Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is obesity the responsibility of the NHS?

531 replies

snookspooks · 26/03/2023 12:54

I've read a few posts lately where posters say the NHS isn't doing enough to combat obesity. As far as I am aware people are taught from pre-school age upwards about healthy eating and the importance of exercise and a healthy lifestyle. This continues through secondary school. I don't know about in further education but I don't remember any from my own FE days. We have access to NHS information online about healthy lifestyles, and the information is repeated in pregnancy and post-natal days by midwives and health visitors (that was my experience but I appreciate it might not be the same for others). We are given the information and it's up to us as individuals what we do with that information. The idea is we use it to prevent getting obese in the first place.

If people do get obese, through whatever factors, and there are many that contribute to this, is it up to the NHS to fix this or should the onus be on individuals? What happened in countries without an NHS style system?

Cancers are mainly preventable but the NHS provides treatment for those but then we can't fix cancers by ourselves, or heart disease, or strokes, but obesity is something we can treat ourselves. I'm not saying it's easy but it is possible. Of course obesity is linked to those diseases/conditions so it's not straightforward.

Is too little responsibility put on those who are obese?

I don't think it's straightforward and I think it's impossible to give treatment for some partially or completely self-inflicted conditions but not others. It's an ethical nightmare. What do other countries do?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
13
Lovelyring · 26/03/2023 21:35

hettie · 26/03/2023 15:08

In answer to your original question no obesity is not the responsibility of the NHS. It is responsible for treating the diseases obesity causes, which is why it tries (a little bit) to engage in prevention. Unfortunately it doesn't get funded very well for that bit and prevention is a complicated issue (involving food supply and regulation etc) so difficult to 'treat'. Strictly speaking it's actually a public health thing. The report by the bloke from Leon, made some really sound recommendations on all of this, but the government (despite commisiong it) don't want to follow the expert recommendations.

What report is this please?

Dymaxion · 26/03/2023 21:30

your honesty is refreshing. Do you know why you eat such big portions of food that is not great nutritionally? Apart from being time poor the same as a lot of people. I'm not asking you to share that reason here, just asking if you know yourself.

Honestly ? Being time poor is a rubbish excuse ( for me anyway ) but it was the only relatively decent one I could think of ! I eat too much because I am used to eating too much, my appetite has changed to fit with this level of food and the type of food I put in ( I can merrily eat 2-3 peoples portions of pasta with a lovely ragu) . If I go low shit carb's and eat a lot of veg, some protein and a little good fat, and drink a lot of water, my appetite reduces significantly. It takes at least a fortnight to reset but it does reset. The key is doing it long term and finding something to replace the exercise I used to do, which didn't feel like 'exercise' because it was essential !

Lovelyring · 26/03/2023 21:22

habbiespond · 26/03/2023 13:59

Despite your feel sorry for me tone, they're not medical marvels, they can't defy physics. Energy in, energy out.

This is ridiculously over simplistic even ignoring people with illnesses causing weight gain. For example, sleeping less than 6/7 hours a night has been linked to obesity. There was also a study where prisoners weren't allowed to exercise and had to eat a ridiculously high amount a day and that showed that people did not gain weight in the same way - so it seems logical they wouldn't lose it in the same way either.

All calories are also not equal. Calories from UPF affect weight differently to the same calories from fresh veg as they are metabolised differently.

Even smelling food can lead to weight gain!
https://news.berkeley.edu/2017/07/05/smelling-your-food-makes-you-fat/

boy smelling hamburger

Smelling your food makes you fat

Mice that lost sense of smell stayed slim on high-fat diet, while littermates ballooned in weight

https://news.berkeley.edu/2017/07/05/smelling-your-food-makes-you-fat

theGooHasGone · 26/03/2023 21:15

People don't actually care about other people's heath or what they cost the nhs. If they did they'd be clamouring to euthanise everyone over 75.

@Botw1 That's a false equivalency. Nobody can control their age, but the vast majority can control their weight.

Howpo · 26/03/2023 21:15

Most people are lazy, too lazy to cook or learn, too lazy to exercise, even a simple walk to the shops.

Then there is poverty and lack of education, you can't make healthy choices if you don't know what they are.

Public health is the governments responsibility, not the NHS but they ve slashed that too, along with the very limited council run leisure centres.

Dymaxion · 26/03/2023 21:04

Glad that you have that option. The vast majority of people can walk, cycle or use means other than cars.

