Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Phones in school

135 replies

Bree82 · 26/03/2023 09:18

Ok don’t know if I’m being old fashioned or stupid here. And I get times are changing ie technology etc. So I understand using computers more in school and for homework.
but why are mobile phones allowed in high school?

it bothers me that kids think nothing of filming fights etc at school and passing it around etc
so many teens I know can’t even look up from phone to say hi and I don’t mind people using phone a lot - but why does it make some people so rude?!
how can we let kids have their phones but still behave respectful etc?
I get this is not every kid maybe just the ones I know and I wonder if the answer is having their phones less, or just helping them learn the balance …
also if there are any teachers who can let me know benefits of phones at school and if they agree or not? I would like to understand more. :)

OP posts:
Butterfly44 · 26/03/2023 10:59

Almost all secondary school children have phones nowadays. In technology schools, like apple accredited schools, they may only use a smart device for lessons. It's expected but there are strict rules around use and conduct.
Eg. Phones off and stay in bags from start to end of school day or risk confiscation ; no access to social apps during lessons (teachers are linked in and can see what each child is doing on their device). On the whole the rules works well. There will of course be some exceptions to those that need their device for medical monitoring as that will be in their healthcare plan.
Our secondary has phones off in bag policy and it's never been a significant problem. If they need to contact a parent in the day they go to reception. Many of our pupils travel long distances and would be on devices before and after school. Would never have an outright ban of no phones on the premises. Even the teachers access their phones in between lessons/frees Grin

Sirzy · 26/03/2023 10:58

KimberleyClark · 26/03/2023 10:38

we used to get told to take them out during lesson to take pictures of the board to save us from spending ages taking notes and not getting to the lesson in time, then the policy changed and became stricter because the school merged into an academy we couldn't even have them at break which was shit because me and my friends were in separate classes so we had no clue where to meet.

why not just arrange to meet at the same place always?

Exactly!

wanting to meet your mates isn’t an argument to allow phones in school. Most friendship groups have a default meeting point anyway don’t they?

reluctantbrit · 26/03/2023 10:49

GneissWork · 26/03/2023 10:11

How was this enforced at say, interval and lunch, when kids are by and large unsupervised? On corridors?

Im guessing this is in a small school?

DD's school has 8 forms of 30 girls/form per year plus 300 Sixformers in a separate block.

There are plenty of adults in the corridors and during lunch/break to see what's going on, much to DD's annoyance.

KimberleyClark · 26/03/2023 10:38

we used to get told to take them out during lesson to take pictures of the board to save us from spending ages taking notes and not getting to the lesson in time, then the policy changed and became stricter because the school merged into an academy we couldn't even have them at break which was shit because me and my friends were in separate classes so we had no clue where to meet.

why not just arrange to meet at the same place always?

BooksAndHooks · 26/03/2023 10:32

GneissWork · 26/03/2023 09:37

And what if a parent turns up demanding the phone back? It’s literally not enforceable.

It is part of the home school agreement you agree to abide by the rules when you start at the school. They have had this rule in place since they allowed phones in bags in 2017. So assume it is working.

MyfanwyMontez · 26/03/2023 10:13

The school my child goes to has a no phones rule but the vast majority of pupils ignore it .

I did not allow my child to take a phone but earlier this week he did not return from school at the usual expected time . I had no way of contacting him . I ended up driving around looking for him .

It turns out he’d been hit by a bus . Luckily it was not serious but it could have been. I will be sending him to school with a phone from now on .

Snorlaxing · 26/03/2023 10:11

When I was a teen the school office were happy to phone home and pass on messages like child will be late because of extra drama practice or whatever.
My kids are told to take a photo of the board (to save money on photocopying ) or use their phone to look something up (easier than teachers having to book iPads- no idea how up to date they may be)
France have a no smartphones to be used on school premises or at school based activities for under 15s.

GneissWork · 26/03/2023 10:11

AnyOldThings · 26/03/2023 10:09

My previous school had very successful no phones seen or on in school policy.

If a phone was seen it was confiscated until end of day. If a child had phone confiscated more than once per term a parent had to collect from the office. Repeat offenders had to hand in phone to school office on arrival each day and sign out at end of day.

It worked really well and school was much better for it.

How was this enforced at say, interval and lunch, when kids are by and large unsupervised? On corridors?

Im guessing this is in a small school?

AnyOldThings · 26/03/2023 10:09

GneissWork · 26/03/2023 09:20

There is no benefit to phoned in school
but there is also no way to police it. How exactly would you stop it?

My previous school had very successful no phones seen or on in school policy.

If a phone was seen it was confiscated until end of day. If a child had phone confiscated more than once per term a parent had to collect from the office. Repeat offenders had to hand in phone to school office on arrival each day and sign out at end of day.

It worked really well and school was much better for it.

GneissWork · 26/03/2023 10:09

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 26/03/2023 10:06

My ds's school did a great job. Phones were turned off and put in bags at the start of school . They were instantly confiscated if taken out for any reason whatsoever and a parent had to go and pick it up from reception after a 3 day confiscation period. Worked a treat.

