Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry about free speech at universities

189 replies

ChristinaXYZ · 26/03/2023 14:42

Despite the various moves by the government to supposedly protect free speech and normal academic deabte the situation on the ground does not seem to change at all.

In the last week Claire Fox was disinvited from Royal Holloway for a deabte on free speech I believe - incredible as that may seem. Some students want to hear what she had to say and had invited her but got 'strong-armed' out of it by the students' union and then failed by the university admin who should have backed free speech.

And before people say it can't be that bad, Claire Fox's was disinvited after liking a Ricky Gervias joke - going on his social media profile that means millions and millions of us are also not fit to speak to university students!

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/03/22/chilling-truth-cancellation/

Today this:

"Dr John Armstrong, a scholar at King's College London (KCL), applied to carry out a survey of elite athletes and volunteers on whether trans women, who are born male, should compete in women's track and field categories and whether they felt they could express their views.

However, the university's ethics panel rejected his application last week citing equality and diversity concerns, in what has been labelled an attack on academic freedom."

Further in the article it goes on to say:

"Dr Armstrong told The Telegraph: "They appear to be trying to prevent me from using the concept of sex at all. I am not misgendering any individuals, I am just accurately using the terms male and female.

"I’m being blocked from conducting research and it’s impacting upon my academic freedom.

"No serious work has been done by the various federations to try to find out the opinions of people in athletics, both at the grassroots and elite athletes.
"By refusing to allow people to conduct research that doesn’t meet certain activist viewpoints, that undermines the credibility of research in general.""

You can read much more here https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/03/26/transgender-athlete-research-rejected-professor-called-trans/

What it must be like to study and work in this kind of cloistered enviroment with a kind of inquisition checking up on whther you have transgressed I can't imagine. there must be hundreds of little choices staff and students make every day to conform - changing what they say,m what they write, the topics they're prepared to research. All the little chilling-effect ramifications that never make the headlines.

And if you think your family is woke enough for your teens to pass the purity tests when they get to unviersity - you're wrong. You can't feed this monster to pacify it. If wants bigger and bigger sacrifices and keeps changing the rules.

I just wish the governemnt would do more. Much more. And now.

The chilling truth about my cancellation

I wasn’t the victim when a university vetoed my talk. It was the young people failed by snowflake adults

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/03/22/chilling-truth-cancellation

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
JemimaTiggywinkles · 27/03/2023 16:57

If you own/run/control a venue then it is up to you who can and cannot speak there

I don't think that is, or even should be, the case for universities. They are largely publicly funded institutions who serve an important role in ensuring ideas are heard and discussed. Provided the speaker is respecting the law they should be allowed to speak to students who want to hear them.

Besides which, you are missing entirely what happened here. It wasn't "we as an institution don't agree with this woman's views so won't allow her in".

What has actually happened is "some people want to hear her speak, some don't want to allow them to hear her speak and we, as an institution, are siding with those who want to prevent others from hearing her". That is censorship, and it shouldn't be happening at universities.

ManipulatorPedipulator · 27/03/2023 16:15

howmanybicycles · 27/03/2023 16:12

The simple issue is that she was invited and there was interest in hearing her speak.

It is not convincing to pretend that the reasons why she was then uninvited were simple. I'm guessing that you don't believe in any structural inequalities? Or do you think that these were not in operation here for some reason?

I didn’t comment on why she was uninvited so how could my comment on that be too simple? I didn’t make any comment - simple or complex - on that.

You’ve guessed incorrectly. I’ve made no comment at all on that. You’ve just taken my non-comment as a comment that I must disagree with you.

GCAcademic · 27/03/2023 16:15

ManipulatorPedipulator · 27/03/2023 16:13

So you’re suggesting the university have acted illegally and that the government are trying to pass an entirely irrelevant law in order to make it illegal? 😂

Several universities have been in breach of their statutory duties in the last few years, yes, deploying loopholes such as claiming not to be able to provide adequate security. The HE Bill is needed to prevent this kind of cowardice.

GCAcademic · 27/03/2023 16:14

It's absolutely laughable that someone thinks a marketing person would or should get to decide who gets to speak on a university campus. But it's also frightening and demonstrates why the Higher Education Bill is needed.

ManipulatorPedipulator · 27/03/2023 16:13

GCAcademic · 27/03/2023 16:01

You clearly don’t understand the first thing about the university sector and what its statutory obligations are.

