting aside you libling the speaker as a transphobe where is your statistic about most students' views? One of the articles I mention in the OP is pointing out that the academic has been prevented from gathering evidence of views and I can't imagine there have been many other studies - so how you have this miraculous access I don't know! Do share your great knowledge ...

You're also out of like with your 'I'm sure you'd complain ..' comment. How the hell would you know what I'd do?? More speaking with no facts eh? And you're bloody well wrong actually - I would support the right of any speaker who was speaking within the terms of the laws we have in this country.

If a transwoman was invited to argue for the participation of transwomen in women's sports (I don't agree with that) I would support the right of the speaker to speak. I would not hold a banner nor protest (though I would defend the right of those that did, provided the protest did not intimidate nor attempt to prevent the meeting going ahead or attempt to prevent a speaker being heard or attempt to defame those attending). I might even go and listen or politely ask a question.

I would just like all speakers to have the same courtesy extended to them.

OP posts:
ChristinaXYZ · 26/03/2023 19:21

Albiboba · 26/03/2023 17:21

Freedom of speech is massively misunderstood. She had the freedom to say what she wants, she doesn’t have the freedom to say it where she wants and she isn’t entitled to use any platform if the platform doesn’t want her.

Not that hard to understand.

I clearly said she was invited by students who wanted to hear her speak - you are the one who does not understand.

Now it has been explained to you carefully - do you think that she should have been disinvited because one lot of students wants to bully those who invited her??

OP posts:
ChristinaXYZ · 26/03/2023 19:18

Merkins · 26/03/2023 15:33

You don’t think she was disinvited because of her political history? The one where she supported the IRA bombing campaign?

That's not what was said - they said it was because of the Ricky Gervais joke. I think what Claire Fox said about the Warringotn bomb was awful. I still would not disinvite her though.

And actually if you think about the implication is of a real moral vacuum in the student body - they object to joke but not to the bomb-justifying? Really? So even if you agree with their right to disinvite her (and I don't) what kind of moral stand are they actually taking and whom holds them, with this power they wield, to account? which ever way you look at the students union at Royal Holloway is demonstrating extremely poor decision making.

OP posts:
ChristinaXYZ · 26/03/2023 19:13

ManipulatorPedipulator · 26/03/2023 15:26

Freedom of speech also means the freedom to say “I don’t want you to speak here”. Freedom of speech is not the right to an audience and is not the right to access any platform you wish to access - the platform decides whether or not you’re entitled to use them, because that decision is their freedom of speech. In the same vein, I’m entitled to make a sign saying “I like chicken nuggets”, I’m not entitled to attach it to your front door.

That is exactly what free speech is not - well, it is fine to say it, but what is happening at the moment as I am sure you know is more than simply saying it - it is bullying, intimidation, sometimes with physical threats or the threats of having future problems with your degree or your career.

No one has a right to an audience but when there is an audience - someone is invited to speak as Claire Fox was, and then the students issuing the invitation are in their words 'strong-armed' into retracting it surely you can see there is a a huge, huge problem.

OP posts:
ChristinaXYZ · 26/03/2023 19:08

YouSetTheTone · 26/03/2023 15:22

Wasn’t it Edinburgh University where women were spat at by the leader of the Students Association for wanting to watch a film by Matt Walsh?
Kathleen Stock, a clever, thoughtful, measured Philosophy Professor hounded out of her job at Southampton for daring to say sex is real and there are times in life that it’s important to observe those differences.

That was a real low. The poor resposne of the uni to organising a re-screening was terrible too.

OP posts:
Newrumpus · 26/03/2023 18:49

lailamaria · 26/03/2023 16:53

freedom of speech doesn't entitle anyone to speak publicly without consequences the majority of students didn't want to hear the transphobic rhetoric when they likely have trans students attending the university, it's democracy, if those students want to listen to that conversation they can go to another one of her talks outside of the university, i'm sure you'd complain if a trans woman was to go in a give a talk and you'd be happy if the students who wanted to listen to her were as you put it 'strong armed' out of it

Wrong! That is not how free speech works. You have to be able to apply it to views you find unpalatable. There is need to have free speech if every just talks about the weather.

