Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Led by donkeys - enough is enough

659 replies

Thisisvenus · 25/03/2023 21:43

Bloody hell, I’ve just watched the new “led by donkeys” video. People like Matt Hancock wanting to work for a fake consultancy firm for obscene amounts of cash.

I cannot tell You how angry MPs make me right now.

I have a relative that is an NHS dr on £14 an hour. She pays for her own travel and parking. All her study… she pays for. She is so busy she sometimes doesn’t eat.

then these idiots earn loads, and then claim back loads of expenses. Disgusting in my opinion. They then get second jobs that pay them £10k a day. Without even checking if company is real first.

In my opinion an mp should only take a second job if it’s in the nhs, army etc or a volunteer job for a registered charity. That’s it. No other reason.

I can’t even process this. I’ve had enough. What on earth can we do to change this? And yes I’ll not be voting Tory at the next election. They are a bunch of posh rich boys that want to just look after themselves. Politics should be more diverse. what on earth can we do?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
Eleganz · 26/03/2023 10:50

allibaby · 26/03/2023 10:44

The thing is though it has been like this for years so they must know what they are getting into before they choose to do so.
Does that mean I don't support my colleagues striking?
No it doesn't but if things are as bad as people make out why do they do it?

Maybe they are looking at the long term of becoming a consultant.

I'm sorry, I don't see what point you are making. If you support strikes then you understand that pay rates are not acceptable, the fact that people know this but go into the profession anyway is irrelevant to whether pay rates are too low or not.

However, many people aren't doing it - they are either not training in medicine or they are moving abroad for better paying positions. The NHS could not staff itself with just home-trained doctors and relies heavily on medical professionals from developing nations.

jgw1 · 26/03/2023 10:49

Clavinova · 26/03/2023 10:44

@Clavinova I take it you agree with Sir Keir that there should be a ban on MPs having 2nd jobs and will therefore vote for his party at the next election?

Eleganz · 26/03/2023 10:46

I do have to say that I am consistently impressed by the Tories' ability to convince enough people to vote against their own self-interests. It is really a political marvel.

At the end of that day they've made it easy for me this time as I don't have any conflict between self-interest and the moral position on wider societal benefits. The Tories have fucked up society at large and made me poorer as an individual so why on earth would I ever vote for them? Yet there are millions of people who are in the same situation who will do so...

Feuillemille23 · 26/03/2023 10:45

FGS God given right not good.

allibaby · 26/03/2023 10:44

Eleganz · 26/03/2023 10:38

Sadly it is pervasive. Even full fact, who are usually pretty good, are claiming that junior doctors earn more because you have to take into account their annual leave! That is a statutory requirement for all employees! The hour pay rates for Pret baristas aren't calculated exclusive of statutory leave entitlements so why should junior doctor's be?

Yes I will happily accept that junior doctors get additional pay for night, weekend and on call work, but so do many other graduate jobs. Of course that is better than a pret barista, but come on, they are highly trained graduates for god's sake!

The graduate scheme I went on pays a minimum of £31,000 a year currently and requires a bachelor's degree only and no night shift, weekend or on call working. They also offer a premium for people with relevant postgraduate qualifications with someone with a relevant PhD getting a starting salary of £36,000 a year.

The thing is though it has been like this for years so they must know what they are getting into before they choose to do so.
Does that mean I don't support my colleagues striking?
No it doesn't but if things are as bad as people make out why do they do it?

Maybe they are looking at the long term of becoming a consultant.

Feuillemille23 · 26/03/2023 10:43

Dress it up however you like, but there are only a tiny number of reasons, when you come right down to it, anyone would vote for the current breed of Tories.

  1. You're mega rich and terrified of losing your wealth
  2. You're mega selfish and don't give a monkey's backside about the rest of humanity
  3. You're poor but delusional and think the Tories are on your side

I get thoroughly exasperated with people using spurious arguments about Tories being the only ones who understand what a woman is to justify their inhumane and badly thought out voting decisions. It was the Tories who initially introduced much of the misogynistic legislation we're now paying for.

Once upon a time there may have been moderate Tories who cared about their constituents and even the country as a whole. Even Thatcher, evil and fond of a good cover up as she was, genuinely seemed to believe she was serving the country's best interests. Those days are long gone. Those still voting Tory are complicit in inhumane, selfish and beyond materialistic attitudes that are breathtaking in their cruelty and self centredness when you actually start looking at the detail.

No, I don't think labour or any other party is perfect, and yes, there are plenty of politicians in other parties who are also venal, greedy, incompetent and delusional about their own abilities and worth.

But as Led by Donkeys and others regularly point out, the evidence shows that these characteristics are found more often amongst Tories. So many Tories seem to think they have a Good given right to rule because they went to the right schools, have a posh accent, and were born with a silver spoon stuck up their rectum.