So you’re suggesting the university have acted illegally and that the government are trying to pass an entirely irrelevant law in order to make it illegal? 😂

howmanybicycles · 27/03/2023 16:12

ManipulatorPedipulator · 27/03/2023 16:08

It’s not too simplistic, it’s just a very simple issue.

The simple issue is that she was invited and there was interest in hearing her speak.

It is not convincing to pretend that the reasons why she was then uninvited were simple. I'm guessing that you don't believe in any structural inequalities? Or do you think that these were not in operation here for some reason?

ManipulatorPedipulator · 27/03/2023 16:12

titchy · 27/03/2023 16:05

There would only be a contradiction if it were a ban from a public place or a public setting. It’s not. It’s a university. The university have complete and total jurisdiction over who can and cannot speak there

Oh dear. How to tell me you know nothing about the Higher Education regulatory framework without telling me you know nothing about the Higher Education regulatory framework Grin

It’s funny because you’re wrong. HERF has no impact at all on what I said.

ManipulatorPedipulator · 27/03/2023 16:08

howmanybicycles · 27/03/2023 15:59

This is too simplistic a way to look at it. Universities are deciding things because TRAs are staging violent and illegal protests. They are deciding things because they are under funding pressure to agree with far right trans ideology views. They are deciding things because they are being put in difficult positions by people with power which is being supported by systemic and structural racist, homophobic and misogynistic views. An uninvite means they wanted her and were pressured into doing something in the interests of a group of people who already hold the power. The initial invitation was an expression of their freedom of expression. The lack of attention to operation of power is really, really worrying.

It’s not too simplistic, it’s just a very simple issue.

titchy · 27/03/2023 16:05

There would only be a contradiction if it were a ban from a public place or a public setting. It’s not. It’s a university. The university have complete and total jurisdiction over who can and cannot speak there

Oh dear. How to tell me you know nothing about the Higher Education regulatory framework without telling me you know nothing about the Higher Education regulatory framework Grin

GCAcademic · 27/03/2023 16:01

ManipulatorPedipulator · 27/03/2023 15:52

The university get to decide, fucking obviously.

As I’ve stated multiple times now (and you have chosen to blatantly ignore), I’m not making any comment on whether she should have been banned, about her personally or statements that she has made. Just that it’s their right to ban her because saying the disagree with her is their freedom of expression.

You clearly don’t understand the first thing about the university sector and what its statutory obligations are.

ManipulatorPedipulator · 27/03/2023 16:01

RosaBonheur · 27/03/2023 15:55

Who specifically at the university?

And if universities are making such batshit decisions, are they actually fit for purpose?

All these woke warriors should be sacked and universities should be allowed to get back to what they are actually for: education (as opposed to indoctrination) and research.

Whoever at the university is employed to make that decision. I have no idea what their name is, how would I? The job title and responsibilities would vary from one university to the next. It could be made by someone managing their marketing, or managing their events, or from a higher level than that. It could be decided by a board rather than one individual. Often it’s the students union rather than the university itself. It doesn’t matter though - the university decided that.

Your second two paragraphs aren’t relevant to me or what I said. They’re just an attempt to drag me into an argument because you got prematurely offended by what I said and are looking for an outlet for your outrage. As I’ve said, I don’t know who she is or what she’s said - how on earth would I know whether their decision was rational or reasonable? The fact is, they’re entitled to be “batshit” if they want to be - it’s their venue.

JoWawa · 27/03/2023 15:59

They aren't being forced to attend.

howmanybicycles · 27/03/2023 15:59

ManipulatorPedipulator · 27/03/2023 15:52

The university get to decide, fucking obviously.

As I’ve stated multiple times now (and you have chosen to blatantly ignore), I’m not making any comment on whether she should have been banned, about her personally or statements that she has made. Just that it’s their right to ban her because saying the disagree with her is their freedom of expression.

This is too simplistic a way to look at it. Universities are deciding things because TRAs are staging violent and illegal protests. They are deciding things because they are under funding pressure to agree with far right trans ideology views. They are deciding things because they are being put in difficult positions by people with power which is being supported by systemic and structural racist, homophobic and misogynistic views. An uninvite means they wanted her and were pressured into doing something in the interests of a group of people who already hold the power. The initial invitation was an expression of their freedom of expression. The lack of attention to operation of power is really, really worrying.

