Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

MNetters obsession with weight and dress size

331 replies

pagopago · 25/03/2023 21:11

Why are MN posters so obsessed with weight and dress size?

There have recently been quite a lot of weight related threads.

Depressing to see that women are still very much judged on appearance and body size. I couldn't care less what size you are or how much you weigh. Just be a decent, kind person.

No fat shaming or body shaming from me.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
10
EddieSteady · 26/03/2023 03:21

Swings and roundabouts. MN has always been a bit extreme one way then swings to the other. Give it a few weeks and there'll be competitive over-eating threads.

Anotherparkingthread · 26/03/2023 03:17

I'm not in the business of telling anybody what to weigh. I was always slim when younger, gained a couple of stone and was unhappy and then lost it all recently and am very slim again.

I am so so much happier being back to my old dress size. So much happier. More confident. Fitter, I do running and yoga, I don't get out of breath at all now, my balance is great and I feel good.

I think what's most sad and hypocritical is that almost all overweight women feel upset about it, unhappy with themselves or their body. Unhappy how they look in certain clothes and unhappy with what they see in the mirror. The belief that if society accepted all overweight people as they are and weight was ignored, that they would magically feel okay with themselves, beautiful and amazing just isnt true. They would still be unhappy because slim women would still exist and be considered attractive and comparison is the theif of joy. Equally, blaming society for having a preference for healthy physical traits is ridiculous, you cant force somebody else to find your body type attractive. And of course people are more commonly drawn to normal, healthy, athletic bodies. It's nature. It is how attraction works. We cant change biology, I find slim men and women more attractive. Most people do outside of those with fetishes for weight.

I'm not excusing people being rude, bullying ir derogatory to overweight and obese people, that is different.

The point I'm making is that if you're unhappy with your body the only person who can change it is you. If you're happy overweight, crack on, but most people aren't.

flowagurl · 26/03/2023 02:51

Literally getting to the point of being sick of being lectured. Some, women actually would like to be a certain number on the scale/ dress size. I don’t care how healthy or not it it is. Please let us be

Rebel2 · 26/03/2023 02:42

Leopardprintisnotaneutral · 25/03/2023 23:49

@BeretRaspberry please can you go and have a look and see if you can find some data on how much sports people breaking bones costs the nhs a year v people being obese and overweight, I mean I don’t like to gamble but I’d put my house on the former being minuscule in comparison….we also have a stupidity epidemic as well quite clearly which in all honesty I do think is part of it.

Yes the pro ana leanings are distributing but so is normalising being obese.

See my obesity doesn't cost the NHS anything
The chronic illnesses I have which aren't caused by my weight did, the spinal surgery caused by repetitive exercise did, the numerous sports injuries etc
Not everyone who is obese is unfit or dropping down from health issues
It's not like I'm advocating being fat is great but within being fat I do my best to be as healthy as I can with food, exercise, managing stress etc etc

I don't think it's clear cut
If you're normal weight, do no exercise, eat processed food, drink and smoke socially is that healthier than someone who is overweight but doesn't drink or smoke and exercises 5 days a week?
My friend is a size 6 and can't run upstairs without being out of breath, I'm not sure that's healthy at any size

WimbourneWasps · 26/03/2023 02:36

It's honestly so pro Ana on here. It reminds me of the old pro ana websites that were around in 2007.

So toxic.

TorringtonDean · 26/03/2023 02:18

As for health, just remember everyone dies of something in the end. Even slim people can become ill. Not all health issues are down to weight.

People don’t choose to be obese. Most people are just going about their daily business and enjoying their life in a food environment where portions are excessive and food is ultra-processed. Plus none of us get as must exercise as our ancestors.

I have been obese my entire life and have battled it endlessly. The slimmest I ever was still counted as overweight officially. I don’t drink excessively or smoke or take illegal drugs. I work hard, pay my taxes and I exercise regularly. I have this one problem which is not of my choosing and despite all my efforts cannot get it under my control.

I don’t think I deserve to be vilified as a result.

newjobnewstartihope · 26/03/2023 00:56

Mumsnet is the worst place for it ever
Nobody in real life is like this. And I don't know hardly any obese people

Gossipxox · 26/03/2023 00:32

Well if it’s down to overeating yes that’s a life style choice. Same as smoking drinking alcohol caffeine drugs etc. And a lot of obesity stems from other health issues. Doesn’t necessarily make it a choice, and it’s always going to be this way so what’s the point in moaning about and putting people down and bringing the NHS in to it the NHS will still have to deal with problems related to obesity.. it’s ALWAYS going to be like that.

Somanycats · 26/03/2023 00:26

mmalinky · 25/03/2023 22:00

Seriously who gives a shit what other people weigh.

that's the weirdest bit.

I don't care how much they weigh, not my problem. But I absolutely care how much room they take up. I want to be able to get my arm rest down at the theatre, sit comfortably on a flight and have half of the bus seat to myself.

BeretRaspberry · 26/03/2023 00:02

Leopardprintisnotaneutral · 25/03/2023 23:49

@BeretRaspberry please can you go and have a look and see if you can find some data on how much sports people breaking bones costs the nhs a year v people being obese and overweight, I mean I don’t like to gamble but I’d put my house on the former being minuscule in comparison….we also have a stupidity epidemic as well quite clearly which in all honesty I do think is part of it.

Yes the pro ana leanings are distributing but so is normalising being obese.

Give over. Do you really think obese people don’t know they’re obese? I mean they’d have to be deaf and blind not to realise. Do you also realise that there are many, many circumstances that can lead to being obese? And that fat people aren’t necessarily lazy, unfit, gluttonous.