Brefugee · 26/03/2023 10:43

It’s not really relevant who I voted for last time. Since we last voted a lot of terrible behaviour has happened

That tories are grasping fuckers out to enrich themselves is not new since the last election.

jgw1 · 26/03/2023 10:43

Roussette · 26/03/2023 10:35

I don't understand it. It's all about scammers. Or a sting in their case. Every one of us has to pay attention. If I get any unexpected email, any phone call, any text, any whatsapp I immediately assume it is a scam. I carry out my own due diligence. Basically I am a total cynic and do not believe anyone is who they say they is, unless I can prove it.

Yet these idiots just take things at face value. Shocking.

They are perhaps a little more greedy than you or I.

jgw1 · 26/03/2023 10:42

allibaby · 26/03/2023 10:35

It did need clarification and it has been clarified.

No it did not need clarification. The original statement was factually accurate. Shocking but accurate.

Roussette · 26/03/2023 10:40

Well said @BitchBrigade

There's France rioting about pension age going from 62 to 64, yet here we are going up to 67. Before I get slated (like I did on another thread) I do not agree with damage to property or violence. Peaceful march is the way to go. Then contacting every news channel imaginable and tweeting the hell out of them for coverage.

I just said we are complacement, unlike the French, and got my arse handed to me on a plate!

Eleganz · 26/03/2023 10:38

jgw1 · 26/03/2023 10:28

I think perhaps if one is a disciple of Gove and live in a world where experts are looked down upon and to be ignored and to think the facts they use are up for debate then arguing about everything is perfectly logical.

Sadly it is pervasive. Even full fact, who are usually pretty good, are claiming that junior doctors earn more because you have to take into account their annual leave! That is a statutory requirement for all employees! The hour pay rates for Pret baristas aren't calculated exclusive of statutory leave entitlements so why should junior doctor's be?

Yes I will happily accept that junior doctors get additional pay for night, weekend and on call work, but so do many other graduate jobs. Of course that is better than a pret barista, but come on, they are highly trained graduates for god's sake!

The graduate scheme I went on pays a minimum of £31,000 a year currently and requires a bachelor's degree only and no night shift, weekend or on call working. They also offer a premium for people with relevant postgraduate qualifications with someone with a relevant PhD getting a starting salary of £36,000 a year.

BitchBrigade · 26/03/2023 10:36

Your post sums up the great British attitude marvellously.

"Government parties are all shit, but why bother holding them to account, nothing will change, can't do anything about it, whine whine whine".

This country has no spine. None. We are getting fucked hard in the arse and instead of getting out there striking like the rest of us and protesting, rioting even, on the streets to force tangible change like the French we shrug our shoulders and whine we can't do anything about it. Or worse, scream about those who ARE out on the picket line or at protests about how grabby and awful they are for daring to.

We can and we should do something about it. We are just bloody well too lazy to bother.

Roussette · 26/03/2023 10:35

I don't understand it. It's all about scammers. Or a sting in their case. Every one of us has to pay attention. If I get any unexpected email, any phone call, any text, any whatsapp I immediately assume it is a scam. I carry out my own due diligence. Basically I am a total cynic and do not believe anyone is who they say they is, unless I can prove it.

Yet these idiots just take things at face value. Shocking.

allibaby · 26/03/2023 10:35

jgw1 · 26/03/2023 10:26

It didn't need clarification. There are doctors paid £14 an hour.
Just because you don't want to believe it does not mean it is not true.

It did need clarification and it has been clarified.

allibaby · 26/03/2023 10:34

Eleganz · 26/03/2023 10:23

The minimum FY1 salary for a junior doctor is 29,384 for 2022-23 for a 40 hour week. This is £14.13 an hour before any deductions for student loans for example.

So, how are no doctors earning that given it is part of the payscale? The arguments I've seen online all refer to taking into account annual leave or overtime/shift payments. If you can explain to me how you can get to the point that no doctor is earning so little despite it being the payscale without invoking annual leave and overtime/shift payments then show your working.

I'm big enough to hold my hands up and say I was wrong as it seems some junior doctors are only earning that much basic pay.

Notonthestairs · 26/03/2023 10:31

The really worrying thing about the Led By Donkeys video is that those MPs and ex Ministers must have received security training. And yet they seemed to have done zero due diligence.

Either they weren't bright enough to understand the training or thought they were too special for it apply to them.

Security services must have their heads in their hands.

jgw1 · 26/03/2023 10:28

Eleganz · 26/03/2023 10:23

The minimum FY1 salary for a junior doctor is 29,384 for 2022-23 for a 40 hour week. This is £14.13 an hour before any deductions for student loans for example.

So, how are no doctors earning that given it is part of the payscale? The arguments I've seen online all refer to taking into account annual leave or overtime/shift payments. If you can explain to me how you can get to the point that no doctor is earning so little despite it being the payscale without invoking annual leave and overtime/shift payments then show your working.

