Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Led by donkeys - enough is enough

659 replies

Thisisvenus · 25/03/2023 21:43

Bloody hell, I’ve just watched the new “led by donkeys” video. People like Matt Hancock wanting to work for a fake consultancy firm for obscene amounts of cash.

I cannot tell You how angry MPs make me right now.

I have a relative that is an NHS dr on £14 an hour. She pays for her own travel and parking. All her study… she pays for. She is so busy she sometimes doesn’t eat.

then these idiots earn loads, and then claim back loads of expenses. Disgusting in my opinion. They then get second jobs that pay them £10k a day. Without even checking if company is real first.

In my opinion an mp should only take a second job if it’s in the nhs, army etc or a volunteer job for a registered charity. That’s it. No other reason.

I can’t even process this. I’ve had enough. What on earth can we do to change this? And yes I’ll not be voting Tory at the next election. They are a bunch of posh rich boys that want to just look after themselves. Politics should be more diverse. what on earth can we do?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
jgw1 · 26/03/2023 11:34

Rhondaa · 26/03/2023 11:32

'You can always rely on clavinova for a bit of deflection and whataboutery'

Grin

The poster posts facts and actual relevant links. The truth is inconvenient obviously but it's hardly 'whataboutery'.

@Janiie at risk of keeping this on topic about the midemeanors of Tory MPs, and not the fees paid to TV presenters that is off topic, can I ask you a simple question.
Why do you think it is acceptable for a 56 year old to have had a birthday party whilst denying that opportunity to millions of children?

Crikeyalmighty · 26/03/2023 11:33

You know those of you who couldn't vote labour last time because - 'well Corbyn' (I voted Lib Dem because I live somewhere that returns Lib Dem MOs) and you voted Tory anyway , May I suggest you have a reverse think and vote labour in because 'well Truss, Braverman, Patel, Rees Mogg etc' !! Vote Lib Dem in areas where they are likely to be the main rival to the Tory's (Home Counties in particular) Starmer May be a bit earnest, and labour might have a few policies you find a bit woo , but I would take bets that if anyone is found doing anything dodgy they will be out on their ear. Starmer is very into law and order - he won't be soft on corrupt MPs if in power. Many on the left don't like him for this reason , on law and order he's a bit less liberal than some would like. Personally I think he's a good man with strong principles and a very sharp brain- and not remotely corrupt -

Notonthestairs · 26/03/2023 11:33

Well yes I guess expenses claims is another thread we can pull on - heated stables, moats and duck houses and all that.

But getting scammed by a fake South Korean company is a cause for concern whether you accept that or not.

jgw1 · 26/03/2023 11:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Rhondaa · 26/03/2023 11:32

Clavinova · 26/03/2023 11:22

Matt Hancock requesting £1,500 per hour is just shocking

Labour MP Jess Phillips was paid £15,000 to host a single episode of Have I Got News For You.
Ms Phillips was approached for comment by the Mail on Sunday and accepted that £15k is ‘a lot of money’ but believes ‘it’s the standard fee’.

https://metro.co.uk/2022/02/07/labour-mp-jess-phillips-paid-15000-to-host-have-i-got-news-for-you-16063846/

'You can always rely on clavinova for a bit of deflection and whataboutery'

Grin

The poster posts facts and actual relevant links. The truth is inconvenient obviously but it's hardly 'whataboutery'.

TooBored1 · 26/03/2023 11:32

Thisisvenus · 26/03/2023 08:19

Besides I don’t think it is helpful to blame those that voted Tory last time. It does not help the future at all. Not does it do anything but anger people that could possibly vote for something else.

its like telling a kid that fell over and broke their arm that it’s their own fault.

not sure anyone could have predicted Covid, parties, I’m a celeb, snogging, Boris lying to this extent, rishi getting in, etc. it’s a soap opera!

Actually, yes it was all so predictable. We knew the BJ was an out and out liar, bolstered by racists and misogynistic cheats who were just out to line their own pockets. Unfortunately, some people chose to look the other way.

allibaby · 26/03/2023 11:32

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 26/03/2023 11:14

The above post made it sound like she was a student doctor.

Only to someone who has no idea how Drs training is structured. And there you were, making pronouncements from a position of ignorance whilst appealing to the authority of your own employment in the NHS. Maybe put your spade down now?

No I went off what was posted by the OP and later admitted I was wrong.
However it's now easy for the likes of yourself to act all clever AFTER the op clarified what she meant.

Also it's not up to you to tell me I can no longer post so.....

jgw1 · 26/03/2023 11:31

allibaby · 26/03/2023 11:25

Nope I just read NHS doctor and reacted.
The OP later made a post that came across like her relative was a student so yes clarification was needed.

The OP did not make a post that suggested her relative was a student, to anyone who knows anything about students or doctors.

IMustDoMoreExercise · 26/03/2023 11:30

@Thisisvenus

It is very easy to criticise politicians (and yes, I am as sick of them as you are) but why don't you become one?

