Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Phones in school

135 replies

Bree82 · 26/03/2023 09:18

Ok don’t know if I’m being old fashioned or stupid here. And I get times are changing ie technology etc. So I understand using computers more in school and for homework.
but why are mobile phones allowed in high school?

it bothers me that kids think nothing of filming fights etc at school and passing it around etc
so many teens I know can’t even look up from phone to say hi and I don’t mind people using phone a lot - but why does it make some people so rude?!
how can we let kids have their phones but still behave respectful etc?
I get this is not every kid maybe just the ones I know and I wonder if the answer is having their phones less, or just helping them learn the balance …
also if there are any teachers who can let me know benefits of phones at school and if they agree or not? I would like to understand more. :)

OP posts:
Hbh17 · 26/03/2023 09:56

Children do not need phones in school. There is just no justification for it. The fact that they WANT their phones is not a reason to pander to them!

babynoname22 · 26/03/2023 09:55

They are banned in the school I work in for the exact reasons you have stated

LuvSmallDogs · 26/03/2023 09:55

I went to secondary in the early 00s. Nokia 3310s were all the rage, but there were kids who didn't have them, and as phones weren't so ubiquitous, it wasn't seen as a big deal if you forgot to bring it in or it was out of charge.

You know what we had in my shitty school? Payphones. Clean, working payphones in the corridor to tell mum you wanted to go to Liz's house after school/check if you were being picked up or whatever. My mum and dad gave me a phone card for them.

The only time I've seen payphones recently, they've been outdoors ones that you daren't get close enough to see if they work, due to all the smashed glass and stench of piss.

Hellenbach · 26/03/2023 09:54

My son's secondary had a blanket ban on phones. Parents were concerned about the journey on public transport without a phone but everyone survived.
I frequently work in secondary schools. I've been surprised at the variations in how phones are managed. One pupil told me that they messaged each other throughout lessons, filmed teachers and that pupils felt a need to 'perform' such as fighting, scenes etc so that it would be filmed and shared.
A pupil at a private, boys school I visit told me they never use their phones, he asked 'what for?'
Huge differences in how this is managed.

lailamaria · 26/03/2023 09:54

@GneissWork I agree this mumsnet mentality of all phones being evil is very unrealistic, my mum worked all throughout my highschool years, i also have chronic illnesses so i need to go to the doctors all the time and hospital appointments, my mum couldn't walk out of work to take a 30 second phone call but i could walk out of class to do that, it's how it worked best, i needed my phone on me.

I also agree that teachers cannot enforce kids going on their phones on their breaks just like teachers and staff are allowed to do that, it's their time to shut off and have a break

Phones are an essential thing for schooling, both for kids to have an independent social life and also for things like teams, homework being online so kids don't have to cart 2 dozen pieces of paper and so when they don't do it teachers have an actual log and can see they haven't actually attempted it nevermind just not done it. And yeah my teachers were nice, they let us take pictures of the board so we didn't have to waste 20 minutes for the worlds slowest writers to copy a presentation into their workbooks

GneissWork · 26/03/2023 09:54

User1990C · 26/03/2023 09:52

Prepare for non teachers telling us how to use common technology on classrooms.

I’m more worried about the non teachers suggesting we try to take a teenagers phone off them and keep it for months, which is most definitely less disruptive than throwing a kid a raised eye brow and continuing our lesson.

Reugny · 26/03/2023 09:52

We had phone boxes then, they don’t.

There are still phone boxes plus school offices still have phones.

The crime has increased significantly since we were kids

Reports of crime have increased plus what we consider are crimes so they are dealt with has changed.

Basically the old way of agreeing plans in advance with a contingency in case they need changing has gone out of the window.

User1990C · 26/03/2023 09:52

Prepare for non teachers telling us how to use common technology on classrooms.

GneissWork · 26/03/2023 09:51

RobinRobinMouse · 26/03/2023 09:42

@GneissWork Just having the phone around may cause disruption, doesnt matter when - what messages are being sent/photos taken/videos recorded?! Also a safeguarding nightmare. As long as the school don't keep them forever I think it probably is enforceable, I believe confiscation is still allowed. It is also safer for the children not to have them.

Oh I confiscate plenty of phones, don’t get me wrong. I stick a post-it with the kids name on it and stick it in my drawer til the end of the class, when I hand it back. I would never do this for an accidental phone call though! This would be for something like actively using their phone during class when they are meant to be working.
For more serious offences (like taking a picture of someone) I’d pass the phone to someone in management and there would be a phone call home. They’d still get it back before the end of the school day though.
I’ve only had to pass a phone on maybe 3/4 times in my whole career.

thatsn0tmyname · 26/03/2023 09:48

Phones are very useful in class if policed effectively. At a time when schools are trying to go paper- free and there are so many excellent resources online, we use phones at set times in class. There are not enough IT resources in our school. Any student misusing their phone will have it confiscated and returned after a short detention.