I saw three patients one morning last week and clocked up 67 miles, rural area so people are spread out. That was in under three hours, buses in rural areas are very limited, I don't have a bicyle or the ability to do 1 in 4 hill climbs and most people I know can't cover that distance in 3 hours by foot and see another lot of people in the aftenoon plus call outs ?

pncr · 26/03/2023 21:03

My bad @snookspooks I missed that it was the same poster.

snookspooks · 26/03/2023 20:58

Dymaxion · 26/03/2023 20:00

In all honesty my obesity is as a result of a huge reduction in the level of exercise I do each day and a big increase in my calorie intake, I inhale carbs in either liquid or solid form. My portion sizes would put most of MN into a food coma !
I know how to cook nutritious food, I have cupboards full of healthy ingredients, love all vegtables except kale and have recipe books a plenty. I actually love a massive salad Grin
I am knowledge rich and time poor, I get back from work and flick on the deep fat fryer and go big on the beige.
What makes it worse is I spend my working days with a lot of people whose health has been hugely impacted by their lifestyle choices, not all by a long shot, as this thread shows, some people do just get the shitty end of the stick, health wise.
One patient with cancer who was really angry about his recent prognosis, given his incredibly healthy and lifelong lifestyle, asked me 'why me and not you, I have done everything right ?' , whilst I stood there, slightly puce, getting my breath back after climbing a flight of stairs and weighing at least twice what he did. The honest answer is, I have no idea, there is possibly a weird plague surviving gene that allows a certain level of self inflicted harm, that I have been fortunate enough to inherit.
If I carry on as I am, I will end up living with very poor health, less going out with a bang more going out with a whimper. I can't use ignorance as an excuse, nor pre-existing and unrelated health conditions, nor childhood trauma or MH reasons.
Am I the person that @snookspooks has written this thread about ?

@pncr they said so themself.

OP posts:
Meadowland · 26/03/2023 20:56

Losing weight was the hardest thing I ever did. But it was down to me, me alone, and my choices. I had to take responsibility and not rely on anyone else.
It's still a daily battle not to dive into a family size crisp packet, but I don't expect anyone else to do it for me.

pncr · 26/03/2023 20:56

snookspooks · 26/03/2023 20:55

@kitsuneghost I don't know where you have got that from but it's nothing to do with lockdown.

@Dymaxion your honesty is refreshing. Do you know why you eat such big portions of food that is not great nutritionally? Apart from being time poor the same as a lot of people. I'm not asking you to share that reason here, just asking if you know yourself.

I am not overweight because I eat big portions of food. You don't know why the pp is overweight. They haven't said. And yet you jump to massive potions.

snookspooks · 26/03/2023 20:55

@kitsuneghost I don't know where you have got that from but it's nothing to do with lockdown.

@Dymaxion your honesty is refreshing. Do you know why you eat such big portions of food that is not great nutritionally? Apart from being time poor the same as a lot of people. I'm not asking you to share that reason here, just asking if you know yourself.

OP posts:
midgemadgemodge · 26/03/2023 20:50

Exercise helps people stay a healthy weight

But over eating gets them overweight
Often started in childhood- see all the threads about the dangers of giving children eating disorders if you try to fix their bad eating habits - we are scared of saying no yo children, we want them to smile at us

Over eating the wrong thing

Caused by easy availability of bad food
Especially when that is cheap
Especially when they work too hard to have any energy left for good choices

Dymaxion · 26/03/2023 20:48

it's not stupid at all, it's factual for me. My BMI was over 27 at the end of last summer. I made the decision to stop eating so much unhealthy food, get more exercise, not much more though to be fair, and my BMI is now 22.

@snookspooks Sweetheart you are coming at people like me with a BMI of 47+ with all the knowledge and experience of someone who put a few additional pounds on and managed to lose them easily, which is of course great for you and well done and all that Smile
Think about how you would manage the situation if you weighed 10 stone more than you should ? I don't know how much you weigh but imagine adding your bodyweight into a rucksack and then carrying it around with you all the time, regardless of what you were doing and not being able to take it off. Now do starjumps Grin

SecretVictoria · 26/03/2023 20:16

QuertyGirl · 26/03/2023 16:18

Glad that you have that option. The vast majority of people can walk, cycle or use means other than cars.

My work is 30 miles away (give or take) and I have to be there for 0630 tomorrow. The earliest that the train can get me there from the station in town is 0700, the earliest from the station a 5 minute walk away is 0836. I can get there on time from a different station, but I’d have to drive to that station (15 minutes).

It’s the same coming home. In fact, I don’t think I could get home from a late shift without a car. On Sundays, I couldn’t get there/back in any sort of reasonable time.

It takes me 30-40 minutes door-to-door by car.

I’d love a local job but I live in an area of high unemployment and most jobs are zero hour minimum wage care/retail/warehouse, all of which I’d struggle to do as I have an injury meaning I can’t lift or do constant repetitive tasks. There’s also no progression/career development, which I do have now.

I’d also love to live closer to work, but houses similar to what I have now are £500k more. Some are millions more (lots of footballers). My wage is less than national average but I can manage, mainly as DH has a good pension.