Could it because you do not want to you and your family to be targeted by people threatening to kill or rape you and them?

I am suprised that anyone wants to be a politician at all.

acrimoniousone · 26/03/2023 11:28

Matildapower · 26/03/2023 11:27

You can always rely on clavinova for a bit of deflection and whataboutery

I was waiting for them to turn up. So boring.

allibaby · 26/03/2023 11:28

jgw1 · 26/03/2023 11:03

They say ignorance is bliss.

Ooooooo you're so clever aren't you 😁

Matildapower · 26/03/2023 11:27

You can always rely on clavinova for a bit of deflection and whataboutery

allibaby · 26/03/2023 11:25

Eleganz · 26/03/2023 11:03

Well, you seem to think that it needed to be clarified that this person was a junior doctor. Did you seriously think they would be a consultant or GP earning £14 an hour?

Nope I just read NHS doctor and reacted.
The OP later made a post that came across like her relative was a student so yes clarification was needed.

Notonthestairs · 26/03/2023 11:25

Wonder what Johnson received for HIGNFY.

But I doubt receiving a fee from TV production is a security concern.

allibaby · 26/03/2023 11:23

Eleganz · 26/03/2023 11:02

I do see something wrong with questioning from a point of ignorance.

I am not a medical professional, however a few minutes on the internet can provide all you need to know about how medical careers are constructed, basic pay rates, and the fact that there are almost 8,000 medical vacancies in the NHS currently that is over 5% of all NHS medical positions. All from trusted sources.

If, instead of doing that very basic amount of research to address your own questions you challenge others' claims from a point of ignorance then it is hardly surprising that people will interpret your intervention as potentially having malign intent.

Except I admitted I was wrong about pay.

Questioning why people choose to go into a profession that is known to have shit working conditions and pay before you choose to is not really a question for Google.
It's a question on a personal level and as I said it's good to ask questions as it's the only way to move forward.

I was wrong, I held up my hands and said I was wrong but that doesn't mean I can't question anything about it.

As for having malign intent what a ridiculous thing to say.
Nobody can question anything about NHS staff & pay these days without being accused of something bad.

I went into the NHS because I thought at the time the wages were ok and with a decent pension and annual leave it appealed to me.
Even back then I had read about the terrible conditions and pay of junior doctors so from my point of view I wouldn't have even considered that role for me.
So yes I will question why someone chooses to do it knowing how bad it is supposed to be.

Clavinova · 26/03/2023 11:22

Matt Hancock requesting £1,500 per hour is just shocking

Labour MP Jess Phillips was paid £15,000 to host a single episode of Have I Got News For You.
Ms Phillips was approached for comment by the Mail on Sunday and accepted that £15k is ‘a lot of money’ but believes ‘it’s the standard fee’.

https://metro.co.uk/2022/02/07/labour-mp-jess-phillips-paid-15000-to-host-have-i-got-news-for-you-16063846/

Eleganz · 26/03/2023 11:19

Subtlety1985 · 26/03/2023 11:14

I agree with you in regard to the politicians. Matt Hancock requesting £1,500 per hour is just shocking. They are so out of touch with the reality of so many people.

However, I don’t have sympathy for your doctor relative. Firstly, if she’s on £14 per hour, it’s because shes very junior. Doctors salary’s bands increase substantially faster than most other employment sectors/job roles. You make the point that she pays for her own travel, parking and her choice to do further study…. Don’t we all?! Some people are even paying for these things on minimum wage.

I don’t understand this, “oh the poor doctors” - they are doing very well in terms of salary, in my opinion.

Like many professional careers in the public sector they have seen huge levels of pay erosion over the last decade and more. That is the problem.

They should be doing very well as they are highly skilled, highly trained professionals doing life-saving, stressful and intellectually challenging work.

Clavinova · 26/03/2023 11:18

^Ablababla*
It pretty obvious in 2019 that B Johnson was a lying narcissist and his ‘oven ready Brexit’ was a pile of...

Channel 4 FactCheck
Shaky evidence for Starmer’s attack on Johnson Brexit promise.
The Labour leader Keir Starmer was critical of Boris Johnson’s handling of the issue, telling MPs: “The Prime Minister said he had a deal. He didn’t. ”But the evidence Labour offered to support the claim doesn’t add up. Here’s why...

https://www.channel4.com/news/factcheck/factcheck-shaky-evidence-for-starmers-attack-on-johnson-brexit-promise

Eleganz · 26/03/2023 11:16

allibaby · 26/03/2023 11:11

"It might be less. My relative has just had to pay for all her specialty exams, on top of parking, and student loan repayments. She never ever leaves on time ever. sometimes during busy times it’s a couple of hours extra a shift."

The above post made it sound like she was a student doctor.

Rather than acting all high & mighty and argumentative why not just admit it doesn't hurt to have clarification.

