Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Phones in school

135 replies

Bree82 · 26/03/2023 09:18

Ok don’t know if I’m being old fashioned or stupid here. And I get times are changing ie technology etc. So I understand using computers more in school and for homework.
but why are mobile phones allowed in high school?

it bothers me that kids think nothing of filming fights etc at school and passing it around etc
so many teens I know can’t even look up from phone to say hi and I don’t mind people using phone a lot - but why does it make some people so rude?!
how can we let kids have their phones but still behave respectful etc?
I get this is not every kid maybe just the ones I know and I wonder if the answer is having their phones less, or just helping them learn the balance …
also if there are any teachers who can let me know benefits of phones at school and if they agree or not? I would like to understand more. :)

OP posts:
lailamaria · 26/03/2023 16:42

Florenz · 26/03/2023 13:33

It would be quite easy to ban mobile phones in school. If a pupil is seen or heard on their phone, take it off them and destroy it. If they refuse to hand it over, they're expelled on the spot, and removed from the premises, forcefully if necessary. No excuses, no exceptions, no appeals. Mobile phone use in school would drop to almost nil.

Are you alright? destroy somebody's personal property and have them immediately expelled on their first offence, that would be grounds for a full investigation into the school, plus how are you going to forcefully remove a minor from a school. Also the no exceptions rule is a bit much don't you think, honestly you sound completely barmy but somebody on here will agree with your madness

lailamaria · 26/03/2023 16:36

'how did we manage before phones' that's the thing a lot of people didn't i don't see what the problem is teens having a phone so they can communicate with their parents when their home alone in the evening or going to and from school or at their friends house

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 26/03/2023 15:59

I plan on keeping dds phone at home when she goes to secondary in September- however then I see posts on here which say their dc are told to take a photo of the homework or are told to use their devices to Google stuff.

I'm not bothered about being in contact with her during the commute as she will be getting the scholars bus to and from our street. I assume if something happens at school with the bus she can go back into the building to call me. And if something happens en route the driver would notify the school anyways.

AnyOldThings · 26/03/2023 15:59

@Malbecfan re diabetic pupils, they were given special permission to use their phones. It had to be a trust thing and in class the phone had to be out in plain view on the table so they couldn’t be on social media without the teacher knowing.

girlfriend44 · 26/03/2023 15:50

Spiderboy · 26/03/2023 09:21

most people send their children to school with phones so they are contactable when making their way to/from school. Seems obvious.

How did we manage before phones. We still got to school OK.

Malbecfan · 26/03/2023 15:38

NRTFT but my school has a policy of phones off and in bags once you arrive at school. The students are compliant and we get very few issues. However, as we draw kids in from a wide area, most of whom come by bus, there are occasions when they need to contact home quickly. We do allow that, plus we allow phones at the discretion of the class teacher for a specific purpose.

Some students use their phone to help with their diabetes. We have at least 1 student per year group whose blood sugar is tracked to their phone. They do have permission to use their phones discreetly. How would that work in schools with a ban?

The secondary school closest to my home has a blanket ban. Personally I think that's ridiculous. My students soon learn about sticking to the rules; if they don't, after 2 warnings, the phone is removed and parents have to come in to collect it. In the 21 years I have been there, I haven't had to take one.

User1990C · 26/03/2023 15:32

MyStarBoy · 26/03/2023 15:26

YADNBU
At my DC's school they have to be handed over in the morning and then they're given back at the end of the day.

They carry out bag checks on occasion, and if a pupil has one on them, there are consequences.

Works very well,

Simple.

As a pastoral lead at a large school, I'd rather eat a handful of earth each morning. Draconian nonsense like that is why SLT won't last a decade.

A moronic policy deaf to reality. Phones are useful for learning. Kids have multiple phones. Bag searches should not be routine (and actually a bag search requires CP team involvement).

MyStarBoy · 26/03/2023 15:26

YADNBU
At my DC's school they have to be handed over in the morning and then they're given back at the end of the day.

