Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is obesity the responsibility of the NHS?

531 replies

snookspooks · 26/03/2023 12:54

I've read a few posts lately where posters say the NHS isn't doing enough to combat obesity. As far as I am aware people are taught from pre-school age upwards about healthy eating and the importance of exercise and a healthy lifestyle. This continues through secondary school. I don't know about in further education but I don't remember any from my own FE days. We have access to NHS information online about healthy lifestyles, and the information is repeated in pregnancy and post-natal days by midwives and health visitors (that was my experience but I appreciate it might not be the same for others). We are given the information and it's up to us as individuals what we do with that information. The idea is we use it to prevent getting obese in the first place.

If people do get obese, through whatever factors, and there are many that contribute to this, is it up to the NHS to fix this or should the onus be on individuals? What happened in countries without an NHS style system?

Cancers are mainly preventable but the NHS provides treatment for those but then we can't fix cancers by ourselves, or heart disease, or strokes, but obesity is something we can treat ourselves. I'm not saying it's easy but it is possible. Of course obesity is linked to those diseases/conditions so it's not straightforward.

Is too little responsibility put on those who are obese?

I don't think it's straightforward and I think it's impossible to give treatment for some partially or completely self-inflicted conditions but not others. It's an ethical nightmare. What do other countries do?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
AliceMcK · 29/03/2023 11:56

I’m obese, I have chronic health issues including chronic fatigue, I struggle to get out of bed let alone exercise. My health conditions mean I can’t eat certain foods including what are pushed as healthy foods, lots of green veg makes me violently sick and inflames my symptoms. I’m also restricted on diet due to some of my medications, meaning I have a very limited diet and although I’d love nothing more than to sit down and eat a giant plate of steamed broccoli, I physically can’t. Because I’m now so big it’s creating other medical issues on top of the ones that triggered my weight gain. Are you telling me it’s my fault I’ve become obese and shouldn’t get any help from the nhs?

BeretRaspberry · 29/03/2023 11:48

So if diets don't work should overweight and obese people just not bother to do anything about their weight because there's no point?

Pretty much, yes. That doesn’t mean they shouldn’t be encouraged to move more, drink less alcohol and eat well but those things can be done without focusing on weight.

3littlebeans · 29/03/2023 11:45

Snook that's the million dollar question really. We KNOW diets don't work so just keeping putting the blame on the obese person is completely counter productive. It would be more helpful to see what does work.

snookspooks · 29/03/2023 11:27

So if diets don't work should overweight and obese people just not bother to do anything about their weight because there's no point?

More needs to happen to stop people getting fat in the first place. Individually everyone needs to take responsibility for that, and nationally the government, food manufacturers, the NHS, schools etc. it's a fine balance I think between a responsible government and a nanny state and we all have choices to a greater or lesser extent. Defensiveness and blaming various things isn't the answer. Action not excuses. And I mean that individually and from the government and food manufacturers and anyone else who has the power the effect change.

OP posts:
BeretRaspberry · 29/03/2023 10:10

snookspooks · 29/03/2023 09:03

It might be more accurate to say they work but if people go back to eating too much and doing little exercise then of course it won't work long term. That's why changes need to be be lifelong not just for a few weeks. Healthy lifestyle, not a healthy few weeks or months or whatever. Medical issues aside of course.

They don’t work. Science proves that. There are strong biological reasons they don’t work. Survival being the main one. And people can and do engage in healthy behaviours and they’re still fat. And often ‘healthy’ too.

You mention ‘medical issues aside’…but it’s not just medical issues that affect people. It’s their socioeconomic status, their mental health, their lifestyles and personal circumstances. But people just assume that fat person are lazy and gluttonous, when that is just not true.

Quisquam · 29/03/2023 10:08

It might be more accurate to say they work but if people go back to eating too much and doing little exercise then of course it won't work long term. That's why changes need to be be lifelong not just for a few weeks. Healthy lifestyle, not a healthy few weeks or months or whatever. Medical issues aside of course.

I am a carer and can go to WW, whoever and lose 3 stone; but then something stressful happens - which means me caring 24/7, 3 hours sleep a night, etc and I don’t have the time or energy to think about what I am eating. I just eat whatever is to hand. I gain weight again; but then doctors tell me with regard to dieting:

”Don’t put any more stress on yourself!”