Newrumpus · 26/03/2023 18:46

ManipulatorPedipulator · 26/03/2023 15:26

Freedom of speech also means the freedom to say “I don’t want you to speak here”. Freedom of speech is not the right to an audience and is not the right to access any platform you wish to access - the platform decides whether or not you’re entitled to use them, because that decision is their freedom of speech. In the same vein, I’m entitled to make a sign saying “I like chicken nuggets”, I’m not entitled to attach it to your front door.

Have you read the OP. She was invited. She didn’t turn up unannounced with a loud speaker.

Abitofalark · 26/03/2023 18:35

[clip from the quote in the opening post]:

"...However, the university's ethics panel rejected his application last week citing equality and diversity concerns, in what has been labelled an attack on academic freedom."

I wonder what the ethics panel thinks those two words mean.

CeliaNorth · 26/03/2023 18:34

the majority of students didn't want to hear the transphobic rhetoric

Then they could have just not gone to the event. Or did I miss the part where they were being rounded up and forced to attend?

You don’t think she was disinvited because of her political history? The one where she supported the IRA bombing campaign?

That argument rather ceased to be valid when Martin McGuinness shook hands with the Queen.

Roundandnour · 26/03/2023 18:09

Nightlystroll · 26/03/2023 17:59

I'm amazed how many people are so concerned about free speech in universities now that people who are saying things they agree with are being de-platformed. Were they all so concerned when people they didn't agree were being de-platformed?

I’ve always supported free speech even if I don’t always agree with what is being said.

I don’t want to live in an echo chamber. I enjoy a good debate and listening to all sides. It one of the ways you can make an informed choice.

It’s even harder when one side not only doesn’t want to debate they also want silence the other side.

Roundandnour · 26/03/2023 17:59

wasteoffunds · 26/03/2023 17:50

Sussex(Brighton) not Southampton for Stock. I think it is important that the correct Universities are quoted so people can steer their children away when doing UCAS.

Absolutely. If Unis cannot get basic biology right what else are they gaslighting paying students about?

After the horrific fight with Fallon Fox and Tamikka Brent this should have been when the line was drawn with males competing against females. Not several years later and not when promoting sex blockers for children so they can compete as females.

Nightlystroll · 26/03/2023 17:59

I'm amazed how many people are so concerned about free speech in universities now that people who are saying things they agree with are being de-platformed. Were they all so concerned when people they didn't agree were being de-platformed?

Roundandnour · 26/03/2023 17:54

I’m not surprised many seem to support these bans. Have you seen the verbal and physical attacks on females who want to talk about their experiences about being female or lesbian?

Al least after these discussions the females can walk away and deal with the abuse online. Hard to do that when you have to stay in a community like a uni

wasteoffunds · 26/03/2023 17:50

YouSetTheTone · 26/03/2023 15:22

Wasn’t it Edinburgh University where women were spat at by the leader of the Students Association for wanting to watch a film by Matt Walsh?
Kathleen Stock, a clever, thoughtful, measured Philosophy Professor hounded out of her job at Southampton for daring to say sex is real and there are times in life that it’s important to observe those differences.

Sussex(Brighton) not Southampton for Stock. I think it is important that the correct Universities are quoted so people can steer their children away when doing UCAS.

Roundandnour · 26/03/2023 17:47

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

You would think the trans community would support all research into TW competing in female sports wouldn’t you?

They keep telling us there is no difference so what are they afraid of?

And absolutely this isn’t transphobic to point out and want to talk about the differences.

In the interests of fairness you would think the community would campaign for open categories and other things. For some reason this isn’t wanted. Instead we are hearing they have been kicked out of sports. When reality is they haven’t been kicked out they can still compete just not against women (stonewall, mermaids and more trans groups are stating this since the IOC made the decision the other day).

The real victims in this who are the females who lost places, sponsorship, funding and more due to the ridiculous idea that there are no differences between the sexes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread