Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is obesity the responsibility of the NHS?

531 replies

snookspooks · 26/03/2023 12:54

I've read a few posts lately where posters say the NHS isn't doing enough to combat obesity. As far as I am aware people are taught from pre-school age upwards about healthy eating and the importance of exercise and a healthy lifestyle. This continues through secondary school. I don't know about in further education but I don't remember any from my own FE days. We have access to NHS information online about healthy lifestyles, and the information is repeated in pregnancy and post-natal days by midwives and health visitors (that was my experience but I appreciate it might not be the same for others). We are given the information and it's up to us as individuals what we do with that information. The idea is we use it to prevent getting obese in the first place.

If people do get obese, through whatever factors, and there are many that contribute to this, is it up to the NHS to fix this or should the onus be on individuals? What happened in countries without an NHS style system?

Cancers are mainly preventable but the NHS provides treatment for those but then we can't fix cancers by ourselves, or heart disease, or strokes, but obesity is something we can treat ourselves. I'm not saying it's easy but it is possible. Of course obesity is linked to those diseases/conditions so it's not straightforward.

Is too little responsibility put on those who are obese?

I don't think it's straightforward and I think it's impossible to give treatment for some partially or completely self-inflicted conditions but not others. It's an ethical nightmare. What do other countries do?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
DoorWasAJar · 18/05/2023 14:56

Nimbostratus100 · 26/03/2023 12:57

I think banning margarine and low quality vegetable oils would go a long way to tackling obesity, or at least raising tax sky high on them, and on processed food.

These things are freely available children are eating them and no, I dont think the information on how badly they mess up insulin metabolism is widely publicised enough

Not the NHS, but certainly a wider government responsibility

But then lard and butter will get more expensive 😭

Did you read the writings of Gandhi? He was vegetarian but before he died, he wrote at length how vegetable oils are harming health, and ghee was the better product, how VO is not conducive to life.

There’s a lot of research about this but people have been brainwashed by the ‘animal fat is bad’ conspiracy. VO only took off due to the war, and the low price it had. I was brainwashed too but I’m glad I found animal fats again.

There’s also research re: health of vegans and vegetarians, and many former followers of these diets are coming out about how their health was destroyed. The research shows than even mental health is poorer in vegetarians and vegans.

The group consuming more vegetable oil had a 62% higher rate of death during the seven-year study compared to the group eating less vegetable oil.

BeretRaspberry · 01/04/2023 22:25

It's interesting, but it's just one opinion of many on the underlying mental factors around weight loss. Many people in the world have successfully lost weight and kept it off, whether that means they had to reset their "set point" or not. It's absolutely fine to disagree about this.

The video I posted shows it’s (regain) nothing to do with mental factors, it’s basic physical biology. It’s survival.

Losing weight can be relatively easy, particularly the first time you do it. That’s why I said most of us have probably been where you are. One year is an extremely short period of time in terms of keeping it off though, but as I say, I do hope you keep it off long term. It’s much easier to live life as a slimmer person.

UndertheCedartree · 01/04/2023 22:16

Londongal123 · 29/03/2023 12:00

Obesity 100% starts from parents. The lack of knowledge and understanding about what and how to feed children is what's causing the issue. The constant snacking, massive portion sizes, sugar and quality of food is detrimental to these children who then have to fight the battle for their entire adulthood because of shitty parenting mistakes. It's no coincidence that obesity is higher in less educated parts of the country. As a country we need way more education around what is acceptable nutrition for our children - and maybe the NHS should help with that.

I grew up eating healthily always normal weight, went into adulthood the same. Then I was put on medication that made me gain weight...so no, it doesn't always start with parents.

UndertheCedartree · 01/04/2023 22:09

anunlikelyseahorse · 27/03/2023 00:15

It's part of the problem, but not the only reason. Obesity is multi faceted and complex.
"30-50% of cancer is preventable" well that means 70-50% of cancers aren't. And given WHOs track record, I take their advice with a pinch of salt. Also 20% is a huge discrepancy.
In many cancer cases, we don't fully understand why a cell mutates. Genes are certainly a factor and then given the right environmental factors, whoosh cell mutations away, but what we don't know is why that faulty gene develops and gets passed on in the first place...if we could fully understand the cause it would be easier to find the cure.