Ruffpuff · 27/03/2023 15:57

This ship sailed years ago. 7 years ago when I started at uni, a fresh faced 18 year old, I applied to write an article for The Tab (student newspaper). I entitled my article ‘free speech in universities’ - it got rejected for not being ‘student centric’ enough!

The uni also banned certain newspapers from campus, introduced gender neutral toilets, and campaigned against hosting certain guest speakers they disagreed with in my second year.

I decided not to bother with a master’s in the end.

None of this is new.

RosaBonheur · 27/03/2023 15:55

ManipulatorPedipulator · 27/03/2023 15:52

The university get to decide, fucking obviously.

As I’ve stated multiple times now (and you have chosen to blatantly ignore), I’m not making any comment on whether she should have been banned, about her personally or statements that she has made. Just that it’s their right to ban her because saying the disagree with her is their freedom of expression.

Who specifically at the university?

And if universities are making such batshit decisions, are they actually fit for purpose?

All these woke warriors should be sacked and universities should be allowed to get back to what they are actually for: education (as opposed to indoctrination) and research.

ManipulatorPedipulator · 27/03/2023 15:52

RosaBonheur · 27/03/2023 15:50

Who gets to decide that? Clearly some people did want her to speak at the university, or they wouldn't have invited her.

Are you seriously suggesting that liking Ricky Gervais or not believing that humans can change sex makes you equivalent to a Nazi or a Holocaust denier?

Because if you are, you are part of the problem.

The university get to decide, fucking obviously.

As I’ve stated multiple times now (and you have chosen to blatantly ignore), I’m not making any comment on whether she should have been banned, about her personally or statements that she has made. Just that it’s their right to ban her because saying the disagree with her is their freedom of expression.

RosaBonheur · 27/03/2023 15:50

ManipulatorPedipulator · 26/03/2023 15:26

Freedom of speech also means the freedom to say “I don’t want you to speak here”. Freedom of speech is not the right to an audience and is not the right to access any platform you wish to access - the platform decides whether or not you’re entitled to use them, because that decision is their freedom of speech. In the same vein, I’m entitled to make a sign saying “I like chicken nuggets”, I’m not entitled to attach it to your front door.

Who gets to decide that? Clearly some people did want her to speak at the university, or they wouldn't have invited her.

Are you seriously suggesting that liking Ricky Gervais or not believing that humans can change sex makes you equivalent to a Nazi or a Holocaust denier?

Because if you are, you are part of the problem.

Beowulfa · 27/03/2023 15:48

The BBC gave notorious right winger Nick Griffin a platform on Question Time in the 90s. Once at the table with the grown ups he had to answer proper political questions and not rely on whining that he was an oppressed martyer denied freedom of speech. Support for the BNP pretty much collapsed overnight once it was revealed what a political lightweight one trick pony he really was.

People used to be able to have calm, measured debates with those they strongly disagreed with, to share a platform with individuals who they despised personally. Because they had confidence in the strength of their own arguments, and evidence to back them up.

What are students learning if they can't bring themselves to hear from people they don't like?

ManipulatorPedipulator · 27/03/2023 15:45

Ofcourseshecan · 27/03/2023 15:33

Can you really not see the contradiction in your statements?

Freedom of speech also means the freedom to say “I don’t want you to speak here”. Yes, that's the freedom of one person, or one group, to prevent another being heard at a public meeting.

What about the public's freedom to hear the information that person wanted to give? And when that information is not in step with the currently prevailing orthodoxy, that means the freedom to be given opposing facts in order to build up a clearer picture. Would you protest at a government seeking that kind of censorship?

the platform decides whether or not you're entitled to use them: true, they have the right to do that.
because that decision is their freedom of speech: false. It's their right to decide who uses their platform, but that is not freedom of speech.

Firstly, “freedom of speech” isn’t actually a legal concept. The legal concept is freedom of expression - which includes actions and words. Refusing a platform is an action protected as freedom of expression (or what people refer to as freedom of speech).

There would only be a contradiction if it were a ban from a public place or a public setting. It’s not. It’s a university. The university have complete and total jurisdiction over who can and cannot speak there. That’s the difference. In a public space, I’d agree with you. In a space that is controlled by a specific person or organisation, they call the shots. Preventing them from making that decision is preventing them from expressing their viewpoint in the way that they wish to do so. If you own/run/control a venue then it is up to you who can and cannot speak there - if you wish to express your opinion by banning certain speakers, that is your right under freedom of speech. If they were saying she couldn’t speak because it violates fire safety policy or because they accidentally double-booked then that wouldn’t be freedom of speech, banning her to express that they disagree with her comments is freedom of speech.