They carry out bag checks on occasion, and if a pupil has one on them, there are consequences.

Works very well,

Simple.

Untitledsquatboulder · 26/03/2023 15:16

GneissWork · 26/03/2023 09:37

And what if a parent turns up demanding the phone back? It’s literally not enforceable.

At our school there is a returns process to be gone through which seems always to end up with the phone being returned last thing on a Friday so they can demand all they like. Second offence, phone is confiscated again and child ends up in isolation. You'd be amazed at how quickly everybody gets the message: switched off at the bottom of your bag on school premises.

Stompythedinosaur · 26/03/2023 15:10

The benefit of phones in school is that when our totally unreliable school bus fails to collect the kids, breaks down or abandons them in a random location, they can ring me so I can get them.

That said, clearly they should be off and away. My dc's school makes the kids hand them in to be locked away, but I appreciate that won't be possible for bigger schools.

AnyOldThings · 26/03/2023 15:03

@GneissWork also schools results were through the roof so something was working.

AnyOldThings · 26/03/2023 15:01

GneissWork · 26/03/2023 13:27

No teacher I know would rather be standing in the corridors monitoring mobile phone use than standing teaching a class. I’d question what kind of teachers would willingly take menial supervision over pupil contact time. Not to mention it’s a massive waste of money to use a highly trained professional for supervision.

@GneissWork no not instead of teaching time. Full classes but very little work required past 3:30 due to way school was structured. Actively encouraged to leave on time and things put in place to avoid evening work. No marking etc.

it does feel like you’re insisting on being negative. It probably was a bit progressive but it worked well and staff liked how it a structured.

user1496146479 · 26/03/2023 14:42

Florenz · 26/03/2023 13:33

It would be quite easy to ban mobile phones in school. If a pupil is seen or heard on their phone, take it off them and destroy it. If they refuse to hand it over, they're expelled on the spot, and removed from the premises, forcefully if necessary. No excuses, no exceptions, no appeals. Mobile phone use in school would drop to almost nil.

Yeah good one!! HmmWink

user1496146479 · 26/03/2023 14:36

Reugny · 26/03/2023 09:52

We had phone boxes then, they don’t.

There are still phone boxes plus school offices still have phones.

The crime has increased significantly since we were kids

Reports of crime have increased plus what we consider are crimes so they are dealt with has changed.

Basically the old way of agreeing plans in advance with a contingency in case they need changing has gone out of the window.

My kids school doesn't allow them to use the phone in the office no matter how urgent.
No phone boxes either

Fairislefandango · 26/03/2023 14:20

Change the rules to make it easier.

Schools don't get to decide those rules.

Fairislefandango · 26/03/2023 14:19

It's not easy. Kids will get around phone rules. They often have a sob story or compelling excuse as to why they have their phone out. Some carry an old phone to hand over to teachers instead of their actual one. Parents often don't support the school confiscating phones.

Phone use at break and lunch time is impossible to police. As is getting phones out in the toilets. Students almost certainly ask to go to the toilet precisely in order use their phones. I know of students who have been filmed on the toilet. But parents complain about phone restrictions and toilet access restrictions. We can tell students they have to leave their phone with the teacher if they go to the toilet, but then they often say 'Oh I didn't bring my phone today'. Short of physically searching them, what are we supposed to do?

Florenz · 26/03/2023 14:16

thesnailandthewhale · 26/03/2023 14:09

Do you have any idea of the cost to a school to permanently exclude a student?
And you wouldn't be able to permanently exclude for not following a rule once either.

Change the rules to make it easier.

ScentOfAMemory · 26/03/2023 14:12

redbigbananafeet · 26/03/2023 09:23

How would you suggest getting mobile phones off of 800 teenagers?