I think perhaps if one is a disciple of Gove and live in a world where experts are looked down upon and to be ignored and to think the facts they use are up for debate then arguing about everything is perfectly logical.

jgw1 · 26/03/2023 10:26

allibaby · 26/03/2023 10:18

It did need clarification as in the original OP it was stated NHS Dr on £14 an hour.
Not wanting to misrepresent at all just wanting facts not lies and exaggeration to push a narrative which seems to happen a lot on here.

It didn't need clarification. There are doctors paid £14 an hour.
Just because you don't want to believe it does not mean it is not true.

Eleganz · 26/03/2023 10:23

allibaby · 26/03/2023 10:15

Who mentioned overtime and paid annual leave?

The minimum FY1 salary for a junior doctor is 29,384 for 2022-23 for a 40 hour week. This is £14.13 an hour before any deductions for student loans for example.

So, how are no doctors earning that given it is part of the payscale? The arguments I've seen online all refer to taking into account annual leave or overtime/shift payments. If you can explain to me how you can get to the point that no doctor is earning so little despite it being the payscale without invoking annual leave and overtime/shift payments then show your working.

MeinKraft · 26/03/2023 10:21

Boomboom22 · 26/03/2023 10:14

Thing is the current gov do not espouse tory values. And Labour whilst less corrupt on an individual level, seem to lack bad sense.

Kier said it is wrong to say only women have a cervix. Lammy said those men on hormones grow a cervix. Nandy says rapists should be held in women's Prisons. Raynor is an extremist. Yes they claim less expenses but their ideology is so far detached from reality how could they make reasonable laws?

Remember the last Labour gov. Scandals aplenty, an illegal war that led to issues today including instability and migration. Ruined education, its taken years to get back up the global league tables. Tax credits so those in benefits had more money than workers up to about 70k. Race to the bottom politics and envy of success! And Blair was way more electable than kier.

So no good options at the mo.

Honestly anyone would think Keir Starmer is going to win the next election, charge onto the stage and announce single sex spaces are HEREBY ABOLISHED.

allibaby · 26/03/2023 10:18

jgw1 · 26/03/2023 10:15

It didn't need clarifying, it was always obvious, except for those who for their own reasons were trying to misrepresent the OP.

It did need clarification as in the original OP it was stated NHS Dr on £14 an hour.
Not wanting to misrepresent at all just wanting facts not lies and exaggeration to push a narrative which seems to happen a lot on here.

MeinKraft · 26/03/2023 10:18

'Some people thought they were going to be in the privileged group and voted Tory to keep others down, only to find they were the ones to suffer. But they will forgive them if the Tories pull out divisive or greed-based slogans in the near future. They always do.'

This is it. Lots of people out there thinking the Tories are for the wealthy, well that's me, I own my house and we both have good jobs, I'll vote Tory and maybe I won't have to pay inheritance tax when my parents die and leave me their house. No...the Tories want to protect a different kind of wealth. The £10,000 a day consultancy fees for a fake business kind of wealth. And they will screw everyone underneath to benefit the very wealthy.

jgw1 · 26/03/2023 10:17

Boomboom22 · 26/03/2023 10:14

Thing is the current gov do not espouse tory values. And Labour whilst less corrupt on an individual level, seem to lack bad sense.

Kier said it is wrong to say only women have a cervix. Lammy said those men on hormones grow a cervix. Nandy says rapists should be held in women's Prisons. Raynor is an extremist. Yes they claim less expenses but their ideology is so far detached from reality how could they make reasonable laws?

Remember the last Labour gov. Scandals aplenty, an illegal war that led to issues today including instability and migration. Ruined education, its taken years to get back up the global league tables. Tax credits so those in benefits had more money than workers up to about 70k. Race to the bottom politics and envy of success! And Blair was way more electable than kier.

So no good options at the mo.

Thank you for your post.
Two of the entries on my bingo card for this thread were But Jeremy Corbyn and they know what a woman is.

Quite why anyone would think that, those are reasonable explanations for the level of corruption shown in the Led by Donkeys video I will never know.

allibaby · 26/03/2023 10:15

Eleganz · 26/03/2023 10:09

Interesting - the £14 an hour figure comes from the lowest F1 salary for 2022-23. You say you are interested in facts but claim that no doctor anywhere earns this little despite it being there in black and white that that is the payscale. The arguments that I've seen against this appear to use claims around overtime pay and paid annual leave - I'd say these are pretty disingenuous as the hourly rates for jobs like the Pret barista will also include accrual of statutory paid leave as well and of course overtime can pay more but you are working more hours or antisocial hours!

You can get more on a graduate scheme with a bachelor's degree at the end of the day.

Who mentioned overtime and paid annual leave?