Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry about free speech at universities

189 replies

ChristinaXYZ · 26/03/2023 14:42

Despite the various moves by the government to supposedly protect free speech and normal academic deabte the situation on the ground does not seem to change at all.

In the last week Claire Fox was disinvited from Royal Holloway for a deabte on free speech I believe - incredible as that may seem. Some students want to hear what she had to say and had invited her but got 'strong-armed' out of it by the students' union and then failed by the university admin who should have backed free speech.

And before people say it can't be that bad, Claire Fox's was disinvited after liking a Ricky Gervias joke - going on his social media profile that means millions and millions of us are also not fit to speak to university students!

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/03/22/chilling-truth-cancellation/

Today this:

"Dr John Armstrong, a scholar at King's College London (KCL), applied to carry out a survey of elite athletes and volunteers on whether trans women, who are born male, should compete in women's track and field categories and whether they felt they could express their views.

However, the university's ethics panel rejected his application last week citing equality and diversity concerns, in what has been labelled an attack on academic freedom."

Further in the article it goes on to say:

"Dr Armstrong told The Telegraph: "They appear to be trying to prevent me from using the concept of sex at all. I am not misgendering any individuals, I am just accurately using the terms male and female.

"I’m being blocked from conducting research and it’s impacting upon my academic freedom.

"No serious work has been done by the various federations to try to find out the opinions of people in athletics, both at the grassroots and elite athletes.
"By refusing to allow people to conduct research that doesn’t meet certain activist viewpoints, that undermines the credibility of research in general.""

You can read much more here https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/03/26/transgender-athlete-research-rejected-professor-called-trans/

What it must be like to study and work in this kind of cloistered enviroment with a kind of inquisition checking up on whther you have transgressed I can't imagine. there must be hundreds of little choices staff and students make every day to conform - changing what they say,m what they write, the topics they're prepared to research. All the little chilling-effect ramifications that never make the headlines.

And if you think your family is woke enough for your teens to pass the purity tests when they get to unviersity - you're wrong. You can't feed this monster to pacify it. If wants bigger and bigger sacrifices and keeps changing the rules.

I just wish the governemnt would do more. Much more. And now.

The chilling truth about my cancellation

I wasn’t the victim when a university vetoed my talk. It was the young people failed by snowflake adults

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/03/22/chilling-truth-cancellation

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
JemimaTiggywinkles · 28/03/2023 09:12

Pointing out that a particular behaviour is freedom of speech is not defending that behaviour.

I don't think it counts as "pointing out" when your assertion is incorrect.

Failing to invite someone you don't want to hear is (arguably) a demonstration of freedom of expression. Rescinding an invitation due to pressure from a group intent on censoring people is most certainly not.

ManipulatorPedipulator · 28/03/2023 09:06

RosaBonheur · 28/03/2023 08:51

I mean, it's literally there in your first post, but whatever.

Except it’s not. Pointing out that a particular behaviour is freedom of speech is not defending that behaviour. Just because you recognise someone’s right to say something doesn’t mean you’re defending the content of what they’re saying. That’s the whole premise of freedom of speech - if you agree with freedom of speech it applies to opinions that you both agree with and disagree with.

It’s freedom of speech for John to say he hates olives. If you were saying John had no right to say that then I’d point out it’s his freedom of speech. It doesn’t mean I’m making any comment at all on olives.

RosaBonheur · 28/03/2023 08:51

ManipulatorPedipulator · 28/03/2023 08:43

So, I (checks notes) didn’t do what you’re accusing me of? Cool

I mean, it's literally there in your first post, but whatever.

ManipulatorPedipulator · 28/03/2023 08:43

RosaBonheur · 27/03/2023 22:39

When you called... (checks notes) deplatforming someone whose views don't align with the establishment position "freedom of speech".

In the context of a university, no less.

So, I (checks notes) didn’t do what you’re accusing me of? Cool

JemimaTiggywinkles · 28/03/2023 08:20

ToWhitToWhoo, in your point (2) you are completely sidestepping the fact that some students did want to hear the speaker. I have no problem with a person not being invited because nobody wants to go to their talk. But if some people do want to hear her, and others don't, surely the obvious thing is to allow the talk to go ahead and nobody is forced to attend? The university have instead allowed censorship, which is certainly a free speech issue.