To answer your question OP, what we need is more research into obesity, 'willpower' has pretty much been debunked as a load of religious pious, virtuous bollocks. But if one can blame it on 'lack of virtue' then it's not contagious, and therefore not dangerous, the sociology of health is fascinating, I'm sure it won't be long before covid enters the syllabus, it's also a good get out clause for not spending money on research, blame the person on lack of will power and the jobs a goodun!
So, so much about the human psyche remains a mystery, and until we understand more about our physiological, psychological and sociological function of our brain we'll never fully understand the link between physical and psychological health. In the meantime we continue to treat the illness brought about by obesity, so yes if obesity could be tackled, the NHS would be better off, but that is the same with most preventive illnesses (alcohol, drugs, STIs) it's a bit like saying could education reduce our prison population,and yes it could, but it requires a ton of investment at the beginning of life, instead we spend money and resources on fighting the fires instead of preventing the fires in the first place. The sad thing is labour tried really hard to prevent the fires by introducing sure start and other community services, and then the conservatives pulled the plug on it, it wasn't long enough to see the effects take hold. And therein lies a biggest issue of all, politicians only ever look at the short term goals, they don't take the longer view, that's why we're in the mess we're in (yes okay it's a bit more nuanced and complex than that, but ultimately politicians need to look at the longer goal, and regardless of which party they are in, they need to look at society as a whole. An educated working population should always be the long term goal, and that is tackled at grass roots).

The Tories closing all the children's centres was absolutely disgraceful.

theGooHasGone · 01/04/2023 21:47

You’re missing the point about why they don’t work. The video I posted explains well.

It's interesting, but it's just one opinion of many on the underlying mental factors around weight loss. Many people in the world have successfully lost weight and kept it off, whether that means they had to reset their "set point" or not. It's absolutely fine to disagree about this.

And if your weight loss is only recent, I hope you’re in the small minority who do keep it off. I imagine most of us who are trying to tell you it doesn’t work long term have been exactly where you have with your “I’ve lost weight so anyone can” way of thinking.

Thank you for the kind wishes. I've been at my current weight for over a year and I'm happier than I've been in a very long time. I'm never going back.

I made a lot of excuses for why I couldn't lose weight in the past, kept telling myself I was happy being overweight, it didn't matter, the world was ignorant etc. I was lying to myself, though.

DrMarciaFieldstone · 01/04/2023 09:37

No.

Sparrow80 · 01/04/2023 09:35

I’m one of those people who has health reasons that led me to put on weight (hypothyroidism and pcos). I worked a very stressful job, was a single parent etc etc. I was 4 stone overweight and just couldn’t lose it. Whenever I ran (something I’d done lots in the past, running marathons etc) I had a flu like response. My diet was ok but nowhere near good enough really.

Then when lockdown happened things changed. I no longer had to travel. No commute. Kids were old enough for me to leave for an hour to exercise locally.

Short version I managed to slowly start exercising and slowly ate better food. I lost 2 stone over about 6 months and then another stone more slowly. I’m still very very gradually losing weight through eating a good diet and running and walking lots. I’m now so fit I can run marathons again. If you’d told me that 3 years ago I’d have laughed.

What changed? Well I could say me - I’ve put huge amounts of effort in to be consistent, running in horrible weather, spending time consistently meal planning etc. It’s been really tough especially with health issues still there.

But also changes to my job gave me more time. I’d just moved to a nice area with lots of green space. My kids were older so I could leave them. I had pay rises which meant we could afford decent food - so much easier to eat better. I became more senior in work meaning I had more flexibility. My partner moved in so I could get out more easily.

In other words my environment changed for the better. It still took huge amounts of effort from me but that effort was easier because my environment was easier. Some people will never get that change and some people will never have barriers such as health problems removed.

Short version - my privilege enabled me to work hard at making changes. Until we change the environment, tackle poverty, exhaustion, food industry, long hours etc it’s going to be so much harder for people.

BeretRaspberry · 01/04/2023 08:29

theGooHasGone · 01/04/2023 02:17

It might be more accurate to say they work but if people go back to eating too much and doing little exercise then of course it won't work long term. That's why changes need to be be lifelong not just for a few weeks. Healthy lifestyle, not a healthy few weeks or months or whatever.

This is exactly my point. I totally agree that "diets" don't work at all - it isn't physically possible to just eat a lot less for a few months, lose weight, then go back to the way you were before and expect the weight to stay off. It has to be a wholesale change in the way you eat and view food for the rest of your life. You cannot ever go back to the way you were before, and that's often where people fall down.

if you are already obese at 18 years old, losing 50lbs in a healthy way would take years and years.

