Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MNetters obsession with weight and dress size

331 replies

pagopago · 25/03/2023 21:11

Why are MN posters so obsessed with weight and dress size?

There have recently been quite a lot of weight related threads.

Depressing to see that women are still very much judged on appearance and body size. I couldn't care less what size you are or how much you weigh. Just be a decent, kind person.

No fat shaming or body shaming from me.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
Suzi9989 · 25/03/2023 22:57

I find the behaviour very odd. Analysing food, asking strangers if they ate too much listing consumption. Bizarre

Fairislefandango · 25/03/2023 22:54

Yes we know that, and do you think the current strategies for tackling it are working, given that people continue to get fatter in spite of this knowledge?

But the OP didn't ask how we solve obesity. She asked why people are obsessed with it. And the serious health implications are no doubt one of the reasons why. That and the fact that we live in a society which aesthetically highly values thinness and are surrounded by images selling it. I don't think people's obsession with weight loss is any mystery at all tbh.

Miajk · 25/03/2023 22:48

Honestly the diet culture, demonising carbs and total disinformation on here is really bad.

On the other hand, lots of people are living really unsustainable lifestyles on the other end of the spectrum (drinking alcohol frequently, eating lots of ultra processed foods, no movement), and it's becoming really normalised too.

I rarely seem to see people who just eat normally and move a bit, it seems so extreme on both ends.

EightChalk · 25/03/2023 22:39

EightChalk · 25/03/2023 22:10

I think the phrase "all that food" should be banned on here. In any thread where someone describes a meal or their daily food intake, no matter how little, someone seems to come along to say they couldn't possibly eat "all that food", or if they ate "all that food" they wouldn't eat the next day, or whatever. It's so unhelpful and loaded with judgement. Also agree that a lot of the diet and food comments on here are weirdly old-fashioned sounding, the kind of "give your daughters an eating disorder"-speak from decades ago, with oddly pinched, Hyacinth Bucket-like snobby overtones, more so than elsewhere on the internet.

I've been thinking about why the types of replies I described above bother me so much and I think it's because they often seem to be disingenuous. When people on here make a point of talking about how thin they are and how tiny their appetites are compared to those who "guzzle" and "wolf down" food and drink, to me it has the opposite effect of what they intend - i.e. it shows them as someone whose whole life is actually dominated by food, food choices, fear of getting fat, disgust towards (and envy of) those who don't care so much about what they eat/don't eat at every second. The kind of people who make comments if you take a piece of birthday cake at work or order a dessert AND a starter.

As someone who grew up in the 90s/00s with heroin chic and very thin women as the standard for beauty, these voices sound like spectres from that period and earlier, not like the modern women I know in real life (of any age). I remember women older than my mother's generation who were obsessed with dieting in that particular, judgemental, fastidious (maybe not quite the right word, but I mean it in the sense of e.g. cutting up a biscuit and carefully wrapping up half for another day) way from when I was a child, but don't really encounter those views in real life any more except on here, where they are strangely common.

BeretRaspberry · 25/03/2023 22:35

Plock · 25/03/2023 22:03

There is also a lack of critical thinking because all most people want to do is a) say how thin they are and b) fat bash.

There are a myriad of reasons why people are more overweight now than they used to be, and sanctimoniously writing off all fat people as "lazy" or "making excuses" is not going to resolve the situation. Absolutely nothing the NHS is doing is resolving the situation - people are continuing to get fatter. Therefore perhaps we might come to the conclusion that shaming people for their weight is not, perhaps, the best way to go about solving the obesity crisis. Unless of course all you want to do is criticise and you're not interested in coming up with any solutions that might work.

EXACTLY!

I’ve said before that I’m now the fattest and ‘healthiest’ (in terms of weight) I’ve ever been. My eating is the ‘healthiest’ and least disordered it’s ever been. I’ll likely never be objectively healthy due to chronic illnesses (not caused by my weight).

And you’re so right. The NHS/government has been trying to ‘fix’ the ‘obesity epidemic’ for nigh on 30 years and what’s happened? They’ve done exactly the opposite.