Our school has a written rule that no phones will be visible at any time, unless sanctioned by the teacher for lesson purposes. (tomorrow morning one of my lessons is in a classroom with a whiteboard that's not working, the kids will use their phones) If the rule isn't followed, the phone goes into the school safe and the parents come in and collect it.

Nobody gets the phones from the teenagers. The teenagers accept the consequences of not following the rule. In the last couple of years I've only had one student whose phone went in the safe. It stayed there for a fortnight as his parents also decided to teach him a lesson.

thesnailandthewhale · 26/03/2023 14:09

Florenz · 26/03/2023 13:33

It would be quite easy to ban mobile phones in school. If a pupil is seen or heard on their phone, take it off them and destroy it. If they refuse to hand it over, they're expelled on the spot, and removed from the premises, forcefully if necessary. No excuses, no exceptions, no appeals. Mobile phone use in school would drop to almost nil.

Do you have any idea of the cost to a school to permanently exclude a student?
And you wouldn't be able to permanently exclude for not following a rule once either.

JacobsCrackersCheeseFogg · 26/03/2023 14:09

My daughter's school has a ban on phone use throughout the day from the moment they step on the grounds to when they leave. If they need to ring home they have to ask a teacher to contact reception.

Doesn't stop some kids from using their phones in the toilets though.

thesnailandthewhale · 26/03/2023 14:02

Reugny · 26/03/2023 09:52

We had phone boxes then, they don’t.

There are still phone boxes plus school offices still have phones.

The crime has increased significantly since we were kids

Reports of crime have increased plus what we consider are crimes so they are dealt with has changed.

Basically the old way of agreeing plans in advance with a contingency in case they need changing has gone out of the window.

Our office doesn't have phones, we'll not ones that students can use. We use Teams for calls so we are logged in on our account and we have our own headsets that are not to be shared since covid.

ChickenDhansak82 · 26/03/2023 14:00

I don't know any secondary school that does allow phones!

I'm a teacher and if I even see a phone in a pocket I'm allowed to confiscate it. The parents then need to come and collect it.

If a child refuses to hand it over then someone senior will come and remove them from their lesson and put them in isolation.

Phones are a nuisance in school! The source of too much bullying.

Bree82 · 26/03/2023 13:58

ReformedWaywardTeen · 26/03/2023 13:44

No I wouldn't like the idea of the phones being used for nastiness, and I know our head and some of the SLT have dummy accounts and check TikTok, Snapchat and the rest.

With the music for DD, it's only at lunch, not in class, but she had said during lockdown she would study with headphones in and Spotify on, so school very kindly allowed her to do so at lunch, quite a few now have the same but the school have said no speakers, just wired headphones.

I actually think it’s not a bad idea to allow music if it helps people concentrate on their studies and music is a great thing!

OP posts:
GneissWork · 26/03/2023 13:57

Florenz · 26/03/2023 13:33

It would be quite easy to ban mobile phones in school. If a pupil is seen or heard on their phone, take it off them and destroy it. If they refuse to hand it over, they're expelled on the spot, and removed from the premises, forcefully if necessary. No excuses, no exceptions, no appeals. Mobile phone use in school would drop to almost nil.

😂 I hope this is a joke! Someone is bound to take it seriously and agree with you though.

ReformedWaywardTeen · 26/03/2023 13:44

Bree82 · 26/03/2023 11:34

Aw that’s a good point though the music.
i did find it easier to focus on studying with music in the background.
maybe some kids use their phones for that reason. But then it’s being used to help focus on study which I think is fine. It’s when it’s being used to ignore lessons or make fun of people etc I don’t agree with.

No I wouldn't like the idea of the phones being used for nastiness, and I know our head and some of the SLT have dummy accounts and check TikTok, Snapchat and the rest.

With the music for DD, it's only at lunch, not in class, but she had said during lockdown she would study with headphones in and Spotify on, so school very kindly allowed her to do so at lunch, quite a few now have the same but the school have said no speakers, just wired headphones.

Swipe left for the next trending thread