This isn't really true. I lost 60lbs recently over a period of about 18 months. It was in no way dangerous or unhealthy. Younger people have higher metabolism and energy levels, so the younger you are, the easier it is to do. They get a lot more return even on small changes to diet or lifetstyle.

You’re missing the point about why they don’t work. The video I posted explains well.

And if your weight loss is only recent, I hope you’re in the small minority who do keep it off. I imagine most of us who are trying to tell you it doesn’t work long term have been exactly where you have with your “I’ve lost weight so anyone can” way of thinking.

theGooHasGone · 01/04/2023 02:17

It might be more accurate to say they work but if people go back to eating too much and doing little exercise then of course it won't work long term. That's why changes need to be be lifelong not just for a few weeks. Healthy lifestyle, not a healthy few weeks or months or whatever.

This is exactly my point. I totally agree that "diets" don't work at all - it isn't physically possible to just eat a lot less for a few months, lose weight, then go back to the way you were before and expect the weight to stay off. It has to be a wholesale change in the way you eat and view food for the rest of your life. You cannot ever go back to the way you were before, and that's often where people fall down.

if you are already obese at 18 years old, losing 50lbs in a healthy way would take years and years.

This isn't really true. I lost 60lbs recently over a period of about 18 months. It was in no way dangerous or unhealthy. Younger people have higher metabolism and energy levels, so the younger you are, the easier it is to do. They get a lot more return even on small changes to diet or lifetstyle.

BeretRaspberry · 29/03/2023 18:13

Rainbowsandbutterflies1990 · 29/03/2023 15:58

Thank u it seems from reading a few of ur posts u that IE has worked for u its good to hear from someone who has been doing it for a while. I'm only year in so very new and still find it extremely difficult but know this is the best for me and even thou I'm the heaviest I've ever been I'm the most active and have the least disordered eating I've ever had.

It’s the same for me too. The only thing is, I’m not active but that’s because of my illnesses and I would be if I could because I miss my long walks (particularly when we go to the Lake and Peak Districts) and swimming like I used to.

In terms of the IE, yes, it’s been a revelation. At first it was definitely a learning curve and I didn’t always do it ‘right’ but it’s not like something you’re off and on, it’s just relearning what we were born knowing.

Rainbowsandbutterflies1990 · 29/03/2023 15:58

BeretRaspberry · 29/03/2023 13:43

Elyse Resch and Evelyn Tribole. They were the ones who originally wrote a book about it but I think it’s been something that’s been known about for a while, even before they did the book. And of course, it’s great. You’re right in that restriction causes bingeing.

The only thing I would caution against is making the principles of IE into hard and fast rules. Otherwise that’s just another form of restriction. Like it’s absolutely ok to continue eating past fullness, or eat when you’re not hungry, depending on your circumstances. Eventually you settle into a pattern that works for you and heals your relationship with food and eating.

Thank u it seems from reading a few of ur posts u that IE has worked for u its good to hear from someone who has been doing it for a while. I'm only year in so very new and still find it extremely difficult but know this is the best for me and even thou I'm the heaviest I've ever been I'm the most active and have the least disordered eating I've ever had.

Rainbowsandbutterflies1990 · 29/03/2023 15:54

3littlebeans · 29/03/2023 13:45

Unfortunately I tried to experiement with intuitive eating nad it opened the floodgates and I put lots more weight on.

I think my hunger cues are off (likely autistic)

U wasn't doing intuitive eating wrong as u put on weight it's very normal to do that while u first begin to find ur feed and after years of diet culture its very difficult to trust your body. I know personally I've found it very difficult. And has put on weight. Its only after year that I'm now beginning to stop and loose. That's difficult in inself as ive got to stop then going into diet thinking about and restricting what im eating to loose more weight. So trying to find balance . I'm also Neurodiverse which has its added struggles. As i eat to stim and dopamine, I'm doing a course for adhder with intuitive eating. And it's been really helpful.

3littlebeans · 29/03/2023 14:00

I think over 3 years of obsessively reading the intuitive literature I gained about 4 stone which hasn't come off. I really don't know the answer! I think intuitive eating is a great concept for those who haven't gained weight though.

BeretRaspberry · 29/03/2023 13:52

3littlebeans · 29/03/2023 13:45

Unfortunately I tried to experiement with intuitive eating nad it opened the floodgates and I put lots more weight on.