I’d love to be back in the SE, I didn’t drive for years as I didn’t need to, I walked/bus/trained everywhere, but when we were both made redundant, we moved back to my hometown as we could afford a property outright.

Doesn't help that I don’t really like where I live and so struggle to want to go out and walk as there’s nowhere interesting/nice to go. When I lived in the Home Counties, I’d go out all over the place; around London, down to the coast, mooching round nice market towns…

Dymaxion · 26/03/2023 20:00

In all honesty my obesity is as a result of a huge reduction in the level of exercise I do each day and a big increase in my calorie intake, I inhale carbs in either liquid or solid form. My portion sizes would put most of MN into a food coma !
I know how to cook nutritious food, I have cupboards full of healthy ingredients, love all vegtables except kale and have recipe books a plenty. I actually love a massive salad Grin
I am knowledge rich and time poor, I get back from work and flick on the deep fat fryer and go big on the beige.
What makes it worse is I spend my working days with a lot of people whose health has been hugely impacted by their lifestyle choices, not all by a long shot, as this thread shows, some people do just get the shitty end of the stick, health wise.
One patient with cancer who was really angry about his recent prognosis, given his incredibly healthy and lifelong lifestyle, asked me 'why me and not you, I have done everything right ?' , whilst I stood there, slightly puce, getting my breath back after climbing a flight of stairs and weighing at least twice what he did. The honest answer is, I have no idea, there is possibly a weird plague surviving gene that allows a certain level of self inflicted harm, that I have been fortunate enough to inherit.
If I carry on as I am, I will end up living with very poor health, less going out with a bang more going out with a whimper. I can't use ignorance as an excuse, nor pre-existing and unrelated health conditions, nor childhood trauma or MH reasons.
Am I the person that @snookspooks has written this thread about ?

LemonSwan · 26/03/2023 20:00

Tbh I eat as much as I want and stayed a consistent weight regardless of whether I excercised or not. I did put on a huge amount of weight once - ironically when I was forced into eating slimming world meals whilst staying with the mil for a year.

Whos responsible is a difficult thing when it comes to this topic. I’m a smoker and that’s cut and dry good and bad yet I still can’t quit. I am wholly responsible for that. But losing weight is so difficult as it’s not cut and dry.

I only figured out through the slimming world debacle that I have high amylase. Carbs are like water vapour to my body and the more I eat the better my metabolism works and faster I burn food. I actively lose weight the more white goods I eat. Cut them out and even if the quantities of other food groups are the same ie. protein/ fat and I balloon at a rate of noughts.

So I do think nhs could have a part to play in this. Early intervention for those struggling is key to most illnesses. It wouldn’t be difficult to have off shelf dietician plans and a spit test to analyse someone’s salival structure.

kitsuneghost · 26/03/2023 19:59

snookspooks · 26/03/2023 18:58

@Atethehalloweenchocs it's not stupid at all, it's factual for me. My BMI was over 27 at the end of last summer. I made the decision to stop eating so much unhealthy food, get more exercise, not much more though to be fair, and my BMI is now 22.

I am so happy for you that you have never had long term weight issues and gaining a few pounds on lockdown makes you an expert.

Believeitornot · 26/03/2023 19:50

BeretRaspberry · 26/03/2023 19:48

The NHS and the government have been trying to ‘fix’ obesity for decades. And all it’s done (according to them) is make it ‘worse’. I wonder why that is?? That would probably be because intentional weight loss is known to make people bigger on the whole.

And if the NHS is going to start picking and choosing who it treats and not helping ‘obese’ people, then we really should be doing the same for the person who breaks their leg after falling over drunk, or the footballer who pulls their hamstring, the alcoholic who has caused their organs to work inefficiently, the driver involved in a crash, the mountain climber who falls etc etc etc.

Honestly, particularly on MN, it’s like being fat is the worst thing a person can be.

It doesn’t work because the NHS is dealing with the symptoms and not the causes.

BeretRaspberry · 26/03/2023 19:48

The NHS and the government have been trying to ‘fix’ obesity for decades. And all it’s done (according to them) is make it ‘worse’. I wonder why that is?? That would probably be because intentional weight loss is known to make people bigger on the whole.

And if the NHS is going to start picking and choosing who it treats and not helping ‘obese’ people, then we really should be doing the same for the person who breaks their leg after falling over drunk, or the footballer who pulls their hamstring, the alcoholic who has caused their organs to work inefficiently, the driver involved in a crash, the mountain climber who falls etc etc etc.

Honestly, particularly on MN, it’s like being fat is the worst thing a person can be.

TheyThemJugs · 26/03/2023 19:48

People who’ve blown up due to medications/metabolic conditions/physical disability aside, where it’s down to personal poor choice maybe we shouldn’t be too annoyed as it’s natural selection (or deselection) in action.

rwalker · 26/03/2023 19:43

Timeforachangeisitnot · 26/03/2023 12:58

‘Cancers are mainly preventable ‘? Where the fuck did you get that idea ?