Don't forget that a great many important academic theories were once considered unpopular, controversial and even offensive. Darwin and Galileo are two very obvious examples. Just because someone is unpopular and goes against the prevailing wisdom of their time doesn't mean they're wrong. And universities should be places were unpopular ideas aren't censored.

ToWhitToWhoo · 27/03/2023 23:50

WishingMyLifeAway · 27/03/2023 18:54

But surely you don't want to be deplatforming people with differing viewpoints at a university? Surely universities should be exactly where differing viewpoints should be freely discussed and debated and critical thinking taught?

If we don't have this we are effectively teaching our young people to have one point of view and not to be able to think for themselves. That's extremely worrying.

It also seems as if some students do want to hear what these speakers have to say. And other's (a minority?) are blocking it by "shouting loudly". People should not be blocked from speaking because others are shouting over them.

Plus the OP has drawn attention to a wider issue in that research is now being blocked in the name of inclusivity. This seems like another step further in censorship and the promotion of one way of thinking.

I personally don't care what your opinion is and what the subject is about. This attack on free speech and academic freedoms is extremely concerning.

In most cases, such speakers are being invited or disinvited by student organizations- not by the academic lecturers, or the university as an institution.

I agree that people shouldn't be invited and then disinvited. Very unprofessional and 'flaky'. But no one has a right to be invited in the first place.

BTW, the strongest attacks on 'free speech and academic freedoms' that I have observed or heard about over many years as a university teacher have involved, not big-P Political controversies, but occasions where senior academics have tried to block speaker invitations, publication of journal articles, and even job appointments, grant applications, and even students' examination success, as a result of disagreements over rather obscure academic theories, or simply someone being considered insufficiently respectful toward a powerful person. Not common, I'm glad to say; but certainly happens on occasion; and the most extreme cases that I know about occurred 20 or 30 years ago, so it's not a new thing.

ToWhitToWhoo · 27/03/2023 23:33

I think there are two rather different issues that keep being confused:

(1) Whether students should have the right to avoid potentially 'triggering' course content. There, I am with the free speech absolutists. Nobody has GOT to study any particular subject; but if you do choose to, you should not be able to select only what's comfortable for you. If you don't want to hear about serious illness and death, don't study medicine. If you don't want to read books that might make you feel uncomfortable, don't study English literature. If you don't want to hear anything that might call your religious faith into question, don't study philosophy. Etc. But don't demand that the subjects be watered down to avoid upsetting you, or that you should have special exemptions from parts of the content.

(2) Whether people with unpopular views should be invited to speak at universities in an extracurricular context. That is a more complex issue, as such talks are not part of a course, and no one has a RIGHT to be invited to speak. I think it's a pity if people are too readily excluded as speakers- but they are not being denied a basic freedom, as after all, most people never get to give talks to university societies; and such societies usually have limited budgets and have to select speakers on one basis or another. I also think there's a difference between, at one extreme, excluding a speaker on an academic subject because they posted something controversial on social media 10 years ago; at the other extreme, excluding a professional troll like Katie Hopkins who only wants to come to stir up trouble; and, between the extremes, excluding a politician whose views are disliked by the student organizers.

RosaBonheur · 27/03/2023 22:39

ManipulatorPedipulator · 27/03/2023 21:40

Strange. Where did I defend it?

When you called... (checks notes) deplatforming someone whose views don't align with the establishment position "freedom of speech".

In the context of a university, no less.

howmanybicycles · 27/03/2023 22:31

Free speech and academic freedoms means hosts of any event can bar any speakers they choose. It works both ways.

But they invited someone then disinvited them. You are refusing to address that fact. They made a choice to change their decision - why do you thin that is and how can it still be free speech if they felt the need to do that? Are you suggesting that they just randomly changed their minds? If that's not what you're suggesting, please explain.

ManipulatorPedipulator · 27/03/2023 21:40

RosaBonheur · 27/03/2023 20:45

Well you certainly appeared to be defending it in your very first post on this thread.

Strange. Where did I defend it?

RosaBonheur · 27/03/2023 20:45

ManipulatorPedipulator · 27/03/2023 19:52

Where did I defend it? Stop accusing me of things I haven’t done just because you want to be angry at me.

Well you certainly appeared to be defending it in your very first post on this thread.

GCAcademic · 27/03/2023 20:07

JemimaTiggywinkles · 27/03/2023 19:24

But surely you don't want to be deplatforming people with differing viewpoints at a university?