Imo, until England treats disabled people better in the NHS, social care and the benefits system; then they and unpaid family carers end up with additional long term health problems and a shorter life expectancy, due to poverty, stress and lack of time for medical appointments (for the carers). I have noticed most of my friends with disabled children have ended up overweight and/or with chronic health problems.

BeretRaspberry · 29/03/2023 10:06

QuertyGirl · 29/03/2023 09:26

So the consensus is, that the UK should give up and be fat and unhealthy?

Despite other countries having lower rates of obesity and much better health outcomes generally?

Exercise doesn't just protect against obesity but also dementia, heart disease, mental degradation, the ageing process (actually true- Google it) depression, anxiety, joint pain, arthritis...

But fat and unhealthy don’t always go hand in hand. People can exercise, eat well, not smoke or drink and still be fat.

Just like people can eat shit, not exercise, smoke like a chimney, drink like a sailor and still be thin.

QuertyGirl · 29/03/2023 09:26

So the consensus is, that the UK should give up and be fat and unhealthy?

Despite other countries having lower rates of obesity and much better health outcomes generally?

Exercise doesn't just protect against obesity but also dementia, heart disease, mental degradation, the ageing process (actually true- Google it) depression, anxiety, joint pain, arthritis...

GettingStuffed · 29/03/2023 09:04

Some obese people don't know how to eat healthily, some have mental health issues or eating disorders and some people just don't care.

The NHS does support obese people but if the underlying reason isn't tackled it fails

snookspooks · 29/03/2023 09:03

It might be more accurate to say they work but if people go back to eating too much and doing little exercise then of course it won't work long term. That's why changes need to be be lifelong not just for a few weeks. Healthy lifestyle, not a healthy few weeks or months or whatever. Medical issues aside of course.

OP posts:
3littlebeans · 29/03/2023 09:00

And yes of course I've tried diets...

3littlebeans · 29/03/2023 08:59

@theGooHasGone studies show it works for about 5% of people.
Can you imagine anything else where we say "do this it works!!!" Where there is only a 5% success rate?!

And to those above I have ME/cfs too and currently feeling so debilitated by it. I am scared what my future will look like. Before ME/cfs I used to belong to a walking group and walk coastal paths in particular. I really did like walking so it wasn't hard to "exercise." Now I can't its so hard when people suggest it as it isn't for want of trying!

pncr · 29/03/2023 08:41

theGooHasGone · 29/03/2023 04:28

I'm large and it's so disheartening knowing there isn't a real solution.

There absolutely is a real solution that works for the vast majority of people - eat less and exercise more. As long as you consume fewer calories than you use in the course of a day, the vast majority of people will lose weight. It really is that simple.

But it isn't that simple for everyone it isn't for me.

Howpo · 29/03/2023 07:35

3littlebeans · 28/03/2023 17:42

I'm large and it's so disheartening knowing there isn't a real solution.

Take heart, my MiL was obese, she is also in her 70s, she was waiting for knee surgery but after losing a significant amount of weight & physio, she no longer does need a new knee.

She has also kept it off too, diet and an indoor exercise bike, which she uses daily.

It can be done but its not easy at all.

BeretRaspberry · 29/03/2023 05:43

theGooHasGone · 29/03/2023 04:28

I'm large and it's so disheartening knowing there isn't a real solution.

There absolutely is a real solution that works for the vast majority of people - eat less and exercise more. As long as you consume fewer calories than you use in the course of a day, the vast majority of people will lose weight. It really is that simple.

It realy isn’t that simple. This explains why.

Why dieting doesn't usually work | Sandra Aamodt

In the US, 80% of girls have been on a diet by the time they're 10 years old. In this honest, raw talk, neuroscientist Sandra Aamodt uses her personal story ...

https://youtu.be/jn0Ygp7pMbA

theGooHasGone · 29/03/2023 04:28

I'm large and it's so disheartening knowing there isn't a real solution.

There absolutely is a real solution that works for the vast majority of people - eat less and exercise more. As long as you consume fewer calories than you use in the course of a day, the vast majority of people will lose weight. It really is that simple.

