Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry about free speech at universities

189 replies

ChristinaXYZ · 26/03/2023 14:42

Despite the various moves by the government to supposedly protect free speech and normal academic deabte the situation on the ground does not seem to change at all.

In the last week Claire Fox was disinvited from Royal Holloway for a deabte on free speech I believe - incredible as that may seem. Some students want to hear what she had to say and had invited her but got 'strong-armed' out of it by the students' union and then failed by the university admin who should have backed free speech.

And before people say it can't be that bad, Claire Fox's was disinvited after liking a Ricky Gervias joke - going on his social media profile that means millions and millions of us are also not fit to speak to university students!

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/03/22/chilling-truth-cancellation/

Today this:

"Dr John Armstrong, a scholar at King's College London (KCL), applied to carry out a survey of elite athletes and volunteers on whether trans women, who are born male, should compete in women's track and field categories and whether they felt they could express their views.

However, the university's ethics panel rejected his application last week citing equality and diversity concerns, in what has been labelled an attack on academic freedom."

Further in the article it goes on to say:

"Dr Armstrong told The Telegraph: "They appear to be trying to prevent me from using the concept of sex at all. I am not misgendering any individuals, I am just accurately using the terms male and female.

"I’m being blocked from conducting research and it’s impacting upon my academic freedom.

"No serious work has been done by the various federations to try to find out the opinions of people in athletics, both at the grassroots and elite athletes.
"By refusing to allow people to conduct research that doesn’t meet certain activist viewpoints, that undermines the credibility of research in general.""

You can read much more here https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/03/26/transgender-athlete-research-rejected-professor-called-trans/

What it must be like to study and work in this kind of cloistered enviroment with a kind of inquisition checking up on whther you have transgressed I can't imagine. there must be hundreds of little choices staff and students make every day to conform - changing what they say,m what they write, the topics they're prepared to research. All the little chilling-effect ramifications that never make the headlines.

And if you think your family is woke enough for your teens to pass the purity tests when they get to unviersity - you're wrong. You can't feed this monster to pacify it. If wants bigger and bigger sacrifices and keeps changing the rules.

I just wish the governemnt would do more. Much more. And now.

The chilling truth about my cancellation

I wasn’t the victim when a university vetoed my talk. It was the young people failed by snowflake adults

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/03/22/chilling-truth-cancellation

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
Riapia · 27/03/2023 07:57

If freedom means anything at all it means being able to tell people things that they do not wish to hear.
George Orwell.

Nightlystroll · 27/03/2023 04:45

TheKeatingFive · 27/03/2023 04:26

Then you started posting to me, accusing me of aiming comments at you.

I didn't 'accuse' you of anything. I said I didn't know where you were getting this idea from. Turns out you were apparently talking about posters on an entirely different thread, without ever making that clear. Just a bit odd really.

Oh, you and all your odds. 🙄

TheKeatingFive · 27/03/2023 04:26

Then you started posting to me, accusing me of aiming comments at you.

I didn't 'accuse' you of anything. I said I didn't know where you were getting this idea from. Turns out you were apparently talking about posters on an entirely different thread, without ever making that clear. Just a bit odd really.

Nightlystroll · 27/03/2023 03:47

TheKeatingFive · 26/03/2023 22:44

People in general.

Well that's a bit vague

I've been making this point for a long time and I've had people on threads agree with me, saying that they'd ignored complaints they'd read about because they didn't agree with those de-platformed.

So you're addressing your points to these unnamed posters, but not anyone actually on this thread? Odd. As this doesn't seem to apply to anyone on this thread (by your own admission), I'm not sure why you keep reiterating it.

I didn't keep reiterating it. I wrote one post. The op then contended that I was against free speech. I corrected them.
Then you started posting to me, accusing me of aiming comments at you. I replied denying that. If you don't want me to reply to you, don't keep quoting me, questioning my posts!