I think my hunger cues are off (likely autistic)

That’s very possible. Though it is normal for floodgates to open when you first try it. Most people go a bit mad with ‘forbidden’ foods when they first start but it generally settles down so if you didn’t try it for long it could be worth another go. That said, I understand being ND can cause differences in lots of things so your experience makes sense as well. And obviously you know your body and mind best.

I gained a bit of weight when I first started IE, though I had gained considerably more than that prior because of recovery from bulimia. It pretty much settled and has stayed the same in the 7 years I’ve been practising it.

lavenderfine · 29/03/2023 13:46

This is a much more complex issue than 'you're obese because you eat too much and don't move enough' lots of people have underlying mental health issues that cause the binging behaviours etc. lots of people are time and money poor especially at the moment, which in turn leads people to buy cheap, convenient foods which aren't as good for you as pre packaged fruit and veg or freshly prepared home cooked meals. Schools and home (especially those who come from poorer economic backgrounds) aren't providing the education around preparing easy home cooked meals and education in the earlier years of your life are proven to be the best combat to obesity. The education around healthy eating in schools is often misguided and not researched enough also, for example in DS's school this week they've started giving out stickers to the children that finish all their lunch, it's just not helpful, encouraging finishing all your food stops children from being able to recognise feeling full. It's too complex to just say 'don't treat fat people on the NHS and tax all the beige food to high heaven'
Another point though is people do dangerous things all the time, if they injured doing said dangerous thing, does this mean they don't deserve to be treated by the NHS? These conversations don't occur in places where healthcare is paid for at the point of use, but plenty of obese people work and pay taxes that pay to run the healthcare system, everyone deserves health care regardless of the choices they make in life in my opinion.

3littlebeans · 29/03/2023 13:45

Unfortunately I tried to experiement with intuitive eating nad it opened the floodgates and I put lots more weight on.

I think my hunger cues are off (likely autistic)

BeretRaspberry · 29/03/2023 13:43

Rainbowsandbutterflies1990 · 29/03/2023 13:33

They I mean intuitive eating. Its deigned by 2 dietitians who talk about the damage the diet culture is doing and what to do to build a healthy relationship with food.

Elyse Resch and Evelyn Tribole. They were the ones who originally wrote a book about it but I think it’s been something that’s been known about for a while, even before they did the book. And of course, it’s great. You’re right in that restriction causes bingeing.

The only thing I would caution against is making the principles of IE into hard and fast rules. Otherwise that’s just another form of restriction. Like it’s absolutely ok to continue eating past fullness, or eat when you’re not hungry, depending on your circumstances. Eventually you settle into a pattern that works for you and heals your relationship with food and eating.

Rainbowsandbutterflies1990 · 29/03/2023 13:33

They I mean intuitive eating. Its deigned by 2 dietitians who talk about the damage the diet culture is doing and what to do to build a healthy relationship with food.

Rainbowsandbutterflies1990 · 29/03/2023 13:31

They talk about Abundance versus scarcity mindset. And I 100% belive it. When u don't restrict what food u eat and can eat anything and buy it anytime u want. U are not going to feel need to binge on it or keep thinking about eating it. As u can have it anytime u want. If the food is scarce then there is more chance of binging on it. It happened to me when I got covid last year. I had to stay at home and on first day I binged all the chocolate in the house because I know I just couldn't go buy it. I panicked. The brain is wired like this due to food not always being so widely available.

3littlebeans · 29/03/2023 13:25

Beret - there are so many stories like this. The actual dieting and the message that so many on this thread want to get out to people is in fact the thing that makes people bigger in the long run.

We need to stop doing this.

BeretRaspberry · 29/03/2023 12:55

Londongal123 · 29/03/2023 12:44

I hear what you're saying but that's not exactly what I meant with my post. Studies have shown that if you are obese as a child you are more likely to be obese as an adult and also the other way around. So if you can get your kids through their childhood without becoming obese then you've gotten them off to a good start and after that it's up to them to make their own food choices.

If a child is obese at age 5, and can eat whatever they want growing up, then when they do become teens they are more likely to have body image issues, eating disorders, etc. and it's much harder to get the weight off. As a society, we blame adults for not having will power or discipline to be able to lost the weight when for most people, the weight has always been there.

