Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To worry about free speech at universities

189 replies

ChristinaXYZ · 26/03/2023 14:42

Despite the various moves by the government to supposedly protect free speech and normal academic deabte the situation on the ground does not seem to change at all.

In the last week Claire Fox was disinvited from Royal Holloway for a deabte on free speech I believe - incredible as that may seem. Some students want to hear what she had to say and had invited her but got 'strong-armed' out of it by the students' union and then failed by the university admin who should have backed free speech.

And before people say it can't be that bad, Claire Fox's was disinvited after liking a Ricky Gervias joke - going on his social media profile that means millions and millions of us are also not fit to speak to university students!

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/03/22/chilling-truth-cancellation/

Today this:

"Dr John Armstrong, a scholar at King's College London (KCL), applied to carry out a survey of elite athletes and volunteers on whether trans women, who are born male, should compete in women's track and field categories and whether they felt they could express their views.

However, the university's ethics panel rejected his application last week citing equality and diversity concerns, in what has been labelled an attack on academic freedom."

Further in the article it goes on to say:

"Dr Armstrong told The Telegraph: "They appear to be trying to prevent me from using the concept of sex at all. I am not misgendering any individuals, I am just accurately using the terms male and female.

"I’m being blocked from conducting research and it’s impacting upon my academic freedom.

"No serious work has been done by the various federations to try to find out the opinions of people in athletics, both at the grassroots and elite athletes.
"By refusing to allow people to conduct research that doesn’t meet certain activist viewpoints, that undermines the credibility of research in general.""

You can read much more here https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/03/26/transgender-athlete-research-rejected-professor-called-trans/

What it must be like to study and work in this kind of cloistered enviroment with a kind of inquisition checking up on whther you have transgressed I can't imagine. there must be hundreds of little choices staff and students make every day to conform - changing what they say,m what they write, the topics they're prepared to research. All the little chilling-effect ramifications that never make the headlines.

And if you think your family is woke enough for your teens to pass the purity tests when they get to unviersity - you're wrong. You can't feed this monster to pacify it. If wants bigger and bigger sacrifices and keeps changing the rules.

I just wish the governemnt would do more. Much more. And now.

The chilling truth about my cancellation

I wasn’t the victim when a university vetoed my talk. It was the young people failed by snowflake adults

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/03/22/chilling-truth-cancellation

OP posts:
Thread gallery
6
howmanybicycles · 28/03/2023 11:44

titchy · 28/03/2023 11:06

For transparency - can we stop saying it's the university /management/ diversity officers that has decided/does decide who to invite/disinvite etc.

It isn't - it's the students union.

Unis fund their students unions, and have a statutory responsibility to uphold freedom of speech which extends to ensuring all student voices are heard. Including those that did the initial inviting. I'm not discipline their SU for not allowing that initial group of students to have a voice, RH has not upheld that statutory responsibility.

OfS could take action, but as that is likely to be a costly and long process, appears to prefer to wait till the free speech bill has gone through parliament.

But I repeat this case, and most others, is not the uni doing the inviting/no platforming. It's the SUs, hell bent on only representing some of their students.

Thank you. This is really helpful context.

howmanybicycles · 28/03/2023 11:43

ManipulatorPedipulator · 28/03/2023 11:13

That’s not what I said. This is your problem - you think the whole world is stupid if they don’t agree with you. You ignore anything said to you and twist everything.

You know, freedom of speech also comes with the option to listen. Maybe you should consider that choice some time.

If you're listening, why are you not answering my question about how your point relates to the scenario being discussed?

howmanybicycles · 28/03/2023 11:41

ManipulatorPedipulator · 28/03/2023 11:27

Interpret it as if I meant the exact words I wrote rather than some strange twisted invention, like you keep doing.

If we just look at the exact words then it's hard to see it as relevant to this conversation.

ManipulatorPedipulator · 28/03/2023 11:27

JemimaTiggywinkles · 28/03/2023 11:21

I think we all know that universities can make any decision they want.

My point is actually, no, they can't. hey do not have the same rights to freedom of expression as I do, because I am a human and the university (or its student union) is not. So ManipulatorPedipulator's whole argument is based on a faulty premise. A university does not have the human right to freedom of expression because it isn't a flipping human!

Unis fund their students unions, and have a statutory responsibility to uphold freedom of speech which extends to ensuring all student voices are heard.

This is really good to know. Its a shame it isn't being done by the university, though. And even more annoying that nobody bothers enforcing it.

😂I didn’t say they were human.