DemiColon · 27/03/2023 02:54

It's not just a standard free speech question either. Universities are unique in their role. It's imperative that ideas of all kinds are heard and discussed. That's the point of them.

BluebellBlueballs · 26/03/2023 23:49

ManipulatorPedipulator · 26/03/2023 15:26

Freedom of speech also means the freedom to say “I don’t want you to speak here”. Freedom of speech is not the right to an audience and is not the right to access any platform you wish to access - the platform decides whether or not you’re entitled to use them, because that decision is their freedom of speech. In the same vein, I’m entitled to make a sign saying “I like chicken nuggets”, I’m not entitled to attach it to your front door.

This is bullshit.
No one was forced to go to the debate

Those who didn't want to go had the choice to stay away

What they did not have was the right to stop other people who did want to go to the debate from going

Now THAT is totalitarinism

VölligLosgelöst · 26/03/2023 23:31

"Dr Armstrong told The Telegraph: "They appear to be trying to prevent me from using the concept of sex at all. I am not misgendering any individuals, I am just accurately using the terms male and female."

Just on this one point, she might want to tweak her language use a bit, regarding the word 'misgendering' (hopefully my screenshot will post)

To worry about free speech at universities
TheKeatingFive · 26/03/2023 22:44

People in general.

Well that's a bit vague

I've been making this point for a long time and I've had people on threads agree with me, saying that they'd ignored complaints they'd read about because they didn't agree with those de-platformed.

So you're addressing your points to these unnamed posters, but not anyone actually on this thread? Odd. As this doesn't seem to apply to anyone on this thread (by your own admission), I'm not sure why you keep reiterating it.

jcyclops · 26/03/2023 22:19

I disagree with no-platforming guest speakers just because they may offend someone. It is totally ridiculous.

Regarding the academic wanting to study if trans women have an advantage over cis women in athletics - the only institution that should allow spending thousands of pounds on this should be The University of The Bleeding Obvious. Similar academic studies have previously concluded:

  1. Students have more accidents and injuries after drinking excess alcohol.
  2. Women who get epidurals experience less pain during childbirth than women who don't.
  3. People who don't get enough sleep make more mistakes at work than those who do.
  4. Wearing high heels for a long time hurts your feet.
  5. Chocolate is a poor material for heat resistant applications like fireguards.

Not forgetting the classic:

Fast Show - Professor Denzil Dexter

CBT-Experiment

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UIUdyBG_DT0

ATerrorofLeftovers · 26/03/2023 22:17

GCAcademic · 26/03/2023 22:14

From the poster who told someone to fuck off a few posts back . . .

Exactly 🙄

ATerrorofLeftovers · 26/03/2023 22:16

It’s you who can’t put forward a logical argument and can’t follow what’s explained to you, despite numerous people explaining it you in various very simple ways. Which does rather give the impression of either posting with mischief or perhaps more charitably, being so blinded by pre-conceived notions that you’re unable to take in new information and process it adequately.

GCAcademic · 26/03/2023 22:14

ManipulatorPedipulator · 26/03/2023 22:11

😂so everyone has to debate respectfully, except you? You resort to insults because you can’t put forward a logical argument. I’m not reading beyond the insult because it’s a waste of time, which is my right to do. Bye.

From the poster who told someone to fuck off a few posts back . . .

ManipulatorPedipulator · 26/03/2023 22:11

ATerrorofLeftovers · 26/03/2023 22:08

Oh good lord, are you really struggling this much with reading comprehension, or deliberately trolling? Or perhaps very, very young and finding it heard to keep up?

You don’t appear to be reading carefully enough to actually understand what I am saying. And hence arguing as though I’m saying something completely different, and sometimes opposite, to what I’ve actually said.

I don’t support Claire Fox. I’m not anti her either. I don’t actually know enough about her to have an opinion on her one way or they other.

What I am very much FOR is freedom of speech and I am AGAINST censorship. I make no bones about that and own it 100%. I don’t understand why you’re frightened of free speech.