I’m quite shock that anyone would think it’s okay. The government have recently reminded schools that they are categorically not allowed to only offer a platform to one side of any political argument. So a school cannot, for example, only invite speakers who are left wing. Because we have a responsibility to those we educate to ensure that they hear a balance of viewpoints rather than indoctrinating them. The same standard surely should apply to universities.

Universities are supposed to uphold a higher standard in this regard. That's not just an opinion of what they ought to do, it's a statement of what they are required to do, according to regulatory frameworks. The fact that some people on here are saying "they can ban who they like" is indicative of poor understanding. That a poster would also say that a marketing department could ban a speaker is indicative of how corrupted the university sector (or attitudes to it) has become thanks to capitalism.

GCAcademic · 27/03/2023 20:03

Free speech and academic freedoms means hosts of any event can bar any speakers they choose. It works both ways

But the hosts of the event wanted to host it. They were prevented from doing so.

You're repeatedly failing to understand the difference between freedom of expression and censorship. It's a pretty crucial distinction. Nor do you understand the specific role that universities are charged with to uphold freedom of speech and academic freedom.

ManipulatorPedipulator · 27/03/2023 19:55

WishingMyLifeAway · 27/03/2023 18:54

But surely you don't want to be deplatforming people with differing viewpoints at a university? Surely universities should be exactly where differing viewpoints should be freely discussed and debated and critical thinking taught?

If we don't have this we are effectively teaching our young people to have one point of view and not to be able to think for themselves. That's extremely worrying.

It also seems as if some students do want to hear what these speakers have to say. And other's (a minority?) are blocking it by "shouting loudly". People should not be blocked from speaking because others are shouting over them.

Plus the OP has drawn attention to a wider issue in that research is now being blocked in the name of inclusivity. This seems like another step further in censorship and the promotion of one way of thinking.

I personally don't care what your opinion is and what the subject is about. This attack on free speech and academic freedoms is extremely concerning.

Nothing I’ve said disagrees with anything you’ve said except for the final line. Free speech and academic freedoms means hosts of any event can bar any speakers they choose. It works both ways.

ManipulatorPedipulator · 27/03/2023 19:52

RosaBonheur · 27/03/2023 17:21

People are calling you out for defending this chilling behaviour in the higher education sector.

Universities are supposed to encourage independent thought, not try to ban it.

You get that, right?

Where did I defend it? Stop accusing me of things I haven’t done just because you want to be angry at me.

titchy · 27/03/2023 19:29

JemimaTiggywinkles · 27/03/2023 19:24

But surely you don't want to be deplatforming people with differing viewpoints at a university?

I’m quite shock that anyone would think it’s okay. The government have recently reminded schools that they are categorically not allowed to only offer a platform to one side of any political argument. So a school cannot, for example, only invite speakers who are left wing. Because we have a responsibility to those we educate to ensure that they hear a balance of viewpoints rather than indoctrinating them. The same standard surely should apply to universities.

The same standard DOES apply to universities:
Registered universities and colleges must comply with our regulatory frameworkk^. This framework, among other conditions, sets out standards for the way universities and colleges are managed and governed. And one of these ‘public interest governance principles’ is freedom of speech.

From OfS.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 27/03/2023 19:24

But surely you don't want to be deplatforming people with differing viewpoints at a university?

I’m quite shock that anyone would think it’s okay. The government have recently reminded schools that they are categorically not allowed to only offer a platform to one side of any political argument. So a school cannot, for example, only invite speakers who are left wing. Because we have a responsibility to those we educate to ensure that they hear a balance of viewpoints rather than indoctrinating them. The same standard surely should apply to universities.

WishingMyLifeAway · 27/03/2023 18:54

ManipulatorPedipulator · 26/03/2023 15:26

Freedom of speech also means the freedom to say “I don’t want you to speak here”. Freedom of speech is not the right to an audience and is not the right to access any platform you wish to access - the platform decides whether or not you’re entitled to use them, because that decision is their freedom of speech. In the same vein, I’m entitled to make a sign saying “I like chicken nuggets”, I’m not entitled to attach it to your front door.

But surely you don't want to be deplatforming people with differing viewpoints at a university? Surely universities should be exactly where differing viewpoints should be freely discussed and debated and critical thinking taught?

If we don't have this we are effectively teaching our young people to have one point of view and not to be able to think for themselves. That's extremely worrying.

It also seems as if some students do want to hear what these speakers have to say. And other's (a minority?) are blocking it by "shouting loudly". People should not be blocked from speaking because others are shouting over them.

