Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Phones in school

135 replies

Bree82 · 26/03/2023 09:18

Ok don’t know if I’m being old fashioned or stupid here. And I get times are changing ie technology etc. So I understand using computers more in school and for homework.
but why are mobile phones allowed in high school?

it bothers me that kids think nothing of filming fights etc at school and passing it around etc
so many teens I know can’t even look up from phone to say hi and I don’t mind people using phone a lot - but why does it make some people so rude?!
how can we let kids have their phones but still behave respectful etc?
I get this is not every kid maybe just the ones I know and I wonder if the answer is having their phones less, or just helping them learn the balance …
also if there are any teachers who can let me know benefits of phones at school and if they agree or not? I would like to understand more. :)

OP posts:
Florenz · 26/03/2023 13:33

It would be quite easy to ban mobile phones in school. If a pupil is seen or heard on their phone, take it off them and destroy it. If they refuse to hand it over, they're expelled on the spot, and removed from the premises, forcefully if necessary. No excuses, no exceptions, no appeals. Mobile phone use in school would drop to almost nil.

GneissWork · 26/03/2023 13:27

AnyOldThings · 26/03/2023 13:04

@GneissWork it was teachers and SLT. School planned staffing (academy) so that teachers covered lunches in exchange for less work elsewhere. It was a positive point when recruiting teachers.

No teacher I know would rather be standing in the corridors monitoring mobile phone use than standing teaching a class. I’d question what kind of teachers would willingly take menial supervision over pupil contact time. Not to mention it’s a massive waste of money to use a highly trained professional for supervision.

AnyOldThings · 26/03/2023 13:04

GneissWork · 26/03/2023 12:27

Who supervises it? As a teacher, it absolutely won’t be me. My lunchtime is for eating, or setting up my own class. It’s completely unfair to ask staff to do this.

@GneissWork it was teachers and SLT. School planned staffing (academy) so that teachers covered lunches in exchange for less work elsewhere. It was a positive point when recruiting teachers.

FrippEnos · 26/03/2023 13:03

GneissWork
What people seem to be missing is there is a direct correlation between the kids that use their phones inappropriately and the parents who do not support the school to police it.

Just to add to this

It is also those with the most expensive phones as well

No child needs a £500 phone.

Changechangechanging · 26/03/2023 13:02

As a teacher, I believe access to the Internet in some lessons, some of the time has a useful place in the arsenal of learning activities we have up our sleeves. Lots of useful sites from the games in blooket/quizlet/kahoot to the more serious seneca, Bitesize etc. What parents don't necessarily realise is that many of these sites give us all sorts of insight into learning gaps in particular- we can see what students are getting right and wrong and can use results for targeted interventions for individual students and/or for realising we need to look at a topic again because no one understands it.

As the parent of a type 1 diabetic, I can tell you that the phone is used as a medical device and is used to effectively manage his condition. The use of a phone is built into his careplan and not allowing him constant access to it would become a disability discrimination issue. Banning phones all together is simply not possible.

GneissWork · 26/03/2023 12:39

What people seem to be missing is there is a direct correlation between the kids that use their phones inappropriately and the parents who do not support the school to police it.

Almost every parent who I have discussed phone use with comes up with excuses like his gran is in hospital/he was texting me/he needs his phone for x,y and z. And almost every single pupil has a phone on them at all times; but only a minority ever bring them out in class unless asked (eg to add a reminder about homework, to do a kahoot, to take a photo of a textbook/board)

GneissWork · 26/03/2023 12:35

BibbleandSqwauk · 26/03/2023 11:26

@GneissWork did you miss-read? 8 forms of 30 per year? That's fairly standard for a comp. Whilst there are some up to 2000 it's not small. Not sure what difference it makes in this particular context anyway.

I did misread - apologies.

School size is relevant. I’ve worked in small schools (600ish) and larger schools (1600ish) - in the small schools, the corridors are far less busy, and I know most of the kids by names. In large schools, the corridors are a wall of children, most of whom I’ve never met before. It’s far easier to catch Jenny on her phone than it is to catch the boy with the blue jumper on his phone. Especially true of schools with a strict uniform/dress standards where they are all dressed identically anyway.

MoreSleepPleasee · 26/03/2023 12:35

My sons school must be an exception as they need a phone for some lessons. Kids that don't have 1 buddy up with a kid that does.

Bree82 · 26/03/2023 12:30

redbigbananafeet · 26/03/2023 12:18

So rather than you and your husband policing the phone usage of your one child, you want school staff to police the use of tens of hundreds of children?

Aw no i never said it should be on teachers to police. I did say if parents aren’t bothered that makes it harder for teachers.
I also said this is my step kid and it does frustrate me that their dad and their mother are not bothered. I have spoken with with my step kids about it but it’s not so easy for me (or my place really) to implement something if their parents are not bothered. .
I think it’s disrespectful of the kids and the parents who are not bothered - that’s what I think makes it harder for the teachers.