No good ever comes of restricting freedom of speech. No good ever comes of totalitarianism.

I’m not telling anyone they have to engage in debate. I’m saying they have to respect the right of others to do so, if they so wish. Nobody should be seeking to control others, or prevent them from hosting or listening to speaker.

Nobody is obliged to invite a speaker to speak. But equally nobody should be trying to censor or deplatforn if a speaker they don’t like is invited by somebody else.

This is what’s happening here.

Maybe this will help you understand. If the University Tiddlywinks Society wants to invite a speaker to one of its events and the University Lawn Bowls Society takes exception to the person, and runs off to complain to the University management, the University management should tell the Bowls Soc complainers that it’s the business of the Tiddlywinks Soc who they invite. Nobody from the Bowls Soc is obliged to show up if they don’t want to. But they don’t get to prevent others from doing so either.

Instead, what’s happened here is the University management has shit its pants and given in to bullying, instead of taking a stand for freedom of speech. It’s pathetic.

😂so everyone has to debate respectfully, except you? You resort to insults because you can’t put forward a logical argument. I’m not reading beyond the insult because it’s a waste of time, which is my right to do. Bye.

ATerrorofLeftovers · 26/03/2023 22:08

ManipulatorPedipulator · 26/03/2023 21:52

It doesn’t matter what different groups of students want. They don’t make the decisions. It’s irrelevant. The fact you’ve described one group as “silly” with their “knickers in a twist” demonstrates you support one side, which I’ve remained entirely neutral.

It’s funny how you’ve gone from saying it to denying anyone said it. You said people have to listen and rebutt opinions they don’t like. They don’t. They can just say “I don’t want to give you a platform” and end the discussion. That’s their right. Telling people that they have to engage in debate and they have to rebutt arguments is not respecting their freedom of speech.

Freedom of speech means you do get to control what you allow to be broadcast in your own venues. Which is what has happened here.

Just own the fact you want her to speak because you agree with her views and stop pretending it’s about defending freedom of speech. The opinion you actually hold is perfectly valid. It loses all validity when you try to masquerade it as something else.

Oh good lord, are you really struggling this much with reading comprehension, or deliberately trolling? Or perhaps very, very young and finding it heard to keep up?

You don’t appear to be reading carefully enough to actually understand what I am saying. And hence arguing as though I’m saying something completely different, and sometimes opposite, to what I’ve actually said.

I don’t support Claire Fox. I’m not anti her either. I don’t actually know enough about her to have an opinion on her one way or they other.

What I am very much FOR is freedom of speech and I am AGAINST censorship. I make no bones about that and own it 100%. I don’t understand why you’re frightened of free speech.

No good ever comes of restricting freedom of speech. No good ever comes of totalitarianism.

I’m not telling anyone they have to engage in debate. I’m saying they have to respect the right of others to do so, if they so wish. Nobody should be seeking to control others, or prevent them from hosting or listening to speaker.

Nobody is obliged to invite a speaker to speak. But equally nobody should be trying to censor or deplatforn if a speaker they don’t like is invited by somebody else.

This is what’s happening here.

Maybe this will help you understand. If the University Tiddlywinks Society wants to invite a speaker to one of its events and the University Lawn Bowls Society takes exception to the person, and runs off to complain to the University management, the University management should tell the Bowls Soc complainers that it’s the business of the Tiddlywinks Soc who they invite. Nobody from the Bowls Soc is obliged to show up if they don’t want to. But they don’t get to prevent others from doing so either.

Instead, what’s happened here is the University management has shit its pants and given in to bullying, instead of taking a stand for freedom of speech. It’s pathetic.

Newrumpus · 26/03/2023 22:04

ManipulatorPedipulator · 26/03/2023 21:57

It’s not censorship though. It’s an organisation picking one side, which they’re allowed to do. They aren’t obliged to be impartial, or even rational. As I said, it doesn’t matter why she was disinvited. The fact is, she was. So she’s not welcome.