One of the biggest risk factors for being obese is a previous history of dieting. One of the biggest risk factors for developing eating disorders is a previous history of dieting. ‘Obesity’ costs the NHS approx £6billion. Eating disorder treatment costs the NHS approx £9.4 billion (yearly).

NannyOggsWhiskyStash · 26/03/2023 00:01

Iusedtobedontcall · 25/03/2023 22:12

Yes - seeing as I’ve lost 2 babies in a year during pregnancy- seeing that my weight gain of 2 stone now makes me lazy and completely hideous is quite triggering. I gained the weight in each pregnancy and couldn’t lose it because of hormones and grief. And no baby to show for it. It’s not as simple as calories in, calories out.

So sorry to hear that. And it's not always as simple as cals in and out.

Leopardprintisnotaneutral · 25/03/2023 23:49

@BeretRaspberry please can you go and have a look and see if you can find some data on how much sports people breaking bones costs the nhs a year v people being obese and overweight, I mean I don’t like to gamble but I’d put my house on the former being minuscule in comparison….we also have a stupidity epidemic as well quite clearly which in all honesty I do think is part of it.

Yes the pro ana leanings are distributing but so is normalising being obese.

anonymous98 · 25/03/2023 23:48

DryIce · 25/03/2023 23:34

There was a thread recently about having a roast for lunch at around 2pm and what, if anything, you'd eat later. I was astonished that over half the responses claimed they'd eat nothing for the rest of the day, or perhaps some fruit etc. I know roasts can be a large meal, but they're still essential meat and some veg - I wouldn't think to not have dinner 6 or so hours later.

I always need 3 meals a day, unless I'm ill or severely stressed. I actively look forward to breakfast every morning.

Mumsnet and the intermittent fasting trend make me feel incredibly gluttonous for this, when it's actually the 'normal' way to eat.

SweetCoriander · 25/03/2023 23:46

It's always the carbs. And that bloody annoying 'hmmmm' thing.

'Hmmmm. I'd cut down a bit on the carbs. No-one needs half a pitta and a piece of rye in one day'.

Oh fuck off.

Leopardprintisnotaneutral · 25/03/2023 23:42

@Gossipxox ah that makes it alright then, drugs are illegal, alcohol and smoking in g heavily regulated….food however! Please stop it with the whataboutery

DerekFaker · 25/03/2023 23:41

The competitive under-eaters and over-exercisers pop up in threads that aren't even related.

And you can't even, say, discuss your favourite chocolate bar without them popping up to say they only ever eat one square of good quality dark chocolate 🙄

I'm glad you made this thread, OP. It's been bugging me for a while, and it seems to be getting worse. I do thinK MNHQ need to clamp down.

DerekFaker · 25/03/2023 23:36

ItsBeginningToScabOverNow · 25/03/2023 21:13

There’s a seriously pro-ana undertone here of late.

There is. I reported a particularly disturbing thread and MNHQ did nothing.

YANBU , OP.

DryIce · 25/03/2023 23:34

There was a thread recently about having a roast for lunch at around 2pm and what, if anything, you'd eat later. I was astonished that over half the responses claimed they'd eat nothing for the rest of the day, or perhaps some fruit etc. I know roasts can be a large meal, but they're still essential meat and some veg - I wouldn't think to not have dinner 6 or so hours later.

Fizbosshoes · 25/03/2023 23:22

I notice it too. I used to have an ED and I am drawn to certain threads but I notice a lot of (what I consider) disordered eating or thinking about food. I don't look at "what have you eaten today" because I know I would feel shit about myself....but also its probably very dull.

If anyone comments whether a model looks healthy or has been airbrushed, you get loads of posters falling over themselves to say they are 5'11 and naturally a size 4 (and conveniently enough their favourite food is salad) and that we've lost sight of normal bodyweight.

Ktime · 25/03/2023 23:20

SweetCoriander · 25/03/2023 21:17

Are you thinking of that '1000 calories a day' thread? At least one poster said that would be too much for her or some-such. Really dangerous stuff.

Is there a link to the 1,000 cals thread? Not something I would do but would be good to see ehy they think it’s too much calories.

surrenderdorothy · 25/03/2023 23:16

It's like a sick cult. One that promotes obsessing over weight and dress size, demonising carbs, rigid and intense devotion to being very thin - and then pumping the poor gaunt face with botox and fillers. At some point, osteopenia kicks in, and so everyone else must also go on HRT to prevent osteoporosis...

BeretRaspberry · 25/03/2023 23:00

Miajk · 25/03/2023 22:48

Honestly the diet culture, demonising carbs and total disinformation on here is really bad.

On the other hand, lots of people are living really unsustainable lifestyles on the other end of the spectrum (drinking alcohol frequently, eating lots of ultra processed foods, no movement), and it's becoming really normalised too.

I rarely seem to see people who just eat normally and move a bit, it seems so extreme on both ends.

My parents, sisters and I all lived like that. Good old fashioned food with a good variety and we walked everywhere. The variety of food was a privilege of course and not something everyone has.

My parents and sisters still live like this. They’re all still slim. No extremes food wise or alcohol etc. Exercise regularly. I’m the only one who ever dieted in our family and the only one who ended up fat and with an ED.

As I’ve mentioned a few times, my diet is the least disordered it’s ever been and the healthiest since back before diet culture got its claws in me. I can’t exercise now, sadly, much as I wish I could. I don’t drink or smoke or anything but because I’m fat, I get treated like the scurge of society!

beastlyslumber · 25/03/2023 22:58

YANBU. Some threads on here are genuinely distressing.

I wonder if MN could ban any numbers talk when it comes to weight and food? I feel like there's a real problem with eating disorders on this site.