Rainbowsandbutterflies1990 · 28/03/2023 19:45

Also wanted to add. Not only is the guilt and shame from yourself at failing a diet u have society in general guit and shaming u for just the Audacity to be in a bigger body. I don't actually belive being in a bigger body is nessasery healthy but I belive when I was intuitively eating I was loosing weight (unfortunately diet culture thinking stepped in and I ended up putting on weight due to restricting and binging again) but I do belive when I've been in thinner body I havent been healthy either because I was in extremely disordered eating. Thin does not equal good and fat bad. People need to get that, unfortunately years and years of diet culture has ingrained that into us

pncr · 28/03/2023 19:44

ConstableGoody · 28/03/2023 19:42

@pncr presumably we are all a) liars and b) a bit dim as well as being disabled.

People don’t tend to use the word invalid anymore, but clearly they think of us as in-valid.

Oh this. Yes. This. IN - valid.

ConstableGoody · 28/03/2023 19:42

@pncr presumably we are all a) liars and b) a bit dim as well as being disabled.

People don’t tend to use the word invalid anymore, but clearly they think of us as in-valid.

Loraloralaughs · 28/03/2023 19:39

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Rainbowsandbutterflies1990 · 28/03/2023 19:39

Pestispeeved · 28/03/2023 19:25

It would be great if we could bring back Sure Start centres and keep them going for at least two generations. It would be wonderful if we could find ways to prevent excess weight in children. If only we could undo the starve binge cycle of the diet industry and encourage intuitive eating. But we can't even have the conversation.

The NHS will (of course) continue to treat as many people as it can, for as many thing as it has to.

This is what I find so baffling, when I started looking into intuitive eating I was like why isn't this like the standard. If I went to doctors about my weight, they would tell me to go on (another) diet. And i think they were giving free slimming world sessions. And the cycle would continue. Why isn't healthy relationship with food what the goal is. Why is restricting the normal and then ur called lazy and a failure when it doesn't work. Why are children taught about good and bad food when the natural way of eating food doesn't have good or bad it's just food. It's so hard to be in the intuitive eating space. When it isn't seen as normal. Disordered eating is seen as normal and diets cycles are seen as normal. No wonder there is a weight problem .

pncr · 28/03/2023 19:36

Until I became physically disabled I was fit and active and slim.

Funny how lots of disabilities mean I have meds that have a side effect of weight gain and also can't exercise due to pain and it not being recommended - and now I'm fat.

But that must be my FAULT. I SHOULD. JUST. TRY. HARDER.

Have I tried this or that. I must be lying about what I eat. I can't possibly have been told that I shouldn't exercise as it will wreck my leg and hip. Nope. Couldn't have been told that by a consultant. Not at all.

Why is it so prevalent to not believe disabled people?

Makes me so angry.

ConstableGoody · 28/03/2023 19:29

@pncr oh yeah, the fat parents always have fat kids yada yada yada… the long skinny kid here must not be mine! Or the healthy dog.

@BeretRaspberry I have M.E too. It’s as if people think you prefer being ill/disabled instead of desperately wishing you could still get on with your life… and all these judgey people think it’s a choice and it will never happen to them.

Pestispeeved · 28/03/2023 19:25

It would be great if we could bring back Sure Start centres and keep them going for at least two generations. It would be wonderful if we could find ways to prevent excess weight in children. If only we could undo the starve binge cycle of the diet industry and encourage intuitive eating. But we can't even have the conversation.

The NHS will (of course) continue to treat as many people as it can, for as many thing as it has to.

BeretRaspberry · 28/03/2023 19:22

ConstableGoody · 28/03/2023 19:14

@pncr I hear you. People tell me I should exercise, I explain that I’ve been told I shouldn’t because it causes chemical reactions in my brain that reduce brain function and… people don’t believe me! Like I spend my time making up excuses not to do stuff.

Made all the more aggravating because until I got ill I was a size 6/8 fitness freak! Not that that should matter- people should keep their neb out. Who cares how far or thin other people are?!

This is a similar scenario to me with having ME/CFS. Some days I hardly have the energy to get out of bed. If I do anything, it affects me. We went for a meal on Friday night and afterwards I was in agony because of being sat on a dining chair for a couple of hours. And on Saturday I slept most of the day to recover.

This is a far cry from my previous life where I swam 5/6 times a week (for leisure, not competitively or anything). I played football, walked a lot. I’d give anything to be able to go back to that.