You know what else has serious implications for your health? Berating and shaming people for their weight.
Like I said, we tried it already. And all we got was an uptick in mental illnesses, especially eating disorders...and a fatter population.
We know the health implications of being overweight. Seriously, a person with their head in a block of cement could have picked that up by now.
But the phenomenon some of you are complaining about right now - that of obese people stating how healthy they are - is also a result of the OTT shaming on that count. The more you insist that the sky will cave in if you have a BMI of 27 or skip a gym session, the more a person with a high BMI will see that despite all the opprobrium, they're not dead yet (they can dance and they can sing) and therefore start to discredit everything that's being said. Since the purpose appears to be not a genuine health concern, but a satisfying opportunity to fat bash. Which it usually is, to be fair.
It's also why so many obese people believe they're not obese, because they don't look like the extreme examples of morbid obesity that are always used to illustrate stories like this. Hey, we're not being sensationalist! We're just worried about your health!
All this shame and sensationalism does is create a sense of defiance, a push back and, of course, shattered self esteem that leads to more overeating. "If I'm such a fat worthless pig, I might as well eat the cream pie..."
If you won't stop doing it because it's horrible, then stop doing it because it makes people fat!