Of course it is censorship. And in a university. It’s a disgrace and part of a very worrying trend.

GCAcademic · 26/03/2023 21:59

Newrumpus · 26/03/2023 21:54

Again - she was disinvited because one group of students silenced another group of students. Let’s not pretend it was just of change of mind and she was no longer welcome. Pressure was applied by one group to make the other group conform. They were silenced. It is censorship and it is worrying.

This. Universities have a statutory duty to protect freedom of expression and academic freedom. The Office for Students needs to go in hard on universities that fail to uphold these obligations, defunding them or their student unions if necessary. In this case, the speaker was invited by a group of students who then had undue pressure put upon them to rescind the invitation. This is sinister and not the sign of a functioning institution that is part of a healthy democracy.

titchy · 26/03/2023 21:58

It doesn’t matter what different groups of students want. They don’t make the decisions

Except they did. The debating society, run by the NUS, invited her, then were persuaded by another group of students, not involved with the society, to silence her.

The fucking debating society. Silencing debate.

ManipulatorPedipulator · 26/03/2023 21:57

Newrumpus · 26/03/2023 21:54

Again - she was disinvited because one group of students silenced another group of students. Let’s not pretend it was just of change of mind and she was no longer welcome. Pressure was applied by one group to make the other group conform. They were silenced. It is censorship and it is worrying.

It’s not censorship though. It’s an organisation picking one side, which they’re allowed to do. They aren’t obliged to be impartial, or even rational. As I said, it doesn’t matter why she was disinvited. The fact is, she was. So she’s not welcome.

Newrumpus · 26/03/2023 21:54

ManipulatorPedipulator · 26/03/2023 20:58

So? She was disinvited. Therefore she was no longer welcome. Why is that so hard to understand? I made no comment on whether she should have been disinvited. I simply said she’s not welcome to speak if they’ve disinvited her.

Again - she was disinvited because one group of students silenced another group of students. Let’s not pretend it was just of change of mind and she was no longer welcome. Pressure was applied by one group to make the other group conform. They were silenced. It is censorship and it is worrying.

ManipulatorPedipulator · 26/03/2023 21:52

ATerrorofLeftovers · 26/03/2023 21:45

You’re the one being ridiculous. And hard of comprehension/thinking.

As has been pointed out to you numerous times on this thread, people at the university DID want to host Claire Fox. Then OTHER people at the university got their knickers in a twist because they didn’t like her views and made a big silly fuss that resulted in her invitation being rescinded.

This is not how intelligent, civilised adults behave.

Do you seriously think you’re defending freedom of speech by saying someone has to say what you want them to say?

Nobody has said this. You appear to be constructing an argument you wish people had said and are arguing with that, rather than engaging thoughtfully with what posters have actually said.

In fact, the whole point of what those in favour of free speech have been saying on this thread is that people ARE allowed to say exactly what they think, even if I or others don’t agree. We are NOT trying to stop them or get them to parrot what we believe.

Freedom of speech does NOT mean deciding you get to control what others say or hear. Which is what has happened here.

It doesn’t matter what different groups of students want. They don’t make the decisions. It’s irrelevant. The fact you’ve described one group as “silly” with their “knickers in a twist” demonstrates you support one side, which I’ve remained entirely neutral.

It’s funny how you’ve gone from saying it to denying anyone said it. You said people have to listen and rebutt opinions they don’t like. They don’t. They can just say “I don’t want to give you a platform” and end the discussion. That’s their right. Telling people that they have to engage in debate and they have to rebutt arguments is not respecting their freedom of speech.

Freedom of speech means you do get to control what you allow to be broadcast in your own venues. Which is what has happened here.

Just own the fact you want her to speak because you agree with her views and stop pretending it’s about defending freedom of speech. The opinion you actually hold is perfectly valid. It loses all validity when you try to masquerade it as something else.

Nightlystroll · 26/03/2023 21:48

TheKeatingFive · 26/03/2023 21:33

Where did I say that? I never referred to anyone on here.