LarryStylinson · 26/03/2023 09:47

Our local secondary is 30 miles away. It's the only one available at all and the kids travel by public transport. There is definitely a necessity for children to be able to make contact with an appropriate adult if something went wrong.

lailamaria · 26/03/2023 09:47

@RobinRobinMouse Just having a phone around is a safeguarding concern, what the hell, plus it's not fair to keep them for the entire term, that's literal months, also it's not up to you to say it's safer for children not to have them, what if they're a young carer, what if they get into an emergency outside of the house when they're alone, what if they need to get themselves out of a situation and can't call their parents or a taxi, what if there's a fire at home. I'm sorry but you cannot justify taking somebody else's possessions for an entire term just because they broke a rule once, also if the parents were to go to school they would have to hand it to them because it's not their property

IHateFlies · 26/03/2023 09:47

They should definitely be banned. Anyone caught with a phone in school should have it confiscated.
Phones are so harmful to developing brains. There's been recent research that all those TikTok's and quick videos impairs memory.
We already know it's harmful to their well-being. We should be taking this more seriously and it should be down to us as parents, rather than leaving it to teachers to police.

GneissWork · 26/03/2023 09:45

A few things at play here.

  • a phone ringing in class is not that disruptive. A quick glance at the class usually prompts the phones owner to quickly flick it to silent. Then, half the class check their own phones are on silent. Takes less than 30 seconds, no words need to be spoken. What would be disruptive would be for me to stop my lesson to confiscate said phone. Potentially this would escalate the situation too.
  • Every kid has a phone. They use it before/after school, at lunchtime, etc. It’s unenforceable at these times.
  • Parents WANT their children to have access to phones, and there is little to no parental support (except from the parents who’s children only use their phones appropriately)
  • a phone can be a good tool in school, and we simply don’t have the physical resources. Sometimes a question will come up that I don’t know the answer to and I can ask the kid to quickly Google it. Sometimes someone doesn’t finish the work and I can get them to take a quick picture of the board to do at home. I’ve got one boy who is colourblind who takes a photo of things and puts it into greyscale as he can see it easier. They can add homework to their calendar. They can email me things.
RobinRobinMouse · 26/03/2023 09:44

@lailamaria Also not acceptable, in fact in most schools I have worked with in recent times adult mobile phones must be in a locked drawer. There is an office number for emergencies.

lailamaria · 26/03/2023 09:43

@BooksAndHooks and parents are completely okay with their property being taken for an entire term, something that they likely got their children to keep them safe, that's ridiculous and so unreasonable

RobinRobinMouse · 26/03/2023 09:42

@GneissWork Just having the phone around may cause disruption, doesnt matter when - what messages are being sent/photos taken/videos recorded?! Also a safeguarding nightmare. As long as the school don't keep them forever I think it probably is enforceable, I believe confiscation is still allowed. It is also safer for the children not to have them.

lailamaria · 26/03/2023 09:41

@RobinRobinMouse but adults phones disrupt too, i remember most of my teachers getting a phone call in class because they had kids or had a phone call from the doctors/hospital and nobody would dare take their phones off of them

lailamaria · 26/03/2023 09:40

we used to get told to take them out during lesson to take pictures of the board to save us from spending ages taking notes and not getting to the lesson in time, then the policy changed and became stricter because the school merged into an academy we couldn't even have them at break which was shit because me and my friends were in separate classes so we had no clue where to meet.

Then loads of people left including myself, not over phones but because the academy changed a lot of the rules that were the reason a lot of people chose the school in the first place, i just think that phones are a good tool to have in class and demonising them won't help anyone.

Also you can say 'just have an agreed place to meet' but have you met teenage girls, we never new when anyone was getting out of lesson if we didn't have phones so we'd just all waste our breaktimes.

Bucketheadbucketbum · 26/03/2023 09:39

Should be banned. Terrible all round. The leading schools in the UK do not allow them.

7Worfs · 26/03/2023 09:38

I’m not sure how it can be enforced in secondary, but primaries absolutely don’t need mobile phones.

The Tories were considering a national ban for primaries but backtracked; not sure why as they would have had overwhelming public support for it.

GneissWork · 26/03/2023 09:37

BooksAndHooks · 26/03/2023 09:36

Yes if their phone goes off because they haven’t turned it off they lose the phone. They enforce the phone rule very strictly.

And what if a parent turns up demanding the phone back? It’s literally not enforceable.

GneissWork · 26/03/2023 09:37

RobinRobinMouse · 26/03/2023 09:35

@GneissWork I think that is fair enough, all children must know the consequences of their phone causing disruption.

How would a phone going off at interval/lunchtime cause disruption?

Im a teacher and my own phone has gone off in class!

BooksAndHooks · 26/03/2023 09:36

GneissWork · 26/03/2023 09:32

The school takes a child’s property from them for half a term due to an accident?

Yes if their phone goes off because they haven’t turned it off they lose the phone. They enforce the phone rule very strictly.

RobinRobinMouse · 26/03/2023 09:35

@GneissWork I think that is fair enough, all children must know the consequences of their phone causing disruption.

Swipe left for the next trending thread