Sure, kids who come from a healthier household, may gorge when they leave the nest or are able to make their own food decisions but it's easier to come back from that - gaining 20lbs then losing 20lbs, etc. whereas if you are already obese at 18 years old, losing 50lbs in a healthy way would take years and years.

I see what you mean and yes it makes sense. That said, it’s still not always straightforward, especially if poorer or with other disadvantages but I do get what you’re saying.

I was brought up in a very privileged household food wise. We had a wide variety of food available - lots of fruit and veg, as well as access to crisps and sweets. Some home cooked meals and some M&S days! We had dinners and puddings. I was like a bean pole until I was 18 and my nick name was Olive (Oil). I got pregnant at 19, gained weight as you do, went for my post natal check at 6 weeks and still had about 10 lbs to get back to my normal pre pregnancy weight. The doctor recommended Weight Watchers. So I lost a stone relatively easily. I kept it off for quite a while but it slowly crept back on. The cycle started again and continued for about 20 years, with me getting bigger and bigger at each attempt, and culminating in bulimia. My point being, I am more convinced than anything that if I never attempted the weight loss in the first place, I’d likely still be a similar weight and would not have ever needed to diet. This is sort of proven by the fact my parents and sisters have never dieted and are all slim still!

Londongal123 · 29/03/2023 12:44

I hear what you're saying but that's not exactly what I meant with my post. Studies have shown that if you are obese as a child you are more likely to be obese as an adult and also the other way around. So if you can get your kids through their childhood without becoming obese then you've gotten them off to a good start and after that it's up to them to make their own food choices.

If a child is obese at age 5, and can eat whatever they want growing up, then when they do become teens they are more likely to have body image issues, eating disorders, etc. and it's much harder to get the weight off. As a society, we blame adults for not having will power or discipline to be able to lost the weight when for most people, the weight has always been there.

Sure, kids who come from a healthier household, may gorge when they leave the nest or are able to make their own food decisions but it's easier to come back from that - gaining 20lbs then losing 20lbs, etc. whereas if you are already obese at 18 years old, losing 50lbs in a healthy way would take years and years.

BeretRaspberry · 29/03/2023 12:37

Londongal123 · 29/03/2023 12:00

Obesity 100% starts from parents. The lack of knowledge and understanding about what and how to feed children is what's causing the issue. The constant snacking, massive portion sizes, sugar and quality of food is detrimental to these children who then have to fight the battle for their entire adulthood because of shitty parenting mistakes. It's no coincidence that obesity is higher in less educated parts of the country. As a country we need way more education around what is acceptable nutrition for our children - and maybe the NHS should help with that.

It’s not as straightforward as that. Humans are born with an innate ability to know when they need nourishment. That’s why babies cry when they’re hungry and start pushing away when they’re satisfied. It’s the intuitive eating @Rainbowsandbutterflies1990 is referring to.

The problem comes when we start interfering with that and telling people what they ‘should and shouldn’t’ eat. That said, it’s best all round to be given a wide variety of foods, including sugary/fatty stuff. But being able to accommodate a wide variety of food is a privilege not everyone has, for many reasons. Which may be the reason obesity is higher in poorer areas.

I remember the experiment they did on tv once. Well, I think it was on tv, I’ll try and find it. They put a lot of kids in a room - like a party atmosphere - and had lots of sweets as well as ‘healthier’ snacks. Prior to this they had split them into two groups. One of which was allowed pretty much unlimited access to sweets/crisps etc and the other group was told to cut them out and not have any. The group that had previously been allowed sweets mostly ate all of the foods provided, including the carrot sticks etc and ate what they needed. Yet the group that were previously deprived of the sweets pretty much ate nothing but sweets and crisps.

Rainbowsandbutterflies1990 · 29/03/2023 12:14

Loosing weight needs to stop being the foucs and developing a healthy relationship with food should be. Intuitive eating main foucs is not to loose weight. People are not going to become healthier when you guilt and shame them. That doesn't work it makes the problem worse.

Londongal123 · 29/03/2023 12:00

Obesity 100% starts from parents. The lack of knowledge and understanding about what and how to feed children is what's causing the issue. The constant snacking, massive portion sizes, sugar and quality of food is detrimental to these children who then have to fight the battle for their entire adulthood because of shitty parenting mistakes. It's no coincidence that obesity is higher in less educated parts of the country. As a country we need way more education around what is acceptable nutrition for our children - and maybe the NHS should help with that.

Swipe left for the next trending thread