ManipulatorPedipulator · 28/03/2023 11:27

RosaBonheur · 28/03/2023 11:20

I didn't call anyone stupid.

I am just not sure how we are supposed to interpret your first post other than, "not letting people speak at a university is just the university exercising it's right to free speech".

Interpret it as if I meant the exact words I wrote rather than some strange twisted invention, like you keep doing.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 28/03/2023 11:21

I think we all know that universities can make any decision they want.

My point is actually, no, they can't. hey do not have the same rights to freedom of expression as I do, because I am a human and the university (or its student union) is not. So ManipulatorPedipulator's whole argument is based on a faulty premise. A university does not have the human right to freedom of expression because it isn't a flipping human!

Unis fund their students unions, and have a statutory responsibility to uphold freedom of speech which extends to ensuring all student voices are heard.

This is really good to know. Its a shame it isn't being done by the university, though. And even more annoying that nobody bothers enforcing it.

RosaBonheur · 28/03/2023 11:20

ManipulatorPedipulator · 28/03/2023 11:13

That’s not what I said. This is your problem - you think the whole world is stupid if they don’t agree with you. You ignore anything said to you and twist everything.

You know, freedom of speech also comes with the option to listen. Maybe you should consider that choice some time.

I didn't call anyone stupid.

I am just not sure how we are supposed to interpret your first post other than, "not letting people speak at a university is just the university exercising it's right to free speech".

ManipulatorPedipulator · 28/03/2023 11:13

RosaBonheur · 28/03/2023 11:00

You think that the group of people capable of having the loudest tantrum being able to stop those with opposing points of view from speaking at their university is "free speech". Despite the fact that they are literally opposing (other people's) free speech.

If you want to die on that hill, I won't stop you.

We will have to agree to disagree.

Jesus wept.

That’s not what I said. This is your problem - you think the whole world is stupid if they don’t agree with you. You ignore anything said to you and twist everything.

You know, freedom of speech also comes with the option to listen. Maybe you should consider that choice some time.

titchy · 28/03/2023 11:06

For transparency - can we stop saying it's the university /management/ diversity officers that has decided/does decide who to invite/disinvite etc.

It isn't - it's the students union.

Unis fund their students unions, and have a statutory responsibility to uphold freedom of speech which extends to ensuring all student voices are heard. Including those that did the initial inviting. I'm not discipline their SU for not allowing that initial group of students to have a voice, RH has not upheld that statutory responsibility.

OfS could take action, but as that is likely to be a costly and long process, appears to prefer to wait till the free speech bill has gone through parliament.

But I repeat this case, and most others, is not the uni doing the inviting/no platforming. It's the SUs, hell bent on only representing some of their students.

RosaBonheur · 28/03/2023 11:00

ManipulatorPedipulator · 28/03/2023 10:53

I’m not misunderstanding you - I understand you just fine. I disagree with you. There’s a difference. Not everyone who thinks differently from you is some kind of intellectual subhuman.

You keep stating your opinion as if it’s fact and then acting like it means actual facts are incorrect.

You don’t seem to recognise that you’re the one being a “shouty snowflake” right now, throwing a tantrum and assuming I must be stupid because I dared to think you’re wrong. I’ve heard you out, I’ve read your comments, I’ve put up with you repeatedly ignoring what I’ve said and changing direction when you have no response, I’ve countered you making incorrect assumptions and false accusations. I still think you’re wrong.

You think that the group of people capable of having the loudest tantrum being able to stop those with opposing points of view from speaking at their university is "free speech". Despite the fact that they are literally opposing (other people's) free speech.

If you want to die on that hill, I won't stop you.

We will have to agree to disagree.

Jesus wept.

ManipulatorPedipulator · 28/03/2023 10:53

RosaBonheur · 28/03/2023 10:48

You're misunderstanding me. Deliberately, I suspect.

There should be no person and no group of people within a university who have the power to ban speakers invited by another group simply because they disagree with their views. This is not free speech. It is the literal opposite of free speech.

If these censorship decisions are being made by staff, those staff need to be sacked for such an egregious abuse of power and failure to understand what a university is actually for.

If they are being made by shouty snowflake students, an actual grown up needs to stand up to them and make it clear that if they feel threatened by opposing points of view, they should not be at university.

I’m not misunderstanding you - I understand you just fine. I disagree with you. There’s a difference. Not everyone who thinks differently from you is some kind of intellectual subhuman.

You keep stating your opinion as if it’s fact and then acting like it means actual facts are incorrect.