Also, lots of people state about the ‘risks’ of being a higher weight but that never takes into account the effect of weight cycling, which is proven to cause the alleged risks. They also don’t take into account delayed treatment due to weight stigma either. Nor do people seem to take on board that even IF it was as straightforward as people make out, intentional weight loss is not sustainable long term for the vast majority of the population.

And then you get the people saying they’re ‘only thinking of their health’…are they bollox! And then the NHS tripe..yet I bet they don’t say the same to sportspeople who break bones, drivers who have accidents etc etc.

Why can’t we all just be less judgmental and realise that everbody’s lives and circumstances are different. Berating someone for not being the current trend body size wise is going to do nothing but make them feel utterly shit.

UpperLowerMiddleClass · 25/03/2023 22:35

I agree OP, there was one poster recently lamenting the fact she was 8.5 rather than 8 stone and how massive she felt, and how - shock horror! - there was some fat on her stomach and thighs. Yep, that’s how adult women are supposed to look, some body fat is normal.

Also the threads where posters obsessively dissect what the OP eats. Regardless of what this includes there seems to be a group of posters who are the self-appointed carb police and who will tell the OP she’s eating way too many carbs. Despite not knowing if ‘toast for breakfast’ means 1 or 2 slices, or 1/2 or 4 slices for that matter.

And of course, this is an anonymous online forum, some people will be lying. I’m 5ft 3 and weight 11 stone. Or maybe I’m 5ft 8 and 9 stone. Or maybe I’m something else.

Teafor1please · 25/03/2023 22:34

It's all the 'today I ate a handful of nuts, some leaves and some grilled chicken. I feel so full I simply must eat less tomorrow' posts.

Tinybrother · 25/03/2023 22:33

Oh wow that was deleted quickly

Suzi888 · 25/03/2023 22:33

You can scroll past…

Tinybrother · 25/03/2023 22:32

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

explain more about it being “unacceptable” to be overweight. What does that mean exactly? On a day to day basis, how should an overweight person experience their unacceptability, and how will it help them lose weight?

TheObstinateHeadstrongGirl · 25/03/2023 22:32

ItsBeginningToScabOverNow · 25/03/2023 21:13

There’s a seriously pro-ana undertone here of late.

Yep.

I ended up going toe to toe with a clearly pro-ana poster recently on a “Am I eating enough?” Thread.

The poster was grieving the loss of her mum and all she was eating every day was (IIRC) 3 vegan ‘chicken’ nuggets, a handful of nuts, a yoghurt, an apple and a packet of crisps.

She was told “I’d say that’s plenty - cut the crisps out it’s very unhealthy” by SO many posters. The one I argued with insisted that that equates to 2,000 calories. It’s seriously scary on here and no one should ever ask for any advice on weight or food.

Plock · 25/03/2023 22:29

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Goodness me, you've solved the obesity crisis! Well done you, give yourself a pat on the back.

underneaththeash · 25/03/2023 22:28

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Backstreets · 25/03/2023 22:26

I also feel sad about the many threads posted by women who feel ugly, fat and undesirable but it’s hardly a new phenomenon amongst women in a world that constantly judges us on our looks. Every time I see a stunningly beautiful actress premiere a narrower nose or fuller mouth I’m reminded it’s literally all of us.

coffeeandcola · 25/03/2023 22:25

I do think MNHQ should be doing more to stop posters who clearly have eating disorders and try to convince others to under eat with them.

Its the same with dangerous amounts of exercise and cardio that some promote.

I'm personally glad that women being strong in the gym is normal now, not endless running to be skinny. But it does seem to be going back to promoting skinny again.

Promoting fitness instead of dress size or being under 9st would be better. I'm 'fat' by standards here but lift very heavy at the gym and consider myself 'fit', but because I'm big people here would say I'm unhealthy.

Fat doesn't equal unhealthy, thin doesn't equal healthy.

Plock · 25/03/2023 22:24

I assume anyone else making unkind comments (whether they're dressed up as concern or not) about someone's looks is a deeply unhappy person.

Tinybrother · 25/03/2023 22:21

Plock · 25/03/2023 22:03

There is also a lack of critical thinking because all most people want to do is a) say how thin they are and b) fat bash.