I admitted I was wrong about junior doctors pay and honestly it didn't hurt that much 😀

Or you could just spend a bit of time on the internet learning about how medical careers progress like I have done and understand that speciality exams occur after a doctor has begun practicing medicine.

Many scientific and numerate careers are similar in that they have additional experiential training to become a senior practitioner for example becoming a chartered engineer or chartered accountant. Of course, this not the same length or depth as becoming a consultant in medicine.

jgw1 · 26/03/2023 11:14

allibaby · 26/03/2023 11:11

"It might be less. My relative has just had to pay for all her specialty exams, on top of parking, and student loan repayments. She never ever leaves on time ever. sometimes during busy times it’s a couple of hours extra a shift."

The above post made it sound like she was a student doctor.

Rather than acting all high & mighty and argumentative why not just admit it doesn't hurt to have clarification.

I admitted I was wrong about junior doctors pay and honestly it didn't hurt that much 😀

Students don't take specialty exams. Most students (I only use the word most because for some time I was in reciept of a student loan whilst also paying it back, but that situation is vanishingly rare) don't make student loan repayments.

So it is utterly illogial to conclude from those words that they were a student.

WiseUpJanetWeiss · 26/03/2023 11:14

The above post made it sound like she was a student doctor.

Only to someone who has no idea how Drs training is structured. And there you were, making pronouncements from a position of ignorance whilst appealing to the authority of your own employment in the NHS. Maybe put your spade down now?

Subtlety1985 · 26/03/2023 11:14

Thisisvenus · 25/03/2023 21:43

Bloody hell, I’ve just watched the new “led by donkeys” video. People like Matt Hancock wanting to work for a fake consultancy firm for obscene amounts of cash.

I cannot tell You how angry MPs make me right now.

I have a relative that is an NHS dr on £14 an hour. She pays for her own travel and parking. All her study… she pays for. She is so busy she sometimes doesn’t eat.

then these idiots earn loads, and then claim back loads of expenses. Disgusting in my opinion. They then get second jobs that pay them £10k a day. Without even checking if company is real first.

In my opinion an mp should only take a second job if it’s in the nhs, army etc or a volunteer job for a registered charity. That’s it. No other reason.

I can’t even process this. I’ve had enough. What on earth can we do to change this? And yes I’ll not be voting Tory at the next election. They are a bunch of posh rich boys that want to just look after themselves. Politics should be more diverse. what on earth can we do?

I agree with you in regard to the politicians. Matt Hancock requesting £1,500 per hour is just shocking. They are so out of touch with the reality of so many people.

However, I don’t have sympathy for your doctor relative. Firstly, if she’s on £14 per hour, it’s because shes very junior. Doctors salary’s bands increase substantially faster than most other employment sectors/job roles. You make the point that she pays for her own travel, parking and her choice to do further study…. Don’t we all?! Some people are even paying for these things on minimum wage.

I don’t understand this, “oh the poor doctors” - they are doing very well in terms of salary, in my opinion.

Brefugee · 26/03/2023 11:12

The fact is that many well educated, highly qualified people earn a lot more than 80k. So should MPs be drawn only from lower paying careers, or from the exceedingly wealthy who can afford to earn less (and are then blamed for being wealthy).

Or do we expect intelligent, experienced competent people to limit their earnings - and their families' lifestyles - to be an MP?

it's a controversial view, but I'm not against MPs earning a bit more, and their expenses being capped and scrutinised at a level akin to the scrutiny i get when i claim travel expenses at work.

I would prefer a model where their assistants etc are paid by the civil service, and not via an expense claim. That way they would be subject to the same rules that other small business/self employed people have. I would also introduce a minimum distance from their place of work before they can claim a 2nd home allowance (and it wold be something like 90 minutes) etc etc

2nd jobs? run through an independent ethics committee. Donations? same. Clear and transparent accounts for all.

I'm not a tory voter, and while i didn't exactly dance when she died i did loathe Thatcher and all she stood for. But compared to the current tories? Those were days of small c conservatives and the level of corruption - there was sleaze after all - was of a whole other magnitude.

PP asked what you do if your local MP is good, effective, and clearly works in the best interests of their constituents but you don't want to have their party in government? I would say, vote for them. Or if they have a huge majority and you really don't want to vote for any other candidates either? don't vote. (i know i know - turn up and spoil your ballot?

allibaby · 26/03/2023 11:11

jgw1 · 26/03/2023 10:59

Only if you don't know that junior doctors are doctors and for some reason think they are students.

"It might be less. My relative has just had to pay for all her specialty exams, on top of parking, and student loan repayments. She never ever leaves on time ever. sometimes during busy times it’s a couple of hours extra a shift."

The above post made it sound like she was a student doctor.

Rather than acting all high & mighty and argumentative why not just admit it doesn't hurt to have clarification.

I admitted I was wrong about junior doctors pay and honestly it didn't hurt that much 😀

Swipe left for the next trending thread