You don’t seem to recognise that you’re the one being a “shouty snowflake” right now, throwing a tantrum and assuming I must be stupid because I dared to think you’re wrong. I’ve heard you out, I’ve read your comments, I’ve put up with you repeatedly ignoring what I’ve said and changing direction when you have no response, I’ve countered you making incorrect assumptions and false accusations. I still think you’re wrong.

RosaBonheur · 28/03/2023 10:48

ManipulatorPedipulator · 28/03/2023 10:19

Universities are not run by the students. Just because the customers who hate olives pay for their meals too doesn’t mean they get to decide on the decor. Universities are managed by their boards, the board can delegate certain responsibilities to whomever they choose.

If you’re now arguing that the people who made the decision she’s not welcome didn’t have the authority to make that decision then why is she listening? She should just turn up if that’s the case.

You're misunderstanding me. Deliberately, I suspect.

There should be no person and no group of people within a university who have the power to ban speakers invited by another group simply because they disagree with their views. This is not free speech. It is the literal opposite of free speech.

If these censorship decisions are being made by staff, those staff need to be sacked for such an egregious abuse of power and failure to understand what a university is actually for.

If they are being made by shouty snowflake students, an actual grown up needs to stand up to them and make it clear that if they feel threatened by opposing points of view, they should not be at university.

ItsMeAgainYesHowDidYouGuess2 · 28/03/2023 10:24

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

ManipulatorPedipulator · 28/03/2023 10:19

RosaBonheur · 28/03/2023 09:27

Right, so whose university is it?

These little tin pot dictators in the diversity office own the university, do they?

According to whom?

I'm pretty sure the people who disagree with them paid their fees too.

Universities are not run by the students. Just because the customers who hate olives pay for their meals too doesn’t mean they get to decide on the decor. Universities are managed by their boards, the board can delegate certain responsibilities to whomever they choose.

If you’re now arguing that the people who made the decision she’s not welcome didn’t have the authority to make that decision then why is she listening? She should just turn up if that’s the case.

howmanybicycles · 28/03/2023 09:43

ManipulatorPedipulator · 28/03/2023 09:23

It’s freedom of speech to say “no John, I like olives, you can’t come to my restaurant and put up a sign saying “I hate olives” even though some of my customers also hate olives and have said they want that sign because I have other customers who do like olives and I have an olive supplier that I don’t want to upset”. And it’s not a violation of John’s freedom of speech to tell him to put his sign somewhere else.

That example bears no relation to the one that started the conversation. Olives are a relatively neutral topic, no one was trying to put up a sign and there was no initial invite then a disinvite. So you are not making a relevant point. Is anyone saying that such a simple issue is not freedom of speech? This is what I mean by simplification. It's like saying that people have the right to choose what colour pants they wear and then trying to use that as am argument to suggest that they also have the right to choose whether to pay taxes.

For those staying on topic, I have found your ideas really interesting and informative. Sometimes attempts at a derail are actually really useful because it prompts others to share thoughts and ideas which help think deeper about important issues. In this instance it's helped me better understand the ways in which censorship is hampering education.

AlisonDonut · 28/03/2023 09:41

JemimaTiggywinkles · 28/03/2023 09:35

As an individual I can refuse entry to my home based on whatever I want. I can refuse entry to all members of a particular race, or religion or whatever I want. You might think me racist, or phobic or whatever, but I can still do it without any legal recourse. Because I am a human and have human rights. A business simply cannot do that. Because the business is not a human and therefore does not have the same rights as me.

When the business used to be centrally funded it couldn't.

Now it is funded by the students (many of whom will never pay back the loans of course) they play to the loudest and most aggressive tune.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 28/03/2023 09:35

As an individual I can refuse entry to my home based on whatever I want. I can refuse entry to all members of a particular race, or religion or whatever I want. You might think me racist, or phobic or whatever, but I can still do it without any legal recourse. Because I am a human and have human rights. A business simply cannot do that. Because the business is not a human and therefore does not have the same rights as me.

JemimaTiggywinkles · 28/03/2023 09:32

ManipulatorPedipulator, are you aware that a university is not the same thing as a human? And that only humans can claim human rights? Organisations / businesses do not have human rights. The people who work there do, and the people who use them do. But the individual business does not.

RosaBonheur · 28/03/2023 09:29

AlisonDonut · 28/03/2023 09:23

Weirdly, I want to listen to the opinions of people I disagree with, so that I can continue to measure my thinking against theirs.

This whole attitude of a generation of young adults unable to even listen to another point of view without having to rush to a safe space and quiver in fear of what another person might think, is crippling the whole of society and will end up in a massive backlash.