I’m not making any comment on whether I agree with her or why she’s been banned. I have no idea who she is or what she’s said. It’s just that this particular scenario is a simple case of their freedom of expression trumping her freedom of expression because they own the venue.

Ofcourseshecan · 27/03/2023 15:33

ManipulatorPedipulator · 26/03/2023 15:26

Freedom of speech also means the freedom to say “I don’t want you to speak here”. Freedom of speech is not the right to an audience and is not the right to access any platform you wish to access - the platform decides whether or not you’re entitled to use them, because that decision is their freedom of speech. In the same vein, I’m entitled to make a sign saying “I like chicken nuggets”, I’m not entitled to attach it to your front door.

Can you really not see the contradiction in your statements?

Freedom of speech also means the freedom to say “I don’t want you to speak here”. Yes, that's the freedom of one person, or one group, to prevent another being heard at a public meeting.

What about the public's freedom to hear the information that person wanted to give? And when that information is not in step with the currently prevailing orthodoxy, that means the freedom to be given opposing facts in order to build up a clearer picture. Would you protest at a government seeking that kind of censorship?

the platform decides whether or not you're entitled to use them: true, they have the right to do that.
because that decision is their freedom of speech: false. It's their right to decide who uses their platform, but that is not freedom of speech.

Verv · 27/03/2023 14:07

It's not just speech thats being curtailed in the pursuit of an ideology, it's reality.

Fascinating really given that universities were supposed to be bastions of knowledge and reason.

wasteoffunds · 27/03/2023 13:40

86% YANBU 'to worry about free speech at Universities'

wasteoffunds · 27/03/2023 13:38

I know it is only a tiny sample but I cannot think of any other point in my life or my parents lvies when over 80% of people responding would agree that there is an issue with saying what you think at university!

Christina over 80% agree with you including me....I think you have got your YABU and YANBUs mixed up!

howmanybicycles · 27/03/2023 13:28

Yes. If she was disinvited then she wasn’t welcome to speak. The reason why isn’t relevant. It’s flatly not a violation of freedom of speech for an organisation to say they don’t want you to speak at their venue.

No, the reason why really DOES matter and it would be of great concern if Uni students don't understand that - something would be going very wrong with their education. It is not a level playing field re: who are 'disinvited' - this demonstrates the operation of power. If you let things play out, then if there is not enough interest, ideas can fizzle. If, however, you choose one side of a divided debate to disinvite and allow the other side free reign, e.g. to make policies and influence structures, you are an instrument of power. Presenting it as a neutral face that she was disinvited and refusing to examine the reason shows a lack of critical thinking. Now maybe that's OK in the average Jo(anna) but it's absolutely not OK for people who are being university level educated. Anyone who has had higher education and can't see that has been a victim of a poor system IMHO. Thinking in terms of analogies, if a black rights movement, or a suffrage movement (which maybe this is) speaker were disinvited, I don't think any intelligent person would try and argue that he reason why they were cancelled doesn't matter.

ChristinaXYZ · 27/03/2023 11:48

Riapia · 27/03/2023 07:57

If freedom means anything at all it means being able to tell people things that they do not wish to hear.
George Orwell.

Too right.

It is disproportionately women who seem to be suffering too. I agree with @DemiColon that it is not just a standard free speech issue either as universities really do have a very particular role. I know it is only a tiny sample but I cannot think of any other point in my life or my parents lvies when over 80% of people responding would agree that there is an issue with saying what you think at university!

I just wish the so-called-conservative government would fine both Royal Holloway and Kings and then set about truly establishing free speech for all side including the right for restrained protest that is not intimdating and does not prevent speakers being heard. (like this lot here trying to prevent women form speaking to each other https://twitter.com/Ashworth101/status/1640250941709377536 not at a university I know but I bet a large proportion of the mostly young male protestors are students and seeing this is part of the chilling effect on young women including at university)

When I was at university you couldn't walk past the union building without someone shoving a leaflet arguing for or against something into your hand. Back when building an argument was a thing. So sad for students now - all that money spent just to learn the hymn book.

https://twitter.com/Ashworth101/status/1640250941709377536

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread