Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Phones in school

135 replies

Bree82 · 26/03/2023 09:18

Ok don’t know if I’m being old fashioned or stupid here. And I get times are changing ie technology etc. So I understand using computers more in school and for homework.
but why are mobile phones allowed in high school?

it bothers me that kids think nothing of filming fights etc at school and passing it around etc
so many teens I know can’t even look up from phone to say hi and I don’t mind people using phone a lot - but why does it make some people so rude?!
how can we let kids have their phones but still behave respectful etc?
I get this is not every kid maybe just the ones I know and I wonder if the answer is having their phones less, or just helping them learn the balance …
also if there are any teachers who can let me know benefits of phones at school and if they agree or not? I would like to understand more. :)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
thing47 · 27/03/2023 16:34

Re. Type I diabetes, the use of the Libre for blood-sugar monitoring is highly encouraged by diabetes consultants and DSNs, and everyone who wants one is entitled to have one. The Libre is monitored by a phone app and alarms if sugars go too high or too low so having your phone on you at all times is essential. A blanket ban on phones which did not provide exemptions for DCs with Type I diabetes would be illegal under the terms of the 2010 Equality Act.

Tlittle · 27/03/2023 00:37

I have never known them allowed in schools round here. Two of my kids are allowed them at school as type one diabetic and they have my life diabetic app on their phones. Only brought them as hospital asked me to. They have medical exception for the phones and it is in their care plans. Their friend told me they were jealous lol.
But yes in general I agree about the phones and keeping them off in high schools.

meganorks · 27/03/2023 00:17

My daughter isn't allowed her phone in school. She has to keep it off in her locker. I assumed all schools were the same. But I recently found out her other 2 school options don't have lockers (which I find insane!) so that would make it a lot harder to police. I don't think they allow phones to be used still but if the kids have them on them at all times some will sneakily try and film or take pictures if something is happening.

Stompythedinosaur · 27/03/2023 00:04

Florenz · 26/03/2023 13:33

It would be quite easy to ban mobile phones in school. If a pupil is seen or heard on their phone, take it off them and destroy it. If they refuse to hand it over, they're expelled on the spot, and removed from the premises, forcefully if necessary. No excuses, no exceptions, no appeals. Mobile phone use in school would drop to almost nil.

This is an amazing suggestion. Are you aware that teachers are no exempt from the requirement to follow the law? They clearly can't go around destroying hundreds of pounds of personal property.

I work with teens, and I guarantee a large number would opt for expulsion rather than hand over their phone. I'm not sure mass expulsions would be the huge success you are imagining.

Fairislefandango · 26/03/2023 22:25

It would be quite easy to ban mobile phones in school. If a pupil is seen or heard on their phone, take it off them and destroy it. If they refuse to hand it over, they're expelled on the spot, and removed from the premises, forcefully if necessary. No excuses, no exceptions, no appeals. Mobile phone use in school would drop to almost nil.

You can't surely be under the impression that schools have free rein to just decide to do things like this? They are neither allowed to destroy students' property nor expell students on the spot. Permanently excluding even one student is a long and cumbersome process which often fails. It baffles me when people just blithely say that schools 'should just' do x, y or z.

BaileysBreakfast · 26/03/2023 22:25

Poster mentioning diabetes- I work in a school with v strict no phones policy but my diabetic student is allowed hers.

phones are locked in a yonder pouch at the start of the day and released at the end of the day. Divisional head detention if you forget your phone or pouch.

schools are so much better with phones locked away

justasmalltownmum · 26/03/2023 22:06

You can't stop them.

Spiderboy · 26/03/2023 22:04

VickyEadieofThigh · 26/03/2023 09:26

Yes, it's astonishing how many kids simply disappeared off the face of the earth on their way to and from school before mobiles were available.

Of course, every child needs one so they can call a parent if they're being abducted, or use it to fight off an assailant...

Are you feeling extra sensitive today? 🙃 god forbid parents want to be responsible and keep and eye on their kids in this day and age

Hoppinggreen · 26/03/2023 21:34

When my DC arrive at school they go to their form room and all phones are placed in a locked cabinet. They are collected at the end of the day.
If a child needs to contact a parent they go to the school office.
Any child caught with a phone has it confiscated and they collect it at the end of the day. The second time onwards this happens (rare) the phone is only returned to a parent.
I fully support it

GneissWork · 26/03/2023 21:30

Saltywalruss · 26/03/2023 21:14

Just because phones are "personal property" it doesn't mean that pupils should be allowed to bring anything to school!

Just because they shouldn’t have the phone on them doesn’t mean the school has the right to take it off then and destroy it or expel the child for merely having an alarm go off during class 😂

If they get expelled for having a phone go off, what do we do if they smash a window? Firing squad? Drown them?

VestaTilley · 26/03/2023 21:17

YANBU. They should be banned in schools and for all under 13s.

Saltywalruss · 26/03/2023 21:14

lailamaria · 26/03/2023 16:42

Are you alright? destroy somebody's personal property and have them immediately expelled on their first offence, that would be grounds for a full investigation into the school, plus how are you going to forcefully remove a minor from a school. Also the no exceptions rule is a bit much don't you think, honestly you sound completely barmy but somebody on here will agree with your madness

Just because phones are "personal property" it doesn't mean that pupils should be allowed to bring anything to school!

Saltywalruss · 26/03/2023 21:10

redbigbananafeet · 26/03/2023 09:23

How would you suggest getting mobile phones off of 800 teenagers?

Well, you either ask them to keep phones in bags or you ask them to hand phones in (you'd have to have a system for that obviously).

GneissWork · 26/03/2023 21:07

Ohthejoyous · 26/03/2023 18:53

Unfortunately we've had a fight tooth and nail even to get him allowed to have his monitor on his desk in gcse exams. Yes it really isn't good enough but what can you do?

The school toilets - that's a whole other issue. They are so disgusting both my kids avoid drinking so they don't have to go at school. My son usually skips lunch. Not ideal but the reality when the alternative is battling through the vapers or injecting in front of mates.

Surely your son should qualify for using the disabled toilet? Where I am, those are normally the staff loos too and therefore are generally clean and well maintained. There would be space for him to place his equipment too, should he need it.

User1990C · 26/03/2023 20:54

ScentOfAMemory · 26/03/2023 17:34

You're a pastoral lead and think a term like the one you have used is acceptable language? You need training in not using offensive language.

I am. Amazingly, one doesn't need to speak like Miss Honey in one's personal life to be a teacher. I, like all teachers, speak to children differently to adults.

Ohthejoyous · 26/03/2023 18:53

Unfortunately we've had a fight tooth and nail even to get him allowed to have his monitor on his desk in gcse exams. Yes it really isn't good enough but what can you do?

The school toilets - that's a whole other issue. They are so disgusting both my kids avoid drinking so they don't have to go at school. My son usually skips lunch. Not ideal but the reality when the alternative is battling through the vapers or injecting in front of mates.

Changechangechanging · 26/03/2023 18:24

@Ohthejoyous I’m sorry that doesn’t work for your son. Teachers should be informed when they start teaching that there is someone in class using cgm and/or a pump like omnipod dash (where the controller looks like a phone) . There should be no need to explain it. Supply teachers should always be made aware of type 1s in classes they are covering. If your son is constantly having to explain himself, it really isn’t good enough. How can they know who/how to support if they’re not sure who’s who and don’t know what tech they are using? He should also have somewhere to go to inject in peace. Ask your DSN to get it written into careplans if necessary. Is he coded on registers so he’s able to go out to the loo with out any questions?

Ohthejoyous · 26/03/2023 18:08

Changechangechanging · 26/03/2023 17:47

We have at least 1 student per year group whose blood sugar is tracked to their phone. They do have permission to use their phones discreetly. How would that work in schools with a ban?

why should they have to be discrete about it? Alarms go off if things are too high/too low so it’s hardly unobtrusive, unfortunately. I even with a ban on phones diabetic children will need to be allowed to use them - as I said up thread, it is written into care plans and immediately becomes an issue of disability discrimination (use of tech for type 1 is ‘reasonable adjustment’) if a teacher tries to stop it.

That's all sounds good on theory but the reality is a diabetic constantly having to explain their condition to new teachers etc. It's bad enough having diabetes without this.

As a result of his school's draconian policy my son uses a different monitor *ie not a phone) which makes it much harder to monitor his condition. He hates having to inject in front of friends and chooses not to take his phone/use an app so he doesn't have to have constant embarrassing arguments.

whittingtonmum · 26/03/2023 17:56

Our secondary school only allows brick phones. Obviously kids still bring in smart phones but they do get confiscated for a while if found during spot checks.

Gave me the wriggle room I needed to hold out longer until giving a smartphone than I would otherwise have.

SammyScrounge · 26/03/2023 17:51

Bree82 · 26/03/2023 09:18

Ok don’t know if I’m being old fashioned or stupid here. And I get times are changing ie technology etc. So I understand using computers more in school and for homework.
but why are mobile phones allowed in high school?

it bothers me that kids think nothing of filming fights etc at school and passing it around etc
so many teens I know can’t even look up from phone to say hi and I don’t mind people using phone a lot - but why does it make some people so rude?!
how can we let kids have their phones but still behave respectful etc?
I get this is not every kid maybe just the ones I know and I wonder if the answer is having their phones less, or just helping them learn the balance …
also if there are any teachers who can let me know benefits of phones at school and if they agree or not? I would like to understand more. :)

They were banned when they first hit the schools but parents complained that they were necessary in the event of an emergency. We just laughed but the education authority conceded the matter under the threat of a court action.

Sometimes parents demonstrate a complete lack of sense. The children phoned friends in other classes, orchestrated phones going off simultaneously all over the school, or sat playing games on their phones. They even phoned their parents in the middle of classes to complain about the teacher. I read about one parent who sent the police to a teacher's house to investigate the theft of their son's phone when the teacher confiscated it.

There is a preserved Victorian school in Glasgow. In the office lies the headmaster's Day Book. It is open at a page where he describes a complaint from a parent about her child being punished for a clear breach of rules. He told the woman to go home.and mind her.own business and leave him to his. And that was that.
Sigh. We need more of that attitude today.

Changechangechanging · 26/03/2023 17:47

We have at least 1 student per year group whose blood sugar is tracked to their phone. They do have permission to use their phones discreetly. How would that work in schools with a ban?

why should they have to be discrete about it? Alarms go off if things are too high/too low so it’s hardly unobtrusive, unfortunately. I even with a ban on phones diabetic children will need to be allowed to use them - as I said up thread, it is written into care plans and immediately becomes an issue of disability discrimination (use of tech for type 1 is ‘reasonable adjustment’) if a teacher tries to stop it.

kimchifix · 26/03/2023 17:36

Phones handed in at DDs school also. Collect at end of day. I wonder if it works because they all have laptops - private school, privileged kids. Don't need the phone for work. They can still message but but it's not as easy as using a phone. It's a large school, but probably relatively high staff to student ratios. High levels of compliance as rule breaking has sanctions ranging from detention to Saturday detention to suspension to ultimately being asked to leave. Easier to enforce.

ScentOfAMemory · 26/03/2023 17:34

User1990C · 26/03/2023 15:32

As a pastoral lead at a large school, I'd rather eat a handful of earth each morning. Draconian nonsense like that is why SLT won't last a decade.

A moronic policy deaf to reality. Phones are useful for learning. Kids have multiple phones. Bag searches should not be routine (and actually a bag search requires CP team involvement).

You're a pastoral lead and think a term like the one you have used is acceptable language? You need training in not using offensive language.

catgirl1976 · 26/03/2023 17:23

DS takes his phone to school (Y6 primary) because he walks home and I can track him and he can call me if there’s a problem.

he has it switched off on his bag and knows if he gets it out or turns it on it will be confiscated. The school are still unhappy about this and say he can’t have it but I’ve said “Sorry. He will have it for his safety walking home. If he has it out or switches it on confiscate it by all means but he will be bringing it in and keeping it his bag switched off for my peace of mind and his safety.”

GneissWork · 26/03/2023 16:54

BernadetteRostankowskiWolowitz · 26/03/2023 15:59

I plan on keeping dds phone at home when she goes to secondary in September- however then I see posts on here which say their dc are told to take a photo of the homework or are told to use their devices to Google stuff.

I'm not bothered about being in contact with her during the commute as she will be getting the scholars bus to and from our street. I assume if something happens at school with the bus she can go back into the building to call me. And if something happens en route the driver would notify the school anyways.

To be fair, it’s never assumed that a kid would have a phone.

An example would be if we are discussing a volcanic eruption from the 1960s and a kid asks me if the volcano has erupted recently - which has nothing to do with the lesson, but is still a point of interest. Instead of shutting down their interest, I might ask them if they have a phone and allow them to google it and tell the class. Now obviously if they don’t have a phone, it’s going to have little impact, and I can check later on in the lesson.

I also never ask if they have a phone directly because that leads to the potential for embarrassment. Instead I ask if their phone has charge/if they are connected to the school Wi-Fi/if they have any data left. So nobody feels the social pressure to have a phone.

Similarly with homework, I don’t directly say “note this in your phone” - I say “note this down how you normally record your homework” - and I also post it on Google classroom. However, not all kids have computers/tablets/phones at home, so I also offer them a paper copy (under the guise of “if you prefer to have a paper copy too” rather than saying “if you don’t have a computer” because obviously that reinforces a stigma for those who don’t have)

Its perfectly fine not to send your kid with a phone, they most definitely don’t NEED it. Despite what your kid will undoubtedly tell you. However, I’d say that at the start of high school, it’s maybe 70:30 phone:no phone, and by Christmas almost every kid has a phone.

I guess it depends how the teachers manage phones in their classrooms as to whether it’s an issue or not.