Lots of lessons involved the use of phones so they do have their place in school just not between lessons.

So phones are automatically confiscated on sight but also they were used lots in school? That makes no sense.

Sirzy · 26/03/2023 10:08

Ds school has a very firm rule that phones aren’t used on site (including at dinner) and that if they are seen they will be confiscated for the day. Seems to work well.

lailamaria · 26/03/2023 10:07

anyway yeah we get it phones are evil and they make teenagers turn into rude insolent people despite the fact teenagers have been like that for hundreds of years, i'm over arguing some people are just determined to demonise technology and forget the bigger picture

MrsPelligrinoPetrichor · 26/03/2023 10:06

GneissWork · 26/03/2023 09:20

There is no benefit to phoned in school
but there is also no way to police it. How exactly would you stop it?

My ds's school did a great job. Phones were turned off and put in bags at the start of school . They were instantly confiscated if taken out for any reason whatsoever and a parent had to go and pick it up from reception after a 3 day confiscation period. Worked a treat.

Lots of lessons involved the use of phones so they do have their place in school just not between lessons.

Ohdearwhatnow4 · 26/03/2023 10:06

At my DS school, phones are banned and if seen teacher confiscates it and a adult has to collect, but they also ask the kids to bring phones in to do surveys and to take pictures of certain things so mixed messages.
My DS had phone confiscated, his own fault, but they they expected me to go and get it which I said I couldn't.
The homework is all on a app on the phone so I told the school whilst I back them they need to sort out another way for DS to do homework. They then changed and gave him phone back. DS is autistic and adhd and a little sod, so learnt that if phone is confiscated he doesn't have to do homework.

LuvSmallDogs · 26/03/2023 10:05

@Ohthejoyous , does he have that app thingy? DH was telling me about his diabetic coworker using it the other day, can't remember the details but it sounds really convenient for such a condition!

lailamaria · 26/03/2023 10:03

@Ohthejoyous very clever thanks for that

lailamaria · 26/03/2023 10:02

i don't get why they aren't allowed at break i really don't understand it

Ohthejoyous · 26/03/2023 10:01

My son can't monitor his diabetes properly because he's not allowed a phone in school. 😏

lailamaria · 26/03/2023 10:01

a week is kind of feasible but not months on end, that's complete overkill

BibbleandSqwauk · 26/03/2023 10:00

I teach in a (private) school where we ask that kids all have access to a device. The younger ones have laptops but most of the older ones use their phones for research, accessing apps like kerboodle, Seneca, kahoot, BBC bitesize, various maths platforms and most importantly Teams which we still use as our basic framework for communication - daily bulletin, messages about meetings etc, kids use it to tell me they're at a music lesson so I know what to mark them as in the register. They aren't allowed to have them out around the site or at lunch. Yes we have the odd issue with photos / filming etc but no.more than schools that "ban" them.
Whether we like it or not, they are here to stay and as evidenced on another thread about the amount of apps parents have to constantly access to deal with admin, they are a normal part of life. I think secondary schools pretending they don't or shouldn't exist just sets up a really poor dynamic of "us" and "them".

lailamaria · 26/03/2023 10:00

I feel like so many people are talking about 'normal' kids but that's literally not the norm anymore teenagers are young carers, teenagers are responsible for younger siblings, teenagers have illnesses that need to be monitored through their phone, also nobody is saying let them have free reign in class but a two minute phone call won't hurt anyone and making them keep it away at breaktime is just unreasonable. Also fun fact this all gets undone in college when they're 16 and they're allowed their phones whenever they want

lechatnoir · 26/03/2023 10:00

BooksAndHooks · 26/03/2023 09:30

I don’t know any school around here that allows phones in school. They have to be in bags turned off. If they are seen or heard even accidentally in school they lose them for the entire half term. They can only turn them on once they are off the school premises.

Same here although ours is a week and parent to collect. Obviously there is the odd indiscretion, but to be honest, most kids don't want to risk losing their phone so do comply. Zero tolerance is the only way if you want to implement a phone ban (my youngest dc school tried to implement it with a polite request to pupils and parents last year and you honestly wouldn't know - all the kids use their phones in school

SpecialControlGroup · 26/03/2023 09:59

we couldn't even have them at break which was shit because me and my friends were in separate classes so we had no clue where to meet.

This is hilarious

reluctantbrit · 26/03/2023 09:58

DD's school has a "phone in bag" policy. They can take them out if a teacher asks them to check on something, for visual art lesson for example.

If a phone is spotted during break you better have a really good excuse or you loose it until a parent comes and collect it. We had it once.

But, DD uses it on the way to and from school, bus app, phoning a parent, us contacting her.

Before mobiles there were phone boxes all over the way, that's just not there anymore.

lailamaria · 26/03/2023 09:56

why do people want to take away kids phones for months on end i don't understand it, confiscate them until the end of the day then let them go pick them up that's like a normal thing to do that won't endanger their safety