OP posts:
GneissWork · 26/03/2023 12:27

AnyOldThings · 26/03/2023 12:22

@GneissWork no it was a typical 1000 pupil school. Lunches and breaks were fully supervised at all times. It was run in such a way that facilitated full supervision so it was never an issue.

Who supervises it? As a teacher, it absolutely won’t be me. My lunchtime is for eating, or setting up my own class. It’s completely unfair to ask staff to do this.

AnyOldThings · 26/03/2023 12:24

@GneissWork also any parent was allowed to come collect a confiscated phone if they wanted it. But I only saw that happen once or twice. Most parents loved the no phone thing as it caused less stress or drama

AnyOldThings · 26/03/2023 12:22

GneissWork · 26/03/2023 10:11

How was this enforced at say, interval and lunch, when kids are by and large unsupervised? On corridors?

Im guessing this is in a small school?

@GneissWork no it was a typical 1000 pupil school. Lunches and breaks were fully supervised at all times. It was run in such a way that facilitated full supervision so it was never an issue.

redbigbananafeet · 26/03/2023 12:18

Bree82 · 26/03/2023 11:25

Wow what a response :)
ok I understand the Benefits of phones for safety/ being contactable etc
also taking photos of lessons and certain apps & research etc
but I guess it bothers me than sometimes it is hard to police? But I see that some schools manage?
I know times are changing but it’s more that for example - my step kid sending me random tik toks they thought I would find funny (I don’t even have tik tok) but during class time. When we pointed this out they said it was ok because it was during lunch break… when we pointed out it was sent at 3pm they changed their story and claimed the teacher let them as the lesson was finished (30 mins early).

so I get the feeling the school don’t actually allow use of them in that manner that but I guess kids do it anyway.
then I felt frustrated that my husband and their mum didn’t seem bothered 😕
but I just find it so disrespectful to ignore a class like that and in my case if parents are not bothered then not much I can do, but that just make it harder for the teachers?
it does also bother me how easy it is to film someone being beat up and laugh about it and pass it around. I don’t find that ok at all :/

So rather than you and your husband policing the phone usage of your one child, you want school staff to police the use of tens of hundreds of children?

Rosebel · 26/03/2023 12:18

BooksAndHooks · 26/03/2023 09:30

I don’t know any school around here that allows phones in school. They have to be in bags turned off. If they are seen or heard even accidentally in school they lose them for the entire half term. They can only turn them on once they are off the school premises.

That's incredibly harsh and ridiculous. What happens if the child actually needs their phone, say for example their bus gets cancelled or breaks down? What happens when the school loose the phone as will probably happen? The school my DD is at now are incredibly relaxed on phone use and they are allowed to use them in certain lessons.
They seem to have very few issues with phones being used for the wrong thing whereas the school she was at before with a very strict phone policy had endless issues and virtually every child had their phone confiscated at some point (only until the end of the day not for half a term).

reluctantbrit · 26/03/2023 11:48

GneissWork · 26/03/2023 11:18

So yes, a small school. And presumably a private school?

Not representative for the majority, I’m afraid.

No, state secondary. And average size for the secondaries in our area.

So, at least representative for our part of London.

Bree82 · 26/03/2023 11:40

BibbleandSqwauk · 26/03/2023 11:33

@Bree82 I'm afraid it is largely a generational thing in terms of how you feel about it. Having said that, Phone use is ubiquitous in all age groups...first thing people (including some police officers) do now is take a picture of a crime scene / incident / accident and share it on SM. Couples or families in restaurants all on devices. My kids will get their phones out rather than chat about their day for the ten min drive home. It is v v difficult to police in class..if I ask them to use their phones to access the work set on Teams (for a cover lesson say) there's no actual way I can know if they are messaging...unless they are doing it with someone in the class and they don't have the wit not too smirk across the room which is a dead giveaway 🤣. Sometimes it gets picked up because they message a teacher about something, or a friend in another class and that teacher sees them check their phone. It gets picked up when they do that.

Oh I didn’t think about that actually re asking the kids to do something on their phone and they do something else. Yes that would be hard to police.
i guess the messaging someone in class is the modern way of passing notes lol
I think I find the most frustrating thing about it all is how disrespectful some people are with it. And I know it’s not everyone. And I know it’s not just school kids. :/

OP posts:
Bree82 · 26/03/2023 11:35

Lindy2 · 26/03/2023 11:33

Phones out of sight and silent at all times at our Secondary school.

The kids have them in their bags for travelling to and from school but they are not seen or used once through the school gates. It seems to be enforced pretty effectively by the teachers. The kids don't want to have their phones taken off them so they stick to the rule.