Plus the OP has drawn attention to a wider issue in that research is now being blocked in the name of inclusivity. This seems like another step further in censorship and the promotion of one way of thinking.

I personally don't care what your opinion is and what the subject is about. This attack on free speech and academic freedoms is extremely concerning.

howmanybicycles · 27/03/2023 17:48

ManipulatorPedipulator · 27/03/2023 17:07

No. That isn’t my argument. I don’t know why you’ve invented an argument, attributed it to me and then argued against your invention rather than just countering what I actually said.

I'm not inventing an argument, I'm asking you to explain yourself more clearly. Iv that's not what you were saying then can you say again what you mean in relation to an disinvite (not an original decision not to invite which is irrelevant to this discussion) towards an oppressed group. Apologies if I got you wrong, it just looks like you're not addressing the reality of the fact that a member of an oppressed group was disinvited or suggesting that even though she was disinvited, the reality of her oppression is not relevant and that this can be seen as simply a matter of free speech in the way that perhaps asking a person to present a 3 hour long presentation about something people generally aren't interested in in a massive hall is. How do you account for the reality of the context when you suggest this is free speech?

Sartre · 27/03/2023 17:28

Agree. I’m a lecturer and seriously have to watch my step. I know there are certain topics not even worth broaching, it could mean the end of my career and isn’t worthwhile. Students are much more ‘offended’ than they were when I was at uni, it seems to almost be a cultural thing. As if being offended is actually an argument. I don’t mention trans issues at all, I wouldn’t dare.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 27/03/2023 17:25

That isn’t my argument.

Is your argument that the university is entitled to kowtow to whoever shouts loudest and ban speakers on that group's say so? Because I profoundly disagree with that too.

RosaBonheur · 27/03/2023 17:22

Any person employed by a university who has the power to cancel an event such as this and actually does so for this reason is not fit to be in their job and they should be fired.

RosaBonheur · 27/03/2023 17:21

ManipulatorPedipulator · 27/03/2023 16:01

Whoever at the university is employed to make that decision. I have no idea what their name is, how would I? The job title and responsibilities would vary from one university to the next. It could be made by someone managing their marketing, or managing their events, or from a higher level than that. It could be decided by a board rather than one individual. Often it’s the students union rather than the university itself. It doesn’t matter though - the university decided that.

Your second two paragraphs aren’t relevant to me or what I said. They’re just an attempt to drag me into an argument because you got prematurely offended by what I said and are looking for an outlet for your outrage. As I’ve said, I don’t know who she is or what she’s said - how on earth would I know whether their decision was rational or reasonable? The fact is, they’re entitled to be “batshit” if they want to be - it’s their venue.

People are calling you out for defending this chilling behaviour in the higher education sector.

Universities are supposed to encourage independent thought, not try to ban it.

You get that, right?

ManipulatorPedipulator · 27/03/2023 17:07

howmanybicycles · 27/03/2023 17:05

So your argument is that it could have been that the university, of their own violation and free from any of the current abounding pressures just changed their mind. Well, it's an argument. Just one that I think ignores power, structural inequalities and the reasons why people make decisions. Yes, they have the right to say "I don't want you to speak here" but that's not what happened here. They invited then disinvited someone. To see that as just a 'freedom of speech' issue is, I think, worryingly simplistic. You are welcome to disagree with me but simplifying the issue to something which did not happen is not helpful.

No. That isn’t my argument. I don’t know why you’ve invented an argument, attributed it to me and then argued against your invention rather than just countering what I actually said.

howmanybicycles · 27/03/2023 17:05

ManipulatorPedipulator · 27/03/2023 16:15

I didn’t comment on why she was uninvited so how could my comment on that be too simple? I didn’t make any comment - simple or complex - on that.

You’ve guessed incorrectly. I’ve made no comment at all on that. You’ve just taken my non-comment as a comment that I must disagree with you.

So your argument is that it could have been that the university, of their own violation and free from any of the current abounding pressures just changed their mind. Well, it's an argument. Just one that I think ignores power, structural inequalities and the reasons why people make decisions. Yes, they have the right to say "I don't want you to speak here" but that's not what happened here. They invited then disinvited someone. To see that as just a 'freedom of speech' issue is, I think, worryingly simplistic. You are welcome to disagree with me but simplifying the issue to something which did not happen is not helpful.

Swipe left for the next trending thread