Precisely who are you referring to when you make the point then?

People in general. I've been making this point for a long time and I've had people on threads agree with me, saying that they'd ignored complaints they'd read about because they didn't agree with those de-platformed. Subsequently they regretted it when discussion about issues important to them were quashed. I think their comments actually reflected those of many in the public at large.

ATerrorofLeftovers · 26/03/2023 21:45

ManipulatorPedipulator · 26/03/2023 21:33

Don’t be ridiculous. People are perfectly within their rights to say “I disagree with your views and therefore I am not hosting you”. Do you seriously think you’re defending freedom of speech by saying someone has to say what you want them to say? People are under no obligation at all to provide a platform to anyone that they don’t want to. This isn’t a new concept - bitching about it appears to be a new concept.

Freedom of speech works both ways. Telling someone they have to use their freedom of speech in the way you’re demanding is so incredibly ironic. Freedom of speech means rebutting someone’s points if you choose to. It also means ignoring someone entirely if you choose to. It means telling people they aren’t welcome if you choose to.

You’re the one being ridiculous. And hard of comprehension/thinking.

As has been pointed out to you numerous times on this thread, people at the university DID want to host Claire Fox. Then OTHER people at the university got their knickers in a twist because they didn’t like her views and made a big silly fuss that resulted in her invitation being rescinded.

This is not how intelligent, civilised adults behave.

Do you seriously think you’re defending freedom of speech by saying someone has to say what you want them to say?

Nobody has said this. You appear to be constructing an argument you wish people had said and are arguing with that, rather than engaging thoughtfully with what posters have actually said.

In fact, the whole point of what those in favour of free speech have been saying on this thread is that people ARE allowed to say exactly what they think, even if I or others don’t agree. We are NOT trying to stop them or get them to parrot what we believe.

Freedom of speech does NOT mean deciding you get to control what others say or hear. Which is what has happened here.

ManipulatorPedipulator · 26/03/2023 21:36

titchy · 26/03/2023 21:04

Yes. If she was disinvited then she wasn’t welcome to speak. The reason why isn’t relevant. It’s flatly not a violation of freedom of speech for an organisation to say they don’t want you to speak at their venue.

Actually the reasoning behind the disinvite is vitally important given that it was to take place at a university - are you aware of the (admittedly flawed) free speech bill currently ping ponging in parliament?

Equipping students with the opportunity to hear viewpoints they don't agree with, and encourage them to engage in respectful debate is a vital part of university life.

🙄Read what I said.

ManipulatorPedipulator · 26/03/2023 21:33

ATerrorofLeftovers · 26/03/2023 21:23

‘Not putting up and shutting up’ means turning up to a debate, putting your side and arguing cogently and intelligently for it. All the while, taking into account what the other side is saying, rebutting their points that you don’t agree with, and even sometimes (gasp!) conceding any points where you see they correct.. .

It’s not gagging the other side so they are unable to speak, now, is it?

This used to be such commonly accepted knowledge/practice that it didn’t used to need to be stated amongst adults. Very young teenagers, perhaps. As they are learning. But never adults. What the fuck has happened to our education system and society?

Don’t be ridiculous. People are perfectly within their rights to say “I disagree with your views and therefore I am not hosting you”. Do you seriously think you’re defending freedom of speech by saying someone has to say what you want them to say? People are under no obligation at all to provide a platform to anyone that they don’t want to. This isn’t a new concept - bitching about it appears to be a new concept.

Freedom of speech works both ways. Telling someone they have to use their freedom of speech in the way you’re demanding is so incredibly ironic. Freedom of speech means rebutting someone’s points if you choose to. It also means ignoring someone entirely if you choose to. It means telling people they aren’t welcome if you choose to.

TheKeatingFive · 26/03/2023 21:33

Where did I say that? I never referred to anyone on here.

Precisely who are you referring to when you make the point then?