Phones were previously allowed and the no phone rule introduced about a year ago. I think it's an improvement and the kids adjusted very quickly. They now talk to each other and take part in lunchtime clubs instead.

Oh that’s good. So I see it can be implemented with a positive outcome.
then they still have it for emergencies etc but also respect the rules

OP posts:
Bree82 · 26/03/2023 11:34

ReformedWaywardTeen · 26/03/2023 11:22

Our school doesn't allow them. They can have them in their bags or pocket but they are not allowed to use them until they are off school property.

As a result, DS doesn't even bother taking his and DD only has it for emergencies. She does however take a very old iPod to school for at lunchtime as she studies in the media centre and puts her headphones in. She did one time have a teacher question whether it was a mobile at lunchtime, she showed her no it was just an iPod and then the teacher scrolled through the music, suggested they were impressed with their love of old music and let her get on with it.

Aw that’s a good point though the music.
i did find it easier to focus on studying with music in the background.
maybe some kids use their phones for that reason. But then it’s being used to help focus on study which I think is fine. It’s when it’s being used to ignore lessons or make fun of people etc I don’t agree with.

OP posts:
Lindy2 · 26/03/2023 11:33

Phones out of sight and silent at all times at our Secondary school.

The kids have them in their bags for travelling to and from school but they are not seen or used once through the school gates. It seems to be enforced pretty effectively by the teachers. The kids don't want to have their phones taken off them so they stick to the rule.

Phones were previously allowed and the no phone rule introduced about a year ago. I think it's an improvement and the kids adjusted very quickly. They now talk to each other and take part in lunchtime clubs instead.

BibbleandSqwauk · 26/03/2023 11:33

@Bree82 I'm afraid it is largely a generational thing in terms of how you feel about it. Having said that, Phone use is ubiquitous in all age groups...first thing people (including some police officers) do now is take a picture of a crime scene / incident / accident and share it on SM. Couples or families in restaurants all on devices. My kids will get their phones out rather than chat about their day for the ten min drive home. It is v v difficult to police in class..if I ask them to use their phones to access the work set on Teams (for a cover lesson say) there's no actual way I can know if they are messaging...unless they are doing it with someone in the class and they don't have the wit not too smirk across the room which is a dead giveaway 🤣. Sometimes it gets picked up because they message a teacher about something, or a friend in another class and that teacher sees them check their phone. It gets picked up when they do that.

BibbleandSqwauk · 26/03/2023 11:26

@GneissWork did you miss-read? 8 forms of 30 per year? That's fairly standard for a comp. Whilst there are some up to 2000 it's not small. Not sure what difference it makes in this particular context anyway.

Bree82 · 26/03/2023 11:25

Wow what a response :)
ok I understand the Benefits of phones for safety/ being contactable etc
also taking photos of lessons and certain apps & research etc
but I guess it bothers me than sometimes it is hard to police? But I see that some schools manage?
I know times are changing but it’s more that for example - my step kid sending me random tik toks they thought I would find funny (I don’t even have tik tok) but during class time. When we pointed this out they said it was ok because it was during lunch break… when we pointed out it was sent at 3pm they changed their story and claimed the teacher let them as the lesson was finished (30 mins early).

so I get the feeling the school don’t actually allow use of them in that manner that but I guess kids do it anyway.
then I felt frustrated that my husband and their mum didn’t seem bothered 😕
but I just find it so disrespectful to ignore a class like that and in my case if parents are not bothered then not much I can do, but that just make it harder for the teachers?
it does also bother me how easy it is to film someone being beat up and laugh about it and pass it around. I don’t find that ok at all :/

OP posts:
ReformedWaywardTeen · 26/03/2023 11:22

Our school doesn't allow them. They can have them in their bags or pocket but they are not allowed to use them until they are off school property.

As a result, DS doesn't even bother taking his and DD only has it for emergencies. She does however take a very old iPod to school for at lunchtime as she studies in the media centre and puts her headphones in. She did one time have a teacher question whether it was a mobile at lunchtime, she showed her no it was just an iPod and then the teacher scrolled through the music, suggested they were impressed with their love of old music and let her get on with it.

GneissWork · 26/03/2023 11:18

reluctantbrit · 26/03/2023 10:49

DD's school has 8 forms of 30 girls/form per year plus 300 Sixformers in a separate block.

There are plenty of adults in the corridors and during lunch/break to see what's going on, much to DD's annoyance.

So yes, a small school. And presumably a private school?

Not representative for the majority, I’m afraid.

Badbudgeter · 26/03/2023 11:10

Kids access the online learning platform in school using their phones. Teachers ask them to research using their phones/ take pictures of homework. Not a fan myself but it's 9 miles away with no public transport, if he misses the bus or wants to play football/ swimming with friends after school then I need to know.