There are a myriad of reasons why people are more overweight now than they used to be, and sanctimoniously writing off all fat people as "lazy" or "making excuses" is not going to resolve the situation. Absolutely nothing the NHS is doing is resolving the situation - people are continuing to get fatter. Therefore perhaps we might come to the conclusion that shaming people for their weight is not, perhaps, the best way to go about solving the obesity crisis. Unless of course all you want to do is criticise and you're not interested in coming up with any solutions that might work.

Agree, all the evidence shows that “shaming” does nothing to reduce obesity rates, but people continue to do it. So clearly they just get enjoyment out of it. It’s just old-fashioned bullying but they think they get away with it by putting a handwringing “concern” facade on it.

AbreathofFrenchair · 25/03/2023 22:21

SunshineGeorgie · 25/03/2023 21:49

How is it obsessive? There's been a few threads, probably as we are heading into summer holiday territory and summer clothes are in the shops?

Hardly obsessive though..

It's there replies that are the problem.

I've seen someone reply that they couldn't finish half a tin of soup for their lunch as it left them stuffed so her and her husband share a tin for lunch.

You can clearly see the unhealthy relationships showing on all replies and the nastiness that goes with it, where they insist healthy weights are below 9 stone and BMI below 19 and thinking that size 12 is plus sized and thinking the problem is with everyone else thinking the opposite has lost sight of what is healthy.

Even those wanting to lose a stone or whatever for summer are scorned at for allowing themselves to get above 10 stone on the first place and the famous mumsnet "massive salad' that fills them up for days and thats all they need.

They simply cannot comprehend or understand everyone single one of us is different eith different issues, health concerns, circumstances or conditions etc.

They might all be "thin" but they all soukd deeply unhappy and miserable as sin

Tinybrother · 25/03/2023 22:18

underneaththeash · 25/03/2023 22:12

Stop normalising obesity?

How do you think it’s normalised? Do you mean that you think people aren’t ashamed enough of being fat? How would you make them feel more ashamed?

PlinkPlonkFizz · 25/03/2023 22:18

The "massive salad" people on MN often come across as competitive undereaters with eating/body dysphoria issues.

Unless you're size 6-8 and exercising like an elite athlete at 5am daily you don't seem to count for much in their eyes.

It doesn't seem to occur to them that far from be the ideal, they fear that drives them is quite pitiful. Acceptance about ones' natural weight, an unassuming confidence in oneself, an ability to see worth and value in people without focusing on external characteristics, kindness, they are true ideals to be impressed by. Weight is a shallow thing to obsess about.

LolaSmiles · 25/03/2023 22:17

I don't think Mumsnet is any more bothered about weight or food than the rest of the population.

I've never worked in a workplace where people weren't on various diets or talking about their health kicks.

Gossipxox · 25/03/2023 22:16

Iusedtobedontcall · 25/03/2023 22:12

Yes - seeing as I’ve lost 2 babies in a year during pregnancy- seeing that my weight gain of 2 stone now makes me lazy and completely hideous is quite triggering. I gained the weight in each pregnancy and couldn’t lose it because of hormones and grief. And no baby to show for it. It’s not as simple as calories in, calories out.

So sorry for your loss. One step at a time 💐

CalmDownBoris72 · 25/03/2023 22:15

underneaththeash · 25/03/2023 22:10

If it didn’t have major health implications - yes!

But it’s the competitive under eating I’m taking about. The almost gloating about how slim they are, how more that 500 calories would be far to gluttonous. It’s BS.

This stuff is definitely not going ti sort out this country’s obesity crisis!

Plock · 25/03/2023 22:15

mmalinky · 25/03/2023 22:13

Obesity is a factor in almost every major health issue; heart disease, hypertension, cancer, diabetes… and it’s become normalised.

And yet with have frontline NHS staff who know all the above & struggle to manage their weight. It's almost like it's not easy or there are no socio economic factors involved.

Quite! I know a lot of doctors and frankly they all have utterly awful diets, partly because they work such mad hours they don't have the time or the inclination to cook, shop or exercise.

High levels of drinking and smoking amongst medical staff as well.

Gossipxox · 25/03/2023 22:14

underneaththeash · 25/03/2023 22:10

If it didn’t have major health implications - yes!

So does smoking, drinking, drugs and other lifestyle factors.