Better tell my Haematologist then and ask him to explain how I could have prevented it ?

There are many many causes of obesity, and it is often the result of past trauma, abuse, or indeed drugs prescribed for other illnesses.

i don’t even know why I am responding to you, your ignorance is astounding.

my friends dad was told his cancer was caused by years of smoking

whilst quiet rightly you pointed out
There are many many causes of obesity, and it is often the result of past trauma, abuse, or indeed drugs prescribed for other illnesses.
but there is also a % where it’s down to poor choices

how many and how big the % are no idea but there are some preventable cancers and some obese people by poor choice

snookspooks · 26/03/2023 19:27

@UndertheCedartree I've seen that happen in patients. It was alarming how quickly they put on weight. I'm sorry that happened to you too. When I was in hospital bank in the early 90s it was a private hospital and there was a daily exercise class we had to go to which I avoided like the plague, relaxation every day, snooker room, exercise bikes, pool tables, extensive grounds for walks, art therapy, group therapy, psychotherapy, ECT <shudders> and a really holistic approach. What I saw in NHS units was awful. No exercise facilities, fed snacks of doughnuts and cakes every evening, no grounds, no therapies, no relaxation, just drugs.

OP posts:
snookspooks · 26/03/2023 19:22

@3littlebeans why don't you start a thread like that? I think it would be a good idea. I can't remember which ozempic thread it was now but talk of trauma and abuse was not appreciated. The consensus was that there was no underlying reason for their obesity, they just needed the wonder drug to resolve their obesity. It's all about insulin resistance not trauma or poverty or abuse or anything else for some. They are quite interesting threads to read.

I can't remember if I said this upthread or not but it's going to be impossible to single out the cause for most people because there will be many. My ex told me grabbing his belly that he was like this because he'd be told to clear his plate as a child. As was I. He was in his 40s by this time so at least 25 years had passed since his childhood plate clearing days. what he didn't take into account was the copious number of take aways he was eating each week. At least 3 deliveries per week and he would order 2 meals with each. So say a Chinese chicken dish with chips and noodles AND chips and Chinese curry. That was for 2 days but even so, its a lot of food, not yo mention no vegetables. He had an active job and cycled to work but his evenings and weekends were spent sat on the sofa gaming or watching tv. He would claim poverty all the time but was spending around £150 a week on take aways. He's an intelligent man but was addicted to nicotine, gaming, energy drinks, take aways and couldn't or wouldn't see the impact it was having on his health and his relationship with me and his sons. Very sad. There was other stuff going on with his childhood but he wouldn't accept his own contribution to his health. Then he had the cheek to call me greedy once when i ate a full meal. i was recently bereaved and had no appetite for ages but really enjoyed that meal. i was about 9 stone at the time.

OP posts:
UndertheCedartree · 26/03/2023 19:16

My experience is I was a healthy weight (underweight sometimes) for my whole life. Then I had a mental breakdown and was in hospital for 3 years. Over that period of time I've been put on multiple medications, most of which have weight gain as a side effect. I asked for help as soon as I started putting on weight, but none was forthcoming as I was just encouraged to continue taking the medication. I think there should be help as I'm really struggling.

ItchycooParkCult · 26/03/2023 19:08

Bucketheadbucketbum · 26/03/2023 17:59

The menu you quote from Iceland doesn't meet any of your 7 veg criteria either so you're not comparing like for like, and you're also wrong about the prices. You can get cheap healthy food, just not in iceland

You can get 2.5kg of potatoes for 90p, tinned fish for 40p, tinned beans 20p, tinned tomatoes, lentils, frozen veg etc

Are developing countries full of Iceland? Do poor people there stuff themsleves wirh frozen pizza to get by? No, people cook low cost meals from scratch

There are ways to do it, but people don't want to make the effort. Ultimately, in most instances (genuine medical issues aside- which are v v rare) it IS their fault they're obese, but apparently we aren't allowed to point that out because they don't want to hear it

I capitalised it at the top. COST PER CALORIE that’s what I was pointing out. And clearly stated it’s not nutritionally complete.

a tin of sardines in oil is 200cals for 44p
a can of plain beans is around 200-250 cals for 63p
most frozen veg will be cheap but still the cost per calorie is important.

the only ones that is cheap per calorie is potatoes.

to be fed aka get enough calories to sustain your daily activities it’s cheaper to do so on highly processed foods.

for a nutritionally complete meal with the right amount of calories it would cost significantly more. Even if you substituted meats for beans

I know this because I have lived this. I have lived both ways and it’s more expensive to eat properly and get all your macros and nutrients and the right amount of veg a day.