The ones willing to listen and engage and talk to other people who don't like Dr Who/Star Trek/Harry Potter are the ones who will be more able to cope with real life.

Exactly this.

A university isn't supposed to be a safe space. It's supposed to be somewhere you learn and grow, in large part through exposure to different people and ideas.

If you're looking for a safe space, I suggest you enrol in a crèche instead.

RosaBonheur · 28/03/2023 09:27

ManipulatorPedipulator · 28/03/2023 09:23

It’s freedom of speech to say “no John, I like olives, you can’t come to my restaurant and put up a sign saying “I hate olives” even though some of my customers also hate olives and have said they want that sign because I have other customers who do like olives and I have an olive supplier that I don’t want to upset”. And it’s not a violation of John’s freedom of speech to tell him to put his sign somewhere else.

Right, so whose university is it?

These little tin pot dictators in the diversity office own the university, do they?

According to whom?

I'm pretty sure the people who disagree with them paid their fees too.

AlisonDonut · 28/03/2023 09:23

Weirdly, I want to listen to the opinions of people I disagree with, so that I can continue to measure my thinking against theirs.

This whole attitude of a generation of young adults unable to even listen to another point of view without having to rush to a safe space and quiver in fear of what another person might think, is crippling the whole of society and will end up in a massive backlash.

The ones willing to listen and engage and talk to other people who don't like Dr Who/Star Trek/Harry Potter are the ones who will be more able to cope with real life.

ManipulatorPedipulator · 28/03/2023 09:23

RosaBonheur · 28/03/2023 09:15

As for your olives analogy, it's freedom of speech for John to say he hates olives. It's not freedom of speech for John to prevent others from saying they like olives, or eating them.

It’s freedom of speech to say “no John, I like olives, you can’t come to my restaurant and put up a sign saying “I hate olives” even though some of my customers also hate olives and have said they want that sign because I have other customers who do like olives and I have an olive supplier that I don’t want to upset”. And it’s not a violation of John’s freedom of speech to tell him to put his sign somewhere else.

ManipulatorPedipulator · 28/03/2023 09:21

RosaBonheur · 28/03/2023 09:14

Saying that something is free speech is defending it.

And you've got it wrong anyway. Some jobsworth on the diversity committee deciding that the university should deplatform anyone they personally don't agree with is not a university exercising its right to free speech. A university is a broad church. It is not just one person, or one small group of people who get to decide what "the university's" views should be. A university is the sum of the people within it.

If one group within a university have decided they would like to invite a certain speaker, another group shouldn't be able to just veto them. That's not exercising your right to free speech. It's preventing others from exercising their right to free speech.

If you don't agree with the views of the speaker, don't attend the event. Or better still, do attend the event, listen to what they have to say, and then debate them in an intelligent manner.

But this isn't debate, this is dictatorship, and it has no place in a university.

Saying that something is free speech is defending it.

No, it really isn’t. If you think people are only allowed to say things that you agree with, you’re not pro-freedom of speech.

RosaBonheur · 28/03/2023 09:15

As for your olives analogy, it's freedom of speech for John to say he hates olives. It's not freedom of speech for John to prevent others from saying they like olives, or eating them.

RosaBonheur · 28/03/2023 09:14

ManipulatorPedipulator · 28/03/2023 09:06

Except it’s not. Pointing out that a particular behaviour is freedom of speech is not defending that behaviour. Just because you recognise someone’s right to say something doesn’t mean you’re defending the content of what they’re saying. That’s the whole premise of freedom of speech - if you agree with freedom of speech it applies to opinions that you both agree with and disagree with.

It’s freedom of speech for John to say he hates olives. If you were saying John had no right to say that then I’d point out it’s his freedom of speech. It doesn’t mean I’m making any comment at all on olives.

Saying that something is free speech is defending it.

And you've got it wrong anyway. Some jobsworth on the diversity committee deciding that the university should deplatform anyone they personally don't agree with is not a university exercising its right to free speech. A university is a broad church. It is not just one person, or one small group of people who get to decide what "the university's" views should be. A university is the sum of the people within it.

If one group within a university have decided they would like to invite a certain speaker, another group shouldn't be able to just veto them. That's not exercising your right to free speech. It's preventing others from exercising their right to free speech.

If you don't agree with the views of the speaker, don't attend the event. Or better still, do attend the event, listen to what they have to say, and then debate them in an intelligent manner.

But this isn't debate, this is dictatorship, and it has no place in a university.